
Suspects in violent home invasion in northern Ont. go free
In all, four people were charged in connection with the July 15, 2021, incident and lawyers for two of them -- Nicholas Aaron Martin and MacKenzie Doyle – argued successfully that their clients' right to a speedy trial had been violated.
A big issue, ruled Superior Court Justice Gregory Ellies, was the Crown's decision to try all four defendants at the same time, making scheduling too big an obstacle and leading to delay after delay.
Total delay of 52.6 months
The suspects were charged by the Ontario Provincial Police on July 16, 2021, and the trial was scheduled to begin in November of this year and be completed around Dec. 15. That would have been 52.6 months, more than 22 months beyond the maximum of 30 months criminal cases must come to court in Canada.
The Crown argued that it wasn't responsible for much of the delay because of the lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and the difficulty of coordinating schedules for all the defendants.
In addition to Martin and Doyle, Jordan Dustin Cayer and Randy Allen were also charged with the case. All but Martin were eventually freed on bail. Martin has been in custody since he was arrested until the case was dismissed last December.
'His detention was continued following a contested bail hearing held on Oct. 4, 2021, and a bail review held in February 2022,' Ellies wrote in his decision, released earlier this month.
'He remained in custody until I stayed the charges against him on Dec. 20, 2024.'
While the total delay had the case proceeded would have been 52.6 months, any delay caused by the defence or beyond the control of the Crown must be deducted from the total.
That net delay must not exceed 30 months, under what is known as the Jordan principle.
Pandemic contributed to delays
The Crown argued that, in addition to delays caused by the pandemic, delays caused by any of the four defendants should be deducted from the total.
'I am unable to agree,' Ellies wrote.
The decision detailed each delay, often caused by the lawyer of one of the defendants not being available on a certain day, then another lawyer not being available on another day. At one point, one defendant changed lawyers, causing more delays.
While Ellies accepted some of the Crown's arguments regarding delays caused by the defence, he wrote that by Dec. 2, 2022, the complexity of trying all four suspects together had become clear.
By then, the judge said, 'the time had come for the Crown to reconsider proceeding against the accused jointly.'
After a few stops and starts, the preliminary hearing in the case began in April 2023. By then, Rogers' case had been severed from the other three defendants.
'The time had come for the Crown to reconsider proceeding against the accused jointly.'
— Superior Court Justice Gregory Ellies
The hearing resumed in August, but only lasted for 15 minutes. Two of the suspects had not been brought to court on time for the hearing. It started without them present, but only briefly.
'The Crown advised the court that two or three of the police officers she expected to call as witnesses were 'off sick' and that they might not be returning to work at all,' the court decision said.
'She also told the court that another officer was on annual leave. As a result, the Crown was only able to call one witness that day, another police officer whose evidence related only to the continuity of the evidence seized at the time of the arrest of the plaintiffs.'
Criminal cases surged by 46%
The preliminary hearing resumed on Oct. 18, 2023, but two of the officers were still unavailable.
Further delays followed, Ellies wrote, and the situation was complicated by a surge in criminal cases in the region since the pandemic.
'Between 2019 and 2020, there was a drop in the number of new criminal cases in … in the northeast region,' the judge said.
'However, between 2020 and 2023, the number of new criminal cases commenced … in the northeast region increased by approximately 46 per cent.'
While the Crown argued the rise in the number of criminal cases was a circumstance beyond its control, Ellies wrote that 'the Crown (bears) responsibility for the failure to fill a much-needed judicial vacancy in a region suffering from a gradual, but alarming, increase in crime.'
While determining who is responsible for judicial delay 'is not an exact science,' Ellies calculated that the net delay in this case was 37.5 months, well beyond the 30-month limit.
'Therefore, the applications must be allowed and the charges stayed against each of the applicants,' he ruled.
