IHC rules telecom's tower deal taxable
A Division Bench of the Islamabad High Court (IHC), led by Justice Babar Sattar, has recently delivered a significant ruling in favour of revenue in a tax reference filed by a major telecom operator.
The ruling upholds the powers and jurisdiction of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) in assessing tax liability on a high-value intra-group transaction involving the transfer of telecom operator's tower assets. As a result, the telecom operator is now liable to pay taxes amounting to approximately Rs22 billion ($78 million) on its gain from the transaction.
The landmark case focused on a 2018 internal asset reorganisation, where the Telecom Operator transferred its nationwide tower infrastructure to its wholly owned subsidiary.
The disposal of these assets for Rs98.5b ($940m) by the telecom operator was recorded in its financial statements as an accounting gain of approximately Rs75.9b. However, the telecom operator contended that the transaction was not taxable because the asset was disposed of to its wholly owned subsidiary, according to section 97(1) of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 (ITO) concerning intra-group transfers.
The IHC dismissed the petitioner's argument, stating that the provision permits a tax-neutral event only if all conditions of section 97 of the ITO are met. This includes ensuring that the written-down value of the transferred asset remains unchanged in the hands of the transferee compared to the transferor, meaning the transaction should not generate any economic value leading to taxable income. The Court determined that the transaction was conducted at a fair market value of USD 940 million, accepted by the petitioner as consideration, thereby violating section 97 of the ITO.
Consequently, the court concluded that the gain from the transaction was clearly a taxable event since nothing remained to defer taxation to a later date. Additionally, the Court ruled that the Commissioner had the authority to consider accounting income when evaluating taxable income.
This remarkable success of the FBR on judicial front is another step toward accomplishment of vision of the Hon'ble Prime Minister for expeditious liquidation of state revenue involved in the cases pending before the various appellate fora.
Under the guidance of Rashid Mehmood, Chairman of the FBR, Legal Wing of the FBR headed by Mir Badshah Khan Wazir, Member (Legal IR) in association with Director General (Law) has already taken a number of initiatives to actively pursue the pending cases by providing proper assistance to the courts.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
10 hours ago
- Business Recorder
UAE markets decline over profit booking and tariff tensions
United Arab Emirates markets declined on Friday, mirroring losses in global equities, after the U.S. slapped steep tariffs on dozens of trading partners, while investors await U.S. jobs data that could impact the Federal Reserve rate cut decision. MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan fell 0.8%, while Japan's Nikkei closed 0.7% lower. Late on Thursday, President Donald Trump signed an executive order imposing tariffs of 10% to 41% on U.S. imports from foreign countries, including 25% on goods from India, 20% from Taiwan, 19% from Thailand and 15% from South Korea. The Fed's decisions impact monetary policy in the Gulf, where most currencies, including the Saudi riyal, are pegged to the U.S. dollar. Dubai's main index dropped 0.8%, retreating for a second straight session, as investors booked profits after the index surpassed a 17-1/2-year high, with top lender Emirates NBD Bank falling 2.4% and toll operator Salik Company decreasing 1.1%. However, maritime and shipping company Gulf Navigation Holding surged 5.8% after it raised the foreign ownership limit to 100% from 49%. Abu Dhabi's benchmark index settled 0.5% lower, snapping a five-session winning streak after reaching its highest level in over two and a half years earlier in the week. Gulf stocks gain on earnings optimism, ahead of US Fed outlook The downturn was led by a 3.4% decline in Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank, the UAE's third-largest lender. Commercial Bank International also slumped 7.8% after reporting a 5% decrease in second-quarter profit to 42.6 million dirhams ($11.60 million). Nevertheless, losses in the index were partially capped by a 5.1% jump in IHC-owned investment firm Multiply Group as investors continued to buy dips after sluggish earnings last week. National Bank of Fujairah also climbed 9.6%, its biggest single-day gain since early February, following a 67% growth in its Q2 profit. Oil prices - a key catalyst for the Gulf's financial market - slipped 0.9% to $71.03 a barrel by 1136 GMT. Dubai and Abu Dhabi indices ended their five-week winning streaks with weekly declines of 0.6% and 0.2% respectively, but still posted strong monthly gains with Dubai clinching 8%, its highest in over four years, and Abu Dhabi climbed 4.2%, its highest in more than two years, according to LSEG data. --------------------------------- ABU DHABI down 0.5% to 10,317 DUBAI fell 0.8% to 6,112 ---------------------------------
