BHP faces UK contempt charge for funding case over Brazil dam collapse
Thursday's ruling is the latest development in long-running litigation over the collapse in 2015 of the Mariana dam in southeastern Brazil that was owned and operated by BHP and Vale's (VALE3.SA), opens new tab Samarco joint venture.
Judge Adam Constable said it was arguable that BHP, the world's biggest miner by market value, funded Brazilian litigation to stop the municipalities suing in London "with the purpose ... of interfering with the administration of justice".
It is not yet known when the contempt hearing will take place.
BHP, meanwhile, awaits judgment in a London lawsuit that the claimants' lawyers have valued at up to 36 billion pounds ($49.3 billion).
A BHP spokesperson said the ruling did not determine the merits of the contempt application made by the municipalities that it "will continue to vigorously defend".
Lawyers representing the claimants suing BHP – which include more than 600,000 Brazilians, 46 local governments and around 2,000 businesses – welcomed the decision as "a significant step forward in holding BHP to account".
The dam burst and unleashed a wave of toxic sludge that killed 19 people, left thousands homeless, flooded forests, polluted the length of the Doce River – and led to one of the largest lawsuits in English legal history.
The trial began in October and finished in March. Judgment on whether BHP can be held liable for the collapse is pending.
BHP denies liability and says the case duplicates legal proceedings and reparation and repair programs in Brazil. In the trial's first week, Brazil signed a 170 billion reais ($30.6 billion) compensation agreement with BHP, Vale and Samarco.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Brazil tightens credit fund rules to limit bank risk-taking
SAO PAULO, Aug 1 (Reuters) - Brazil's National Monetary Council (CMN), the country's top economic policy body, approved on Friday fresh rules for the contributions that financial institutions associated with the country's Credit Guarantee Fund (FGC) must make to the fund. Among the changes, the CMN increased the so-called additional contribution by doubling its multiplier to 0.02%. The new rules will come into effect in June 2026. In a statement, the body said the measures aim to mitigate excessive risk-taking by the institutions. The FGC is a private nonprofit entity created to manage protection mechanisms for clients of financial institutions in the event of bank resolution. The fund has drawn renewed attention following the high-profile acquisition of lender Banco Master by BRB ( opens new tab, a deal the central bank is currently analyzing. The transaction has sparked scrutiny as it involves two similarly sized banks, with Master having grown rapidly in recent years through an aggressive funding model based on high-yield debt, backed by FGC guarantees and distributed via investment platforms. Under another new rule approved by the monetary council, any member institution deemed excessively leveraged by the technical standards established by the central bank will be required to allocate excess funds to federal government bonds, seen as safe assets, thereby limiting risk-taking in other types of investments.
Reuters
5 hours ago
- Reuters
Brazil's Justice Moraes ignores US sanctions, says he will continue doing his job
SAO PAULO, Aug 1 (Reuters) - Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who is overseeing a criminal case against an ally of President Donald Trump, told a court session on Friday that he will continue to do his job and "ignore the sanctions" imposed by the United States that effectively block him from the country's wide-reaching financial system. On Wednesday, the U.S. imposed sanctions on Moraes for overseeing the trial of former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, accusing the judge of authorizing arbitrary pre-trial detentions and suppressing freedom of expression. Justice Moraes has presided over the criminal case against Bolsonaro, who has been charged with plotting a coup to overturn Brazil's 2022 presidential election after his supporters violently stormed government buildings following the election victory of leftist Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva. The U.S. sanctions were accompanied by an executive order imposing a 50% tariff on Brazilian goods, which was also tied to the case Moraes is overseeing against Bolsonaro, an unwavering supporter of the U.S. president. Bolsonaro, a far-right former army captain, and several of his closest allies were charged with plotting a coup to overturn his 2022 electoral loss, in a case that was in many ways similar to accusations against Trump. Moraes said the court would not submit itself to foreign coercion or what he likened to new coup attempts by Bolsonaro's allies. Moraes said the Federal Supreme Court will continue to exercise its role as guardian of the Constitution. "It will continue to exercise its role in criminal proceedings so that it can provide a final answer to all Brazilian society regarding who was truly responsible" for the attempted coup, he said, adding that there will be due process of law with no internal or external interference. Congressman Eduardo Bolsonaro, a son of the former president who moved to the U.S. to persuade the White House to intervene in his father's favor, has claimed credit for Trump's policies on Brazil. "This criminal organization's insistence on implementing measures harmful to Brazil, by encouraging the imposition of these tariffs and making spurious and illegal attacks against Brazilian public officials, is aimed at creating a severe economic crisis in the country," he said. "But to the dismay of these traitorous Brazilians, that crisis will not happen." Moraes added that the court would conclude the trial of those accused of attempting a coup d'état before the end of the year.
