Fewer women should become doctors as they ‘have got to have babies', retired surgeon says
Dr Meirion Thomas, a former professor of surgical oncology at Imperial College, said the gender balance has swung too far in favour of female medical students.
Asked what was wrong with having more female doctors in training, Dr Thomas told Times Radio 'the fact of life is that women have got to have babies'.
He said: 'You're putting me on the spot now, and I'll be hated for this, but the fact of life is, of course, women have got to have babies. Of course, they've got to have time to bring up their children.'
Dr Thomas said women often end up working part-time or job-sharing, and that it takes two women to work the equivalent of one full-time man. 'I'm going to be hated for saying that, but I'm afraid it's true,' he added.
His comments came as part of a discussion about NHS strikes, which are set to run for five days from 7am on Friday, with thousands of resident doctors expected to join the walkout in an ongoing dispute over pay.
Dr Thomas said 'please don't take offence at this', before referencing a photograph from a previous doctors' strike, which he said showed that of the 30 to 40 people pictured, only two were men. 'All the rest were women. So that tells me something,' he said.
Pressed on why that would be a problem, Dr Thomas said: 'The one problem is that medical schools now are taking 60 to 70 per cent women as medical students. It's a huge imbalance, huge imbalance and that should be reduced to 50-50 for sure.' Dr Thomas has previously complained about GPs working part-time, which the Royal College of General Practitioners has said 'misses the point'.
He has also previously warned that the NHS is being flooded with doctors from poorer countries, claiming that the UK has 'no idea if they are competent'.
The public is being urged to continue coming forward for NHS care during a five-day strike, which is likely to see tens of thousands of operations and appointments cancelled.
NHS England said hospitals and local teams have been preparing before the strike, and have plans in place to 'minimise disruption to patient care and ensure life-saving care continues'.
Thousands of resident doctors are expected to join the walkout, which is the 12th by resident doctors since March 2023.
New NHS England boss, Sir Jim Mackey, has urged hospital leaders to keep routine operations and appointments going if possible and to only cancel if there is a risk to patient safety.
During the strike, GP surgeries will open as usual and urgent care and A&E will continue to be available for those who need them, NHS England said.
It urged the public to use 111 online as the first port of call for urgent but not life-threatening issues.
Professor Meghana Pandit, NHS England national medical director, said: 'There is no doubt this industrial action will take a toll on patients and NHS staff, and it is disappointing it is going ahead.
'While it will mean some appointments won't be able to go ahead as planned, we are doing all we can to limit this, and patients should continue to use NHS services in the usual way.
'The public should dial 999 in an emergency, and otherwise use 111 online, your local pharmacist or GP, and patients should attend NHS appointments unless told otherwise.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
5 minutes ago
- The Sun
From dizzy spells to fainting and skin that bruises easily – Dr Zoe answers YOUR health concerns
IT'S a sobering thought that some cancers can advance quietly in the body until they have reached a late stage. This is frequently what we see with liver cancer, which is often diagnosed too late. Last week, researchers projected cases of this disease worldwide could double, to 1.52million by 2050. But crucially, three in five cases could be prevented, the Lancet Commission on Liver Cancer said. You can reduce your risk of the condition by cutting down on alcohol, quitting smoking and, if you are carrying excess body fat, getting support to lose weight healthily. Some risk factors can't be changed – being over the age of 60, being male or having a family history of the disease all increase your chances. So it's important to focus on what we can change. While early symptoms can be rare, unexplained weight loss, persistent fatigue, discomfort or pain in the upper abdomen, and yellowing of the skin or eyes – jaundice – are all potential red flags. Here's a selection of what readers asked me this week . . . FEARS OVER FAINTING 4 Q) CAN the NHS offer me any help with fainting? Since I was a teenager I have had episodes in response to blood tests, smear tests or examinations and other random events involving my body. Now I am worried about pregnancy and childbirth in the future, with all the procedures. What happens if I spend the entire time fainting? No one will know what to do with me. I'm sure this would be discussed with a team of doctors at the time, but is there anything I can do to prepare? A) It sounds to me as though you are describing an issue that is rooted in your psychology but leads to a physiological response. Therefore, the best approach may be psychological therapy, such as cognitive behavioural therapy. 'Vasovagal syncope' is the most common reason that people faint. The classic stereotype is in the black-and-white movie where a woman sees a mouse and throws her hand to her forehead before fainting. But in real life, we can have the same response triggered by things that are painful, overwhelm us emotionally or that we fear, such as needles or examinations/procedures. So past experiences can make you more likely to experience this response. These can overstimulate the vagus nerve, which regulates heart rate and blood pressure. Heart rate and blood vessels widen, particularly in your legs, leading to a sudden decrease in blood pressure. Then, less blood reaches your brain, resulting in a temporary reduction in oxygen supply, which causes you to faint. It's clever, really. Fainting causes our body to collapse, and that loss of gravity means more blood can get to the brain. Some theories suggest fainting has evolutionary roots, possibly acting as a way to avoid immediate physical harm by making an individual appear more submissive. My advice would be to self-refer to NHS talking therapies to see what type of help would be available to you – most likely cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) initially. Because some of your triggers involve medical procedures, gradual exposure therapy might help. It's a good idea to deal with this now, so when the time comes, you will have alleviated your fears. But do bear in mind the NHS has perinatal mental health services too. Why do I keep losing my balance? 