Kevin Pietersen leaps to Ben Stokes' defence following fourth Test criticism
England's toil might have ended earlier as Stokes offered to shake hands with 15 overs left but he was rebuffed by Ravindra Jadeja as he and fellow spinner Washington Sundar were approaching their hundreds.
2 days fielding and no result on the cards – you WANT to get off the field! You cannot have a pop at Ben Stokes for his frustration. Very easy to have a pop at him when you're sitting in your lounge watching. You're NOT in the battle. Leave the men in the ring to be emotional.
— Kevin Pietersen🦏 (@KP24) July 28, 2025
The hosts were visibly irritated by the decision and a few offered some choice words, while Stokes withdrew his frontline bowlers and turned to Harry Brook's loopy mid-30mph off-spin to hasten a finish.
Only when both Jadeja and Washington brought up three figures did the penultimate Test of the series conclude, but Stokes was labelled a 'spoilt kid' by former India batter Sanjay Manjrekar on streaming service JioHotstar in India.
Pietersen, a former England team-mate of Stokes, views things differently, though, as he said on X: 'Two days fielding and no result on the cards – you WANT to get off the field!
'You cannot have a pop at Ben Stokes for his frustration. Very easy to have a pop at him when you're sitting in your lounge watching. You're NOT in the battle. Leave the men in the ring to be emotional.'
With a blockbuster Ashes series looming on the horizon, many Australian media outlets have seized upon the contentious day five incident in Manchester, with a Sydney Morning Herald opinion piece titled: 'Spare us the whinging, England. The only thing embarrassing about Old Trafford was your tantrum.'
Stokes, whose side will look to seal a series win at the Kia Oval this week, insisted he would not have had more satisfaction from getting a hundred than an 80 or 90 not out to help his side avoid defeat.
But former Australia opening batter and head coach Justin Langer told Australian daily digital newspaper The Nightly: 'It's great to see that Test cricket still has that hard edge.
'If the roles were reversed, I imagine if it were Ben Stokes whose young team-mates had the chance to score a Test 100, he would have done the exact same thing (as Jadeja and Sundar).'
Every BIG series I played in had needle and some sort of controversy at some stage. Enjoy this controversy leading into the 5th Test. It's what makes a series memorable!
— Kevin Pietersen🦏 (@KP24) July 28, 2025
Tensions between England and India had died down in Manchester after the rancour at Lord's earlier this month although this latest flashpoint adds another layer of drama to this week's fifth and final Test.
Pietersen added: 'The Stokes issue should NOT distract from the batters who batted to save the Test Match! Outstanding effort and one which makes The Oval a v v important Test.
'Every BIG series I played in had needle and some sort of controversy at some stage. Enjoy this controversy leading into the 5th Test. It's what makes a series memorable!'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
a few seconds ago
- Telegraph
England's 10 greatest non-Ashes series and where India 2025 ranks
England and India have just completed an epic series that ended 2-2 after the most dramatic of climaxes. Telegraph Sport ranks where it sits in England's greatest non-Ashes series of all-time. 10. England 1 West Indies 3, 1963 A series of West Indies victories in England have a fine case for inclusion. For social significance, none can match 1950, when West Indies first won in England. For cricketing significance, none can match 1976, when brilliant performances from Michael Holding and Viv Richards marked the start of the West Indies super team. But for sheer compelling cricket, the criterion that covers this list, 1963 stands out. Garry Sobers – the most complete player that Test cricket has ever known – was in his prime and with the bat was supported by the runs of Rohan Kanhai, Conrad Hunte and Basil Butcher. The side also had a brilliant, varied attack that included the pace of Charlie Griffith and Wes Hall who were supplemented by Lance Gibbs's off spin. At Lord's, Colin Cowdrey came out with a broken arm to secure a draw. England could well have salvaged a 2-2 draw at the Oval, but Fred Trueman was injured early in their defence of 253. 9. South Africa 3 England 2, 1909-10 After losing to South Africa four years earlier, for the first time ever, England resolved to select a stronger side to try and enact revenge. Instead, South Africa completed an encore, again bewitching England were their phalanx of leg-spinners, who all possessed a fine googly. One of these bowlers, Bert Vogler, took 12 wickets in the Test as South Africa won the opening match by 19 runs. It was the first of three classic finishes: Jack Hobbs steered England to a three-wicket win in the third Test, before Aubrey Faulkner, South Africa's great all-rounder, clinched a four-wicket chase – and, with it, the series – in the fourth Test. 8. England 2 South Africa 2, 2003 The series began with England captain Nasser Hussain infamously getting the name of his counterpart, new South Africa skipper Graeme Smith, wrong. Within one Test, Hussain had resigned, and Smith scored the first of consecutive double centuries. When South Africa thrashed England at Lord's to go 1-0 up, there seemed to be a chasm between the sides. But England, now led by Michael Vaughan, fought back, culminating in a classic victory at the Oval to secure a 2-2 series draw, with local boy Graham Thorpe scoring a century on his Test return. 