NFL, union kept players in dark over key details from bombshell collusion decision
The league and senior leaders of the NFLPA struck an 'unusual confidentiality agreement' that hid details of an arbitration agreement from players, including a discovery that the NFL management council pushed for teams to lower guarantees in player contracts, ESPN reported Wednesday.
In January, arbitrator Christopher Droney ruled there was no collusion between NFL owners to keep salaries down, but he did conclude that 'by a clear preponderance of the evidence,' commissioner Roger Goodell and the league's general counsel encouraged owners to restrict players' guaranteed money in their contracts.
That was part of a 61-page ruling, which was hidden by the confidentiality agreement until reporter Pablo Torre brought it to the public two weeks ago in an episode of his podcast, 'Pablo Torre Finds Out.'
3 NFLPA executive director Lloyd Howell Jr. in July 2023.
Lev Radin/Pacific Press/Shutterstock
Some players told ESPN they were 'surprised by details in the ruling and didn't understand why the union hadn't shared the ruling with them.'
Tuesday night, the NFLPA, which is led by executive director Lloyd Howell Jr., reportedly opted to seek an appeal of Droney's ruling — nearly six months after it was made.
'The appeal is a reflection of our obligation to enforce the CBA and our commitment to protecting our players' interests,' a senior union source told ESPN. 'We'll do what's best for players and we'll exhaust our options in doing so.'
Attorney Peter Ginsberg, a lawyer at Moskowitz Colson Ginsberg & Schulman who has represented several NFL players over many years, told ESPN: 'By agreeing to a confidentiality agreement, the union purposefully blocked the players from receiving crucial information about the operations of the NFL.
'The NFL and the union should not be conspiring together to keep important information from the players.'
3 Deshaun Watson signed a fully guaranteed $230 million contract with the Browns in March 2022.
Getty Images
The alleged collusion stems from a lawsuit in 2022, when the NFLPA claimed that the teams and league broke the NFL's collective bargaining agreement by colluding to not offer players fully guaranteed contracts after Deshaun Watson signed his fully guaranteed $230 million deal with the Browns that March.
The lawsuit specifically focused on quarterbacks Lamar Jackson, Kyler Murray and Russell Wilson, who each reportedly sought fully guaranteed deals.
3 NFL commissioner Roger Goodell on May 21 at the NFL owners meeting.
AP
None of the three signed guaranteed contracts, and the lawsuit called for damages and for the three quarterbacks' contracts to be voided.
In his findings, Droney did not void the contracts or award any money to the NFLPA — even if he did determine that it seems the league urged its teams to act in a certain manner.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
21 minutes ago
- USA Today
Status of 49ers early position battles revealed in first training camp practice
The San Francisco 49ers on Wednesday held their first training camp practice and offered a glimpse of what the early defensive depth chart looks like. ESPN's Nick Wagoner in a tweet ran through some of his observations from Wednesday's session and noted who the first-team reps went to on that side of the ball. Here's what that group looked like per Wagoner's tweet, along with our own takeaways from the personnel choices: DE: Mykel Williams, Sam Okuayinonu Nick Bosa will hold down one of the starting jobs. He didn't participate in team drills. Okuayinonu getting the initial first-team reps is a good sign for his chances of making the roster. He posted 3.0 sacks in 16 games last year and had enough flashes to be interesting as a fourth pass rusher. It looks early in camp like he's in line for that spot. DT: Kevin Givens, Jordan Elliott It's not a huge surprise the two veterans got the initial first-team reps. Draft picks Alfred Collins and CJ West should be worked into some first-team looks eventually. The 49ers will be in trouble if they go into the year with Givens and Elliott as their starters at DT. LB: Fred Warner, Dee Winters, Luke Gifford Winters was first up in the Will LB battle. He'll be fighting Kyle Shanahan's confidence in 49ers rising star could set table for new Super Bowl windowfor that three-down job with rookie third-round pick Nick Martin. There's no real surprise it was the third-year veteran Winters getting the early first-team reps. Gifford hasn't played a ton defensively over his six-year