logo
Divorce: Even if wife is earning husband is liable to pay maintenance money to her in this condition; HC

Divorce: Even if wife is earning husband is liable to pay maintenance money to her in this condition; HC

Time of Indiaa day ago
How did this divorce maintenance case start?
November 28, 2012: The marriage took place.
May 2015: The wife left the matrimonial home and started residing with her parents.
June 2019: The husband filed a divorce petition in Bandra family court under Section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Hindu Marriage Act.
September 29, 2021: The wife filed an interim application for maintenance.
August 24, 2023: The family court decided to grant maintenance to the wife at the rate of Rs 15,000 per month from October 1, 2022 till the disposal of the petition.
What did the Bombay High Court say?
The claim of the Petitioner has been falsified by the salary slips annexed to the reply affidavit filed by the Respondent herein for the months of April 2022 and September 2022, which discloses his net pay as Rs 1,51,284 and Rs 1,17,338 respectively.
It also needs consideration that, though he claims that his parents are dependent on him, his own affidavit discloses that his father draws a pension of Rs 28,000 per month. Therefore, his parents are not financially dependent on him and in fact they must be contributing to the monthly maintenance of the family.
I find substance in the submission of the learned counsel for the Respondent that the Petitioner has not disclosed his true income in the affidavit of assets and liabilities. The salary slips placed on record disclose his income above Rs 1,00,000.
The Respondent-wife has disclosed her income to be Rs 18,000 per month from her salary as an Assistant Teacher working in a Convent School. Though it is claimed by the Petitioner that the Respondent-wife has an additional income from the interest of the Fixed Deposits, the interest is negligible. Even the income from tuition classes cannot be said to be a permanent source of income.
Bombay High Court final judgement
Judgement: 'I do not find the maintenance awarded by the Family Court is unreasonable or extreme. Hence, the impugned order passed by the Family Court does not warrant interference. In view of the aforesaid observations, the Writ Petition is hereby dismissed. Rule is discharged.'
Supreme Court precedent applied in this case
Status of the parties, social and financial.
Reasonable needs of the wife and the dependent children.
Parties' individual qualifications and employment statuses.
Independent income or assets owned by the applicant.
Standard of life enjoyed by the wife in the matrimonial home.
Any employment sacrifices made for responsibilities.
Reasonable litigation costs for a non-working wife.
Financial capacity of the husband, his income, maintenance obligations, and liabilities.
How did Bombay High Court apply the Supreme Court precedent in the present case?
In the present case though the wife is earning, the said income is not sufficient for her own maintenance since she has to travel daily a long distance for her job. She is staying with her parents which she cannot stay indefinitely.
Because of her meager earning, she is constrained to stay in the house of her brother along with her parents causing inconvenience and hardship to all of them. In such an income she is not in a position to live a decent life.
As against, it if compared against the Petitioner's income, his income is far more than the Respondent-wife's, with no financial responsibilities on him. Even assuming the certain expenses must be necessary for the maintenance of himself and the family members whom he is obliged to maintain, the amount that remains is sufficient enough to enable him to support the Respondent-wife as per the order passed by the Judge, Family Court at Bandra.
Merely because the wife is earning, she cannot be deprived of the support from her husband with the same standard of living to which she is accustomed to in her matrimonial home.
What is the significance of this judgement?
On June 18, 2025, a husband lost a divorce maintenance case in the Bombay High Court as the court held that merely because the wife is earning, she cannot be deprived of the support from her husband, especially when it comes to maintaining the same standard of living she was accustomed to in her matrimonial home.The husband argued that about three years into their marriage, things started to get tense. He alleged that she was throwing tantrums and treated him very badly. The husband also mentioned that he bought a new flat hoping it would be comfortable for her, but her attitude still did not change. She kept making demands that he just could not meet, which led him to file for divorce . Soon after the husband filed for divorce, the wife submitted a maintenance petition in court.The high court while hearing the maintenance petition noted that the husband lives in a posh locality in Mumbai and his father also gets pension while the wife is a school teacher and lives with her parents who in turn live at their brother's house.The Bombay High Court said: 'Because of her meager earning, she is constrained to stay in the house of her brother along with her parents causing inconvenience and hardship to all of them. In such an income she is not in a position to live a decent life. As against it, if compared against the Petitioner's (husband's) income, his income is far more than the