logo
In landmark decision, judge rules California FAIR Plan's smoke-damage policy illegal

In landmark decision, judge rules California FAIR Plan's smoke-damage policy illegal

Miami Herald25-06-2025
In a landmark decision, a Los Angeles judge ruled that California's home insurer of last resort is violating state law by how it treats smoke-damage claims - a policy that homeowners have long complained shortchanges them, including, most recently, victims of the Jan. 7 firestorms.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Stuart Rice on Tuesday said that the California FAIR Plan Assn's policy violates the insurance code because it provides less coverage than what is required by the state's Standard Form Fire Insurance Policy, which provides coverage for all "loss by fire" damages without making any distinction for smoke damage.
Since 2017, the plan has required that fire claims must result in "direct physical loss" as defined by "permanent physical changes" to a property, which owners allege has made it more difficult to be compensated for smoke damage.
The plan issued a notice to its customers that year that said the new definition of direct physical loss "will result in the denial of claims that might have been paid under prior policy wording," Rice noted in his decision, in a case brought by a former Mono County property owner.
"This notice seems to admit that the CFP Policy is less favorable to insureds than the Standard Form Policy," the judge wrote, in declaring the policy illegal.
Hilary McLean, a spokesperson for the plan, said it did not have an immediate comment on the ruling.
Rex Frazier, president of the Personal Insurance Federation of California, which represents major property and casualty insurers, said the ruling could lead to untenable increases in costs for the plan.
"If the case stands for the proposition that the FAIR Plan needs to pay for very expensive lab testing in order to deny a smoke claim, then we will all suffer," Frazier said. "That would dramatically increase claims expenses, which would, without doubt, lead to rate increase needs for the FAIR Plan."
The FAIR Plan's handling of smoke-damage claims has angered homeowners who say that instead of being promptly offered industrial hygienic testing for toxic substances and professional cleaning services - even after homes were infiltrated by soot, ash and other fire debris - they were told to try to clean up their properties and given low-ball offers to close their claims.
The decision could have broad implications given the fast growth of the FAIR Plan, which is based in Los Angeles and operated by the state's licensed home insurers. Long a minor player in homeowners market, it has seen its rolls skyrocket in the last several years as insurers have pulled out of California's home insurance market, citing a growing risk from climate change, resulting in a series of catastrophic fires.
The plan covered less than a quarter-million California homeowners in 2021, but as of March its residential enrollment had reached 556,000. The number of homes on the plan in the Palisades and Eaton fire zones rose nearly 50% last year to 28,440, according to a Times analysis.
"This is a complete game changer," said attorney Dylan Schaffer, who represents the plaintiff in the case.
He said this is the first time a judge has ruled the plan's smoke-damage policy illegal and it could ultimately result in the FAIR Plan changing its policy. "This decision clearly says you can't not pay for these claims. You can't have a policy that doesn't provide coverage for this kind of damage."
Rice also struck down the plan's requirement that smoke damage must be something perceptible rather than detected by laboratory testing. But Schaffer said the plan had already abandoned that provision of its policy since June 2024 after a state Supreme Court ruling in another insurance case.
Plaintiff Jay Aliff sued in 2021 after his river-front cabin south of Lake Tahoe was damaged by the Mountain View fire in November 2020.
The blaze damaged the roof and broke windows, allowing soot and ash to infiltrate the interior. However, the plan only agreed to pay $2,724.03 after subtracting depreciation and his deductible, even though Aliff claims the on-site adjuster estimated the damage at $7,034, according to his lawsuit. Aliff has since sold the property.
The plan amended its fire dwelling policy in 2012, when it added language that said smoke damage must be "visible to the unaided human eye" or capable of being "detected by the unaided nose of an average person" rather than being perceptible "by the subjective senses of (the insured) or by laboratory testing."
Schaffer said that provision led to the rejections of more smoke claims, a problem that escalated after 2016. That was when the FAIR Plan sought approval from the state Department of Insurance for a new policy form that changed the definition of "direct physical loss" to require "permanent physical changes."
In seeking approval from the department, the plan told regulators that the new policy language might result in a "broadening" of coverage, according to the Aliff lawsuit. But after receiving complaints about how the plan was handling smoke-damage claims, state regulators in 2022 conducted a market conduct examination of the plan's smoke-policy language and claims procedure.
The report found that in seeking approval of its new definition of "direct physical loss," the FAIR Plan "omitted relevant facts and misrepresented revised language as providing broad or broader coverage than the policy provided previously." The plan denied its policy was illegal, prompting the department to threaten possible "administrative action."
The report also found that from Jan. 1, 2017, through March 18, 2021, the plan violated California's Code of Regulations and Insurance Code 418 times. The violations included issuing fire policies that failed to meet state codes, failing to cover all by fires and failing to "diligently pursue a thorough, fair and objective investigation" of claims, including more than 200 involving smoke damage.
Victoria Roach, the plan's president, defended the insurer's handling of smoke-damage claims during an Assembly Insurance Committee hearing this year. She contended that the policy provides adequate coverage, even though it asks policyholders to first try to clean up their own properties.
"Smoke or ash in a house is not necessarily covered if it hasn't damaged anything. Now, sometimes smoke, in and of itself, will damage things, right? It'll damage the walls. It'll damage porous surfaces, a lot of times, the carpets, the couches, the mattresses, things like that. If it's beyond repair, we'll cover it if it needs to be repaired," she said.
The lawsuit originally sought class action status but that request was rejected by Rice in December. In his most recent decision, the judge also ruled that the FAIR Plan did not violate the state's Unfair Competition Law, because it was not proved that Aliff had actually suffered any economic loss due to the policy.
Rice admitted this was an "incongruous" result, but said that was only because it was a high legal hurdle to prove such a matter before trial - and that Aliff may eventually win on this issue at trial.
Schaffer said he plans to file additional unfair competition motions with more evidence prior to trial, because a favorable decision on the law would allow him to seek a court injunction forcing the plan to change its smoke-damage policy statewide.
That might apply not only to new and outstanding claims, but also to cases closed since 2017, the attorney said. The plan has received thousands of such claims since then, including those from the Jan. 7 fires, he said.
Amy Bach, an attorney and executive director of United Policyholders, a San Francisco insurance advocacy group, said the judge's decision was "profound" and would force the FAIR Plan to change how it handles smoke-damage claims aside from any injunction.
"You have a court of law telling the FAIR Plan, what we have been telling them, what people have been telling them, what lawyers have been telling them, what the Department of Insurance told them: 'Your language is is illegal. You can't use it, and now you're going to have to make it right.'"
The losses suffered by Los Angeles County homeowners have spawned multiple lawsuits against insurers and the plan.
Schaffer's Oakland-based firm Kerley Schaffer has filed lawsuits against the plan over its smoke-damage policy dating back to 2017, including proposed class actions in Alameda and Butte counties.
Most recently his firm has teamed with Edelson, a large Chicago-based law firm, to represent victims of the Palisades and Eaton fires who have filed multiple lawsuits against the plan over its smoke-damage policy.
Other law firms have filed lawsuits over the plan's policies since the Jan. 7 fires. Two lawsuits filed in April accuse hundreds of insurers of colluding to drop policyholders and force them onto the plan, which offers limited policies that typically cost more.
Copyright (C) 2025, Tribune Content Agency, LLC. Portions copyrighted by the respective providers.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Korea's Lee Risks Wrath of Farmers With Concessions for US Deal
Korea's Lee Risks Wrath of Farmers With Concessions for US Deal

