logo
Could the Scottish Tories do a deal with Reform?

Could the Scottish Tories do a deal with Reform?

Spectator4 days ago
It's not a good time to be a Scottish Conservative. While the SNP has seen a bounce in the polls – despite the infighting that followed Nicola Sturgeon's resignation and the Operation Branchform police probe – the Tories and Labour have both suffered from a surge in support for Reform UK north of the border. Scottish Labour is projected to lose Members of the Scottish Parliament (MSPs) but ultimately it is the Tories who look to be hit the hardest.
It is the fear of an electoral wipeout next year – and projections that suggest Reform will pick up around 15 seats from a standing start – that has prompted senior Tories to float the idea of an electoral pact with Nigel Farage's Scottish outfit. As reported in the Telegraph, party figures have suggested a deal could help avoid splitting the vote on the right and oust the SNP from government.
The idea at present would involve the Tories avoiding standing candidates in areas where Reform is projected to do well and vice versa. It comes after 14 Tory councillors defected to the Farage‑run group ahead of next year's Holyrood election, and both the Conservatives and Reform UK expect that a sitting Tory MSP could switch sides. Some Scottish Tories have dismissed switchers as being ambitious and seeing an easy way into Holyrood via Reform, while Farage's Scottish organisers have suggested that the party could introduce a deadline for defectors to stop opportunistic politicos taking advantage of Reform's surge.
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay is against the idea of a pact – and so is Nigel Farage. The Reform leader told the Telegraph: 'No chance. The Tories are dying in Scotland and I've got no desire to do a deal with them whatsoever.' His Scottish team echoed the sentiment, with a senior party source telling me: 'Why would we stand down in areas we'll win?' They added that no Scottish Tories have approached Reform with the strategy and reiterated that the party will stand candidates in all 73 constituencies as well as on the regional list. They concluded: 'There's absolutely nothing in it. They're at it.'
The SNP is the only party to have published its candidate list for the 2026 election – featuring a mix of former MPs, current MSPs and a number of younger councillors. Scottish Labour and the Conservatives have not finalised their lists yet, while Reform UK is vetting candidates and conducting parliamentary assessment meetings with the help of its London team. After this, a committee will approve applicants before branches select candidates for 2026. A full finalised list is expected early next year. The Scottish Conservatives will be hoping no more councillors – or MSPs – defect before then.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

We must have transparency over migrants and crime. The politicians who lose control of our borders cannot be allowed to hide the consequences from us
We must have transparency over migrants and crime. The politicians who lose control of our borders cannot be allowed to hide the consequences from us

Daily Mail​

time2 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

We must have transparency over migrants and crime. The politicians who lose control of our borders cannot be allowed to hide the consequences from us

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, looking more beleaguered and sounding less convincing than ever, said yesterday that the police should routinely reveal the nationality and asylum status of those charged with criminal offences. New legal guidance, she promised, would shortly be issued for police forces to provide greater 'transparency'. Not for the first time, Labour was rushing to follow in the footsteps of Nigel Farage 's Reform party. Only 24 hours before, as part of Reform's 'Britain is lawless' campaign, Farage had called for the ethnicity of suspects charged with rape and sexual assaults to be made public. Now Cooper was in a hurry to oblige.

Prison staff expose 'shambles' of early release scheme as they back new plan
Prison staff expose 'shambles' of early release scheme as they back new plan

Daily Mirror

time3 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Prison staff expose 'shambles' of early release scheme as they back new plan

