Air India plane crash: Pilots question preliminary probe report's intent, cite ambiguities
MUMBAI: What do pilots have to say about the AAIB report?
Capt Amit Singh, an air safety expert, commented: "At what stage did the engines actually stop producing thrust? The AI-171 Preliminary Report says: 'After 08:08:42 UTC when Fuel Control Switches were moved to CUT OFF.
But in a later paragraph, the report stated the RAT (ram air turbine) was already deployed immediately after take-off. A simple report consisting of the collated data to date would have served the purpose of a preliminary report. This report has raised questions and suspicion about the intent and motive."
Capt Sam Thomas, president of the Airline Pilots' Association of India (APAI), said: "The conversation between the pilots enquiring who cut off the fuel control switch is alarming.
Another crucial issue is, why did the emergency locator transmitter not work after the accident? It should emit signals if the force of impact is between 3.2 to 3.5 G; the impact of the accident would have been exponentially higher. The AAIB report carries no official signature or attribution, investigations continue to be shrouded in secrecy, undermining credibility, and public trust.
Thirdly, qualified, experienced personnel - especially line pilots - are still not being included in the investigation team.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
An engineer reveals: One simple trick to get internet without a subscription
Techno Mag
Learn More
Undo
ALPA-I renews its request to be included, at the very least as observers, in the investigation process to ensure transparency and accountability. A July 10 report in the "Wall Street Journal" references inadvertent movement of the fuel control switches, ALPA questions how such sensitive investigative details were leaked to international media."
Capt Mohan Ranganthan, a former Boeing 737 commander and instructor, claimed: "The pilot cut off the fuel knowingly.
The left engine failed several seconds after the right engine, indicating that the fuel control switches were cut off one after the other. The AAIB report has a lot of ambiguity."
A senior Boeing commander, requesting anonymity, said: "The argument that since Boeing has not issued an advisory, it indicates the pilot moved the fuel to the cut-off position is flawed. Lack of advisory does not confirm system safety. Several aircraft design flaws were acknowledged only after multiple incidents, history has shown. We know how pilots were the first to be blamed after the Lion Air crash involving the Boeing 737 MAX aircraft in 2018.
"
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
5 surprising laws that secretly shape relationships and success
In the pursuit of success and meaningful relationships, we often look to advice from books, mentors, or even social media. But some of the most important lessons do not come from motivational speeches, but from oddly simple laws of life. These laws are the ones that aren't found in legal textbooks, but in everyday experiences. These are not man-made rules to follow, but rather universal truths that quietly govern how things play out, whether we like it or not. These laws hold powerful truths that apply to everything from how we handle love and friendships, to how we chase goals or deal with failure. They also help explain why things fall apart at the worst moment, why ideas get ignored, or why overthinking ruins progress. Here are some of the most famous life laws that can help one sail through relationships and success in life: Murphy's Law This law says, 'What can go wrong, will go wrong'. In love or ambition, things rarely go perfectly. Murphy's Law reminds us that expecting setbacks isn't pessimistic, it's practical. Situations like missed flights, misunderstood texts often come as curveballs. Relationships break when we assume nothing can go wrong. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Affordable Car Insurance Rates Shriram General Insurance Get Quote Undo Projects fail when we don't plan for mishaps. So one must always be prepared for any unexpected situation with a built-in margin, delays, and stay calm when things go sideways. Those who succeed aren't always lucky; they're just prepared for what could fail. Kidlin's Law According to this law, 'If you can write the problem down clearly, you're halfway to solving it'. This is gold for communication, especially in relationships. Kidlin's Law tells us that clarity unlocks progress. When you're overwhelmed at work or upset with a partner, try putting it into words. Defining the issue, on paper or out loud often makes the situation clear and the solution findable. Half the problems come from not knowing what we're really upset about. Articulating the problem helps to ease emotions, find patterns, and approach both work and love with intention. Gilbert's Law This law says, 'The biggest problem at work is that none of the people in charge know what they're doing'. Gilbert's Law says the real problem is that people in charge often don't know what they're doing, and that's true in life too. No one has it all figured out, not your boss, not your parents, not even that perfect-looking influencer. Once you realise that, you stop waiting for permission and start making your own path. In relationships or a career, confidence matters more than perfection. People follow those who take action, not those who overthink. Wilson's Law 'If you put information and intelligence into a system, but don't change the structure, the behaviour stays the same.' This is apt in relationships and personal growth. You can read all the books, take therapy, or share feelings, but if you don't change your environment or habits, nothing sticks. Wilson's Law tells us that change requires action, not just knowledge. If your relationship keeps repeating the same fights, maybe it's not about communication, but about the way to deal with it, may it be roles, routines or boundaries. Information is step one. Changing the system is step two. Falkland's Law This law says, 'When you don't have to make a decision, don't make one'. This law is about having patience. In both career and love, not every situation needs an immediate answer. We rush into choices because silence feels uncomfortable. But sometimes, letting things breathe creates clarity. If you're unsure about quitting, confessing, or reacting, then one must wait. Falklands Law permits one to not force decisions. Time often solves what panic cannot. Successful people know when to act fast and when to sit still. Secrets of lifelong couples
