Legacy Act halted investigations into 202 Troubles-related killings of British soldiers
Hilary Benn, the Northern Ireland secretary, is expected to tell MPs on Monday afternoon that 202 live inquiries into the Troubles-related killings of members of the armed forces were brought to a stop in May 2024 and a further 23 involving veterans.
They include the case of Pte Tony Harrison, a paratrooper from London who was shot five times in the back and killed by the IRA in 1991 while watching television with his girlfriend. His murder has never been solved.
Andy Seaman, his brother, said he wanted to see Labour spell out how cases such as that of Harrison would be investigated once the Legacy Act was repealed – and hit out at the Conservatives for halting the murder inquiry in the first place.
'My brother's case was shut down when the Legacy Act passed. The opposition cannot pretend to care about the plight of victims' families – including military victims – when their actions demonstrate the precise opposite,' he said.
At the same time, another group of military veterans, in association with the Conservatives, are expected to stage a protest in Whitehall – fearing Labour's plans will reopen the possibility of more prosecutions against army veterans.
Conservatives sources said they believe the issue is a concern for 'red wall' voters in traditionally Labour-supporting working-class areas in Great Britain. Last week, Mark Francois, a shadow junior defence minister, accused Labour of 'selling veterans down the river' with its plans.
More than 170,000 people signed a petition backed by Francois, demanding Labour not make any changes to the law that would allow Northern Ireland veterans to be prosecuted – a level which means the subject has to be debated by MPs.
The debate is due to happen at Westminster Hall at 4.30pm with Benn responding for the government, demonstrating the significance of the issue. Normally, only junior ministers reply to debates in the lesser chamber.
The previous government's aim was to end what it said were vexatious prosecutions against British army veterans. To do so, it passed the Legacy Act halting all but the most serious allegations involving Troubles-related cases, including killings by paramilitaries, from being investigated any further.
Backlogs dating back decades mean there was never a police or coroner's investigation into a wide range of deaths during the Troubles – but the plan to halt almost all inquiries was met with opposition from both nationalist and unionist parties in Northern Ireland and the families of those affected.
Emma Norton, the director of the Centre for Military Justice, who represents Pte Harrison's family, said concerns about veterans being prosecuted were exaggerated, and there had only been 'a single conviction of a veteran since the Good Friday agreement' in 1998.
In September, the trial is due to begin of Soldier F, a former paratrooper, accused of two murders and five attempted murders on Bloody Sunday in 1972. Soldiers from the regiment fired on a peaceful civil rights demonstration in Derry, killing 13.
A government source said the Legacy Act passed by the Conservatives 'made false and undeliverable promises to our veterans about immunity' and blocked investigations into the unsolved killings of British troops in Northern Ireland.
'That is why the Legacy Act was opposed by many, including armed forces families who lost relatives serving in Northern Ireland. Any incoming government would have had to fix it,' they added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
16 minutes ago
- BBC News
Data shows immigration status of benefit claimants for first time
Data showing the immigration status of those claiming universal credit (UC) - a benefit designed to help both employed and unemployed people with living costs - has been published for the first June, nearly eight million people received universal credit, 83.6% of whom were British and Irish than a million claimants were born overseas, including around 700,000 EU citizens who arrived in the UK before Brexit and have the right to live and work in the 1.5% of claimants were refugees and 0.7% had arrived in the UK via safe routes such as those for Ukrainians and Afghans. More than 75,000 claimants who are in the UK temporarily and would typically not be able to receive benefits are also claiming UC. The BBC has asked the Department for Work and Pensions for more information. The figures were published following pressure from some Conservatives and the independent MP Rupert Lowe. A Downing Street spokesperson said the prime minister wanted to see the number of claimants reduced and insisted the government was "toughening up the system" by doubling the time a migrant has to wait before qualifying for permanent - or settled - status in the UK. They added that people in the UK illegally are not allowed to access UC. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said the "staggering figures" were "clear proof that the Labour government has lost control of our welfare system". "Under Kemi Badenoch, we've set out a clear, common-sense position. This is about fairness, responsibility and protecting support for those who've contributed to this country," he Conservatives have said foreign nationals should not get the personal independence payment (Pip) disability benefit or the health element of said the publication of the data was a "huge win" for those who had "relentlessly pushed for this".He described the levels of foreign nationals claiming UC as "absolute insanity" adding: "We cannot afford it. The country is BROKE."
Daily Mail
17 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Brits' immigration fears at highest level since Brexit referendum - with issue now seen as bigger than stalling economy
Brits' immigration fears have hit the highest level since the Brexit referendum, according to a poll. YouGov research has found 53 per cent view control of borders as one of the three biggest problems facing the country. That was up two points over the past week, and more than the 48 per cent who cited the economy among their their main concerns. The score for immigration is a peak since June 2016, when the UK voted to leave the EU. The findings will cause alarm in No10 as Keir Starmer struggles to get a grip on the Channel boats crisis. Legal net migration is also still running at eye-watering levels, although it has fallen from record highs. Sir Keir was heavily criticised over a 'migrant merry go round' deal with Emmanuel Macron last week that will see some Channel arrivals sent back to France - but the UK take an equivalent numbers of other asylum seekers. Labour has been struggling to counter the threat from Reform as Nigel Farage vows to take a tough approach on immigration. The insurgent party has been recording a clear lead in polls. Last week Mr Farage took to a boat in the Channel to witness people attempting the perilous crossing. The YouGov research found 48 per cent of Brits regarded the economy as the main concern, down four points in a week. A third cited health, 23 per cent crime, and 21 per cent defence. Some 18 per cent said the environment with the same mentioning wefare. Housing and tax worries were lower at 16 per cent and 14 per cent respectively.
Glasgow Times
37 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
No 10 says work on repealing Legacy Act ‘in lockstep' but minister may quit
Sir Keir Starmer's Government plans to repeal and replace the Legacy Act, brought in by the Conservatives in 2023 to halt investigations into all but the most serious allegations involving Troubles-related cases. Human rights groups criticised the act for providing immunity to British soldiers. But opponents to scrapping it fear that the changes will open up a 'two-tier' system in which IRA members are given immunity but British troops are open to prosecution. Veterans minister Al Carns is expected to quit over plans to repeal the law, The Times reported. A No 10 spokesman said the Government was 'working in lockstep' when asked if Mr Carns agreed with Sir Keir's approach, a No 10 spokesman said. 'The Government is always working in lockstep to deal with issues such as this, and we're working in lockstep to fix this issue and the mess that we were left.' 'And as I say, we will set out a process that gives veterans and their families confidence and sets out a process that's proportionate, that's not malicious, that has safeguards in place, and fixes the mess that we were left with. He said the Government was setting out a course that is 'lawful with fairness at its heart' and that 'we will always protect our veterans'.