4 Q) OVER the past few months, I notice that I lose my balance when walking. I am a 75-year-old male and take a few medicines for blood pressure, diabetes and cholesterol, which I have sent you a list of. Could any of these cause the balance issue? A) Yes, it is possible your medication is causing dizziness, especially the blood pressure medications and Gliclazide. It's important to always keep an eye on blood pressure. Sometimes, as people get older, especially if they lose weight, their blood pressure can start to get lower over time and sometimes BP medications need to be stopped. Gliclazide is a diabetes medication which can cause low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) – a major cause of dizziness, faintness and balance loss. You can become more sensitive to these side effects as you age, especially if you have missed meals or are eating less than before. Another factor in your case is polypharmacy, defined as the regular use of five or more medications at the same time. The combination of several drugs increases the risk of side effects and interactions. I would advise you to ask your GP surgery for a review of all your medications – a GP or pharmacist can evaluate whether any can be reduced, swapped, or spaced out. Also, get your blood pressure checked – including a lying/standing test to see how your blood pressure responds to you standing up – and a diabetes test if you haven't had them done recently. It's worth asking about doing some blood glucose tests at home to check for low blood sugar episodes. If your symptoms persist you may require a further balance assessment – your doctor might refer you to a falls clinic, physiotherapist, or neurologist if needed. Q) I BELIEVE my skin has become very thin, as I bruise and bleed very easily. I am an 83-year-old male. My current medication is nifedipine and levothyroxine, and has been for years. Would taking collagen powder help my skin? A) Skin thinning and easy bruising are quite common with age, especially after 80, and it can be influenced by a natural reduction in collagen and elastin in the skin. However, it is important to always see your GP to be checked for other causes of bruising and easy bleeding before assuming it is just down to thin skin. Your medications – nifedipine (a calcium channel blocker used for high blood pressure) and levothyroxine (thyroid hormone replacement) – are not typically known to thin the skin or cause easy bruising directly. If you get the all-clear from your doctor regarding the bruising and bleeding then it might be worth trialling a collagen supplement. There still isn't what we would say robust evidence to support collagen supplements yet, but studies have shown collagen peptides can modestly improve skin thickness, elasticity, and hydration in older adults. They have other health benefits too, such as supporting the health of joints and bones. However, results vary and the improvements may be modest and take at least two to three months of daily use to show noticeable effects. Not all collagen supplements are the same either. Look for hydrolysed collagen peptides or collagen hydrolysate – these are better absorbed. A dose of 5-10 grams per day is commonly used in studies. Vitamin C helps with collagen synthesis, so either choose a collagen supplement with added vitamin C or ensure you're getting enough through your diet (citrus, berries, etc). Make sure you have a healthy, varied diet too. While collagen powder won't reverse the ageing process, it may offer mild benefits to your skin's strength and hydration, and could be worth trying, especially since it's generally safe. But do keep a note of whether it's helping, and if not, it might be worth stopping so as not to waste money. Cook to slim faster HOME cooking could help you lose weight twice as fast as eating shop-bought meals, according to a study. Research by University College London found that slimmers lost more weight even if the foods were matched for calories, fat and sugar. For example, participants eating porridge and home-made spaghetti bolognese slimmed faster than those who ate shop-bought oat bars and pasta ready meals. People on the balanced but processed diet lost 1.05 per cent of their body weight in two months, while those eating similar but non-processed versions lost 2.06 per cent in the same time. The difference was equal to eating 170 fewer calories per day so could lead to more weight loss over a longer period. The results suggest the way foods are processed makes them less healthy, even when they look like normal meals. We rely heavily on ultra-processed foods, which mak up around two thirds of our daily diet. They include most packaged foods such as crisps, chocolate, ready meals, biscuits and breakfast cereals. Minimally processed foods are those that have to be made such as pasta, rice and milk. Unprocessed foods include fresh fruit and veg, meat, fish and eggs. Senior study author Professor Rachel Batterham said: 'The best advice to people would be to moderate overall energy intake and limit intake of salt, sugar and saturated fat, while prioritising high-fibre foods such as fruits, vegetables, pulses and nuts.' Care after jabs is vital FAT jabs are not a 'quick fix' and patients must be followed-up for at least a year to keep the weight off, warns The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. With more than 1.5million Brits thought to be taking weight loss injections such as Wegovy and Mounjaro, most are on private prescriptions and many do not receive help with diet and exercise alongside it. Studies suggest people start regaining weight within two months of stopping the jabs and often put it all back on within two years. Professor Jonathan Benger, chief medical officer at Nice, said: 'Successful weight management doesn't end when medication stops or when someone completes a behavioural programme. 'The transition period after treatment is crucial. People need structured support to maintain the positive changes they've made. This new standard makes sure services provide that vital continuity of care.' The standard issued to UK medical clinics tells them how to look after patients taking weight loss injections. They must get action plans for staying healthy at home and at work, have regular check-ins and have community support available. Dr Rebecca Payne, head of standards at Nice, said: 'Weight management is a long-term journey, not a short-term fix. 'The evidence is clear that advice and support for maintaining weight after stopping medicines can help prevent weight regain.'
