Advocates Call On Government To Act As Independent Children's Monitor Reveals Poorer Outcomes For Māori In Care
VOYCE – Whakarongo Mai has been advocating for care experienced tamariki since 2017, and CEO Tracie Shipton says unfortunately the report confirms what the organisation already knew.
'How Many More Reports Will It Take?'
As the first Aroturuki Tamariki | Independent Children's Monitor report into outcomes for tamariki and rangatahi Māori in care is released, care experienced advocates are questioning how to get policy makers to put politics aside and put children first.
130 young Māori and 1600 others who support them including whanau, caregivers, social workers and teachers informed the report, which revealed that while most tamariki Māori and their whānau have no involvement in the Oranga Tamariki system, when they do they're over-represented and being let down.
VOYCE – Whakarongo Mai has been advocating for care experienced tamariki since 2017, and CEO Tracie Shipton says unfortunately the report confirms what the organisation already knew.
'Aroturuki Tamariki have captured the experiences and perspectives of tamariki, rangatahi, whānau and professionals which has been shared in the hope of making a difference. They have dug deep into the data that surrounds young people's lives and tried to bring meaning to what it's telling us.'
'Unsurprisingly, they found that tamariki and rangatahi Māori are overrepresented in every part of the care system, and the deeper into the care system we look the greater this overrepresentation becomes. The least we can do to acknowledge them is to act on the information they've share in a timely fashion.'
The report also found a number of missed opportunities to intervene and invest earlier in these young people's lives to change and improve their outcomes.
'92% of tamariki referred for a Youth Justice Family Group Conference had a previous care and protection concern raised, just think what difference could have been made if they were offered more support following that initial notification.'
'Tamariki are ending up in Youth Justice interventions because we, the system and community, have not been able to address their early care and protection needs.'
VOYCE Care-Experienced Youth Participation Advisor Cameron McKay says the report reiterates the known link between adversity, trauma, discrimination, and so-called 'behavioural problems' in our young people.
'I think it's important these findings are brought into conversations about the shift toward punitive approaches to youth offending. The evidence is clear; address the issues that lead to youth offending in the first place, and stop criminalising traumatised and disenfranchised tamariki.'
'The report highlights the need to invest more into early intervention, frontline services, holistic/wraparound support, and iwi and community led initiatives.'
Among the grim findings there was a glimmer of positivity, that tamariki and rangatahi were hopeful for their future, but more could and should be done to help them realise these aspirations.
'The fact that our tamariki Māori feel aspirational and hopeful despite everything is a small salve, however this speaks more to their resilience and world view, than it does the system, as these aspirations are often unrealised, not by fault of our tamariki.'
Shipton agrees, and says this isn't the first report to tell us these things.
'Aroturuki Tamariki should be commended for their tenacity in seeking the views of young people at all times, but how many more reports and recommendations do we need before we start to see change?'
She wants to see the various agencies that work with young people to start making a difference and stop scrapping about who is responsible for which piece of the puzzle.
'How do we get our decision makers and leaders around the table to agree on a pathway forward based on the evidence of what is best for our tamariki rather than ideology or politics?'
'Something has to change.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Farming native wildlife: Could commercialisation boost conservation efforts?
However, weka are protected and considered a vulnerable species - there are thought to be between 70,000 to 120,000 weka. 'The weka is an interesting species in New Zealand because it's not quite endangered as other native species like the kākāpō or takahē.' He said New Zealand's conservation efforts were at a 'crossroads', with mounting ecological and funding challenges, requiring some number 'From an economic and institutional perspective, commercialisation presents an opportunity for self-sustaining species management through strategic resource redistribution throughout the conservation sector.' In international examples, such as buffalo in parts of Southern Africa and alligators in the United States, Mark said commercialisation had ultimately led to an increase in numbers for those animals. However, commercialisation could also lead to further population decline, like the overfishing of North Atlantic Cod off the coast of Newfoundland, Canada. Locally, he also drew from the tītī or muttonbird harvest experience; Rakiura Stewart Island whanau and hapū are able to harvest muttonbird between April 1 and May 31 each year. Though they are primarily harvested for cultural or customary purposes, they can also be sold commercially. Mark said it had worked 'quite successfully', noting the importance of any commercialisation aligning with Māori perspectives on the practice and the Treaty of Waitangi. 'It is the most distinctive example of ongoing sustainable native bird harvest in New Zealand.' Mark said that commercialisation offered a way for many different groups in New Zealand to become directly involved in conservation, including Māori, landowners and hunters. It could also allow for both conservation and economic gains, he said. He said a more detailed analysis would need to be worked through before such a policy was enacted. - RNZ
