Lenny Scott: Witness denies lying for prison guard murder accused
Asked if he was providing an alibi out of "fear", he said: "I don't mean to disrespect anyone but have you seen the size of Mr Morgan?"If you go to Aintree you will see a bigger jockey on the back of a horse. He isn't intimidating no-one."
He told the jury the two men got to know each other two or three years ago through their mutual interest in dogs after he saw Mr Morgan walking XL bullies in the Edge Hill area of Liverpool where they both lived. Mr Cole, who the court heard has criminal convictions including for stalking, harassment, supplying Class A drugs and assault, said he told Mr Morgan he had bred Chow Chows in the past and was hoping to get into breeding Tibetan mastiffs.Mr Cole said on the day the murder, he had been called by Mr Morgan and asked to look at a Chow Chow at a house in Squire Street, Edge Hill, which needed rehoming. He said he left home at some point between 19:00 GMT and 21:00, and stayed in Squire Street talking to Mr Morgan for between one to two hoursMr Scott was shot six times with a handgun at 19:35, by a killer who had waited for about 53 minutes in the gym car park at Peel House, Peel Road. Mr Cole said when he heard Mr Morgan had been accused of the murder he "knew he didn't do it".
When asked by judge Mr Justice Goose how he knew that, he replied: "Well I was getting a dog off him. "He didn't seem like he'd just murdered someone, I would imagine a murderer to not be very relaxed."Mr Cole said he did not come forward as a witness until after the trial started because he did not want to be involved, but then realised it was "the right thing to do".Mr Morgan is on trial alongside 29-year-old Anthony Cleary, also from Edge Hill, who is accused of aiding the murder plot by leaving a getaway van and electric bike on a housing estate near the gym. Both men deny murder while Mr Cleary also denies an alternate count of manslaughter. Mr Cleary's legal team has claimed Mr Morgan called him after the shooting and admitted he had "done someone", and then "bullied" Mr Cleary into silence.
'Pack of lies'
Tim Forte KC, representing Mr Cleary, accused Mr Cole of telling his long-time solicitor, Sara Doyle, in January this year that he had been "asked to act as a false alibi witness and didn't want to". Mr Cole denied having that conversation. Mr Forte said: "She told you that would make you guilty of perjury and perverting the course of justice didn't she?"Mr Cole replied: "Totally untrue."The jury heard Ms Doyle was also Mr Cleary's solicitor, but Mr Cole claimed she had not made him aware of that. Mr Forte read a series of WhatsApp messages that he alleged Mr Cole had sent to Ms Doyle in June, which he claimed were a "set of instructions" intended to be passed to Mr Cleary. The messages mentioned elements of Mr Morgan's defence case including his explanation for a Mercedes car believed to have been used by the gunman being "linked" to him. Mr Cole said he "could not recall" sending the messages, but denied passing on information for Mr Morgan. Mr Forte said: "You were sending that on behalf of Mr Morgan to influence the account of Mr Cleary?"Mr Cole replied: "I have not had contact with Mr Morgan."Alex Leach KC, prosecuting, suggested to Mr Cole that his account of the night of the murder was a "pack of lies". Mr Cole said every one of his previous convictions had followed a guilty plea, and said: "I won't lie, not for myself never mind anyone else."The trial continues.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Merseyside on Sounds and follow BBC Merseyside on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
39 minutes ago
- Times
My teenage daughter talks in therapy speak all the time
Q. I'm struggling with how to parent my 17-year-old daughter. She's started accusing me of being 'toxic', 'emotionally manipulative' and even 'gaslighting' her. These are big words with big meanings and they come out in heated moments — when I ask about her plans, offer advice or challenge her on things like school or screen time. I've always tried to be a loving, involved parent. We've had our clashes, like any mum and teenage daughter, but this feels different. The words she uses come straight from therapy speak online and it's as if she's diagnosing me with something every time we argue. I feel silenced; anything I say could be used against me. I've also become anxious about setting any boundaries with her, especially since a close friend of mine has been completely cut off by her daughter. I'm terrified the same thing could happen to me.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Accused family-slayer warned jurors they would 'regret' convicting him in past trial - years before he 'killed family of four', cops say
