JD Wetherspoon gets green light for acoustic screen at Camden St site
The planning green light overturns a decision by Dublin City Council earlier this year to refuse planning permission after local residents objected, claiming that the application would turn a 'super-pub' into a 'mega-pub' by reopening the courtyard.
JD Wetherspoon closed its beer garden at the venue in April 2022 in response to locals' noise complaints over its operation and the beer garden has remained closed.
In response to the JD Wetherspoon planning appeal, the planning commission has granted planning permission after concluding that the works are "modest in scale and due to the sensitive design, do not detract from the setting of the protected structures".
The order stated that the Commission was satisfied that the proposed works in combination with mitigation measures, would address the issue of noise and its impact on the amenity of the adjoining property.
The commission stated that it took into account the totality of information including both the applicant's and observers' noise expert reports submitted.
In conditions attached to the permission, the planning commission states that the capacity of the courtyard will be limited to 135 persons and it will operate from 10am to 11pm "to protect residential amenity".
The commission has also attached a condition that there will be no music within this application area directed into the external area.
The planning commission has also ordered that there will be no outbreak of amplified music from any activities at nearby noise sensitive locations.
JD Wetherspoon will also be required to carry out further acoustic monitoring post commencement of the use of the beer garden to ensure that the patron noise levels projected within the acoustic report are being compiled with.
The commission stated that the applicant had demonstrated that the physical interventions, the monitoring of noise and the management of the facility to ensure compliance with the operational mitigation measures would protect the residential amenity of properties in the vicinity.
The 13ft high acoustic glass screen is the firm's second bid to address the noise complaints - in 2023, JD Wetherspoon abandoned plans to erect a 43ft high sound barrier, dubbed "taller than the Berlin Wall" by one objector, after strong local opposition.
In an objection lodged with the Council, on behalf of the West of Camden Residents Association, James Wickham stated that the opening of the court-yard would mean that the super-pub would become a mega-pub "which is totally unsuitable to Camden Street's scale and character".
JD Wetherspoon spokesman, Eddie Gershon said on Wednesday: "As you would expect, we are very pleased that An Bord Pleanala has granted the appeal.
He said: "We do not yet have a date for the works to the garden to commence, but we hope to get started as soon as possible.
Mr Gershon said: "We will endeavour to keep our neighbours and the relevant authorities fully briefed when we have more information".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
After 20 years of neglect, a notorious Dublin building can finally be brought back to life
The redevelopment of one of Dublin city's most notorious derelict buildings as a potential template for inner-city regeneration recommended by the Taoiseach's Dublin taskforce can finally proceed following the resolution of an ownership dispute. Dublin City Council has become the legal owner of the former Neary's pub and hotel at 77-78 Parnell Street, after the High Court dismissed judicial review proceedings against the council's acquisition of the buildings under the Derelict Sites Act. The prominent Victorian building close to the O'Connell Street end of Parnell Street has been vacant for at least 20 years and has become increasingly derelict over the last decade. In 2015 it was taken over by squatters claiming to be anarchists and the building was given the moniker the Barricade Inn. The squatters stayed for almost a year before being evicted by order of the High Court in 2016 following an application by Vandelure Ltd, a company with a freehold interest in the property. READ MORE The company at the time said the eviction was essential because the building was in an extremely dangerous condition and the floors on each level had rotted and partially fallen through. The building, a protected structure, mostly dates from the 1850s when it was developed as a hotel. However, substantial parts of the structure are at least 100 years older, with a mid-18th-century staircase in the centre of it. It had previously been operated as a guest house by Ellen McGuill, who died in 2002, with the property understood to have been left to Scottish Catholic clergy. But the will was never executed due to McGuill having no known living relatives to enact it, with a series of legal issues following. Vandelure had during the 2016 court proceedings said it intended to sell the building, but this did not happen and the company was dissolved in March 2021. The council placed the property on a derelict register in December of 2021 and subsequently moved to acquire it under the Derelict Sites Act. The 'vesting orders', which confer all rights and titles to the building to the council, came into force in May 2024. However, these orders were challenged in the High Court by Telstar Investments, which had earlier acquired the property. Telstar, which is connected to publican and hotelier Noel Murray, who owns several venues in the city centre including Fibber Magees next door to Neary's, had sought to have the vesting order quashed. [ Derelict Dublin: Too often, it feels like a place designed by people who despise its inhabitants Opens in new window ] The High Court this month ruled that the company was outside the time limitation for taking the challenge, there was no 'good and sufficient reason' for the delay in taking the challenge and the delay was not outside the company's control. The new special purpose vehicle (SPV) recommended by the Taoiseach's Dublin taskforce is expected to be established in the coming months and will have a specific mandate to regenerate derelict inner-city buildings, particularly in the O'Connell Street area. Green Party councillor Janet Horner said the SPV could be used as the 'developer' of Neary's, providing a 'cheaper and more efficient way of turning around derelict sites'. [ Derelict Dublin: 10 unused northside buildings in a city gripped by a housing crisis Opens in new window ] 'This building is a chance for the city council to trial what that body of work for the SPV will look like. We should be acquiring derelict properties, renovating them to include housing and then finding cost-efficient ways to sell the housing to AHBs [approved housing bodies] to operate as social housing, or selling on any commercial or housing aspects if that is what is best for the site.' The council said it is considering the future use and development of Neary's. Attempts to contact Telstar Investments for comment were unsuccessful.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Derelict Dublin site redevelopment can proceed as potential template for inner-city regeneration