7. England 1 Pakistan 2, 1992 The summer in which England came across reverse swing at its most devastating for the first time. Wasim Akram and Waqar Younis engineered a series of stunning collapses: from 197 for three to 255 all out at Lord's, 292 for two to 320 all out at Headingley, and 182 for three to 207 all out at the Oval. Yet, even while being bewildered by reverse swing and issuing complaints about their opponents' tactics, England should have taken a 1-0 lead at Lord's, when Wasim and Waqar added an unbroken 46 to take Pakistan to a two-wicket victory. More brilliance from the pair, this time with the ball, secured victory in the decider at the Oval. 6. Sri Lanka 1 England 2, 2000-01 Every other series on this list comprised five Tests. That is no coincidence: five matches give greater scope not just for brilliant performances, but also for tensions to flare up. But when England visited Sri Lanka in 2001, the three Tests contained all the drama of the best five-match series: a cocktail of compelling cricket and often appalling umpiring, which contributed to the spikiness between the sides. Thrashed in the first Test against Murali and Co, England resolved to be more aggressive with the bat thereafter. Their flag-bearer was Thorpe, who was the leading scorer in consecutive four- and three-wicket chases. 5. England 3 West Indies 1, 2000 After 27 years, England were developing a team that they believed could finally win a series against West Indies. The first Test at Edgbaston, when Courtney Walsh took eight for 58 from 40 overs in the match to secure an innings victory, seemed to indicate that England were delusional. Midway through day two of the second Test at Lord's, England were bowled out for 134, trailing by 133 on first innings and on the brink of going 2-0 down. Out of despair, Andy Caddick then summoned an astonishing spell, taking five for 16 to bowl West Indies out for 54. Against relentless bowling from Walsh and Curtly Ambrose, England clinched a fraught two-wicket victory on the third day. It would be a hinge point in the modern history of both Test sides. With Caddick orchestrating another cataclysmic collapse at Headingley, to bowl West Indies out for 61, England won 3-1. 4. India 1 England 2, 2012-13 A heist that felt extraordinary at the time, but rapidly came to seem outlandish. After being thrashed in the first Test, England produced an astonishing heist in Mumbai. Captain Alastair Cook hit the second of his three Test centuries on the tour; Kevin Pietersen, newly reintegrated into the side, thrashed 186, one of the greatest ever innings by an overseas batsman in India. Almost as astonishingly, England's spin twins, Monty Panesar and Graeme Swann, outbowled India's own spinners, then repeated the feat in Kolkata as England went 2-1 up. A rearguard in Nagpur secured England's best result since the 2005 Ashes, and arguably even earlier. India would win their next 18 series at home, comfortably the best streak of any side in history. 3. West Indies 2 England 2, 1953-54 A series that some consider, with apologies to Bodyline, the most controversial of all. The clash in the Caribbean was billed as the 'world championship of cricket', and saw England complete a stirring comeback from 2-0 down to leave with a draw. Yet, while the games were lit up by a litany of great players – including the three Ws, Clyde Walcott, Everton Weekes and Frank Worrell, and the spin pair Sonny Ramadhin and Alf Valentine – the cricket was just the start. The series featured controversies about umpiring and throwing, and simmering tensions of class and race, as documented in David Woodhouse's riveting book Who Only Cricket Know. The only snag was that none of the individual matches were particularly close. 