Municipalities call for changes to 'tremendously concerning' N.S. transportation bill
The Progressive Conservative government's proposed Bill 24 grants sweeping powers to the public works minister over transportation and transit decisions. It states the minister could order a municipality to build or remove infrastructure, and "do anything necessary" to ensure the smooth movement of people and goods.
If that work isn't done in a "reasonable time," the province could complete it — and the cost would become a municipal debt owed to the province.
Pam Mood, Yarmouth mayor and president of the Nova Scotia Federation of Municipalities, said dozens of mayors, wardens and senior municipal staff met last week to talk about the pending legislation.
She said there was a "huge fear" that municipalities would receive a bill they couldn't afford, pushing them into bankruptcy because of their inability to run deficits.
"There were pieces like that that were tremendously concerning," Mood said last Thursday.
NSFM members were also worried about municipal autonomy being removed "without a conversation," Mood said.
But Mood said she had a positive meeting with Municipal Affairs Minister John Lohr and Public Works Minister Fred Tilley late last week. Mood said the ministers told her the PC government does not intend to take dramatic steps such as billing a municipality for project work, and are open to clarifying wording that would "take away the angst" and concerns.
"That's certainly not the province's intention. They understand, like we do, whatever is good for municipalities is good to uplift the entire province," Mood said.
But Mood said a wording change is important.
"We can't have municipalities out there believing something that simply won't happen," she said. "Because when it's in the legislation, it's saying it can happen."
Mayor Elspeth McLean-Wile of the District of Lunenburg said she isn't comfortable with the bill's wording.
In a rural district made up of mostly provincial roads and few municipally-owned streets, McLean-Wile said she's concerned the minister could force the municipality to pay for improvements to provincial roadways.
McLean-Wile said municipal leaders are very aware of the importance of improving transportation and transit, and would be happy to collaborate with the government on a provincewide approach.
"One has to wonder, why does the province believe it needs that new power? And why would it not work with us to figure out solutions to this that could help meet their objectives, without jeopardizing the tax base and increasing the tax burden on municipal government?" McLean-Wile said.
"It isn't clear what the intent is behind this, and that is worrisome."
Bill 24 also changes the Joint Regional Transportation Agency (JRTA) to Link Nova Scotia, broadening its scope to the entire province instead of Halifax and surrounding areas.
The JRTA's final report has yet to be released, but the province has announced pieces, like a Halifax light-rail study and new highway connectors. Link N.S. will be able to acquire or build transportation assets, manage a transit service, and prepare a province-wide plan to improve transportation.
Mayor Cecil Clarke of the Cape Breton Regional Municipality said he's glad to see the province owning the transportation file, and is hopeful Link Nova Scotia's work could lead to expanded transit, port capacity, and light rail in CBRM.
"This brings me to a table we weren't at a year ago, so I'll treat it as an opportunity rather than a threat," said Clarke, a former Progressive Conservative MLA.
Bill 24 also states a municipality's regulations, bylaws and policies for transportation must be reasonably consistent with plans from the provincial government and Link N.S.
But Coun. Kathryn Morse of the Halifax Regional Municipality said she's concerned those provincial priorities might not always align with the capital city's — the latest example being Premier Houston's decision to remove the Halifax bridge tolls in April.
"It's going to increase traffic. It's not ideal in terms of managing traffic to remove tolls," said Morse, adding that cities like London and New York have gone in the opposite direction with congestion pricing.
"We're taking our existing congestion pricing away at not the best time. So to me, the whole toll removal, the way it was done is kind of a cautionary tale when it comes to Bill 24," Morse said.
CBC asked Halifax Mayor Andy Fillmore's office for reaction to Bill 24, but did not receive a response.