Bloomberg

time11 hours ago

  • Bloomberg

Korea's Lee Risks Wrath of Farmers With Concessions for US Deal

In a sweltering cattle shed south of Seoul, flies dart across hundreds of cows sitting at the heart of a trade talks between the US and South Korea. Lee Jongtae, 62, has raised cattle and grown rice with his family for more than 15 years in a rural part of Cheonan, just outside of the capital. Now, both parts of his business are under threat as President Lee Jae Myung's two-month-old government considers allowing the US greater access to South Korea's beef and rice markets, a politically sensitive topic that spurred widespread protests back in 2008.

Gyokeres Shirt Sales Surpass Saka and Rice After Arsenal Arrival
Gyokeres Shirt Sales Surpass Saka and Rice After Arsenal Arrival

Yahoo

timea day ago

  • Yahoo

Gyokeres Shirt Sales Surpass Saka and Rice After Arsenal Arrival

Swedish striker stuns Arsenal fans, smashing shirt sale records within days of joining Gyokeres Shirt Sales Surpass Saka and Rice After Arsenal Arrival Viktor Gyokeres's already making splash at Arsenal not on the pitch just yet but through the club's shirt sales. Immediate Impact Before Debut Just days after his official unveiling in Singapore, the Swedish forward has overtaken the likes of Bukayo Saka, Declan Rice and Martin Odegaard in shirt sales, despite not yet playing a competitive minute for the Gunners. Arsenal completed the 63.5 million euro deal to sign Gyokeres from Sporting CP on 26 Jul and fan excitement was evident as he was presented to roaring crowd ahead of friendly against Newcastle United. Why Shirt No14 Matters Although Gyokeres preferred the No9 shirt, his decision to wear the iconic No14, once worn by Thierry Henry boosted his popularity. Many fans see him as the solution to Arsenal's long standing need for true No9. To celebrate the signing, Arsenal launched free shirt printing campaign offering "Gyokeres 14" on any new shirt , a service typically worth £16 at no extra cost. Sales Surge , Website Crashes The promotion triggered massive demand crashing Arsenal's online store temporarily. Analysts expect total sales to rise even higher as the campaign continues until Thursday with figures from external retailers yet to be included. New Era , New Expectations