India Gazette
41 minutes ago
- India Gazette
"Not satisfied": AI171 crash victim's father demands deeper probe, stricter action
Mehsana (Gujarat) [India], July 13 (ANI): The father of Sanket Goswami, a 19-year-old student who died in last month's Air India AI171 crash, stated that he was 'not satisfied' with the preliminary investigation report released by the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), and requested the government to conduct a 'thorough investigation'. He also urged the government to take strict action against those responsible for the incident. Sanket's father, Atul Goswami, told ANI, 'My son was 19 years old... My family is living under such difficult circumstances. We used to rely on my son a lot. He was going to London for three years to get his degree. Our whole family relied on him... We are not satisfied with the report. We request the government to conduct a thorough investigation and strict action be taken against the responsible parties...' The AI171 crash took place on June 12, when the London-bound Air India Boeing 787-8 aircraft crashed shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad's Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport. The aircraft hit a hostel building at BJ Medical College, killing 241 of the 242 people on board. Among the victims was former Gujarat Chief Minister Vijay Rupani. It is one of the worst air disasters in India in recent years. On Friday, the AAIB released its preliminary report into the crash. It described a critical situation that developed just 90 seconds after takeoff, when both engines shut down unexpectedly during the climb. This led to a loss of thrust and a rapid drop in altitude. Flight data from the aircraft's Enhanced Airborne Flight Recorder (EAFR) showed that the fuel cutoff switches for both engines were accidentally moved from RUN to CUTOFF within one second of each other, shortly after takeoff. One pilot was heard asking the other, 'Why did you cut off?' to which the response came, 'I did not.' The sudden shutdown caused the Ram Air Turbine (RAT) to deploy, but the aircraft began losing height immediately and could not stay in the air without engine power. According to the AAIB, the pilots tried to relight both engines by switching the fuel systems back on. While Engine 1 started to recover, Engine 2 did not stabilise. Even though the aircraft briefly reached 180 knots, it continued to descend. The final distress call, a 'MAYDAY', was sent at 08:09 UTC, seconds before the crash. (ANI)
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Weekly Horoscope (July 14 – July 20): Predictions for Rat Chinese Zodiac
This week, Rat-born natives feel a fresh spark inside. A small moment will remind you why you started your journey. That forgotten goal or dream may return with new energy. Use this time to reconnect with your inner fire. Do not worry about speed—focus on direction. Even one strong idea can relight your full path. Trust this motivation. It is not random; it's your own light waking up. Weekly Career Horoscope for Rat Chinese Zodiac At work, you may suddenly feel motivated to push forward in a project that was sleeping for long. This is a sign to act. Your ideas are becoming clearer now. Use this energy to reconnect with old goals or restart a paused plan. A senior might support you if you take initiative. Keep your focus and don't waste this new spark. It can change your future pace. Weekly Love Horoscope for Rat Chinese Zodiac In love, a small talk or moment will bring new warmth. If you felt distance, now is the time to rekindle the bond. Show your heart through actions. This week gives you power to make partner feel special. If single, old feelings may return, or someone may enter who matches your past vision of love. Let your heart guide, not fear. Honest effort makes relationships shine again. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like '기미·잡티' 싹 지우고 싶으면 토닝관리말고 '이것'만 하세요 세계적성분 씨알파이브 더 알아보기 Undo Weekly Money Horoscope for Rat Chinese Zodiac Financially, this is the time to review long-term plans. You may feel ready to save better or try something new. That small idea can grow into steady income if taken seriously. Avoid lazy spending and focus on useful saving. A little motivation brings smart money habits. Ask advice if needed but trust your judgement too. Money grows slowly but surely when effort and vision match together. Weekly Education Horoscope for Rat Chinese Zodiac Students born under Rat sign will feel fresh energy in learning. A new method or a motivational teacher may spark your interest again. Use this to make a better routine. Don't waste this boost on small distractions. Focus on what you really want to achieve. You have the power to catch up even on lost lessons. Be sincere, and long-term success will come step by step. Weekly Health Horoscope for Rat Chinese Zodiac This week, body will respond well to positive energy. Focus on fitness and breath. Lung and heart health are important now. Start with small morning stretches or walking. Let motivation turn into routine. Also, avoid overthinking and night stress. Sleep on time. Fresh fruit and warm meals will support your active mind. You don't need big changes—just regular effort to keep health on track. Discover everything about astrology at the Times of India , including daily horoscopes for Aries , Taurus , Gemini , Cancer , Leo , Virgo , Libra , Scorpio , Sagittarius , Capricorn , Aquarius , and Pisces .