Mayor Mood said conversations with the PC government will continue as the bill moves through Province House. The legislation was introduced on Feb.20, and has yet to pass second reading or the law amendments committee.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
7 hours ago
- CTV News
Ousted United Conservative MLAs resuscitating Alberta's once-dominant PC Party
This composite image shows former United Conservative Party MLA Scott Sinclair, left, at the Alberta legislature building in Edmonton on Monday, March 10, 2025, and former UCP infrastructure minister Peter Guthrie, in Edmonton, on Friday, June 9, 2023. The two are resuscitating the province's once-dominant Progressive Conservative Party. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jack Farrell, Jason Franson EDMONTON — Two former members of Alberta's governing United Conservative Party are resuscitating the province's once-dominant Progressive Conservative Party. Former infrastructure minister Peter Guthrie and legislature member Scott Sinclair were booted from caucus earlier this year for pushing back against the Premier Danielle Smith's government and now sit as Independents. Sinclair says the province's two-party system has become too divisive, and they want to galvanize support from Albertans who feel they don't have a political home. Former NDP premier Rachel Notley ended the PC's 44-year dynasty in 2015, prompting conservatives to merge the Wildrose and PCs into the United Conservative Party. Sinclair told the Ryan Jespersen podcast that Smith has morphed what was supposed to be a mainstream, big tent party into a separatist party. Guthrie said on the podcast that Smith has turned her back on accountability while spending too much money on a growing, bloated bureaucracy. The two are aiming to gather the 8,800 signatures needed to register as a political party with Elections Alberta. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 2, 2025. Lisa Johnson, The Canadian Press
Winnipeg Free Press
7 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Kinew's two options: let Fontaine dig herself out of hole after outburst or fire her
Opinion Is Nahanni Fontaine guilty of a firing offence? Last week, the minister responsible for accessibility was caught making profane complaints about an American Sign Language interpreter. The comments were captured on a 'hot mic' following a June 26 event celebrating Indigenous women graduates at the University of Manitoba. Fontaine, who is also the families minister and minister responsible for gender equity, was on a stage addressing graduates when she reportedly became frustrated by the close proximity of the interpreter. Following her speech, Fontaine exchanged comments with one of her staffers that were captured by a live mic and recorded by the Aboriginal Peoples Television Network, which was covering the event. MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES Families minister Nahanni Fontaine, the minister responsible for accessibility, has apologized for her hot mic moment. But is that enough? 'The woman, she shouldn't have been on the stage…' Fontaine is overheard saying. 'I'm like 'f—-, why did I have her on the stage? Like, Jesus, I'm like, 'You need to leave.'' Fontaine was immediately and summarily condemned by accessibility advocates and activists from Manitoba's deaf community. Fontaine did apologize, but in politics, apologies on their own rarely solve a problem like this. Given the legislature is on summer break, Fontaine has been spared from what would have been a relentless roasting by opposition MLAs that would have no doubt included demands for her resignation. Thanks to social media, those demands were made anyway. On Facebook, Progressive Conservatives condemned Fontaine for comments 'unbecoming of an elected official.' The Tories added, to no one's surprise, that Fontaine needs to go. 'She must also immediately resign this cabinet responsibility that she clearly does not respect,' the PC statement read. In the modern world of hyper-partisanism, resignation demands between political combatants are ubiquitous. Still, Fontaine's ill-advised comments do prompt a question: what is, in the current political climate, a bona fide firing offence? One can only hope that, at the very least, Premier Wab Kinew is asking himself this question. The premier has been put in a difficult position. Fontaine has always been outspoken, both as an activist and later as a politician. While in opposition, she was one of the most disliked critics by the PC government. That alone suggests she has the potential to be an effective politician. In government, Fontaine has been relatively low key, no doubt a reflection of the fact she does not possess one of the handful of truly front-bench portfolios. Families is a huge and potentially tricky department, but it's not health, finance or justice, the marquee cabinet postings that tend to be the most politically challenging. Having said that, Kinew needs Fontaine to be at her best in families and related responsibilities, including accessibility. What he doesn't need is a minister who portrayed herself as more concerned about her personal space than she was about the need for an ASL interpreter. Particularly at an event where, it was reported later, there were deaf graduates. There is no evidence Fontaine's attempts to apologize have not been thorough and sincere. Since her comments were made public, she has issued two statements of apology, she has spoken directly to the interpreter and contacted organizations that advocate for deaf Manitobans. Is that enough? The political calculus on this issue is complex. Fontaine is an ambitious, well-known politician who has deep reach into several key NDP constituencies. Taking her down for this incident would, no doubt, produce blowback within the party's base of support. It isn't clear whether Fontaine's egregious behaviour will cost the NDP in the next election. She has become estranged, possibly on a permanent basis, from the deaf community and many within the broader accessibility community. Even so, there are many within those constituencies who realize that dealing with an NDP government is preferable to the alternative. However, beyond the immediate effect on the accessibility community, this does have the potential to become a smudge on an NDP brand that has been successful in drawing votes outside of the party's traditional base. This is one of those political anecdotes that could put a bad taste in the mouth of some voters who, for the most part, are not deeply engaged in the politics of accessibility. In other words, they won't condemn Fontaine and the NDP specifically for insulting an ASL interpreter; they might, however, see it as a sign the NDP cannot back up its talk about being a party of equity and social justice. To this point, Kinew hasn't said a word about this incident and his continued silence is getting hard to ignore. