High Court challenges to 'super junior' ministers attending Cabinet set for July
A three-judge divisional court will hear the actions, starting on July 7th with Mr Daly's case, High Court president Mr Justice David Barniville said during a case management hearing on Wednesday.
Advertisement
Mr Murphy's case will commence immediately after the expected conclusion of Sinn Féin TD Mr Daly's case on July 9th, the president said.
Super junior ministers are appointed by the Government on the nomination of the Taoiseach. They participate at government meetings but do not vote.
Mr Daly's judicial review proceedings point to article 28 of Bunreacht na hÉireann, which limits the number of government members to 15th, including the Taoiseach.
He claims that in facilitating more non-Government Ministers of State at Cabinet, the Government is 'acting contrary' to the 15-person limit and the 'expressed wish of the people of Ireland'.
Advertisement
Mr Murphy is seeking an injunction restraining super junior ministers from attending Cabinet meetings. His case also points to the 15-person limit outlined in article 28 of the Constitution.
Both TDs are suing the Taoiseach, the Government, Ireland and the Attorney General. The State parties are fully defending the cases.
On Wednesday, Attorney General Rossa Fanning reiterated his side's assertion that Mr Murphy's case raises no legal issue that won't be addressed in Mr Daly's case.
He said Mr Murphy's side had not responded to their questions asking what legal question is raised by their case that is not raised in Mr Daly's case.
Advertisement
Mr Fanning acknowledged that he couldn't stop Mr Murphy's case from getting on, but asked the court to exercise its discretion, and to not fix the Dublin South-West TD's case for after Mr Daly's case.
Ireland
Super junior ministers gift €16,000 pay rise back...
Read More
John Rogers SC, appearing with Paul Gunning and Molly Higgins for Mr Murphy, said that their case would add 'a real dimension' to the court's appraisal and understanding of the Government's practice of including super junior ministers at Cabinet meetings.
Mr Murphy, former TD and minister of State Shane Ross and historian Diarmuid Ferriter are expected to give evidence for Mr Murphy's side.
Mr Justice Barniville, sitting with Ms Justice Siobhán Phelan and Mr Justice Conleth Bradley, said the court was persuaded that it was appropriate for Mr Murphy's case to be heard immediately after Mr Daly's.
Mr Justice Barniville said that running the case consecutively would be the best use of resources, including court time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Tánaiste to hold talks with Northern leaders over US trade deals
Tánaiste Simon Harris will hold talks with the leaders of the Northern Executive on trade deals with the US later on Thursday. A focus of the talks will be the prospect of two different tariff rates being applied on the island, which Mr Harris has warned will pose 'huge complexities' for businesses. Advertisement An agreement was recently reached that will see most goods exported from the EU to the US subject to a 15 per cent tariff. However, exports from Northern Ireland into the US are subject to a 10 per cent levy, under a separate deal made between the UK and the US. The talks with Northern politicians come ahead of a trade forum of business stakeholders in Government Buildings in Dublin on Friday. The forum has been called to map out the Republic's response to the announcement that 15 per cent tariffs will be applied on EU goods. Advertisement Ireland One-off payments for businesses 'not sustainable'... Read More A spokesperson for Mr Harris said: 'With a lower tariff rate of 10 per cent announced for the UK, the Tanaiste will seek the views of stakeholders as to the scale of the challenge that would be posed by two different rates.' Mr Harris is also expected to receive an update on Thursday from the EU's leading negotiator on trade, Commissioner Maros Sefcovic. They will discuss the ongoing work by the European Commission to agree a final negotiation text with the US, and whether exemptions may be granted for certain sectors.