2. England 2 India 2, 2025 In the months before visiting England, India had lost Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma and Ravichandran Ashwin, creating fears that the side, and the spectacle, would be diminished. Instead, India's five Tests this summer have showed the format's continued capacity for regeneration. Shubman Gill swiftly earned comparisons with Don Bradman, never mind Kohli. He was merely one of a brilliant cast of characters to light up a full 25 days of cricket, alongside his rival captain Ben Stokes, the ebullient pair of No 5s, Rishabh Pant and Harry Brook, and the unique brilliance of Jasprit Bumrah. The teams served up four matches which produced fraught on-field moments and gripping denouements. Ultimately, the series got the ending it deserved: the indefatigable Mohammed Siraj yorking Gus Atkinson to secure a six-run win and a 2-2 draw. 1. England 2 South Africa 1, 1998 A victory that remains oddly under-appreciated in English cricketing memory, perhaps because it runs contrary to the lazy popular memory of the 1990s. Yet consider the quality of the side that South Africa possessed. With a pace attack of prime Allan Donald and Shaun Pollock and a deep batting line-up, South Africa recorded the best win-loss ratio of any Test side in the 1990s. After cruising to a 1-0 win at Lord's, South Africa had 171 overs to bowl England out at Old Trafford. Yet Mike Atherton, Alex Stewart and Robert Croft helped England cling on, with the last pair surviving for 5.1 overs to salvage a draw. The last two Tests were even better. On both occasions, England overcame narrow first-innings deficits to win. At Trent Bridge, Atherton came through a pulsating duel with Donald to orchestrate a chase of 247. Then, in the decider at Headingley, Darren Gough bowled England to a 23-run win on his home ground, in a series that went down to the very final morning. So did this year's clash with India, of course – but the 1998 series was further elevated because both sides could win the series on the final day.
South Wales Guardian
5 hours ago
- South Wales Guardian
‘Amazing' series shows Test cricket is not dying
Nearly seven weeks of intense battle, fierce rivalry and knife-edge cricket came to a fitting end on the final morning of the Test summer, with the tourists forcing through a remarkable win. With England needing 35 to win with four wickets in hand for a mammoth chase of 374, they took the last four wickets for 28 runs in riotous scenes that instantly earned a place alongside the sport's most cherished moments. As the tension reached almost unbearable levels, Chris Woakes spent 16 excruciating minutes batting one-handed with a badly dislocated left shoulder. Gus Atkinson protected him from facing a ball but was ultimately unable to protect his own stumps from the indomitable Mohammed Siraj, who etched his name in history with his third wicket of the morning, fifth of the innings and 23rd of the series. Stokes, who missed the fifth-Test decider with a shoulder injury of his own, hurt for his team but accepted the conclusion was deserved. 'The series as a whole has been pretty much toe to toe for 25 days. From a cricket fan's point of view, 2-2 is probably fair,' he said. 'Two very good teams who have thrown everything at each other and left everything out there. We obviously would have loved to get a series win but it wasn't meant to be. 'We're bitterly disappointed we couldn't get over the line but it was another hard-fought game and both teams put so much energy and effort into the series, it's been an amazing one to be part of. 'There's a little bit of frustration there as well but as a massive advocate of this format and for Test cricket as a whole, this has certainly been one of those series that could hopefully keep off the narrative around 'Test cricket is dying'.' The game felt like it was won and lost on a number of occasions over the past few days but England looked to have settled it on the third afternoon, when the twin centuries of Joe Root and Harry Brook took them to 301 for three. From there they lost seven for 66, culminating in the high drama of Woakes' walking wounded cameo. Stokes paid tribute to his bravery but doubled down on his position that injury substitutes have no part in Test cricket. India's Rishabh Pant batted at Old Trafford with a broken foot and Shoaib Bashir took the winning wicket at Lord's with a broken little finger in his left hand. For Stokes, who bowled himself out of the series by pushing his body to the edge, that is how it must be. 'I'm sorry to say this but if someone gets injured, tough s***. Deal with it. That's how we view it,' he said. 'I am still heavily against it. It's just sod's law that this has happened the week after I said I was against it, but my view has not changed. 'There was never going to be a question in Woakesy's mind about what he was going to do. He spent yesterday trying to figure out if he was going to be left or right-handed. He was in a lot of discomfort running between the wickets…but he's out there trying to get his team over the line. 'It shows what it is to play for your country and try to win for your country.' Siraj, who bowled an epic 185.3 overs over the five matches, earned his place in the spotlight as the curtain came down. 'From the first day till the fifth game, fifth day, we have fought an unbelievable fight,' he said. 'God must have written something good for me, that's why I won this match and took the last wicket. When I woke up today, I thought I could do it. I downloaded a picture from Google saying 'believe'.'
