
Google undercounts its carbon emissions, report finds
In 2021, Google set a lofty goal of achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2030. Yet in the years since then, the company has moved in the opposite direction as it invests in energy-intensive artificial intelligence. In its latest sustainability report, Google said its carbon emissions had increased 51% between 2019 and 2024.
New research aims to debunk even that enormous figure and provide context to Google's sustainability reports, painting a bleaker picture. A report authored by non-profit advocacy group Kairos Fellowship found that, between 2019 and 2024, Google's carbon emissions actually went up by 65%. What's more, between 2010, the first year there is publicly available data on Google's emissions, and 2024, Google's total greenhouse gas emissions increased 1,515%, Kairos found. The largest year-over-year jump in that window was also the most recent, 2023 to 2024, when Google saw a 26% increase in emissions just between 2023 and 2024, according to the report.
'Google's own data makes it clear: the corporation is contributing to the acceleration of climate catastrophe, and the metrics that matter – how many emissions they emit, how much water they use, and how fast these trends are accelerating – are headed in the wrong direction for us and the planet,' said Nicole Sugerman, a campaign manager at Kairos Fellowship.
The authors say that they found the vast majority of the numbers they used to determine how much energy Google is using and how much its carbon emissions are increasing in the appendices of Google's own sustainability reports. Many of those numbers were not highlighted in the main body of Google's reports, they say.
After the report published, Google called its findings into question in a statement.
'The analysis by the Kairos Fellowship distorts the facts. Our carbon emissions are calculated according to the widely used Greenhouse Gas Protocol and assured by a third party. Our carbon reduction ambition has been validated by the leading industry body, the Science Based Targets initiative,' said a spokesperson, Maggie Shiels.
The authors behind the report, titled Google's Eco-Failures, attribute the discrepancy between the numbers they calculated and the numbers Google highlights in its sustainability reports to various factors, including that the firm uses a different metric for calculating how much its emissions have increased. While Google uses market-based emissions, the researchers used location-based emissions. Location-based emissions are the average emissions the company produces from its use of local power grids, while market-based emissions include energy the company has purchased to offset its total emissions.
'[Location-based emissions] represents a company's 'real' grid emissions,' said Franz Ressel, the lead researcher and report co-author. 'Market-based emissions are a corporate-friendly metric that obscures a polluter's actual impact on the environment. It allows companies to pollute in one place, and try to 'offset' those emissions by purchasing energy contracts in another place.'
The energy the tech giant has needed to purchase to power its data centers alone increased 820% since 2010, according to Kairos's research, a figure that is expected to expand in the future as Google rolls out more AI products. Between 2019 and 2024, emissions that came primarily from the purchase of electricity to power data centers jumped 121%, the report's authors said.
'In absolute terms, the increase was 6.8 TWh, or the equivalent of Google adding the entire state of Alaska's energy use in one year to their previous use,' said Sugerman.
Based on Google's current trajectory, the Kairos report's authors say the company is unlikely to meet its own 2030 deadline without a significant push from the public. There are three categories of greenhouse gas emissions – called Scopes 1, 2 and 3 – and Google has only meaningfully decreased its Scope 1 emissions since 2019, according to the Kairos report. Scope 1 emissions, which include emissions just from Google's own facilities and vehicles, account for only 0.31% of the company's total emissions, according to the report. Scope 2 emissions are indirect emissions that come primarily from the electricity Google purchases to power its facilities, and scope 3 accounts for indirect emissions from all other sources such as suppliers, use of Google's consumer devices or employee business travel.
'It's not sustainable to keep building at the rate [Google is] building because they need to scale their compute within planetary limits,' said Sugerman. 'We do not have enough green energy to serve the needs of Google and certainly not the needs of Google and the rest of us.'
Thirsty, power-hungry data centers
As the company builds out resource-intensive data centers across the country, experts are also paying close attention to Google's water usage. According to the company's own sustainability report, Google's water withdrawal – how much water is taken from various sources – increased 27% between 2023 and 2024 to 11bn gallons of water.
The amount is 'enough to supply the potable water needs for the 2.5 million people and 5,500 industrial users in Boston and its suburbs for 55 days', according to the Kairos report.