BreakingNews.ie
2 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Gavin Pepper agrees to abide by certain orders but denies filming finance firm boss's son
Dublin city councillor Gavin Pepper has told the High Court he is prepared to abide by orders prohibiting him from attending or filming outside the homes of staff of credit servicing and asset management firm Pepper Finance Corporation. Cllr Pepper, an independent who was elected in the Ballymun/Finglas area, has denied he shot footage for social media outside Pepper managing director Ian Wigglesworth's west Dublin home or of the businessman's son, who has special needs. Advertisement He told the court he and his partner have a child with special needs themselves and had every sympathy with someone in the same situation. He also said that when he was outside the Wigglesworth home, he did not engage with Mr Wigglesworth's son, and it was the child who approached him while he was talking on the phone to his partner. On Tuesday, Mr Wigglesworth and Pepper were granted an interim injunction preventing the councillor from attending the Wigglesworth home or filming and watching him and his family or from publishing home addresses of Pepper employees. That application was made ex parte - meaning only the Wigglesworth/Pepper side was represented - and on Thursday Mr Pepper appeared himself, saying he wished to be given time to get legal representation. Advertisement Cllr Pepper, who is also a taxi driver, of Plunkett Green, Finglas, Dublin, was also required to remove social media posts which contain footage of videoing which took place outside Mr Wigglesworth's home. Brian Conroy SC, for Mr Wigglesworth and Pepper Finance, said Cllr Pepper has a well-established association with the far right and social media posts promoting far-right ideas. Mr Conroy said that while Mr Pepper had since Tuesday agreed to some of the orders, he did not seem prepared to delete certain social media posts or not attend homes of other Pepper employees. Cllr Pepper told Mr Justice Brian Cregan he was prepared to comply with most of the orders made on Tuesday, but he said a number of allegations had been made against him which were not true, including that he had recorded the Wigglesworth family. Advertisement However, certain orders now sought in relation to deleting posts would interfere with his role as a democratically elected representative and his constitutional right to free speech. He needed time to get legal representation, he said. Mr Conroy said his side was particularly concerned in relation to certain posts already up in relation to Mr Wigglesworth and his family. These and other posts were clearly threatening and crossed the line in relation to freedom of expression, counsel said. His claims about Mr Wigglesworth's son "rang hollow" when there was one video in which Cllr Pepper is clearly outside the Wigglesworth home and there is clear identification of a minor who is a member of that family. Advertisement Asked by the judge if he was prepared to abide by the order not to attend outside the homes of other Pepper employees, he said he was. Asked if he was prepared to take down four specific posts, Cllr Pepper said he wanted time to challenge it "because they are making out that I am a bad guy". He did not believe "anything I said was defamation". The judge said he had an absolute right to express any 'understandable grievances about vulture funds", but the business was saying some of the posts clearly crossed the line. Pepper Finance Corporation do not think they can be called a vulture fund, the court heard. Cllr Pepper agreed to a suggestion by the judge that he would take down the posts until the case returns before the court in October, when he will also have a chance to get a solicitor to argue his case in that respect. Advertisement Business Couple allege Pepper Finance is pursuing them over... Read More He also said he did not accept that he was some sort of bad person, and he thought looking for extra orders in this way was unfair before he got representation. The judge said he would have the opportunity to address what he felt was tarnishing his name and an unfair portrayal of him so far when he swears an affidavit. The judge said he would make an order in relation to taking four posts of June 12, July 24, 25 and 27 within seven days of making the order. He also made similar orders on Tuesday in relation to other Pepper employees. The orders must be complied with within seven days of them being formally made. He also gave both sides liberty to apply to the vacation courts should anything arise between now and October.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Conor McGregor loses appeal against civil jury's finding he sexually assaulted a woman
Mixed martial arts fighter Conor McGregor on Thursday lost his legal appeal against a civil court's finding that he sexually assaulted a woman at a Dublin hotel. In November a jury at the High Court in Dublin found McGregor liable for assaulting Nikita Hand, who says he 'brutally raped and battered' her in a hotel penthouse in 2018. He was ordered to pay Hand almost 250,000 euros ($285,000), as well as about 1.3 million euros ($1.5 million) in legal costs. Hand, 35, successfully sued McGregor in civil court after prosecutors declined to bring charges, saying there was insufficient evidence and a conviction was unlikely. The Associated Press generally does not name alleged victims of sexual violence unless they come forward publicly, as Hand has done. McGregor alleged that Hand fabricated the allegations after the two had consensual sex. He launched an appeal, but at a hearing earlier this month his lawyer unexpectedly withdrew a request to introduce new evidence. Three appeals court judges in Dublin on Thursday dismissed the appeal 'in its entirety.' Hand was in court for the ruling, but McGregor was not. The 37-year-old fighter, once the face of the Ultimate Fighting Championship but now past his prime in the ring, has become known for anti-immigration statements and criticism of Irish politicians. He has flirted with the idea of running for president of Ireland. U.S. President Donald Trump, a UFC fan, invited McGregor to the White House to mark St. Patrick's Day in March. McGregor also faces a lawsuit in Florida for allegedly sexually assaulting a woman in the bathroom of the Kaseya Center, home arena of the Miami Heat, during a 2023 NBA finals game with the Denver Nuggets.
