
The third black box: Despite obvious benefits for air crash probes, debate on cockpit cameras has dragged on for decades
Recently, global airline industry body International Air Transport Association's (IATA) Director General Willie Walsh said in Singapore that there is a 'strong argument to be made' for having cockpit video recorders, and based on what little is known about the Air India crash, 'it is quite possible' that a video recording in addition to the cockpit voice recording would 'significantly assist the investigators'. While investigators have been pushing for their installation for over 20 years, cockpit video recorders have been staunchly opposed by pilot unions over privacy and trust issues.
The preliminary investigation report into the crash, released a month after the accident, said that the Air India Boeing 787-8 aircraft crashed after both its engines were starved of fuel as the two fuel control switches transitioned from 'RUN' to 'CUTOFF' position within a second of each other moments after lift-off. From the cockpit voice recorder data, the preliminary probe report notes that one of the pilots asked the other why he cut off the fuel, to which the other pilot responded saying he did not.
To be sure, the report doesn't mention that fuel control switches—which allow and cut fuel flow to the plane's engines—moved physically, and uses the term 'transitioned' to describe the change of mode from RUN to CUTOFF. It also does not state these were moved by either of the pilots, and does not provide any other input from the cockpit voice recording. The selective information presented in the report has many believing that it implicitly pointed a finger at one of the pilots.
The current debate essentially boils down to one question: was it pilot action or a technical issue that brought the aircraft down? While the cockpit voice recording and flight data might lead to more clarity, it is a no-brainer that the presence of a cockpit video recording would have definitively confirmed or ruled out human action.
Convinced of the positive impact cockpit video could have on air crash investigations in cases of suspected crew error or action, the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) first cited the need for video recording of the cockpit in 1989, and officially recommended the installation of video recorder to the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)—the American aviation regulator—in 2000. In a safety recommendation to the FAA in April 2000, NTSB's then chairman Jim Hall made a strong case for cockpit video recorders citing multiple aircraft accidents where videos would have answered important questions that remained unanswered.
The then most recent accident mentioned in that letter was that of EgyptAir Flight 990, a Boeing 767 that plunged into the Atlantic Ocean, killing 217 passengers and crew. '…the Safety Board is concerned that the full circumstances that led to the descent into the ocean may never be fully understood because of the lack of electronic cockpit imagery,' the letter noted. Indeed, the crash remains controversial to this day with the Egyptian authorities not agreeing with the NTSB's conclusion that deliberate action by one of the pilots caused the crash. A video recording could have helped resolve the disagreement by providing additional clarity.
Although flight data recorders show what the aircraft did, they don't always uncover why it did it. Cockpit voice recorders certainly capture what was said in the cockpit and also record other sounds, but they don't tell investigators how pilots physically reacted to a situation, or record their actions, which could be crucial information in air crash investigations. Back in 2004, Ken Smart, the then head of the UK's Air Accident Investigation Branch, had said that cockpit video would offer essential additional information in almost all aircraft accident probes.
Investigators have been arguing that cockpit video could expedite investigations, bring more clarity, and provide important context to existing data from the flight data recorder and the cockpit voice recorder. Over two decades ago, technology and cost-related challenges could have been an argument against installation of cockpit video recorders. In 2025, that's no more the case. There are no technology-related challenges now in installation and operation of these devices.
In fact, cockpit video recorders are being used on various aircraft—like helicopters involved in offshore operations, police choppers, search and rescue aircraft, and test and training aircraft—in different parts of the world. But airliners don't have them.
Thanks to the presence of a cockpit video recorder, the Australian Transport Safety Bureau recently concluded that pilot negligence and error were major factors in a 2023 helicopter crash. According to the investigation report, the pilot was 'occupied with non-flying related tasks…specifically, mobile phone use and the consumption of food and beverages' when the helicopter hit turbulence. The cockpit video also highlighted other errors made by the pilot as he tried to deal with the crisis.
Despite air accident investigation agencies pushing for cockpit video recorders in commercial aircraft, the needle hasn't really moved in the last 25 years. That's because influential pilot unions in the US and even other parts of the world have been strongly pushing back against the idea. The biggest reason for opposition being privacy concerns. They have been arguing that the cockpit voice recorder and the flight data recorder have proved to be sufficient in successfully conducting a vast majority of air accident investigations, and the need for cameras has been felt in very few cases.
