logo
Denial of timely, unfettered access to medical records violates right to life, says consumer panel

Denial of timely, unfettered access to medical records violates right to life, says consumer panel

The Hindu08-07-2025
The Ernakulam District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has observed that the denial of timely and unfettered access to one's medical records undermines not only statutory consumer rights but also compromises the right to life guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India as interpreted in landmark judgments of the Supreme Court.
The Commission said that access to one's medical records — whether physical or digital — was indispensable not only for seeking second opinions and ensuring continuity of care, but also for facilitating effective grievance redressal. It also recommended that doctors prescribe generic medicines in a clear and legible manner.
The Commission, comprising president D.B. Binu and members V. Ramachandran and Sreevidhia T.N., made the observation while dismissing a petition filed by the husband of Saiju Mujeeb, 38, of North Paravur, alleging gross negligence, failure to diagnose, and improper post-operative care.
'Hospitals and healthcare providers are therefore reminded of their ethical and legal obligation to ensure that patients are provided with their medical records in a timely and accessible manner. Both modern medical ethics and advancements in health information technology support a patient-centric system in which medical records are made readily accessible through secure digital means,' said the Commission.
The Commission, drawing on its broader mandate to promote consumer welfare and transparency in healthcare, recommended that regulatory bodies ensure the secure digital delivery of medical records in compliance with applicable data protection laws, fulfil requests for records preferably within 72 hours, and implement interoperable electronic health record (EHR) systems to promote seamless access and continuity of care.
It also called for disclosure to patients at the time of admission or discharge regarding their right to receive medical records in physical or digital format, along with information on encryption, password protection, and consent protocols for all digital transmissions of sensitive medical data. The Commission further recommended public education initiatives to raise awareness about patients' rights to medical records and the confidentiality safeguards.
It also dismissed the petition alleging post-surgery complications on the grounds that no deficiency in service could be established. The complainant had failed to prove that the treatment deviated from accepted professional standards or that the subsequent complications were directly caused by any act or omission on the part of the opposite parties, the Commission observed, while citing the Supreme Court's dictum that 'to hold a medical practitioner liable for negligence, a higher threshold of proof is required to be met by the complainant.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Centre plans to introduce $10,000 fee to recognize foreign medical courses
Centre plans to introduce $10,000 fee to recognize foreign medical courses

Mint

time3 hours ago

  • Mint

Centre plans to introduce $10,000 fee to recognize foreign medical courses

New Delhi: India's National Medical Commission (NMC), the country's apex medical education regulator, has proposed to overhaul rules and introduce a fee to recognize medical courses offered by universities abroad. Under its new draft rules, foreign universities or accreditation agencies will need to pay the NMC a fee of $10,000 ( ₹ 8.6 lakh) for each application seeking recognition by India of a medical course conducted by them. 'Any foreign authority in any country outside India, entrusted with the recognition shall remit $10,000 (US dollars ten thousand only) per qualification as fees to the Commission while submitting its application in a proforma,' the NMC said in a draft notification, amending a clause of the National Medical Commission (Recognition of Medical Qualification) regulations. The development is significant given that 25,000 Indian students go abroad annually to pursue a medical degree, with the preferred countries being Russia, China, Georgia and Kyrgyzstan. These graduate doctors can practise in India only if the NMC recognizes their medical degree. Charging fees for recognition of foreign medical courses is common globally, including in the US, Canada and the UK. Given the limited number of 1.1 lakh MBBS seats in India, and about 2.5 million applicants vying for them, overseas medical education becomes the second choice for many. 'The NMC is doing this to ensure high medical standards in India. The fee helps in formalizing and streamlining the recognition process and ensuring only top-quality foreign qualifications are recognized,' an official familiar with the matter said. 'This amendment particularly impacts the 20,000-25,000 Indian students who study MBBS abroad annually.' The cost of studying medicine in Russia, China, Georgia and Kyrgyzstan ranges from ₹ 18 lakh to ₹ 48 lakh, depending on the course duration (5-6 years), university, city, and living expenses. International bodies such as the World Federation for Medical Education charge about $60,000 to recognize national accrediting agencies. The Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates in the US charges various fees to certify international medical graduates. Mint reported earlier that the government recently appointed a chairman and other key members to fill vacancies in four NMC boards that oversee the functioning of medical colleges in India. Queries sent to the health ministry spokesperson remained unanswered till press time.

From 'OUT INDIA' to 'WELCOME INDIA'. What changed for Muizzu in Maldives?
From 'OUT INDIA' to 'WELCOME INDIA'. What changed for Muizzu in Maldives?

Time of India

time4 hours ago

  • Time of India

From 'OUT INDIA' to 'WELCOME INDIA'. What changed for Muizzu in Maldives?

News • 2 days ago Jagdeep Dhankhar has suddenly resigned as Vice President, effective immediately, citing health concerns – two years before his term was set to end. This shocking move, coming right after the Monsoon Session began, has sparked intense speculation. Was it truly health-related, or was there more to his abrupt exit? Known for his outspoken views and frequent clashes with the judiciary and opposition, Dhankhar's tenure was tumultuous. From questioning Supreme Court rulings to allowing a motion for Justice Yashwant Varma's removal (after wads of cash were found at his home), his actions often stirred controversy. Now, the focus shifts to who will be the next Vice President of India. Names like Rajya Sabha deputy chairman Harivansh Singh are in the running, but social media is abuzz with other possibilities, from Nitish Kumar to Shashi Tharoor. The Constitution mandates that the vacancy must be filled "as soon as possible."

Al-Qaeda's Fake Currency Plot Busted in India
Al-Qaeda's Fake Currency Plot Busted in India

Time of India

time4 hours ago

  • Time of India

Al-Qaeda's Fake Currency Plot Busted in India

News • 2 days ago Jagdeep Dhankhar has suddenly resigned as Vice President, effective immediately, citing health concerns – two years before his term was set to end. This shocking move, coming right after the Monsoon Session began, has sparked intense speculation. Was it truly health-related, or was there more to his abrupt exit? Known for his outspoken views and frequent clashes with the judiciary and opposition, Dhankhar's tenure was tumultuous. From questioning Supreme Court rulings to allowing a motion for Justice Yashwant Varma's removal (after wads of cash were found at his home), his actions often stirred controversy. Now, the focus shifts to who will be the next Vice President of India. Names like Rajya Sabha deputy chairman Harivansh Singh are in the running, but social media is abuzz with other possibilities, from Nitish Kumar to Shashi Tharoor. The Constitution mandates that the vacancy must be filled "as soon as possible."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store