The redevelopment of one of Dublin city's most notorious derelict buildings as a potential template for inner-city regeneration recommended by the Taoiseach's Dublin taskforce can finally proceed following the resolution of an ownership dispute. Dublin City Council has become the legal owner of the former Neary's pub and hotel at 77-78 Parnell Street, after the High Court dismissed judicial review proceedings against the council's acquisition of the buildings under the Derelict Sites Act. The prominent Victorian building close to the O'Connell Street end of Parnell Street has been vacant for at least 20 years and has become increasingly derelict over the last decade. In 2015 it was taken over by squatters claiming to be anarchists and the building was given the moniker the Barricade Inn. The squatters stayed for almost a year before being evicted by order of the High Court in 2016 following an application by Vandelure Ltd, a company with a freehold interest in the property. READ MORE The company at the time said the eviction was essential because the building was in an extremely dangerous condition and the floors on each level had rotted and partially fallen through. The building, a protected structure, mostly dates from the 1850s when it was developed as a hotel. However, substantial parts of the structure are at least 100 years older, with a mid-18th-century staircase in the centre of it. It had previously been operated as a guest house by Ellen McGuill, who died in 2002, with the property understood to have been left to Scottish Catholic clergy. But the will was never executed due to McGuill having no known living relatives to enact it, with a series of legal issues following. Vandelure had during the 2016 court proceedings said it intended to sell the building, but this did not happen and the company was dissolved in March 2021. The council placed the property on a derelict register in December of 2021 and subsequently moved to acquire it under the Derelict Sites Act. The 'vesting orders', which confer all rights and titles to the building to the council, came into force in May 2024. However, these orders were challenged in the High Court by Telstar Investments, which had earlier acquired the property. Telstar, which is connected to publican and hotelier Noel Murray, who owns several venues in the city centre including Fibber Magees next door to Neary's, had sought to have the vesting order quashed. [ Derelict Dublin: Too often, it feels like a place designed by people who despise its inhabitants Opens in new window ] The High Court this month ruled that the company was outside the time limitation for taking the challenge, there was no 'good and sufficient reason' for the delay in taking the challenge and the delay was not outside the company's control. The new special purpose vehicle (SPV) recommended by the Taoiseach's Dublin taskforce is expected to be established in the coming months and will have a specific mandate to regenerate derelict inner-city buildings, particularly in the O'Connell Street area. Green Party councillor Janet Horner said the SPV could be used as the 'developer' of Neary's, providing a 'cheaper and more efficient way of turning around derelict sites'. [ Derelict Dublin: 10 unused northside buildings in a city gripped by a housing crisis Opens in new window ] 'This building is a chance for the city council to trial what that body of work for the SPV will look like. We should be acquiring derelict properties, renovating them to include housing and then finding cost-efficient ways to sell the housing to AHBs [approved housing bodies] to operate as social housing, or selling on any commercial or housing aspects if that is what is best for the site.' The council said it is considering the future use and development of Neary's. Attempts to contact Telstar Investments for comment were unsuccessful.
Irish Times
5 days ago
- Irish Times
Dublin City Council to contribute €250,000 for American college football game at Aviva Stadium
Dublin City Council has agreed to pay €250,000 to Irish American Events Ltd (IAEL), which promotes and operates the Aer Lingus College Football Classic. This year's Classic will take place in the city's Aviva Stadium on August 23rd between Kansas State and Iowa State. From 2022 until 2026 inclusive, the games have been scheduled to take place at the Aviva on the last Saturday in August. The council said the payment 'delivers on the council's strategic objectives supporting an attractive and active city for locals and visitors supporting a vibrant local economy'. READ MORE It is expected that 22,000 tourists from the US will arrive for the match. The council said this 'will significantly benefit the local economy'. [ Aer Lingus College Football Classic: Why a single game is a major money-spinner for Irish economy Opens in new window ] It is the first time a Big 12 Conference match up has taken place in Ireland. The Big 12 Conference is a major collegiate athletic conference in the US, comprising 16 universities. It is known for its competitive football programmes. The council said: 'Traditional ancillary events such as pep rallies and tailgates will take place in Dublin city and a full schedule of business, academic and public events will be held in Dublin during game week each year.' Last year's game between Florida State and Georgia Tech added €146 million to the Irish economy , said a report from Grant Thornton , a sponsor of the event. Of that sum, fans who came from the US spent about €135 million on travel and accommodation. Almost 48,000 people attended the game, more than 25,900 of whom travelled from the US and stayed in Ireland for an average of seven nights, the report said. But Dublin councillor Mannix Flynn has expressed frustration with the financial contribution. He said GAA matches in Croke Park brought many people to Dublin, but 'as soon as the match is over they're running for trains', instead of staying in the area. 'What are we providing for Americans that we can't provide for those using Croke Park?' he said. He said that 'Americans are very welcome, tourists are very welcome'. 'This is not only a sporting issue, it's a political issue, it's an issue of culture and impact,' he said. He said the financial contribution should have been 'a lot more transparent and a lot more debated', claiming it was 'an executive decision'. The council said one of the reserved functions of its councillors was to approve the annual budget. 'This would include the overall budget for particular sections, including the events and filming unit, which funds and supports the planning and delivery for this event,' it said. 'Reports are provided to monthly council meetings and to the Economic Development and Enterprise strategic policy committee outlining the work being carried out by key sections.'