Officers working in jails and those who monitor the release of inmates back Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood 's plans to bring in a Texas-style behaviour model Almost three in five prison and probation staff (59%) are in favour of releasing prisoners early for good behaviour, polling shows. ‌ Officers working in jails and those who monitor the release of inmates back Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood 's plans to bring in a Texas-style behaviour model. It comes as the polling also revealed some 80% of officers were against both the Tories' and Labour 's emergency early release schemes, which saw thousands urgently freed to create more jail space. ‌ Some 87% of staff said the plans derailed day-to-day activity and 80% said work-related stress had increased since the schemes' introduction. One staff member told the survey the release plans had been a 'shambles', adding: 'It was too rushed. It did not allow sufficient time or resources for prisoners to be released safely. People were not being tagged or monitored. The whole thing was a shambles.' It comes after The Mirror's Kevin Maguire wrote: 'Labour must find engaging story for the UK - or face election wipeout'. ‌ Another said staff members are having to take stress leave as the workload is unmanageable. 'I started this role motivated and ready to do my job but as more and more pressure is placed on us, I feel myself breaking,' they said. 'The job role, currently, is unmanageable, stressful, and ridiculous. Numerous staff members are having to take stress related sick leave, and I feel the organisation as a whole will collapse should this continue.' Another added: 'Workload pressures on probation are immense, and without the appropriate resources to manage all the prison releases, something will go wrong, and the public are at risk of serious harm.' More than 10,000 people were released under the Tories' End of Custody Supervised Licence (ECSL) scheme, which was launched in October 2023. ‌ Under the plan, certain prisoners were released up to 70 days early. This was increased from an initial 18-day early release, then from 35 days. The scheme was widely criticised for not giving enough time for probation services to efficiently plan for the release plans of offenders, with just a day's notice given at times. Last September, Ms Mahmood ordered a new scheme to automatically release low-risk prisoners after serving 40% of their sentence - down from 50%. The scheme introduced exclusions for prisoners serving time for serious violent or sex offences. ‌ The Labour government, following a major review of the system, is looking to introduce an 'earned progression' model, inspired by prisons in Texas. It would see inmates on standard sentences of up to four years released after serving a third of their time inside if they behave well. Jon Czul, managing director at Skills for Justice, which did the report, said: 'Whilst the measures introduced last September are generally viewed as an upgrade on previous arrangements, the circumstances in which prisons and probation services were expected to implement and deliver the policy has been met with disapproval. 'For understaffed prisons and probation services, the sheer volume of prisoners needing to be processed in such a short timeframe has contributed to the sense that workloads in the sector are increasingly unmanageable.' ‌ Ian Lawrence, general secretary of probation service trade union Napo, said: 'Decades of underinvestment in prisons meant that once breaking point came, the burden fell disproportionately on the shoulders of probation services. We cannot keep expecting probation officers to pick up the pieces.' Skills for Justice surveyed 481 respondents in May and June 2025. Prison Officers' Association, Prison Governors' Association, Napo, Probation Institute and Community Union supported the survey data collection. A Ministry of Justice spokesman said: 'This Government inherited prisons days from collapse and had no choice but to take decisive action to stop jails overflowing – an event that would have been cataclysmic for frontline staff. 'To ensure we never run out of prison places again, we are building 14,000 prison places and reforming sentencing so our jails reduce reoffending, cut crime, and keep victims safe.'

Tory and Reform politicians endanger trials with immigration ‘hysteria', say former ministers
Tory and Reform politicians endanger trials with immigration ‘hysteria', say former ministers

The Guardian

time5 hours ago

  • The Guardian

Tory and Reform politicians endanger trials with immigration ‘hysteria', say former ministers

