Denial of timely, unfettered access to medical records violates right to life, says consumer panel
The Commission said that access to one's medical records — whether physical or digital — was indispensable not only for seeking second opinions and ensuring continuity of care, but also for facilitating effective grievance redressal. It also recommended that doctors prescribe generic medicines in a clear and legible manner.
The Commission, comprising president D.B. Binu and members V. Ramachandran and Sreevidhia T.N., made the observation while dismissing a petition filed by the husband of Saiju Mujeeb, 38, of North Paravur, alleging gross negligence, failure to diagnose, and improper post-operative care.
'Hospitals and healthcare providers are therefore reminded of their ethical and legal obligation to ensure that patients are provided with their medical records in a timely and accessible manner. Both modern medical ethics and advancements in health information technology support a patient-centric system in which medical records are made readily accessible through secure digital means,' said the Commission.
The Commission, drawing on its broader mandate to promote consumer welfare and transparency in healthcare, recommended that regulatory bodies ensure the secure digital delivery of medical records in compliance with applicable data protection laws, fulfil requests for records preferably within 72 hours, and implement interoperable electronic health record (EHR) systems to promote seamless access and continuity of care.
It also called for disclosure to patients at the time of admission or discharge regarding their right to receive medical records in physical or digital format, along with information on encryption, password protection, and consent protocols for all digital transmissions of sensitive medical data. The Commission further recommended public education initiatives to raise awareness about patients' rights to medical records and the confidentiality safeguards.
It also dismissed the petition alleging post-surgery complications on the grounds that no deficiency in service could be established. The complainant had failed to prove that the treatment deviated from accepted professional standards or that the subsequent complications were directly caused by any act or omission on the part of the opposite parties, the Commission observed, while citing the Supreme Court's dictum that 'to hold a medical practitioner liable for negligence, a higher threshold of proof is required to be met by the complainant.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Early detection of emotional distress key to avert suicides among students
Visakhapatnam: Even if victims drop apparent indications much before taking the extreme step, are parents or teachers or peers or friends able to decipher the hints? In a highly-competitive academic framework coupled with an insatiable drive to be on the top of the score chart all through the academic life, students are often subject to relentless pressure both at home and in the school campus. But, as a community, are there any concrete measures in place to help one another, spot early indications of suicidal feelings, flag warning signs and come to the rescueof the child before it is too late? Emotional wellbeing therapists underline that suicides are very much preventive provided the risk factors are recognised early and an action plan is in place to extend support to vulnerable students. They emphasise that such students not only have to be monitored from close quarters but also be given confidence through counselling at frequent intervals. The National Crime Records Bureau-2022 indicates a distressing data of about 1.71 lakh suicides recorded in India. Of them, 13,044 were students and over 2,000 of them were due to failure in examinations. Following the tragic and unnatural death of a 17-year-old girl, who was undergoing coaching for the NEET examination in a private institute in Visakhapatnam two years back, and keeping the alarming statistics in view, the Supreme Court issued comprehensive interim guidelines to safeguard mental health of students across all educational institutions. Underlining that suicide prevention is a binding obligation to safeguard the right to life, health and human dignity, the bench instructed the educational institutions to engage at least one qualified counsellor, psychologist or social worker based on the strength of the school with demonstrable training in child and adolescent mental health. 'Prioritising mental health for students is a welcome move. However, it would take a while for the educational institutions to appoint counsellors and adopt structured planning. Along with institutional support, massive awareness drives to detect signs of psychological distress among children play a pivotal role. Change starts from home. Parents attending parent-teacher-meeting should be made mandatory so that they would be made aware of the wards' emotional health along with academic performance,' suggests Dr. Pujitha Josyula, a psychologist and founder of 99 Mindfit. Dr. Pujitha Josyula recommends setting short and long term strategies focusing on massive sensitisation drives among parents and hostel wardens, holding regular interactive sessions with students, being empathetic, identifying vulnerable students, monitoring them at regular intervals and connecting parents with counsellors as she says that they serve as an effective suicide prevention mechanism. However, in most cases, the child is often conditioned by fear, high academic expectations and constant comparison-driven pressure. Unless such trend changes, clinical psychologists hint that bottled up emotions invariably make people feel singled out. 'There is a need to build a friendly atmosphere at home so that children would look forward to sharing their secrets and fears with any parent or a trusted adult. However, not many are open to communicating with their parents for the fear of being 'judged'. Coordinated efforts in keeping tabs of the warning signs rests on parents, teachers and peers,' asserts Dr. Harilakshmi Venkataramana, a clinical psychologist. Empathising and narrating real time stories with children and making them feel wanted are some of the strategies Dr. Harilakshmi Venkataramana suggests parents adopt for improving emotional wellness of their wards.