Tech companies have faced both internal and public pressure to power their growing number of data centers with clean energy. Amazon employees recently put forth a package of shareholder proposals that asked the company to disclose its overall carbon emissions and targeted the climate impact of its data centers. The proposals were ultimately voted down. On Sunday, several organizations including Amazon Employees for Climate Justice, League of Conservation Voters, Public Citizen and the Sierra Club, published an open letter in the San Francisco Chronicle and the Seattle Times calling on the CEOs of Google, Amazon and Microsoft to 'commit to no new gas and zero delayed coal plant retirements to power your data centers'.
'In just the last two years alone, your companies have built data centers throughout the United States capable of consuming more electricity than four million American homes,' the letter reads. 'Within five years, your data centers alone will use more electricity than 22 million households, rivaling the consumption of multiple mid-size states.'
In its own sustainability report, Google warns that the firm's 'future trajectories' may be affected by the 'evolving landscape' of the tech industry.
'We're at an extraordinary inflection point, not just for our company specifically, but for the technology industry as a whole – driven by the rapid growth of AI,' the report reads. 'The combination of AI's potential for non-linear growth driven by its unprecedented pace of development and the uncertain scale of clean energy and infrastructure needed to meet this growth makes it harder to predict our future emissions and could impact our ability to reduce them.'
The Kairos report accuses Google of relying 'heavily on speculative technologies, particularly nuclear power', to achieve its goal of net zero carbon emissions by 2030.
'Google's emphasis on nuclear energy as a clean energy 'solution' is particularly concerning, given the growing consensus among both scientists and business experts that their successful deployment on scale, if it is to ever occur, cannot be achieved in the near or mid-term future,' the report reads.
The Kairos report alleges the way that Google presents some of its data is misleading. In the case of data center emissions, for example, Google says it has improved the energy efficiency of its data centers by 50% over 13 years. Citing energy efficiency numbers rather than sharing absolute ones obscures Google's total emissions, the authors argue.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
13 hours ago
- CTV News
Eco-friendly night market offers conscientious shopping in northeast Calgary
An eco-friendly night market took place Saturday at Renfrew Community Association in northeast Calgary A night market with an ethical twist was held Saturday at Renfrew Community Association. Change Makers Collective annual eco-friendly night market doubled in size in 2025, offering more than 40 curated and eco-vetted vendors, selling an array of vintage and upcycled clothes, handmade jewellery, ceramics, prints, small-batch skincare, aromatherapy, low-waste art, home goods and decor. Event organizer Adriane Gerrard-Gauthier said every vendor is vetted before being accepted to the night market. 'They're either providing recycled or recyclable packaging, low packaging, no packaging, everything,' said Gerrard-Gauthier. '(There's) very little plastic, and there's very little waste from their production methods. 'People are kind of surprised, because it's everyday products. It's nothing quirky. I mean, we do have quirky, but it's not super niche stuff. It's everyday products, and just making a small effort can make a huge difference.' For more about Change Makers Collective, go here. With files from CTV's Darren Wright


CBC
21 hours ago
- CBC
Will we have thinking robots by 2030? Or is this just hype from big tech?
These days many people use artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots for everything from dinner suggestions to battling loneliness, but could humanity be on the cusp of creating machines that can think for themselves — and potentially outthink their creators? Some big tech companies say that kind of breakthrough, referred to as general artificial intelligence (AGI), is just a few years away. But skeptics say you shouldn't believe the hype. "Whenever you see someone talking about AGI, just [picture] the tooth fairy, or like Father Christmas," said Ed Zitron, host of the tech podcast Better Offline and creator of the Where's Your Ed At? newsletter. "These are all fictional concepts, AGI included. The difference is you have business idiots sinking billions of dollars into them because they have nothing else to put their money into," he told The Current. Experts disagree on the fine details of what counts as AGI, but it's generally considered to be an artificial intelligence that is as smart or smarter than humans, with the ability to learn and act autonomously. That intelligence could then be installed in a robot body that could complete a multitude of tasks. WATCH | Google's humanoid robot can pack your lunch: Demis Hassabis, CEO of Google's AI lab DeepMind, recently said that his company will achieve AGI by 2030. "My timeline has been pretty consistent since the start of DeepMind in 2010, so we thought it was roughly a 20-year mission and amazingly we're on track," he told the New York Times in May. Zitron isn't convinced. He said that Hassabis is "directly incentivized" to talk up his company's progress, and pointed to uncertainty about the profitability of AI chatbots like Google's Gemini or OpenAI's ChatGPT. "None