The Guardian
8 hours ago
- The Guardian
Ben Stokes hails Chris Woakes' one-armed effort in dramatic defeat to India
Ben Stokes paid tribute to the bravery of Chris Woakes as a series during which players battled at various stages through broken feet and shattered fingers ended with a one‑armed man at the crease, his other arm in a sling, enduring obvious agony as England fell seven runs short of victory. Stokes said: 'That never-say-die, never-back-down attitude we've installed in the group nearly paid off. It was never going to be a question for him to go out there. He was in a lot of discomfort even running between the wickets. 'But we've had Rishabh Pant go out to bat with a broken foot, we've had Shoaib Bashir bowling, batting and fielding with a broken finger and then we had Chris go out there and try and get his team over the line with a quite recently dislocated shoulder. 'Before he went out I didn't get a chance to give him a tap on the back and say: 'Go well.' Coming off it's obvious what would have been said, just: 'Great effort, unbelievable.' He just shrugged his shoulder and said: 'I wouldn't do anything else.'' Stokes, who was ruled out of the game with a shoulder injury of his own, pinpointed when Woakes went down on the opening day as the moment that decided the match – 'It took, I don't know, half a second for a shoulder to pop out and everything just completely changed for us there' – but the captain admitted that the six catches England dropped during India's second innings had not helped. 'You could say those chances we put down did cost us, but back to Headingley where we chased down those runs, India dropped quite a few chances and that probably did contribute to us winning. Maybe if we did hold on to those chances, things could have been a little bit different.' Though the game ended in defeat in the adversity of playing most of it a man down, Stokes felt certain players demonstrated previously unknown courage. 'Some guys will leave this series having found out a lot more about themselves,' he said. 'In particular, with Woakesy going down early on, the responsibility that fell on Gus Atkinson, Josh Tongue and Jamie Overton's shoulders – their roles completely changed from why they were selected, the impact we thought they would have on the game. They had to dig deep. I think a couple of guys have found out more about themselves in a very, very positive way. 'They took that responsibility on without adding pressure to themselves. They did that in a way of pride – one of the boys has gone down and we're going to have to take on that workload. Some people would shy away from that and be worried about what it means for them. They showed a lot of courage, a lot of heart. They can be very proud of the way they threw themselves into that.' After an appropriately, brutally tense conclusion on its 25th day the series will be remembered as a classic, with Stokes admitting the final scoreline of 2-2 was 'probably fair'. He said: 'There's that disappointment and frustration, not to have got the result that gives us the series win, but this series has been fantastic to be a part of. 'It's been full of ups and downs, ebbs and flows, throughout every game. India have been in control, we've been in control, it's gone back to them and then it's come back to us. To be a part of it has been pretty special. 'There is still that disappointment, but for the wider game, and we want to constantly be promoting the game, this series has been great.' At the end of his first series as India's captain, to which he contributed 754 runs and four centuries, Shubman Gill said its – and his own – vacillating fortunes had demonstrated 'how the game of life works'. He said: 'There are moments like this where you feel the journey is worth it. There've been a lot of highs and lows and that's kind of expected in sport. 'Every time you go into bat you want to perform, you want to score a century, but that's not how the game of life works. You should be able to navigate through the highs and lows of life and stay balanced. I want to stay balanced whether we've won the match, lost the match, I've done well or not well. 'This morning summarised what this team's all about. The way Brook and Root were going [on Sunday], not many teams in the world would have given themselves a chance, but this team believes that whenever we have an opening we can get through that opening. 'That's what we were saying once Brook was out – this was our opening and you never know.'