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Could farming native wildlife boost numbers? New research looks at how commercialisation might help
Weka Photo: (Flickr user Sid Mosdell CC BY 2.0) Could farming native wildlife like the weka be the key to helping boost their numbers? That's the focus of a recent research paper by a Victoria University of Wellington graduate who looked at how commercialising native species might help with conservation. Dray Mark said he first got the idea to look into this strategy after reading an old news article about a South Island farmer trying to farm and sell weka. Also known as the Māori or bush hen, there is a history of weka having been eaten in the past. However, weka are protected and considered a vulnerable species - there are thought to be between 70,000 to 120,000 weka. "The weka is an interesting species in New Zealand because it's not quite endangered as other native species like the kākāpō or takahē." He said New Zealand's conservation efforts were at a "crossroads", with mounting ecological and funding challenges, requiring some "outside the box" thinking. "From an economic and institutional perspective, commercialisation presents an opportunity for self-sustaining species management through strategic resource redistribution throughout the conservation sector." In international examples, such as buffalo in parts of Southern Africa and alligators in the United States, Mark said commercialisation had ultimately led to an increase in numbers of those animals. However, commercialisation could also lead to further population decline like the overfishing of North Atlantic Cod off the coast of Newfoundland, Canada. Locally, he also drew from the tītī or muttonbird harvest experience - Rakiura Stewart Island whanau and hapu are able to harvest muttonbird between 1 April and 31 May each year. Though they are primarily harvested for cultural or customary purposes, they can also be sold commercially. Mark said it had worked "quite successfully", noting the importance of any commercialisation aligning with Māori perspectives on the practice and the Treaty of Waitangi. "It is the most distinctive example of ongoing sustainable native bird harvest in New Zealand." Mark said that commercialisation offered a way for many different groups in New Zealand to become directly involved in conservation, including Māori, landowners and hunters. It could also allow for both conservation and economic gains, he said. He said more detailed analysis would need to be worked through before such a policy was enacted. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
99 Years young: Neil Olsen, the cheeky farmer who stole Zoe's heart
He worked in the Far North gum fields and later married Namaha Hakitara, daughter of Te Rarawa chief Hakitara of Peria – one of the Māori signatories to the Treaty of Waitangi in 1840. They bought farmland which was later taken over by their grandsons Neil and his brother Sid. Neil went on to marry Zoe and they raised six children on the farm. Neil an avid sportsman, played tennis, golf and rugby. He met Zoe on the tennis courts, he recalled. 'They put us together in mixed doubles. We were a bit cheeky to each other and yeah, from there it got serious.' They later got married and the couple continued playing tennis and golf together, always sharing laughs. Neil and Zoe Olsen's wedding was a joyous occasion attending by many Peria residents. Photo / Yolisa Tswanya Neil remembered the day they got married and said it was quite the affair. 'We got married at our local church, just down the road, and it was quite a big wedding. There were lots of people there. When we walked out the whole community was there, it was beautiful.' While being a year closer to a hundred and being married for 70 years were among his achievements Neil was proud of his golfing career. He scored a hole-in-one in 1994 and is proudly the oldest member of the Whangaroa Golf Club. Zoe said for as long as they have been married, they have always been there for each other. 'My mum has dementia, and my dad looks after her fulltime. That is love, you look after each other,' said one of their daughter's, Ava Herron, who lives nearby in Coopers Beach and checks in regularly on her parents. She said her parents were a great example to them and she was grateful for the life their parents gave them. Zoe Olsen and her daughter Ava Herron going down memory lane. Photo / Yolisa Tswanya 'We were very happy. We all had to work on the farm. It taught us kids to be quite self-sufficient. I think that was the best childhood. They have given us a lot of good values.'' Kaye Dragicevich has known the couple for over 20 years and said they have been long-cherished members of the Peria community. 'They are a much-loved couple who have earned deep respect and affection for generations of locals.' She remembers them fondly from her days working at the National Bank. 'Zoe, always thoughtful and kind, was known for creating beautiful bouquets and small gifts, often giving them to friends and neighbours just to brighten their day. Neil, ever active, remains a keen golfer and is proudly the oldest playing member of the Whangaroa Golf Club. Still driving and enjoying life.' She said Neil and Zoe have led rich and rewarding lives and she was happy to know them. 'As Neil celebrates his 99th birthday, the community of Peria joins in honouring a remarkable life of dedication, family, and quiet achievement. 'Together, Neil and Zoe have an enduring legacy – not only through the land they loved and worked, but through the warmth, kindness, and integrity with which they've touched so many lives. 'Congratulations Neil, Happy Birthday.' The family will be celebrating with a small get-together and has plans of a bigger party when Neil turns 100 next year.