But given that CCTV cameras are now commonplace in offices, why should the cockpit be treated differently as it is, after all, the pilots' work space? Pilots argue that the cockpit is not a regular office space, but a specialised one where high-pressure decisions and safety-critical operations take place, which may include occasional expression of frustrations and even fear. Having a camera capture all that is something that they are not comfortable with. But those in favour of the cameras argue that the device need not be focussed on the faces of the pilots, but rather on the instruments in the cockpit to capture them accurately, while also capturing the pilots' operation of the instruments.
'Given the high demand for sensational pictures, IFALPA (International Federation of Air Line Pilots' Associations) has absolutely no doubt that the protection of AIR (airborne image recorders, or cameras) data, which can include identifiable images of flight crewmembers, would not be ensured either. If released, this will affect safety and could have a devastating effect on the families of the victims, following a fatal accident,' the global federation of airline unions IFALPA had said in a December 2021 position paper on the issue.
The bigger concern is the fear of how the footage may be used after an accident. There are concerns that videos may be leaked during the investigation, which could tarnish the pilots' reputation. Such concerns stem from the fact that there have been several instances of cockpit voice recordings being leaked to the media during air crash investigations, leading to distress for the families of victims and crew. Pilots and their unions fear that the distress would be far more if cockpit videos of an ill-fated aircraft find their way to the media and the general public.
There are also fears about the videos being used by airlines and even investigators to appropriate blame, footage being used in legal proceedings against pilots, and their actions being misinterpreted or misrepresented.
'Until the misuse of recordings and transcripts has been effectively prevented, IFALPA will remain strongly opposed to the installation of AIRs in aircraft. The Federation supports expanding the existing technology of the Flight Data Recorder (FDR) to provide a better understanding of the state of the aircraft and believes that Safety Management is the most effective way forward for proactive safety improvement,' IFALPA said in its position paper.
In its letter to the FAA in the year 2000, the NTSB had stated that while it recognised 'the privacy issues with recording images of pilots', it believed that 'given the history of complex accident investigations and lack of crucial information regarding the cockpit environment, the safety of the flying public must take precedence'. The NTSB has been arguing that if regulators ensure that cockpit footage gets the same level of legal protections that cockpit voice recordings get, there shouldn't be any reason why they should not be mandatory on airliners. The FAA has so far said that it encourages voluntary use of cockpit video recorders, but doesn't mandate it as it also recognises the associated privacy and security concerns.
Sukalp Sharma is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express and writes on a host of subjects and sectors, notably energy and aviation. He has over 13 years of experience in journalism with a body of work spanning areas like politics, development, equity markets, corporates, trade, and economic policy. He considers himself an above-average photographer, which goes well with his love for travel. ... Read More
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
How a Kerala village beat alcoholism with the game of chess
Marottichal, Kerala – Half a century ago, this forest-fringed village in northern Kerala was best known for something far less noble than strategy and sportsmanship: bootleg liquor and backdoor gambling dens. Today, it holds an Asian record for the highest number of people playing chess simultaneously. The transformation wasn't driven by policy, policing, or public shame—but by a quiet revolution on a chequered board, started by a teenager with a fascination for Bobby Fischer. Back in the 1970s, C. Unnikrishnan, now fondly known as 'Chess Maaman,' was just 16 when he discovered the American grandmaster. Hooked instantly, he travelled to nearby towns to learn the Indian precursor chaturanga and modern chess. Years later, he returned to his hometown, which was then drowning in alcoholism, to open a modest teashop. But it wasn't just cups of chai that Unnikrishnan was serving. He brought with him the board and the game he had grown to love. And as illicit brewing threatened to crush families, he began teaching his customers chess—offering them not just entertainment, but a distraction, a discipline, and ultimately, a lifeline. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Read more: Crime index 2025: 10 least safe countries in the world; check full list There was little space to play outdoor sports, as there were rubber plantations all around, Unnikrishnan once explained. But since a chessboard fits anywhere, that became our playground, he added. At the time, the villagers had also formed the Madhya Nirodhana Samiti, a grassroots anti-alcohol movement. With women of the village secretly informing on brewers and gamblers, and Unnikrishnan introducing chess as a replacement high, the change came swiftly and deeply. Today, chess boards form an integral part of this place. The village bus stop isn't bustling with commuters, but spectators watching roadside matches. Drivers play against conductors before their shifts. Shopkeepers challenge customers between sales. On Sunday evenings, Unnikrishnan's home is filled to the brim with neighbours, shoulders brushing, eyes locked on boards scattered across benches, verandas, and floors. Read more: Old-school India: 6 places that are pure vintage vibes A recent local survey revealed that two-thirds of Marottichal's 6,000 residents play chess daily. This renaissance isn't limited to adults. At the local primary school, rows of children huddle over chessboards during recess. Many of them learned the game in under a week and insisted on bringing boards from home to practice. The local association is now pushing for chess to be introduced into the official school curriculum. Despite Kerala's progressive but often contentious liquor policy, villagers here believe they've found their own solution. The village's commitment has even caught the eye of international visitors, from Germany to the United States, keen to experience this grassroots model of reform. If there is any doubt that technology might erase this culture, you will easily get to see a group of teens absorbed in their devices, only to reveal they're locked in online chess battles. In Marottichal, the game isn't over. In fact, it's just getting started.


