
Review: The Small Boat by Vincent Delecroix
Here's where Vincent Delecroix's story begins. Small Boat is a fictional account of the event, narrated by the woman coastguard who took the calls on the French side. Accused of failing in her duty and facing an inquiry, she refuses to be held more responsible than others for this disaster. Her part internal monologue, part uncomfortable conversation makes up the thorny first section.
This isn't a neat little Netflix re-enactment about What Happened That Night. Phone records show that among the woman's many exchanges with the freezing migrants, are the statements: 'I didn't ask you to leave,' and 'You will not be saved'. In addition, the investigating police officer also happens to look like the woman, perhaps 10 years older. It's a genius device – the investigator serves as both the mirror and the conscience, while the coastguard may well be a synecdoche for France.
The woman insists that she's neutral, that she's trained to view the life of a migrant as no more or less valuable than that of a stranded heir after a party on a yacht. She rationalises that being efficient is more useful than being empathetic in rescue operations. But it is callous insensitivity hiding behind indifference. The notion that humans, making treacherous crossings to safer shores are 'so caught up with not wanting to die', irritates her. Her 'I didn't ask you to leave,' is not what sank the boat. But Delecroix's narrator has no remorse – she's haunted not by corpses, but her own recording playing over the evening news. It's the inspector who often struggles to find the right words to say.
The French-to-English translation is elegant. At one point the woman admits, 'I failed to make the distinction when I should have. And when I shouldn't have, I made the distinction'. But the testimony is at best, a thought experiment, philosophizing an ethical dilemma that shouldn't be a dilemma at all.
There's a brief Section II, a sharp, quiet description of the drowning, for anyone who needs reminding of what migrants risk for a chance at a hard life in a safer country.
Small Boat closes with a look at other players in the story – the coast guard's far-right ex, Eric, their young daughter Léa, and Julien, the cynical but complacent colleague who was on duty that night too. It's a reminder of the banality of evil. Like soldiers at Auschwitz who claimed to be just doing their jobs. Like the Delhi Police who let a corpse lie on a road for 14 hours in 2010 while they argued about jurisdiction. Like the officials at UP's Government Railway Police and Bareilly Police Station after a man had been run over by a train in 2015 – they squabbled for so long over who should collect the body that by the time they picked it up, another 16 trains had run over the corpse.
Delecroix's book is not about the culpability of one woman; it is that we are all culpable. The author is a philosopher. Expect some spiralling passages about the difference between presuming innocence and proving it. But look past them too. Saving lives is not that complicated.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)

First Post
19 minutes ago
- First Post
Bangladesh: Yunus forms panel to probe Gopalganj clashes, blames Hasina's party for 'planned attack'
Bangladesh's Chief Advisor Muhammad Yunus forms an inquiry commission to investigate the July 16 Gopalganj clashes, accusing the banned Awami League and its student wing of orchestrating a planned attack on the National Citizens Party rally. read more Bangladesh's Chief Advisor Muhammad Yunus has formed a six-member inquiry commission to investigate the recent violent clashes in Gopalganj, alleging that the banned Awami League and its student wing, Bangladesh Chhatra League, orchestrated a premeditated attack on a public gathering of the National Citizens Party (NCP) on July 16. In a statement issued by the government, Dr. Yunus said the commission was being formed in response to the 'deterioration of law and order, attacks on the district prison and government establishments, and disruptions to public safety' during the unrest surrounding the NCP's scheduled event in the Gopalganj district headquarters. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD গোপালগঞ্জে হামলার ঘটনায় সাবেক বিচারপতির নেতৃত্বে তদন্ত কমিশন গঠন ঢাকা, ২৪ জুলাই ২০২৫: গত ১৬ জুলাই ২০২৫ তারিখে গোপালগঞ্জ জেলা সদরে জাতীয় নাগরিক পার্টি (এনসিপি) এর পূর্বনির্ধারিত জনসভাকে কেন্দ্র করে সংঘটিত সহিংসতা, আইন-শৃঙ্খলা পরিস্থিতির অবনতি, জেলা কারাগারসহ বিভিন্ন সরকারি… — Chief Adviser of the Government of Bangladesh (@ChiefAdviserGoB) July 24, 2025 The commission will be chaired by retired Supreme Court Justice Dr. Md. Abu Tariq, a decorated freedom fighter. Other members include Khandaker Md. Mahbubur Rahman (Additional Secretary, Public Security Division), Md. Saiful Islam (Senior District and Sessions Judge), Brigadier General Shahidur Rahman Osmany (Commander, 21 Infantry Brigade), Sardar Nurul Amin (Additional Inspector General of Police), and Dr. Sajjad Siddiqui (Chair, Department of Peace and Conflict Studies, University of Dhaka). Formed under Section 3 of the Commission of Inquiry Act, 1956, the panel has been tasked with identifying the causes of the violence, the actors behind it, and recommending legal action. It will also examine the attacks on the prison, other state facilities, and disruptions to public order, as well as suggest measures to prevent similar incidents in the future. The decision follows findings by a preliminary investigation committee that implicated supporters of the outlawed Awami League and its affiliates in what was described as a 'planned' assault on NCP members and sympathizers. The violence prompted local authorities to impose Section 144 of the Criminal Procedure Code, followed by a curfew and the deployment of armed forces under In-Aid-to-Civil Power provisions. The crackdown resulted in casualties, although no official figures have been released yet. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Dr. Yunus's administration has tasked the Public Security Division of the Ministry of Home Affairs with supporting the inquiry commission logistically and financially. The panel is required to submit its findings, along with actionable recommendations, within three weeks. The Chief Advisor's move marks a decisive escalation in the government's response to political unrest, placing blame squarely on former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's banned political network and intensifying scrutiny of its alleged activities despite its proscribed status.