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
‘Counselling must for better mental health'
Lucknow: There is a need for trained counsellors, and counselling should be held right from the school level and continue until higher education for the good mental health of students, said experts reacting to the Supreme Court's acknowledgment of the mental health crisis in educational institutions and mentioning it as a systematic failure. "A suicide is actually a disturbed mind killing the body. It is sad that even with the rising number of suicide cases among teens and undergraduate students in educational institutions, universities, colleges, schools, and coaching centres have yet to take concrete steps in addressing the mental well-being of the students," said wellness and mental health coach Subroto Biswas. He said although the NEP-2020 highlighted the importance of helping students via counselling, and training, little has happened on the ground. "Joint family culture has reduced, and in nuclear families, both parents are working; hence the children don't get the kind of support they need," said renowned academician and Professor Eminence at Lucknow, Prof Nishi Pandey. A member of the All India Association for Educational Research Amita Bajpai, said, "Multiple factors are responsible for the increasing number of suicides in educational institutions. "
Scroll.in
15 hours ago
- Scroll.in
SC issues 15 guidelines to address student suicides, mental health in educational institutions
The Supreme Court on Friday issued 15 interim guidelines to address the rise in student suicides and mental health challenges in educational institutions across India, PTI reported. The guidelines include the appointment of trained counsellors and psychologists, the adoption of a uniform mental health policy and annual reviews of wellness interventions at such institutes. A bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta observed that there was a 'legislative and regulatory vacuum' regarding a unified, enforceable framework for suicide prevention in schools, colleges, coaching centres and similar environments. The court said the guidelines would remain in force and binding until suitable legislation or regulatory frameworks were introduced by the competent authority. The order came in response to an appeal against an Andhra Pradesh High Court decision that had rejected a request to transfer to the Central Bureau of Investigation a probe into the suspicious death of a 17-year-old National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test aspirant in Visakhapatnam. The Supreme Court directed the central agency to take over the investigation, according to The New Indian Express. Mental health safeguards The Supreme Court directed all educational institutions to adopt and implement a uniform mental health policy, drawing from the UMMEED draft guidelines, the Manodarpan initiative and the National Suicide Prevention Strategy. It must be reviewed annually and made publicly available on institutional websites and notice boards. The draft UMMEED, or Understand, Motivate, Manage, Empathise, Empower, Develop guidelines were released in 2023 by the Union Ministry of Education to help prevent student suicides in schools. The Manodarpan initiative was launched to provide psychosocial support during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. The National Suicide Prevention Strategy outlines roles for stakeholders in reducing suicide rates. Among other suggestions, the court said that institutions with more than 100 students must appoint qualified counsellors, psychologists or social workers trained in child and adolescent mental health. Smaller institutions may establish formal referral arrangements with external professionals. The court directed educational and coaching institutions to avoid practices that could harm students' mental well-being, such as public shaming, assigning academic targets that exceed students' capacity and segregating students into batches based on their academic performance. Residential institutions have been advised to install tamper-proof ceiling fans or other safety devices and restrict access to rooftops, balconies and similar high-risk areas to deter impulsive acts of self-harm. The court said that coaching hubs in cities such as Jaipur, Kota, Sikar, Chennai, Hyderabad, Delhi, and Mumbai must implement enhanced mental health protections. All teaching and non-teaching staff must undergo mandatory training twice a year, conducted by certified mental health professionals. These guidelines apply to all public and private schools, colleges, universities and coaching centres.