Read the full decision here.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
Search and vigil held for Indigenous teen who has been missing for nearly 2 months
The loved ones of 14-year-old Samuel Bird, an Indigenous teen that went missing on June 1, are seen at a vigil in Rossdale Park on July 27, 2025. (CTV News Edmonton/Connor Hogg) Friends, family and community members gathered at Rossdale Park for a vigil in support of a young Indigenous man who went missing nearly two months ago. Fourteen-year-old Samuel Bird was last seen on June 1. 'We all have children, grandchildren, cousins, nieces, nephews, and it's hard to imagine if they weren't there to pick up the phone today,' said one speaker at the vigil. 'That's what makes it most difficult: not knowing.' Bird Friends, family and community members gathered at Rossdale Park for a vigil supporting 14-year-old Samuel Bird, an Indigenous teen who went missing on June 1. (CTV News Edmonton/Connor Hogg) Sacred songs were sung and a smudge ceremony was held. Police say Bird was last seen leaving his home to visit a friend in the Canora neighbourhood. During a press conference last weekend, Bird's mother Alanna said she knew something was wrong when he didn't respond to her calls or texts. 'Sam always messaged me. He always told me where he was,' said the mother. Earlier Sunday, a group of volunteers led a search for Bird that went along 170 Street up to around Anthony Henday Drive in hopes of finding something that would help them locate the teen. BIRD Fourteen-year-old Samuel Bird has been missing since June 1. (CTV News Edmonton/Connor Hogg) Bruce Samsin said he hopes to fill the gaps where the police can't. 'They don't really have the resources for all of this,' Samsin told reporters. Edmonton police confirmed with CTV News Edmonton that there have been videos circulating of Bird being physically assaulted after he went missing. The videos were also sent to Bird's mother. 'How awful that they are being sent these violent videos and images,' said an email from the Edmonton Police Service. 'EPS is aware of these images circulating online depicting violent events. Investigators are working to determine the source and authenticity of the images and as such, at this time, the EPS cannot confirm whether this is connected to the missing 14-year-old-youth, Samuel Bird.' Samuel Bird Samuel Bird, 14, has been missing in Edmonton since June 1, 2025. (Courtesy: EPS) Bird is described as 5'8' tall with a slim build. He has brown hair and brown eyes and may have a black-eye and stitches on his cheek and nose. Police say he is known to frequent West Edmonton Mall and is familiar with the city's west end and southside. Anyone with information is asked to contact EPS at 780-423-4567. Anonymous tips can be submitted through Crime Stoppers. With files from CTV News Edmonton's Connor Hogg


CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
‘Standing hand-in-hand': South Asian community uniting amidst targeted crimes
Buttar Gusharan, the general manager and journalist at My Radio 580, speaks to CTV News Edmonton on July 27, 2025. (CTV News Edmonton/Connor Hogg) Ahead of a town hall Monday that will address a spike in crimes against Edmonton's South Asian community, Buttar Gusharan said people standing together in solidarity. 'We are standing hand-in-hand and we are willing to face any challenge,' Gusharan told CTV News Edmonton Sunday. Gursharan is the general manager and a journalist at My Radio 580. He said while his community is staying strong, many are trying to stay under the radar to avoid getting targeted. 'We have lost 14 accounts on the radio directly,' said Gusharan, adding that South Asian businesses are afraid of having their name, telephone number and locations public. 'I know many people who are afraid.' Many in the community are looking to move out of the country because they do not feel safe, Gusharan said. The goal of the town hall is to strengthen the relationship between police and the community and ensure members feel comfortable reporting crimes to police. While he hopes the town hall will fortify that relationship, Gusharan says more needs to be done. 'The government needs to come up with some solution very soon,' he said. 'In a peaceful country like Canada, there is lawlessness, and that scares me.' Edmonton police announced the town hall earlier this month after a surge in crimes against the city's South Asian community. Police say the incidents are believed to be tangentially related to Project Gaslight, a series of 40 arson, extortion and shootings targeting South Asian homebuilders in 2023 and 2024. Investigators believe the current scheme is being run in a similar way to Project Gaslight, with higher ranking gang members ordering younger members to commit the crimes. It is believed that one of the players could be the Lawrence Bishnoi gang. The India Counter Terrorism law enforcement agency said that gang's leader, Bishnoi, operates his syndicate from jails in different states, in India and through an associate in Canada. Gusharan said the threats will often start with extortion over the phone where the victim is asked to provide a large amount of money. The perpetrators will go so far as to contact employers, colleagues, friends and family in order to get money from the victim. B.C. Premier David Eby has called on the federal government to designate the gang as a terrorist organization in Canada. When the Edmonton police held a town hall last year, Gusharan said it was a 'game changer.' 'Lots of people came out to support, the police gave us all the information and there was trust built,' he said. The town hall will be held Monday at 7 p.m. at the Southwood Community League. Capacity is limited and anyone who wishes to attend is encouraged to register online. With files from CTV News Edmonton's Connor Hogg and Karyn Mulcahy


CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
2 dead, 1 in critical condition after vehicle hits pedestrians on Siksika Nation: RCMP
RCMP in southern Alberta said two people are dead and a third is in critical condition after a vehicle hit a group of pedestrians and then left the scene. Mounties said five people were walking on the Siksika Nation on Saturday night when they were struck. Two men, aged 27 and 45, who are both residents of the Siksika Nation, died. The injured woman is 45 and also a resident of Siksika, while police said the two remaining people weren't hurt. RCMP said their Major Crimes Unit has taken over the investigation. Police said they're looking for anyone who may have video of the 54 Map 3 Subdivision area from between 8 p.m. and 10 p.m. on Saturday.