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. It would not be wrong for Kinew to let Fontaine work her way out of the hole she dug for herself; good premiers and prime ministers often leave cabinet members to find their own solutions to self-made problems. On the other hand, if there is concern in the premier's office about longer-term damage from Fontaine's outburst, then Kinew has to show Manitobans he is concerned about what happened. That concern may not become evident right away. Fontaine must know that despite her boundless ambition to move up the cabinet hierarchy, every cabinet shuffle from this point represents a chance she will be demoted or left out altogether. Such is the fate of a politician who lets her inner-most thoughts leak into the public realm. Dan LettColumnist Dan Lett is a columnist for the Free Press, providing opinion and commentary on politics in Winnipeg and beyond. Born and raised in Toronto, Dan joined the Free Press in 1986. Read more about Dan. Dan's columns are built on facts and reactions, but offer his personal views through arguments and analysis. The Free Press' editing team reviews Dan's columns before they are posted online or published in print — part of the our tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Globe and Mail
10 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Independent Alberta MLAs revive PC name to create new political party
The two outcasts in Alberta's Legislature have banded together to form a new provincial party, under the old Progressive Conservative banner. Peter Guthrie and Scott Sinclair have been sitting as Independents since the governing United Conservative Party expelled them earlier this year. Now they are preparing to revive the Progressive Conservative Association of Alberta, the formal name of the party that ruled the province for 43 years before the brand became synonymous with entitlement and cronyism and evolved into the UCP. But the pair, in a joint interview with The Globe and Mail, said they expect Albertans will associate the name with the PC's better days. They plan to pitch it as a conservative alternative to the UCP under Premier Danielle Smith, who in November won the approval of 91.5 per cent of her party members in a leadership review. 'The UCP has gone off course,' Mr. Guthrie said. 'The Premier has abandoned Albertans.' Former Alberta minister removed from caucus alleges Premier 'deliberately misled' cabinet Mr. Guthrie, who serves as the leader of the two-person aspiring party, said the NDP will win the next election if a new centre-right party is not on the ballot. 'Albertans will reject the UCP for the same reason that they voted for change in 2015,' he said. 'And that's to get rid of the same things that are creeping into the government now – that entitlement and corruption, that lack of transparency and accountability.' Mr. Guthrie, who represents the riding of Airdrie-Cochrane, resigned from cabinet on Feb. 25 because he felt Ms. Smith was mishandling allegations, levelled by Alberta Health Services' former chief executive, of government interference in healthcare contracting and procurement. Caucus later kicked him out. The health agency and government deny the allegations, which have not been tested in court. The allegations, coupled with related investigations from the RCMP, Auditor-General, and a former Manitoba judge appointed by the Premier, have not had a major effect on Ms. Smith's popularity and control over the UCP. Mr. Sinclair, meanwhile, was booted because he said he could not support the budget the UCP presented in February, which projected a $5.2-billion deficit. He believes Albertans will gravitate to a revitalized PC party after years of polarization across the province. 'People really don't feel like they have a home politically in our province anymore,' Mr. Sinclair, who represents Lesser Slave Lake, said. 'One party seems too far one way, the other party seems to have shifted too far another way.' He believes voters are longing for a 'a stable, normal government that is not so chaotic and reckless.' Alberta MLA booted from caucus after saying he won't support tabled budget The effort must gather roughly 8,900 signatures to proceed with the Elections Alberta process, Mr. Sinclair noted. He dismissed concerns about recreating a landscape where conservatives split the vote. Mr. Sinclair argued that large swaths of the electorate consider the UCP a separatist party under Ms. Smith. She recently made it easier for citizens to force referendums, appeasing restless members of her party pushing for independence following the federal Liberal party winning its fourth consecutive election in April. And that means Albertans loyal to Canada, Mr. Sinclair predicted, will side with the NDP in the next election. 'We're trying to provide a really healthy alternative for people,' he said. Ms. Smith was the leader of the Wildrose Party in 2012, when the PCs pulled out a last-minute victory. Then, in late 2014, she and eight Wildrose MLAs crossed the floor to join the PCs. The defection crashed her political career – she did not win the PC nomination contest in her riding – and contributed to the NDP's victory in the 2015 snap election. The UCP was founded in 2017, out of fear of vote-splitting. Jason Kenney, a federal cabinet minister under former Prime Minister Stephen Harper, returned to Alberta in 2016 with a plan to unite Alberta's two right-leaning parties. He argued the NDP would win again if conservatives did not consolidate. Opinion: Alberta's independence panel? Been there, done that He first won the leadership of the PCs, on a promise to pursue a merger with the rival Wildrose, which itself was an offshoot of the dynastic party. He then pushed Wildrose and PC members to vote on joining forces and won the new party's inaugural leadership contest. Under his leadership, the UCP trounced the NDP in 2019. After years on the political margins, Ms. Smith won the UCP leadership contest in 2022, pulling the party further to the right. Her tenure has largely been defined by clashing with Ottawa and eschewing scientific consensus on COVID-19. Most recently, critics accuse her of being a closet separatist, despite her insistence that she favours what she calls a 'sovereign Alberta within a united Canada.' Mr. Guthrie said a woman in Calgary had control of the PC's formal name and approached the pair about its availability after they were kicked out of the UCP.