Hindustan Times
7 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
US man warns ‘America is crumbling', urges others to diversify life abroad
An American man has stirred conversation on social media after posting a video in which he suggests the United States is in decline and urges others to prepare for an uncertain future by diversifying their lives globally. A US man sparked debate online by advising people to stop depending solely on America.(Instagram/trvlking) (Also read: 'Sample of racism': American woman lists absurd things trolls say to foreigners married to Indians) The user, identified as Adam, shared a clip on Instagram featuring himself, with a text overlay that reads: "America is crumbling before our eyes. You need to diversify: - Remote income - Second residency - New passport - International banking." Alongside the video, he shared a detailed caption that expands on his concerns. He wrote, 'The USA seems to be falling apart. You need to diversify your life instead of depending on America for everything. There are poor countries today that were great just 100 years ago. You'd be naive to think that it could never happen to the US. You need to diversify your life to protect yourself and your family. You're in the right place.' Take a look here at the clip: Social media reacts The video received a range of reactions, with many users agreeing with Adam's viewpoint. One user commented, 'India gets 130 billion dollars every year from the US by Indians working.' Another joked, 'You forgot international wifey bro.' (Also read: American woman leaves 'average' life in US for extraordinary journey in India, calls it life-changing) Some showed agreement across national lines, with one saying, 'This is true,' while another added, 'As an American, I also agree with you man.' Another user chimed in, 'Even if everything in the US somehow went 'back to normal' tomorrow, the trust has been lost.' One more said, 'I agree with each word of yours.' While some may see the post as alarmist, others viewed it as a timely reminder to think globally and prepare personally.


Economic Times
16 hours ago
- Economic Times
Horror in American Sky! California plane crash, searches are underway. Passengers flee smoking aircraft on emergency at Denver airport
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads FAQs Authorities are searching for three people who were aboard a private twin-engine plane that crashed off the central California coast. Emergency officials responded Saturday night after receiving a lost radar alert and 911 calls from residents, KSBW-TV reported. Witnesses reported hearing an aircraft engine revving and a splash in the water near the coast of Pacific Grove, the station small plane, a Beech 95-B55 Baron, took off from the San Carlos airport at 10:11 p.m. (local time) and was last seen at 10:37 p.m. (local time) near Monterrey, according to flight tracking data from agencies responded to the crash and search effort, including the U.S. Coast Guard and California's Dept. of Forestry and Fire Protection. People on shore reported seeing debris wash up from the crashed aircraft. Coast Guard officials estimated the plane crashed about 200 to 300 yards (183 to 274 meters) off shore, the news station National Transportation Safety Board will slid down an emergency slide of a smoking jet at Denver International Airport due to a possible problem with the plane's landing gear, authorities said. American Airlines Flight 3023 reported a 'possible landing gear incident' during its departure from Denver on Saturday afternoon, the Federal Aviation Administration said. The problem involved an aircraft tire, the Fort Worth, Texas-based company said in a Boeing 737 MAX 8 carrying 173 passengers and six crew members was on its way to Miami International Airport, American aired by local media showed people sliding down the inflatable chute near the front of the plane while clutching luggage and small children. Some passengers, including at least one adult carrying a young child, tripped at the end of the slide and fell onto the concrete runway. Passengers were then taken to the terminal by of the passengers was taken to a hospital with a minor injury, American Airlines said in its statement. Five people were evaluated for injuries at the scene but did not require hospitalization, Denver International Airport officials extinguished a fire on the aircraft, the Denver Fire Department said.'All customers and crew deplaned safely, and the aircraft was taken out of service to be inspected by our maintenance team,' American said. In a statement, the FAA said it will investigate.A1. A small plane, a Beech 95-B55 Baron, took off from the San Carlos airport at 10:11 p.m. (local time) and was last seen at 10:37 p.m. (local time) near Monterrey, according to flight tracking data from Passengers slid down an emergency slide of a smoking jet at Denver International Airport due to a possible problem with the plane's landing gear, authorities said.