logo
Waste firm given go-ahead to sue government

Waste firm given go-ahead to sue government

Yahoo28-01-2025
A judge has ruled that a £166m legal claim against the Scottish government over the failed deposit return scheme can go ahead.
Ministers effectively dropped plans for a Scotland-specific bottle return initiative in June 2023 following a dispute with the UK government.
Biffa Waste Services, which had been hired to collect recycled containers, argued in the Court of Session that ministers assured it the scheme would go ahead - and lost out when it was cancelled.
Ministers denied the firm's arguments and said the case should be thrown out of court.
Biffa, which is seeking up to £166.2m in reparations, says the government breached a duty of care and was negligent when it claimed the scheme was viable.
In a written statement, Lord Clark said ministers had been unable to convince him that Biffa's pleadings "do not disclose circumstances giving rise to a duty of care".
The judge also dismissed an argument from ministers that even if the court did accept they had been negligent and had a duty of care, the case should be thrown out because Biffa's case was "irrelevant" to the legal arguments it made.
He said that to win damages the waste firm would have to convince the court there was a duty of care, that it was breached and that it caused financial losses.
Biffa would have to prove that the firm relied on a written assurance given by former Green minister Lorna Slater about the scheme's viability, and that this led to financial losses.
Lord Clark said "questions remain" about the costs incurred by Biffa, and the amount of future profits it lost out on.
The judge said there should now be a full hearing to examine the arguments in more detail.
Biffa's financial claim includes about £115m in projected profits over a 10-year contract with Circularity Scotland, a non-profit company funded by the drinks industry which was supposed to manage the scheme.
It collapsed with debts and liabilities of more than £86m when the initiative was postponed.
Biffa is also seeking about £50m it said it spent in preparation for the scheme - including buying vehicles and specialist equipment, leasing vehicle depots, processing sites and taking on extra staff.
The deposit return scheme was a headline ambition of the former SNP-Green administration at Holyrood following the 2021 election.
Under the plans, a 20p deposit was be added to all single-use drinks containers made of PET plastic, metal or glass. Consumers could reclaim the deposit by returning the containers to retailers or to specially-designed reverse vending machines.
It was due to be introduced in August 2023 but the launch date was pushed back, with then first minister Humza Yousaf citing concerns from businesses.
A further stumbling block came when Conservative ministers at Westminster refused to grant the scheme the go-ahead unless it conformed to a UK-wide approach excluding glass.
In June 2023 Slater said she had no choice but to delay the scheme until at least October 2025, accusing the UK government of sabotage. She left government last year following the collapse of the Green-SNP power-sharing agreement.
Scotland is not expected to have a deposit return scheme until October 2027 at the earliest, when the UK government aims to launch its own version of the scheme, excluding glass.
Holyrood ministers are expected to align their return scheme to match Westminster's version, though Wales has pulled out of a UK-wide approach because it wants to include glass.
Following a freedom of information request, the Scottish government revealed earlier this month that it had spent £168,000 on legal fees related to the case brought by Biffa.
A spokesperson said it could not comment on live litigation.
A spokesperson for Biffa said: "We are pleased to have received approval from the Court of Session to proceed with legal action to seek appropriate compensation for the losses Biffa has incurred."
Why is SNP government facing £170m court case over recycling scheme?
Why has Scotland's deposit return scheme been delayed?
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump's trip to Scotland: What to know
Trump's trip to Scotland: What to know

The Hill

time13 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Trump's trip to Scotland: What to know