Respondent-wife's, with no financial responsibilities on him.'The husband did not want to pay any maintenance money as he alleged that he might be earning a more than her but he had necessary expenses like looking after his senior citizen parents. The Bombay High Court agreed with his argument but said that the maintenance amount that the court ordered him to pay isn't so big that it will lead to financial issues for him.The Bombay High Court also applied the eight factors laid down by the Supreme Court in the Pravin Kumar Jain V/s. Anju Jain ((2025) 2 SCC 227) case for calculating maintenance money amount in divorce cases. These eight factors helped the court to determine how much money the husband should pay as maintenance.Check out the details below to know more about why this husband lost the case and the wife won. The legal arguments and insights from this case can help you in similar situations.According to the order of the Bombay High Court dated June 18, 2025, here are the details:The husband challenged this order and filed an appeal in the Bombay High Court.The Bombay High Court said:(No part of the judgement is changed and everything is as per what the court said)The Bombay High Court said: 'There is a huge disparity in the income of the Petitioner and the Respondent, which cannot be compared. The Respondent-wife is certainly entitled to be maintained with the same standard of living as she was accustomed to before their separation. While determining the quantum of maintenance, the considerations that are required to be taken into consideration are the income of the respective parties; their age; their responsibilities; their reasonable needs; necessities and income derived from other sources, if any.'The Bombay High Court said: 'A useful reference can be made to the recent decision of the Supreme Court in Pravin Kumar Jain V/s. Anju Jain. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in this judgment has once again reiterated the guidelines for fixing the amount of maintenance. Though it is observed that there cannot be a strict guidelines or fixed formula, but referring to the earlier judgments, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has provided the factors to be looked into while granting maintenance, which reads thus:The Bombay High Court said: 'The factors have been laid down on the basis of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rajnesh V/s. Neha and Anr. 2 as well as Kiran Jyot Maini V/s. Anish Pramod Patel.3 Applying the above factors to the fact of the present case, the wife needs to be granted maintenance from the income of the husband since her own income is insufficient for her maintenance.'The Bombay High Court said:ET Wealth Online has asked various lawyers about what might be the significance of this judgement, here's what they said:The Court, reaffirmed that mere employment of the wife does not absolve the husband of his statutory obligation to provide for her sustenance, especially where her earnings are insufficient to maintain a standard of living commensurate with that enjoyed during the subsistence of the matrimonial relationship.The ruling highlights that the principle of maintenance is not predicated solely on income but rather on the holistic assessment of the respective financial capacities of the parties, their standard of living, and reasonable needs.More importantly, the Court came down heavily on the suppression of material facts and misstatement of income by the Petitioner-husband, who had disclosed a drastically understated figure in his affidavit of assets and liabilities, which was palpably contradicted by salary slips placed on record by the Respondent.This judgment reinforces the guidelines set by the Hon'ble Supreme Court for grant of maintenance. Merely because a wife is working and having income is not sufficient for a husband to disclaim his liability to pay maintenance. For grant of maintenance, all the factors must be considered with the principle objective of maintaining the same standard of living that the wife was maintaining with the husband.This judgment reiterates the stand of the Supreme Court that even if the wife is educated and has an earning job , she is entitled to maintenance if her income is not sufficient to maintain the standard of living . This is a very significant ruling from the perspective of men. It raises alarming questions surrounding gender equality rights & men's rights. A rising trend of transferring all assets to parents before marriage is seen due to such judicial norms being mandated in the country.The Court while ascertaining the interim maintenance to be paid to wife will consider these additional factors in addition to income earned by husband:(a) Income of the parents of the husband(b) Standard of life enjoyed by the wife in the matrimonial home.(c) Reasonable needs of the wife.(d) Assets owned by the husband.Considering the position taken by Bombay High Court, the husband must be very conscious while appealing an interim order of maintenance and must not base the challenge only on the income earned by him and his wife. Husbands while litigating the maintenance orders must look into the income of the family as a whole and the standard of life enjoyed by the wife in the matrimonial home.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Pawan's vision fuels India's first ‘Smart Central Kitchen' in Kadapa
Pawan's vision fuels India's first ‘Smart Central Kitchen' in Kadapa