Daily Mail
35 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
My bulimia was a 'necessary evil', says ex Formula One ace David Coulthard
Scots Formula One star David Coulthard has revealed he saw bulimia as a 'necessary evil' as a young driver. The former McLaren, Williams and Red Bull driver said he weighed himself twice a day to make sure he was the perfect size for racing. He said just saw it as what was required for young drivers to make their way through the ranks. But eating disorder charities have warned that bulimia can cause serious health problems. Speaking to Jake Humphrey on the High Performance Podcast, Coulthard, who has worked as a pundit since retiring in 2008, said: I didn't see it as a pressure. I saw it as a necessary thing to make weight. 'Jockeys, we're familiar with jockeys having to do saunas and whatever to lose the body weight to do the event they're doing. Boxers, I'm sure there's others. Gymnasts I assume. 'Just dysmorphia. They don't see in the mirror what they feel is a reflection of them as an individual. 'I would step on the scales and I was a pound overweight. That was going to affect my performance. So I weighed myself twice a day as a teenager. 'Morning when I got up, completely dry. And evening before I went to bed. Then that gave me my average weight. 'And I could tell a few days out whether I was in the right area for the race weekend. 'It was more of a compromise. It was a necessary evil of which I didn't discuss with anyone. 'I just knew that if I was overweight, then whatever dinner I'd had that night was not going to stay inside me. 'When I went into cars, suddenly I was relatively light for a 17-year-old because I'd kind of starved myself through my late teens. 'And therefore I had room to grow into my body. 'It was making sure I didn't have a disadvantage, because if I was overweight, I had a disadvantage. 'An edge would have been if they didn't include a weight and I could have got even lighter. But of course you're always looking for every advantage you can.' Daniel Magson, CEO of the charity First Steps ED, said: 'It is positive to see David talk so bravely about his experience of bulimia. 'We know that every eating disorder journey is unique, and that is why it is so important to share stories and break stigma, so more people who are impacted by bulimia can reach services like First Steps ED. 'Bulimia can cause serious damage to the body. Long-term effects include damage to teeth, throat, vocal cords and gut, and it may also increase the risk of heart problems. 'That is why early intervention is so important for anyone struggling with an eating disorder or with weight concerns. Our team offers support tailored to where you are on your recovery journey.' Mr Coulthard won 13 F1 races in his career and finished second in the drivers' standings in 2001, behind Michael Schumacher.
The Sun
35 minutes ago
- The Sun
Warning to Brits to brace for winter surge of serious respiratory virus after record cases in Australia
BRITAIN should brace for a winter surge in a serious respiratory virus following a record number of cases in Australia, health experts have said. Medics Down Under have been swamped with cases of RSV, which is a leading cause of death among babies and the main cause of hospital admissions for children. 2 2 NHS England is urging pregnant women to get vaccinated against RSV to help shield their newborns. The virus is a major cause of infant deaths and the top reason young children are admitted to hospital. Pregnant women can receive the jab from 28 weeks onwards via their maternity care team or GP. Adults aged 75 to 79 are also eligible, with NHS England set to begin sending out invitations in the coming weeks. Kate Brintworth, chief midwifery officer for NHS England, said: "While for most adults RSV only causes mild, cold-like symptoms, for older adults and young children it can lead to serious breathing problems that can end up in hospitalisation. "Getting vaccinated while pregnant is the best way to protect your baby from the moment they are born, and now is the time for mums to act, to make sure their babies are protected ahead of their first few months this winter, when there tends to be more bugs circulating." The UK Health Security Agency last week released data on the vaccine's effectiveness. It found that the jab can prevent 72% of RSV-related hospital admissions in babies when given during pregnancy. It also found the vaccine 82% effective at reducing hospitalisations among older adults.