of these companies are really making any money with generative AI … so they need a new magic trick to make people get off their backs," he said. AGI 'always 10 years away' AI expert Melanie Mitchell says people have been making predictions about this kind of intelligent AI since the 1960s — and those predictions have always been wrong. "AGI or the equivalent is always 10 years away, but it always has been and maybe it always will be," said Mitchell, a professor at the Santa Fe Institute in New Mexico who specializes in artificial intelligence, machine learning and cognitive science. She said there isn't a universal agreement about what a working AGI should be able to do, but it shouldn't be confused with large language models like ChatGPT or Claude, which are a type of generative AI. Large language models (LLMs) that power generative AI programs have been trained on "a huge amount of human-generated language, either from websites or from books or other media," and as a result are "able to generate very human-sounding language," she told The Current. Zitron said that distinction is important, because it highlights that "generative AI is not intelligence, it is calling upon a corpus of information" that it's been fed by humans. He defines AGI as "a conscious computer … something that can think and act for itself completely autonomously," and has the ability to learn. "We do not know how human consciousness works," he said. "How the heck are we meant to do that with computers? And the answer is, we do not know." Mitchell worries that without a widely agreed definition, there's a risk that big tech companies will "redefine AGI into existence." "They'll say, 'Oh, well, what we have here, that's AGI. And therefore, we have achieved AGI,' without it really having any deeper meaning than that," she said. AGI could be 'a suicide race' There are people outside the tech industry who believe AGI could be within reach. "If our brain is a biological computer, well, then that means it is possible to make things that can think at human level," said Max Tegmark, a professor at MIT and president of the Future of Life Institute, a non-profit that aims to mitigate the risks of new technologies. "And there's no law of physics saying you can't do it better," he said. Tegmark thinks there's a hubris or excessive pride in asserting that AGI can't be achieved, in the same way that many people once thought human flight was impossible. Some early inventors had tried in vain to create machines that mimicked the rapid wingbeats of smaller birds. But success came with a greater understanding of birds' wings, and the idea of a machine that glides instead. "It turned out it was a much easier way to build flying machines," Tegmark said. "We've seen the same thing happen here now, that today's state-of-the-art AI systems are much simpler than brains. We found a different way to make machines that can think." Tegmark says he wouldn't be too surprised if "it happened in two to five years," but that doesn't mean we necessarily should create robots that can outthink humans. He described these intelligent machines as a new species, one that could easily threaten humanity's place in the food chain "because it's natural that the smarter species takes control." WATCH | Teaching AI literacy to the next generation: Teaching AI literacy to the next generation 7 months ago A group of Calgary high school students is offering free courses on artificial intelligence to younger students. The classes are open to kids in grades seven to 10, take place at the University of Calgary library, and aim to teach students how to responsibly use AI tools like ChatGPT. "[The] race to build superintelligence is a suicide race, but we don't need to run that race," he said.


Globe and Mail
2 days ago
- Globe and Mail
5 Brilliant Growth Stocks to Buy Now and Hold for the Long Term
Key Points Alphabet's AI strengths are being overlooked by the market. Amazon is using AI behind the scenes to become more efficient and drive growth. Meta Platforms and Pinterest are both using AI to drive advertising revenue growth. 10 stocks we like better than Alphabet › The artificial intelligence (AI) boom continues to drive growth and transform industries, but it's not just infrastructure players that are benefiting. Some of the best long-term opportunities are with companies deploying AI behind the scenes. Let's look at five brilliant AI-related growth stocks to buy and hold for the long haul. 1. Alphabet Investors continue to underestimate Alphabet (NASDAQ: GOOG)(NASDAQ: GOOGL), as they worry about AI disrupting its search business. But that view ignores what Google, its major component, actually does. This is a company built around content discovery -- not just traditional search -- and it's integrating AI into tools billions of people already use. And no other company is better at monetizing that content discovery through advertising than Alphabet. Its search data and digital ad network just cannot be matched. The Chrome browser and Android operating system give it unmatched distribution; Chrome is the default search engine on the majority of devices, giving it a huge built-in advantage. And a recent Oppenheimer survey revealed that users found Google Search's new AI Mode more helpful than not only traditional search but also ChatGPT. YouTube remains the world's largest ad-supported streaming platform. Google Cloud, Alphabet's cloud computing unit, is growing fast, helping companies build, train, and run AI models. Google is also becoming a chip leader. Its Tensor Processing Units (TPUs) are helping to power AI development, while