career, but he did play a career-high 203 defensive snaps for the Titans last season. There will likely be other players in the mix for the Sam LB spot, but the veteran Gifford got the first shot to start in the base defense. CB: Deommodore Lenoir, Renardo Green This isn't the notable CB thing. The notable CB thing is that Tre Brown, an offseason free agent signing, got the first nickel CB reps in the slot with Lenoir and Green playing outside. Rookie third-round pick Upton Stout also get some work in the nickel according to Wagoner. This battle is going to be a fun one, and the opening salvo saw the four-year vet with two-career INTs get the nod. S: Jason Pinnock, Ji'Ayir Brown There's an open safety spot because of Malik Mustapha's knee injury. Pinnock appeared to be the frontrunner to start alongside Brown since he spent one season under 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh when Saleh was the New York Jets head coach. That was confirmed with his early first-team reps. It'll be interesting to see if rookie Marquis Sigle gets a look. Free agent Richie Grant could also get a shot at some first-team snaps. Brown's status as a starter may also be in flux if he struggles in camp. For now he's still getting the first-team looks. More 49ers: Kyle Shanahan's confidence in 49ers rising star could set table for new Super Bowl window
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Sophie Cunningham fires back at WNBA after getting fined for mocking refs on TikTok
Sophie Cunningham isn't taking her fine quietly. The Fever star hit out at the WNBA after she was fined $500 for a TikTok she posted last week, where she seemingly took a shot at referees, with a post on X on Wednesday. 'I got fined $500 for this TikTok,' Cunningham wrote on X, along with two crying laugh emojis while sharing the video. 'idk why this is funny to me… like ok you got it bud! Cause there's not more important things to be worried about with our league right now.' Advertisement In the video, Cunningham lip-synched the words to Sabrina Carpenter's song 'Manchild' and had the words written the words '@ some refs.' 'Stupid. Or is it slow? Maybe, it's useless,' Carpenter sings in the portion of the song that Cunningham used in her post. Advertisement 3 Sophie Cunningham celebrates during the first half of the Fever's home win over the Wings on July 13, 2025. AP It wasn't totally clear what Cunningham was referring to when she said the league had 'more important' things to deal with, but there are high-profile CBA negotiations between the WNBA and the players union. Over the weekend, Cunningham had a fiery response to a reporter's question about the number of games in the WNBA season. 'You can just tell [commissioner] Cathy [Engelbert] to pay us, and then we can have a discussion,' Cunningham said at Sunday's Fever practice. Advertisement 3 Sophie Cunningham said she got fined for he TikTok. Sophie Cunningham/X Cunningham was fined last month for her role in a fiery incident during the Sun-Fever game, where she defended Clark after she was hit in the eye by Sun guard Jacy Sheldon. She hit out at the refs afterward as well with postgame comments. 3 Sophie Cunningham celebrates during the Fever's road loss to the Liberty on July 22, 2025. NBAE via Getty Images Advertisement 'During that, it was just part of the game. I think the refs had a lot to do with that,' she said. 'It was a build-up for a couple [of] years now of them just not protecting the star player of the WNBA. At the end of the day, I'm going to protect my teammates. 'That's what I do.'
USA Today
an hour ago
- USA Today
WATCH: Cardinals training camp Wednesday highlights
The Cardinals held their first practice of training camp on Wednesday. For the Arizona Cardinals, 2025 training camp has begun. After reporting on Tuesday, having meetings and taking their physical exams, they took the field at State Farm Stadium for the first time for practice Wednesday afternoon. This practice was not open to fans. Fans will be able to see them in action nine times in camp starting Thursday. What happened? The majority of practice was closed for sharing, but there were a few videos shared by the team and reporters of the open part of practice. If you missed them, here are some of what happened. Wednesday training camp highlights for Cardinals training camp You can catch the Cardinals in action at the stadium Thursday and Friday. Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire's Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on Spotify, YouTube or Apple podcasts.