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Hulking athlete filmed beating his girlfriend to a pulp moans that he's fearful for HIS safety in jail
A former basketball player who was arrested for the savage beating of his girlfriend is now begging a court to allow him to be placed in solitary confinement over fears for his safety. Igor Cabral, 29, flew into a jealous rage July 26 when he confronted his girlfriend, Juliana Soares, 35, and punched her 61 times in the elevator of a condominium in Natal, a city in northeastern Brazil. Cabral, who is facing an attempted murder charge, claimed in a letter submitted by attorney this week that he wanted to be kept away from the general population at the Parnamirim Reception and Triage Center. In the motion, Cabral claimed that he wanted to be separated from the six other detainees he is currently sharing a jail cell with to 'preserve his life and physical integrity.' The Rio Grande do Norte Penitentiary Administration secretariat told O Globo newspaper that Cabral is scheduled to be transferred to a prison 'by the end of this week, or at the beginning of next week.' The secretariat explained that Cabral is currently undergoing physical and mental health evaluations and an 'adaption period' to the jail system. '[He] is not in a 'normal' collective cell, he is in one known as 'insurance cell,' the official said. 'That's why he has six prisoners, in the others there are more, at least ten.' His attorneys argued in the court filing that Cabral should be kept away from the rest of the prisoners because a list of home addresses linked to him had been recently published on social media and that a criminal faction had issued threats against him. Family members distanced themselves from him by releasing a statement indicating they did not share any 'responsibility to the acts committed by' him. The Rio de Grande do Norte Civil Police said the couple at a barbecue with friends before Cabral beat Soares. Video footage of the assault showed Soares standing in an elevator corner opposite Cabral and appearing to make a point during a conversation when Cabral suddenly rushed at her and punched her three times before she fell to the floor. Cabral leaned over a defenseless Soares and continued to punch her for nearly 35 seconds before she stood up on her own with her face covered in blood. The elevator then stopped before the couple walked out together. The building security watched the incident on camera and rushed to help, with residents then helping restrain Soares until the Military Police arrived. Soares was taken to Walfredo Gurgel Hospital, where she was treated for multiple facial fractures. She was scheduled to undergo reconstructive surgery Tuesday, but doctors canceled the procedure after they detected an edema, or fluid buildup, on her face. The young woman, who is recovering at home, addressed the incident for the first time Tuesday. 'I have access to my Instagram profile and I appreciate all the solidarity and love everyone is offering me right now,' she wrote on her Instagram Stories. 'It's a very difficult time and I need to focus on my recovery. Thank you to all my friends who are being my support network right now.' Cabral initially said in a police statement that he attacked Soares because of a disagreement. Soares told Record TV that they were in the pool of the building when she received a text message moments she was attacked in the elevator. After walking out the elevator, she said they took separate elevators to the apartment and declined to leave the apartment to return to their home in Curitbá - a city in the southern state of Paraná - because she was afraid, which angered Cabral even more. 'He said I was going to die and started beating me,' she said. 'I didn't black out, but I also wasn't conscious enough to remember what he said at that moment.' Cabral was part of the Brazilian 3x3 national team at the 2014 Youth Olympic Games in Nanjing, China.