Business Recorder
19 hours ago
- Business Recorder
FBR quietly rolls back 0.25% penalty on declared value
LAHORE: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has rolled back penalty of 0.25 percent on the declared value without any official notification under Section 82 of the Customs Act, 1969, said sources. They said the penalty had been rolled back, pending the issuance of a formal notification. It may be noted that the FBR has taken the decision to save customs clearing agents from undue inconvenience despite the absence of any official notification in this regard. The FBR was set to amend the relevant section to reduce port congestion and dwell time by proposing penalties. The proposed amendments had suggested that the owner of the goods shall be liable to such penalties as may be notified by the federal government in the cases where goods declaration is not filed for home-consumption or warehousing or trans-shipment within 10 days of the arrival of goods at a customs station. For the goods declaration filed prior to berthing of the vessel, the goods are not removed from the customs station after payment of leviable duty and taxes, within three days of completion of assessment and berthing of the vessel. In addition, amendments were also proposed in Section 83(1) to explain the clearance through custom computerized systems. For the goods declaration filed after berthing of vessel, the goods are not removed from the customs station for home-consumption or warehousing or trans-shipment within three days of the clearance of the goods declaration. The Association of Customs Agents had proactively raised this issue with the concerned authorities at FBR and Pakistan Customs. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
20 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Business community leader assails ‘unpredictable' tax policies'
KARACHI: The Chairman of the National Business Group Pakistan, the President of the Pakistan Businessmen and Intellectuals Forum, the President of the All Karachi Industrial Alliance, the Chairman of the FPCCI Advisory Board, Mian Zahid Hussain has said that the business community is currently upset by unpredictable and inconsistent tax policies, which are discouraging both domestic and foreign investment. If the government truly wants meaningful economic recovery, it must urgently take steps to expand the economic base and tax net, reduce production costs, and ensure that the tax burden is shared fairly among all citizens. Otherwise, the ongoing crisis will only get worse. He stated that the pace of tax reforms is still disappointing. He explained that resistance to the digital economy is adding to the growing tax burden on the poor, making their lives harder. He pointed out that current economic policies are worsening unemployment and poverty nationwide. Mian Zahid Hussain said that strict fiscal and monetary policies have heavily impacted industrial activity, job opportunities, and consumers' purchasing power. According to the World Bank, Pakistan's poverty rate has hit 40.5 percent, with unemployment at around 22 percent, revealing the real challenges behind ongoing reforms. He highlighted that 75 to 80 percent of the Federal Board of Revenue's (FBR) revenue comes from withholding taxes, which are technically indirect taxes. These taxes place a disproportionate burden on salaried and middle-income groups already struggling with inflation, high electricity costs, and rising interest rates. He added that the business and industrial communities harbour strong concerns over the powers granted to FBR officers under the Finance Bill 2025. Mian Zahid Hussain warned that, in pursuit of the Rs 14,300 billion tax target, the government must not jeopardize the country's Rs 123,000 billion economy. Instead, efforts should focus on expanding the overall economic base, which would naturally increase tax revenues. He stressed that genuine tax reform is not about further burdening current taxpayers but about expanding the tax base. Without including the country's large informal economy in the tax system, achieving the 13% tax-to-GDP ratio sustainably is unlikely. For long-term progress, Mian Zahid Hussain stressed the crucial need for transparency, fairness, and accountability to be incorporated into the tax system. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