A career criminal accused of murdering a family of four and abandoning their baby once warned jurors would 'regret' convicting him in a past court case. Austin Robert Drummond, 28, remains on the run after he was identified as the primary suspect in the chilling Tennessee quadruple homicide of Adrianna Williams, 20; Matthew Wilson, 21; Cortney Rose, 38; and Braydon Williams, 15, last month. Drummond was released from prison in September after serving 13 years for an armed robbery he committed at a Circle K gas station. And it has now emerged that District Attorney General Jody Pickens vehemently opposed his conditional early release in a previous hearing in June 2020, writing a letter to the Tennessee Board of Parole warning he was 'not capable of living among society.' 'This office strongly opposes his early release on parole,' she wrote, describing him as a 'dangerous felony offender' and member of the street and prison gang, Vice Lords. The Vice Lords gang is considered one of the largest, most notorious and violent prison gangs, founded inside a Chicago juvenile facility in 1958. Pickens noted that after he was convicted of the crime at a jury trial, he called his father and 'threatened the jurors and the victim in this case.' He allegedly told his father 'they are going to regret it' and 'I'll be out one day.' Drummond was not allowed out at that 2020 parole hearing, but at the time of the murders, he was out on bond on an attempted murder charge, relating to an incident inside prison following his release in September 2024. He allegedly had 25 disciplinary actions against him from within custody, including 'refusing orders, drug possession, defiance and being in possession of a deadly weapon.' Pickens said his continued behavior 'clearly demonstrates that Drummond has no desire for rehabilitation and is not capable of living among society.' Drummond is now accused of carrying out the brutal quadruple murders and dumping all four bodies in a dense, wooded area in Lake County. Hours before the bodies were discovered, a baby was dumped in a car seat on the front lawn of a home in a quiet, rural town in northwest Tennessee. The resident reported that a dark-colored minivan or white SUV had pulled into the yard, dropped off the child and sped away. It later emerged Adrianna and Matthew were the baby's parents, and Cortney was the maternal grandmother. Braydon was also Adrianna's younger brother. Authorities now believe that Drummond left the infant on the lawn just minutes before carrying out a coordinated killing of the family in a neighboring county. Drummond had been in a relationship with Rose's sister and Williams' aunt, Kaitlyn Speed, according to the District Attorney of Dyer and Lake County Danny Goodman. The Tennessee Department of Corrections confirmed Speed was a corrections officer at the Northwest Correctional Complex during Drummond's incarceration. Two suspects, Tanaka Brown and Giovonte Thomas, both 29, have been taken into custody and charged with accessory after the fact to first-degree murder. It is unclear how they know Drummond or what role they played in his alleged crimes. He remains wanted on charges of first-degree murder, kidnapping and unlawful firearm possession. The US Marshals Service is even offering up to $7,500 for any information leading to his arrest. He was last seen driving his white Audi A3 sedan with visible damage to the drivers' side and the Tennessee license plate RI 01896. Drummond also described as being around five-foot-10-inches, about 190 pounds with blue eyes, brown hair and a goatee - though authorities note he may have altered his appearance.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
The unusual way America's greatest unsolved double axe murder keeps tiny riverside town thriving decades later
In August 1892, a Massachusetts socialite was accused of bludgeoning her father and step-mother to death. Lizzie Borden went on to be stunningly acquitted, but not before her high-profile trial bitterly divided her hometown of Fall River. And 133 years later, the murders remain a source of fascination in the quaint city but crucially, beyond. Each year thousands of visitors descend on Fall River in an attempt to understand what really happened on that fateful morning on August 4, 1892. But it is not just armchair detectives who stay in the quaint town, paranormal enthusiasts and even legal scholars are among the tourists welcomed each year. While many believe Lizzie got away with the heinous crime, she also has legions of fans who say she was wrongly accused. 