Hans India

time30 minutes ago

  • Hans India

Pawan's vision fuels India's first ‘Smart Central Kitchen' in Kadapa

Kadapa: YSR Kadapa district launched India's inaugural Smart Central Kitchen as part of the revamped Dokka Seethamma Midday Meal Scheme. The facility, set up at the municipal high School in Kadapa city, was made possible with personal support from Deputy Chief Minister K Pawan Kalyan and the leadership of district collector Dr Cherukuri Sridhar. This state-of-the-art kitchen is designed to serve nearly 2,200 students across 12 government schools with meals that are nutritious, hygienic, and tasty. The facility boasts hotel-grade infrastructure, automated cooking systems, dedicated spaces for vegetable cutting and grinding, proper storage, and waste management. A mobile app has been introduced to monitor both kitchen operations and food delivery, while the kitchen itself runs on methane gas generated from food waste. Dr Sridhar highlighted that the kitchen was built without putting extra strain on the state budget. 'This is part of our long-term vision to improve nutrition for school children across the district. Within the next six months, we plan to replicate this model in all mandals,' he said. Solar power units generating 3 kW have been installed at each kitchen, with round-the-clock monitoring through CCTV and a centralized control system. On July 24 and 25, four to five more Smart Kitchens will be launched in CK Dinne and Jammalamadugu mandals to ensure that all schools in these areas are covered, the Collector said. The idea for this transformation was sparked when Deputy CM Pawan Kalyan visited Kadapa during the first Mega Parents-Teachers Meeting in 2024. Disturbed by the outdated, firewood-based cooking methods in schools, he personally donated Rs 10 lakh to modernise the system. The construction of the smart kitchen was completed in time for the new academic year. Students have been quick to appreciate the change. 'The food is tastier than what we get at home,' said Kavya Sri, a Class 7 student. Class 8 student Shaik Mahir added, 'Now we eat to our heart's content with good quality rice and nutritious items like eggs, ragi malt, and sweet pongal.' Teachers have also praised the upgrade. Ruth Mary, an English teacher, said the meals now feel like a 'wedding feast,' noting that all students are now choosing to eat at school thanks to the improved quality and variety. Education Minister Nara Lokesh, who is leading reforms in school education, has directed officials to expand the smart kitchen model across the state. Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu is also said to be closely watching these developments, which are part of broader efforts to strengthen public schools and ensure quality education and nutrition for every student.

Cow gives birth to three calves in Hubbali, vets call it miracle
Cow gives birth to three calves in Hubbali, vets call it miracle

New Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • New Indian Express

Cow gives birth to three calves in Hubbali, vets call it miracle

NAVALGUND/DHARWAD: In a rarest of the rare instances, a cow at Gudadakeri Oni in Navlgund taluk gave birth to three calves on Friday. The mother cow and the calves are healthy. This has become the talk of the town and people are throning the house of the cow owner to see the cow and calves. Veterinary experts in the taluk expressed their joy and said, in their service, they had never heard or seen such a miracle. The owner of the cow, Abdul Razak, who has a lot of affection for cows, purchased the cow at Kittur cattle market in Belagavi district for Rs 70,000 two years ago. At present, he is having three more cows and three calves apart from the cow which has given birth to the triad. Speaking to TNIE, Razak said he is a farmer and looks after agricultural activities along with his father Sayad Basha Huggi. The cow is around five years old. Last year, veterinary doctor H P Savanur had performed artificial insemination. Of the three calves, two are male and one female. 'We have always believed that a cow brings good fortune and now, with the birth of the three calves, our belief has become stronger. In the earlier two lactations, the cow gave birth to a single calf each time. The mother cow is a cross breed of jersey and local bull. We used to feed some dairy products available for cattle and common fodder like grass. The cow has earned name and fame for us', he added.

Lottery Results Today Live, July 14, 2025: Punjab, Manipur, Sikkim, Goa & Arunachal Winners
Lottery Results Today Live, July 14, 2025: Punjab, Manipur, Sikkim, Goa & Arunachal Winners

News18

time3 hours ago

  • News18

Lottery Results Today Live, July 14, 2025: Punjab, Manipur, Sikkim, Goa & Arunachal Winners