PGA Tour Superstore Names Troy Rice As New CEO As Expansion Continues
PGA Tour Superstore Names Troy Rice As New CEO As Expansion Continues

Forbes

timea day ago

  • Forbes

PGA Tour Superstore Names Troy Rice As New CEO As Expansion Continues

PGA Tour Superstore has hired Troy Rice, a former executive at The Home Depot — also owned by Arthur ... More Blank — as the retailer's new CEO. PGA Tour Superstore PGA Tour Superstore, the nation's largest specialty golf retailer, has hired Troy Rice as its new chief executive officer, bringing aboard a leader with a proven track record of scaling major retail chains and driving explosive growth as it continues its nationwide expansion. While Rice most recently served as CEO of Total Wine & More for three years, he also spent 16 years at The Home Depot, which was co-founded by PGA Tour Superstore owner Arthur Blank, rising from management trainee to lead the company's largest division. His tenure there included overseeing $24 billion in sales across more than 600 stores, providing him with deep big-box retail expertise that directly translates to PGA Tour Superstore's model. Rice's appointment, which concludes a three-month search, comes as PGA Tour Superstore pursues ambitious expansion plans to grow the company from its current 77 stores to more than 100 locations over the next two years. Rice officially begins his role on Sept. 2, succeeding Dick Sullivan, who announced his retirement plans in April after guiding the company as CEO for 15 years. Sullivan will remain as executive chairman and continue serving on Blank's board of trustees while Jill Spiegel, who has been instrumental in the company's recent growth, will continue in her role as PGA Tour Superstore's president, reporting to Rice. "Troy's proven record of success makes him an exceptional fit," said Blank, who also owns the NFL's Atlanta Falcons and the TGL-champion Atlanta Drive. "His experience and leadership roles at Home Depot and in dynamic retailers since then underscore his deep understanding of our core values and operational discipline. His achievements, particularly his ability to drive growth, lead transformation and elevate customer experiences, reflect his understanding of today's retail climate.' At Total Wine & More, the beverage retailer nearly tripled its sales from $2.5 billion to $6 billion under Rice's leadership while expanding from 165 to 274 store locations. Additionally, Rice helped accelerate the company's online sales from $300 million to more than $1 billion, a notable rise within an increasingly digital retail landscape that PGA Tour Superstore is also targeting. Rice has had senior executive roles at The Home Depot, Toys "R" Us, Office Depot and, most recently, ... More Total Wine & More. He now succeeds Dick Sullivan as PGA Tour Superstore's CEO. PGA Tour Superstore "I am thrilled to join PGA Tour Superstore and help build on the business that Arthur, Dick, Jill and the entire team have created," Rice said. "This is truly a best-in-class business that leads the way in customer experience and provides golfers with the best the game can offer." Rice also led significant growth at Toys "R" Us, where he increased revenue from $5.5 billion to $8.2 billion across 850 stores, and successfully oversaw the merger between Office Depot and Office Max while serving as chief operating officer, managing 1,500 stores and $6 billion in sales. But the move to PGA Tour Superstore represents something of a homecoming for Rice, who began his career at The Home Depot in 1990, just over a decade after it was founded by Blank and Bernie Marcus. "To work with Arthur again, who is a true visionary in the retail business, is a dream come true for me," Rice said. The leadership transition comes at a pivotal time for PGA Tour Superstore, which has maintained aggressive expansion even as many retailers have scaled back their physical footprint. The men's apparel section at a PGA Tour Superstore location. PGA Tour Superstore The company has opened more than 30 new stores since 2020, maintaining a pace of eight new locations annually in recent years. That will continue in 2025, as the company's growth strategy balances market penetration with geographic expansion. Current and Future Store Growth Recent openings have included first-time entries into markets like Detroit, Kansas City, Greenville, Nashville, and Richmond, alongside additional locations in established territories. The next two months will see two more states get their first Superstore locations, with openings in Norwalk, Connecticut (August) and St. Louis, Missouri (September). The planned expansion to more than 100 stores is in line with the company's model of 10% annual growth through new store openings, with 10 new locations on tap for 2026. "Between the product selection, associate knowledge, and in-store services, PGA Tour Superstore offers an unparalleled experience in the market," Rice noted, highlighting the experiential retail approach that has driven the company's success even in an increasingly digital marketplace. PGA Tour Superstore, the PGA Tour's exclusive off-course retail partner, achieved record revenues in fiscal 2024 and continues gaining market share in 2025.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store