President Trump departed Friday for a five-day stay in Scotland, where he is expected to meet with British and Scottish officials and visit his properties there. The White House has described the trip as a 'working visit,' pointing to planned discussions with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer about a trade agreement between the U.S. and the United Kingdom. But Trump will visit his properties at Turnberry and Aberdeen, giving a publicity boost to his personal golf courses and his family's brand while overseas. Here's what to know about Trump's visit. Talking trade with the UK Trump told reporters while leaving for Scotland that he would be meeting with United Kingdom Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Friday evening, expecting that the two will work through more aspects of the trade deal they struck in May. 'We're meeting with the prime minister tonight. We're going to be talking about the trade deal that we made and maybe even approve it,' Trump said. He added, 'we want to talk about certain aspects, which is going to be good for both countries. More fine-tuning. Also, we're going to do a little celebrating together, because, you know, we got along very well. U.K.'s been trying to make a deal with us for like, 12 years, and haven't been able to do it. We got it done, and he's doing a very good job, this prime minister. Good guy.' Last month, Trump and Starmer detailed the trade agreement together while at the Group of Seven (G7) summit in Canada after they first announced it in May. The deal includes 'billions of dollars of increased market access for American exports, especially for beef, ethanol, and certain other American agricultural exports,' according to the order, and includes a stipulation that the U.S. will create an annual quota of 100,000 cars for U.K. imports at a 10 percent tariff rate. It also stipulates that the U.K. remains committed to 'working to meet American requirements on the security of the supply chains of steel and aluminum products,' which would prompt the U.S. to 'promptly construct a quota at most-favored-nation rates for steel and aluminum articles.' The U.K. agreement was the first trade deal announced since Trump imposed tariffs on trading partners, although it was in the works before then. This week, Trump has also announced deals with Japan, Indonesia and the Philippines and the administration has continued talks with the European Union. In addition to meeting with Starmer, Trump is slated to meet with First Minister of Scotland John Swinney during his visit. 'We have a lot of things in Scotland,' Trump said. 'I have a lot of love, my mother was born in Scotland. And he's a good man.' Spotlight on Trump's properties and possible protests While the White House has billed Trump's trip as a working visit to Scotland, critics have highlighted how the president is once again mingling politics with his business interests. Trump owns two golf courses in Scotland— one in Aberdeen that opened in 2012, and one at Turnberry that opened in 2014. He is slated to celebrate the opening of a third on the trip. The new 18-hold course is outside of Aberdeen and will be named after his mother, Mary Anne MacLeod, who was born in Scotland. Ethics watchdogs and Democrats have accused Trump of blatantly profiting off of the presidency, pointing to the launch of a cryptocurrency, Trump-branded sneakers and Bibles and a line of fragrances, among other ventures. Visits to Trump properties tend to generate scrutiny, as the government pays for Secret Service and other White House staff to stay there as well. Trump is also expected to be greeted with protests during his stay in Scotland. A 'Stop Trump' coalition is organizing demonstrations in Aberdeen on Saturday, and in Edinburgh outside the U.S. consulate. Trump experienced protests during his last presidential visit to his Turnberry golf course in 2018, when groups gathered outside the property to boo the president and demonstrators flew a paraglider around the area with a message criticizing him. Trump left Washington amid GOP turmoil over Epstein Trump headed out of Washington while calls for the release of more materials related to deceased financier Jeffrey Epstein have grown. Trump said he hasn't thought about pardoning Ghislaine Maxwell on Friday morning, as she was set to meet for a second day with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche at the Tallahassee prison where she's serving her sentence. He also told reporters they should be focused on other Epstein associates and other topics, and suggested that he has a list of people who were associated with Epstein, other than him, that he could give to the media. 'People should really focus on how well the country's doing or they should focus on the fact that [former President] Barack Hussein Obama led a coup or they should focus on the fact that [former Treasury Secretary] Larry Summers from Harvard, that [former President] Bill Clinton, who you know very well, and lots of other friends, really close friends of Jeffrey [Epstein] should be spoken about,' Trump said. 'They don't talk about them, they talk about me. I have nothing to do with the guy,' he added. The Trump administration is facing increasing pressure to release more information from the Epstein files after the Justice Department earlier this month released a memo stating that Epstein killed himself and did not keep a client list. Attorney General Pam Bondi had previously said such files were on her desk. The House broke for its weeks-long August Recess one day early this week, while Republican leadership have tried to contain furor over the handling of the Epstein-related materials.