Conservative and Reform UK politicians are fuelling 'hysteria and anger' over immigration, with criminal trials put at risk of collapse, former ministers and police have warned. Protests outside hotels housing asylum seekers have spread across the country in recent weeks, while debate about immigration – including instances of misinformation – has intensified. At a Reform press conference on Monday, a man awaiting trial was referred to as 'the criminal' by a Reform council leader despite not yet being convicted of any crime. Questioned on whether contempt laws had been broken, the party's leader, Nigel Farage, said it was 'good' that the council leader had become 'slightly emotional'. Amid growing pressure, the home secretary, Yvette Cooper, said on Tuesday that she had asked for a change in official guidance to permit police to release the ethnicity or immigration status of criminal suspects. Dominic Grieve, a former Conservative attorney general, told the Guardian he was concerned about the 'fuelling of hysteria by politicians' and said some were breaking the law by commenting on future trials in serious cases such as rape and abduction. Certain politicians 'seem to have thrown the rulebook in the bonfire', he said. Britain's former top counter-terrorism chief warned that comments from Farage and the Tory shadow justice secretary, Robert Jenrick, risked 'unwittingly' inciting violence, accusing them of copying Donald Trump's techniques by hyping fears over immigration to try to win votes. Neil Basu, a former assistant commissioner with the Metropolitan police, said it was 'appealing to the worst kind of populist sentiment'. Asked if such rhetoric risks contributing to a risk of last summer's violence, Basu said: 'Yes … they should be very careful about the language they use. It is capable, demonstrably, of causing violence.' The Liberal Democrat leader, Ed Davey, said it was time for the attorney general, Richard Hermer, to issue a formal warning to Farage about comments on live criminal cases. 'Farage and the Conservatives are … openly trying to tear down our justice system, just as the Maga movement has done in the US,' Davey said. 'Irresponsible comments like these put prosecutions at risk and could let dangerous criminals walk free. The attorney general must step in and send a formal warning to Farage that contempt of court will not be tolerated.' Others who appealed for a change in tone included the former justice secretaries Robert Buckland, David Gauke and Charlie Falconer, as well as the former chair of the justice select committee, Sir Bob Neill, who said they were worried about the febrile environment – though several said more transparency from police over the ethnicity of suspects was also now necessary to calm tensions. The row over information withheld by police has been reignited after the 19-year-old Reform leader of Warwickshire county council, George Finch, said police were refusing to confirm details of two suspects charged after an alleged rape. Among other examples cited by critics was data used by Jenrick that 40% of all of the sexual crimes were committed by foreign nationals last year. The number of convictions is significantly lower. Grieve said he was extremely concerned about the consequence of the frenzied atmosphere on contempt of court laws, also citing the trial of two British Pakistani men over a police assault at Manchester airport. 'With social media, contempt of court has gone out of the window,' he said. 'It seems to be that it's a complete free for all, and for politicians who ought to know better to participate in this is actually scandalous. Certainly with some of the recent cases, politicians seem to have thrown the rulebook in the bonfire.' Buckland said he had supported changes to make the nationality of offenders publicly available, but he was concerned about the potential for misinformation. 'Politicians have a responsibility to use objective and tested data rather than distorted or incomplete information,' he said. Neill, a former Tory MP, said he was in favour of more transparency but alarmed at the willingness of politicians to risk undermining the courts. 'I'm afraid some people, including people in elected office, frankly do not understand the importance of the checks and balances in our system, which includes protecting the jury system,' he said. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion The former Labour justice secretary Charlie Falconer said: 'The opposition feel the need the whole time to get headlines by constantly describing things in an extremist way, all the time it's saying, 'society will be on the verge of collapse unless something is done,'' he said. 'The language is much, much worse than it ever was five years ago. There's a more angry electorate, and there's too many politicians willing to use lurid language.' A Home Office source said it was vital that there was 'greater clarity on how contempt of court laws work alongside social media and today's communication environment', but stopped short of issuing warnings to politicians. Hermer has so far declined to intervene to warn politicians on the risks of potentially collapsing criminal trials. In a sign of how far misinformation has spread, polling from YouGov found the British public 'dramatically overestimate' the number of illegal migrants to the UK. Almost half of Britons – 47% – think there are more migrants staying in the UK illegally rather than legally, including about a third who believe it is 'much higher'. There are varied estimates of the numbers of those living in the UK without formal status, which is difficult to calculate, but the Migration Observatory's most recent figures said it was up to 1.3 million. But legal migration is far higher – about 10.7 million people in the UK were born in a different country. Attitudes to migration have significantly hardened. About 45% of Britons say they would support 'admitting no more new migrants, and requiring large numbers of migrants who came to the UK in recent years to leave'. Rights groups including Amnesty International have cautioned against releasing suspects' ethnicities, accusing the government of 'choosing to pour fuel on the fire of dangerous narratives, instead of taking action to address racism and hostility'. Cooper said the government had asked the Law Commission to review the guidance six months ago and expected it to conclude in the autumn. 'We do think the guidance needs to change,' she said, adding that it was already the case that where police deemed it necessary more information on nationality was released.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store