its Willow quantum computing chip may be a future growth driver. And Alphabet subsidiary Waymo is expanding its robotaxi footprint. Taken altogether, Alphabet is one of the most innovative companies in the world, and one you want to own. 2. Amazon Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN) is using AI to become even more dominant. While it's best known for e-commerce and cloud computing, the company's behind-the-scenes work is where the real long-term value is being built. On the logistics and warehouse side, Amazon is using AI to determine where to store inventory, create more efficient delivery routes, and even navigate hard-to-find drop-off points. Its robotics division just passed 1 million deployed units, and some of its AI-powered robots can detect damaged products or even repair themselves. Amazon also created a new AI model called DeepFleet that coordinates its entire robot fleet to help boost throughput. The company's largest and fastest-growing business is Amazon Web Services (AWS). It helps customers build AI models and apps with tools like Bedrock and SageMaker, and then has them run those programs on its infrastructure. It's also developed custom AI chips that give it a cost advantage, and continues to invest in AI infrastructure to meet rising demand. Overall, Amazon is well positioned for an increasingly AI-focused world. 3. Meta Platforms Meta Platforms (NASDAQ: META) owns one of the world's most valuable digital advertising businesses, and AI is making it better. Its Llama models are driving more engagement across Facebook and Instagram, boosting user time spent on the apps. That gives Meta more ad inventory to sell. It's also using AI to help advertisers create better campaigns and target potential customers, which is increasing demand and leading to higher ad prices. But Meta's growth story is just getting started. The company is only now beginning to serve ads on WhatsApp, which has over 3 billion users. It's also rolling out ads on Threads, its new social platform, which had 350 million users at the end of the first quarter. With two massive platforms still early in their monetization cycles and AI continuing to drive performance, Meta looks like a long-term winner in the AI-powered digital economy. But the company is not stopping there. CEO Mark Zuckerberg is spending aggressively to poach top AI talent. This is all part of an effort to -- as Zuckerberg says -- "deliver personal superintelligence to everyone in the world." If it's successful, Meta could become the top AI stock to own. 4. Pinterest Meta isn't the only social media company using AI to drive growth. Pinterest (NYSE: PINS) has been using AI to evolve into a more shoppable and advertiser-friendly platform. The company has built a multimodal model that understands both images and text, allowing for better personalization and powering new features like visual search. Users can now click on items within images and shop for similar products directly, making Pinterest far more transactional and more attractive to both users and advertisers. It's also working to simplify advertising on its platform. Performance+, its new AI-powered ad product, automates everything from campaign creation to targeting and bidding. That makes the platform easier to use for advertisers and helps them save time and drive better outcomes. Pinterest has a global user base that has historically been undermonetized, especially compared to those of its peers. But with AI improving engagement, search, and ad performance, the company has a big opportunity to start to close that gap. If it can continue executing on its vision of merging content discovery with commerce, Pinterest could be a breakout growth story over the long term. 5. Toast Toast (NYSE: TOST) has become one of the leading software platforms for the restaurant industry. What started as simply a point-of-sale system is now a full-stack software platform that helps restaurants streamline operations and drive more sales. Its newest tools -- like the AI-powered intelligence engine ToastIQ and the agent and assistant Sous Chef -- are designed to help restaurants make better decisions in real time. Meanwhile, the company said a restaurant piloting its new menu upsell tool saw average order volume increase by 6%, while another restaurant group testing its new AI-powered advertising tool saw more than a "10x return on ad spend" with Google Ads. Toast directly benefits from its customers' success, earning a cut of sales through payment processing. That creates a strong alignment between the business and its customers, so the company continues to innovate to help drive restaurant sales. Toast added 6,000 new locations in Q1 and now serves more than 140,000 restaurants. It's also expanding into chains like Applebee's and Topgolf, as well as adjacent verticals like hotel food service and retailers. It's slowly expanding overseas as well. Toast's pace of innovation and expanding customer base give it a long runway of growth. This makes it a growth stock you want to own for the long term. Should you invest $1,000 in Alphabet right now? Before you buy stock in Alphabet, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Alphabet wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $636,774!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $1,064,942!* Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor's total average return is 1,040% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 182% for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join Stock Advisor. See the 10 stocks » *Stock Advisor returns as of July 21, 2025