Caitlin Clark rookie basketball card sells for record $660,000
Caitlin Clark rookie basketball card sells for record $660,000

UPI

time13 minutes ago

  • UPI

Caitlin Clark rookie basketball card sells for record $660,000

July 25 (UPI) -- A Caitlin Clark rookie card sold for $660,000 at auction, setting a record for the priciest women's sports card in history, Fanatics Collect announced Friday. The sale of the 1 of 1 Caitlin Clark Flawless Logowoman broke the previous mark of $366,000, which also was set by a Clark card -- her 2024 Prizm Gold Vinyl 1/1 rookie. The latest card's sale price is nearly double the value of Clark's four-year, $338,056 contract with the Indiana Fever. The Fever guard inscribed the card with her autograph and the words "769 pts and counting," a reference to her rookie scoring total from 2024. The card also features the WNBA patch from one of her uniforms. Clark, 23, averaged 16.5 points, 8.8 assists, 5.0 rebounds and 1.6 steals per game through her first 13 appearances this season. The two-time All-Star logged 19.2 points, 8.4 assists, 5.7 rebounds and 1.3 steals per game over 40 appearances during her Rookie of the Year campaign. BREAKING: The Caitlin Clark Flawless Logowoman 1/1 has just sold for $660,000 It has broke the previous women's sports card record of $366,000 - set by her own 2024 Prizm Gold Vinyl 1/1 rookie auto. This card, inscribed with "769 pts and counting" - her rookie season total -... Fanatics Collect (@FanaticsCollect) July 25, 2025 Clark, who hasn't played since July 15, missed 12 of the Fever's first 25 games this season due to injuries. The Fever said Thursday that she has no timetable for return as she recovers from a groin issue. The Fever beat the Las Vegas Aces 80-70 on Thursday in Indianapolis to improve to 5-7 in games played without Clark this season. They 13-12 record and sit in sixth place in the WNBA standings, behind the first-place Minnesota Lynx, New York Liberty, Phoenix Mercury, Seattle Storm and Atlanta Dream. The Fever will play the 11th-place Chicago Sky (7-17) at 3 p.m. EDT Sunday in Chicago.

Caitlin Clark's WNBA Rookie Card Fetches Record $660,000 at Auction
Caitlin Clark's WNBA Rookie Card Fetches Record $660,000 at Auction

Fox Sports

time13 minutes ago

  • Fox Sports

Caitlin Clark's WNBA Rookie Card Fetches Record $660,000 at Auction

Caitlin Clark has set yet another record, this time with her 2024 WNBA rookie card selling for the most money yet for a female athlete at a public auction. Clark's Rookie Royalty WNBA Flawless Logowoman 1/1 card sold Thursday night for $660,000. That sale price tops the previous mark of $366,000 for Clark's 2024 Panini Prizm WNBA Signatures Gold Vinyl 1/1 PSA 10 in March. The card that sold Thursday night is signed and inscribed with Clark's scoring total for her rookie season. The card also includes a Logowoman patch seen on WNBA jerseys, making such cards a top pick for collectors. This card entered extended bidding at $336,000 before reaching the final sale price. The Flawless Logowoman was one of seven Clark cards sold at Fanatics Collect on Thursday night and one of four cards from Panini America's 2024 Rookie Royalty WNBA collection. Now 14 cards featuring Clark have sold at public auction easily topping her salary this season with the Indiana Fever, with the latest going for more than Clark is scheduled to make over her rookie contract with Indiana. This mark may be challenged Aug. 9 when an Immaculate Logowoman 1/1 Clark card is scheduled for sale. The price for that card was at $180,000 on Thursday night before a buyer's premium on 17 bids. Reporting by The Associated Press. Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account, and follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily! FOLLOW Follow your favorites to personalize your FOX Sports experience Women's National Basketball Association Indiana Fever Caitlin Clark Get more from the Women's National Basketball Association Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store