'Fall River kind of did [her] wrong. But she's really important to us and really important to the fabric of our history,' Patti Rego, the Executive Director of Viva Fall River told Daily Mail. Rego is among Borden's supporters who insist she had nothing to do with the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden, whose deaths today remain the stuff of childhood nursery rhymes. Back then however, it was a much more gory scene. The couple were discovered in their beds hacked to death with a hatchet, sustaining 29 whacks between them. Shortly after the attack, their daughter Lizzie alerted household staff that she'd found her parents bloody and disfigured Curiously, it was mid-morning, yet no one had heard the couple yell for help and despite the unbridled violence of their death, Andrew and Abby appeared to have died in silence. Theories of a silent intruder or scorned business partner floated about, but accusations ultimately landed on Lizzie. After an intense trial, Lizzie was acquitted and the mystery remained unsolved, perhaps fortunately for Fall River which continues to trade in dark tourism associated with the case. 'We're always trying to give people a new reason to come,' Lance Zaal, the owner of The Historic Lizzie Borden House told Daily Mail. Zaal, the founder of US Ghost Adventures, bought the house in 2021 and has allocated a lot of time and money to making sure its as historically accurate as possible. Law students are a regular fixture in the town, owing to its unique place in US legal history. The town of Fall River, Massachusetts' tourism industry is built off of the mystery However, many tourists come drawn to the more mystic aspects, using their visit as a chance to ghost hunt for the Borden's spirits. 'Most people are skeptical and that's fine and understandable,' Zaal said. 'We don't tell people what to think.' However, he insists he has experienced paranormal happenings first hand. 'When I was there before buying the house, I heard footsteps and voices when no one else was there,' he said. He added that he also felt something touch his leg with no one around and felt the hair stand up on his neck, completely unexplained. The reactions have been so strong that some people are too terrified to talk about it. 'I have spoken to guests and we encourage them to share their experience. A lot of people don't like to talk about it,' Zaal said. 'It makes them reflect on their own mortality.' But on Trip Advisor, there are plenty of people gushing about the site's 'amazing paranormal activity'. One guest said: 'If you can stay in Andrew and Abby Suite. My wife's hair was brushed to the side and kept getting woken up by laughing female voices. 'My blanket kept sliding down off my shoulders and woke up with a strange scratch on my upper forehead and a pillow can't do that but paranormal can.' Another said that when staying in the couple's room, 'at times you can smell some sweet perfume in the air,' perhaps indicating the presence of some ghoulish friends. The Historic Lizzie Borden House also hosts tours to nearby Oak Grove Cemetery where Lizzie, her sister Emma, Andrew, and Abby Borden were all buried. But chilling cemeteries and haunted residences aren't Borden's only legacy. After being acquitted of murder when she was 32, she became quite the animal lover and devoted much of her time to supporting the Animal Rescue League of Fall River. She even purchased the barn where the organization's first animals received care. The ARL is still operational today after officially being incorporated on June 25, 1914. Lizzie frequently attended fundraising events for the organizations and even became known for hosting other parties and gatherings at her own home. According to the league's website, she developed a love for Boston Bull Terriers, so much so that per local legend, 'a year after her death in 1927, three of her deceased terriers were dug out of their graves in the Borden's back yard and reburied miles away in the Pine Ridge Pet Cemetery'. Shortly after her death, the ARL Board of Directors discovered that Lizzie had left them $30,000 to support their continued efforts. 'Subsequent "Annual Reports" reveal that these funds were so well invested that some income is still derived from their contributions to this day,' the website states. Despite her charitable endeavors, the murders are undoubtedly why she is best known, something that local businesses also lean into. Rego said breweries sell Lizzie-themed beers titled '40 Whacks' and restaurants don't shy away from playfully capitalizing on her story. But to many locals, like Rego, Lizzie's story is, 'so much less about the actual act, and more about class and gender and power.' 'I always looked at Lizzie as a feminist. Nobody thought that a woman could do that. She pushed back.' Dramatizations of her story have been turned into documentaries, movies, and TV shows. But the best place to get a slice of her story will always be in Fall River, Massachusetts. Beyond that the town has a rich food and culture scene and other historic offerings. 'Lizzie is definitely part of the narrative. Our goal is to use her legacy - or notoriety - as a jumping off point,' said Rego.