Last Updated: Live July 14, 2025 Lottery Results: Lotteries in Punjab, Manipur, Goa, Sikkim, and Arunachal Pradesh continue to captivate players with daily draws and life-changing prizes. Live July 14, 2025 Lottery Results: Lotteries in Punjab, Manipur, Goa, and Arunachal Pradesh continue to draw enthusiastic participants from both urban and rural areas, all hoping for a chance at fortune. With distinct draws taking place at different times throughout the day, these states provide daily opportunities to win. Here's a detailed look at the upcoming lottery events across each region. Punjab State Dear 10 Gold Monday Weekly Lottery Scheme This lottery is officially authorised for sale in Punjab and in other states where lottery operations are legally permitted. First Prize: Rs 1 Lakh Number of Tickets: 1,00,000 tickets issued across ten series (90 to 99), with each series numbered from 0000 to 9999 Ticket Price: Rs 10 per ticket (inclusive of all taxes) Draw Schedule: Conducted every Saturday at 6:00 PM in Ludhiana, beginning October 7, 2023. The Director of Punjab State Lotteries holds the right to modify the date, time, or venue of the draw if necessary. Prize Claim & Payment Details For prizes exceeding Rs 10,000, claims must be submitted within 30 days from the date of result publication in the Punjab State Government Gazette. Submission methods include Claims submitted after the 30-day deadline will be processed in accordance with the Punjab State Lotteries Regulation Rules, 2015, and other applicable legal provisions. Manipur State Lottery The Manipur State Lottery hosts four daily draws as part of its Weekly Lottery scheme, with results announced at the following times: Each draw offers a grand prize of Rs 27 lakh, along with smaller cash prizes for the 2nd to 5th place winners. Additionally, a consolation prize of Rs 10,000 is awarded to winners from all series. Tickets are priced at just Rs 6 and can be purchased from authorised lottery retailers. Each ticket carries a unique alphanumeric code that includes: Example: 83B 87219 How to Check Today's Manipur Lottery Result Sikkim Labh laxmi Bliss Monday Lottery Result The Sikkim Labh Laxmi Bliss Monday Lottery Draw is scheduled for July 14, 2025, with the results set to be announced at 4:00 PM. Organized by the Sikkim State Lotteries, this popular weekly draw is also published by Lottery Sambad, making it widely accessible to participants across the country. The first prize for this draw is Rs 10,000, and tickets are priced at an affordable Rs 10, offering players a budget-friendly chance to win attractive rewards. How to Check the Sikkim Labh Laxmi Bliss Monday Lottery Result Goa Rajshree 30 Som Weekly Lottery Result The Goa Rajshree 30 Som Weekly Lottery Draw is set to take place on July 14, 2025, with results being declared at 8:30 PM. This weekly draw is a part of the Goa Rajshree Lotteries and is also published by Lottery Sambad, ensuring wide reach and accessibility for participants. The first prize for this draw is Rs 7 lakh, and tickets are priced at an affordable Rs 30, making it an attractive option for lottery enthusiasts. How to Check the Goa Rajshree 30 Som Weekly Lottery Result Visit the official Goa Rajshree Lotteries website Navigate to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Look for the result titled 'Goa Rajshree 30 Som Weekly Lottery Result 14.7.2025" Click on 'View Result' Match your ticket number with the winning numbers listed on the results page Goa Rajshree 50 Som Weekly Lottery Result The Goa Rajshree 50 Som Weekly Lottery Draw is scheduled for July 14, 2025, with the results set to be announced at 7:30 PM. Conducted under the Goa Rajshree Lotteries, this popular draw is also featured on Lottery Sambad, ensuring wide visibility and easy access for participants across the country. With a first prize of Rs 21 lakh and tickets priced at just Rs 50, this weekly draw offers an exciting and budget-friendly opportunity to win big. How to Check the Goa Rajshree 50 Som Weekly Lottery Result Visit the official Goa Rajshree Lotteries website Go to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Locate the result titled 'Goa Rajshree 50 Som Weekly Lottery Result 14.7.2025" Click on the 'View Result' link Match your ticket number with the list of winning numbers displayed Goa Rajshree Bumper Lottery Draws Apart from regular weekly draws, Goa Rajshree Lotteries also hosts special bumper lotteries throughout the year, including: Goa Rajshree Lohri Bumper Goa Rajshree Diwali Bumper Goa Rajshree Baisakhi Bumper Goa Rajshree Rakhi Bumper Goa Rajshree Sawan Bumper These festive bumper draws offer even larger prize pools, giving participants more chances to win during special occasions. Arunachal Dear 10 Blue Monday Lottery Result The Arunachal Dear 10 Blue Monday Lottery Draw is scheduled for July 14, 2025, with results to be announced at 1:30 PM. Organized by the Arunachal State Lotteries, this weekly draw is also featured on Lottery Sambad, ensuring broad accessibility for participants nationwide. Offering a first prize of Rs 1 lakh, the draw is both popular and affordable, known for its quick and reliable result announcements. How to Check the Arunachal Dear 10 Blue Monday Lottery Result Visit the official Arunachal State Lotteries website Navigate to the 'Today Lottery Result' section Find the listing titled 'Arunachal Dear 10 Blue Monday Lottery Result 14.7.2025" top videos View all Click on 'View Result' Match your ticket number with the winning numbers shown on the page. About the Author News Desk The News Desk is a team of passionate editors and writers who break and analyse the most important events unfolding in India and abroad. From live updates to exclusive reports to in-depth explainers, the Desk More Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated! view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 14, 2025, 09:45 IST News india Lottery Results Today Live, July 14, 2025: Punjab, Manipur, Sikkim, Goa & Arunachal Winners Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store