India Today
2 hours ago
- India Today
Thailand downgrades diplomatic ties with Cambodia, warns of intensified defence
Amid rising tensions with Cambodia, the Royal Thai Embassy on Thursday released an official statement condemning Cambodia for violating Thailand's sovereignty and international law after anti-personnel landmines injured Thai soldiers during patrols on 16 and 23 official statement issued by the embassy outlined the steps taken by the Thai government after the escalation and urged Cambodia to immediately stop its repeated violations, which it claims is 'severe violation of international law.'advertisement'On the morning of 24 July 2025, heavy artillery was fired into the Thai military base and continued throughout the morning. The attacks also targeted Thai civilian areas, including a hospital,' the statement read. In the statement, Thailand also called on Cambodia to take full responsibility for the attacks and warned that it will intensify self-defense measures if the aggression continues.'The Royal Thai Government is prepared to intensify our self-defense measures if Cambodia persists in its armed attack and violations upon Thailand's sovereignty in accordance with international law and principles,' the statement the embassy urged the media outlets and social media users not to share unverified information. This includes any videos, images, or reports related to military operations, locations or troop escalation follows a recent border clash near Prasat Ta Muen Thom, an ancient temple located along the disputed frontier between the two to the Thai military, Cambodian forces sent a surveillance drone into the area before deploying troops and heavy weapons. Cambodia responded by accusing Thailand of an unprovoked incursion. Cambodian officials said their actions were in health minister, Somsak Thepsuthin, said 12 people were killed in the clash, including 11 civilians and one Thai soldier, Reuters reported. He reported that 24 civilians and seven soldiers were wounded. One of the civilians killed was a child. Cambodian authorities have not confirmed any casualties on their Thursday, both countries closed border crossings and expelled each other's diplomats. The move followed a landmine explosion that injured Thai soldiers, as per a report in Associated officials claimed the mines were recently placed and not part of old stockpiles. They said the mines were Russian-made and not used by Thailand's military. Cambodia denied the claim, stating that many unexploded mines remain in the region from past territorial dispute dates back to the early 20th century. In 1907, French colonial authorities mapped the Thai-Cambodian border, but the map did not follow a 1904 agreement that said the border should follow the natural disputed Preah Vihear temple complex was shown as part of Cambodia, even though natural geography placed it on Thailand's side. Thailand accepted the map at the time, but later challenged it in the 1930s.- Ends


Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
School teacher arrested for sexually assaulting three girl students near Krishnagiri
KRISHNAGIRI: A govt schoolteacher was arrested in Krishnagiri district on Wednesday night on charges of sexually assaulting three girl students. The arrested teacher has been identified as V Balakrishnan, 50, of Krishnagiri town, who was working as an English teacher at a govt school in the district. Educational department officials suspended him on Thursday in the wake of his arrest. It was alleged that Balakrishnan had been sexually assaulting three girl students in the school for several weeks. The students lodged a complaint against him with the district education department on Monday. As directed by district collector C Dinesh Kumar, officials from the district child protection unit and the education department visited the school on Wednesday and investigated. "During the investigation, it was confirmed that the information provided by the students was accurate," said an officer at the Krishnagiri all women police station. The police booked Balakrishnan under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act and arrested him. He was remanded in judicial custody.