&w=3840&q=100)
SC upholds West Bengal's resumption of Hindustan Motors' factory land
Ishita Ayan Dutt Bhavini Mishra New Delhi
The Supreme Court on Wednesday dismissed a special leave petition (SLP) filed by Hindustan Motors, affirming the validity of the West Bengal government's resumption of 395 acres of land allotted to the company at Uttarpara, Hooghly.
Debanjan Mandal, managing partner, Fox & Mandal, said this marks the culmination of a prolonged legal battle, during which the state successfully demonstrated that the land had remained unutilised for several decades and that its resumption was in public interest and in accordance with law.
Fox & Mandal appeared on behalf of the state of West Bengal.
When contacted, Uttam Bose, director of Hindustan Motors, responded 'no comments' via text.
The Hindustan Motors' Uttarpara plant, which used to roll out the iconic Ambassador car, had declared 'suspension of work' in 2014, which continued.
The legal wrangle between the state and the company goes back to 2022. On July 6, 2022, the West Bengal government had expressed its intention to resume the 395 acres of land.
By an order dated November 9, 2022, the state resumed the 395 acres, which was challenged by the company and set off legal proceedings.
Earlier, the Land Tribunal had upheld the state's decision to resume the land under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953. This was challenged by Hindustan Motors before the Calcutta High Court, which, by its judgment dated May 22, 2025, rejected the appeal and confirmed the state's right to resume the unused land.
Earlier in the week, the West Bengal Cabinet approved the transfer of a 40-acre parcel to Titagarh Rail Systems (TRSL). This was part of Hindustan Motors' Uttarpara land and prompted a sharp reaction from the company.
In a filing with the stock exchanges on July 15, Hindustan Motors said that on July 11, 2025, at around 11.00 am, officials including the additional district magistrate, Hooghly, accompanied by the BL & LRO, police personnel and several others, without prior intimation, forcibly entered the factory premises and trespassed, intimidated and wrongfully seized the property at the company's premises situated at Hindmotor, Uttarpara.
'The suo motu action taken by the concerned department of the government of West Bengal, despite our special leave petition listed and pending for hearing before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, has caused considerable prejudice to our challenge,' it mentioned.
However, Wednesday's development in the apex court marks the end of a long road for the country's first carmaker, Hindustan Motors, at Uttarpara — which goes back to 1946.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Supertech homebuyers seek CJI, PM intervention to let NBCC complete projects
Homebuyers of 16 stalled housing projects by Supertech have written to Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and Prime Minister Narendra Modi, seeking their intervention to hand over these projects to state-owned NBCC instead of NCR-based Apex Group. The homebuyers called for vacating a stay imposed by the top court on a National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) order in December 2024, directing that all these projects be entrusted to NBCC (India) Ltd for time-bound completion. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Operations Management Digital Marketing MBA Cybersecurity Project Management healthcare Healthcare CXO Data Science Product Management Public Policy others Design Thinking Degree Finance PGDM Data Science Technology MCA Others Artificial Intelligence Data Analytics Management Leadership Skills you'll gain: Quality Management & Lean Six Sigma Analytical Tools Supply Chain Management & Strategies Service Operations Management Duration: 10 Months IIM Lucknow IIML Executive Programme in Strategic Operations Management & Supply Chain Analytics Starts on Jan 27, 2024 Get Details The stay was based on a proposal Apex Group submitted to the Supreme Court to revive the projects. 'After enduring over a decade of financial loss, mental trauma, and shattered dreams, we now face the imminent threat of being handed over once again to a private entity — Apex Heights Pvt Ltd — whose proposal and compliance affidavit submitted to the SC is fundamentally flawed, financially unviable, ethically questionable, and devastating for homebuyers,' they said in the letter. The 16 stuck projects of Supertech comprise 50,962 homes, of which 39,870 are sold and 11,092 remain unsold. Of the sold homes, 24,871 have been handed over to buyers, while 14,999 are yet to be delivered. Live Events An investment of Rs 1,700 crore is required to complete the sold homes, while receivables from these units are estimated at Rs 2,200 crore. 'NBCC has delivered large-scale, complex stalled housing projects such as Amrapali. It has the technical expertise, government backing, operational credibility, and most importantly — the trust of homebuyers,' said Mujeebur Rahman, a homebuyer. The buyers have also demanded the disqualification of Apex from the resolution process and the complete removal of Supertech promoters from it. 'We have requested the Supreme Court that no further interlocutory applications (IA) be entertained at this advanced stage of the proceedings. It has already been 15 long years, and more than 50,000 homebuyers are still waiting for their homes, having suffered immense financial and mental distress,' Rahman said. Homebuyers have alleged that Supertech is attempting to block NBCC's onboarding by pushing the Apex proposal. Supertech, however, said once the Supreme Court approves the resolution plan submitted by Apex Heights, it will pave the way for all stakeholders to complete the 16 projects, with deliveries to homebuyers starting within three months and being completed in the next 24 months, in addition to repayment to financial institutions and land authorities as agreed in the plan. 'Since the de-linking of the Doon Square Project in reverse insolvency, the handover of units has been done by Ametek, the codeveloper in the project, well before the time stipulated. NCLAT had directed delivery in 12 months, whereas 100% handover of units to homebuyers has been successfully completed in nine months,' Supertech said in a statement. Apex Group has agreed to clear Rs 678 crore of dues to five banks and around Rs 1,900 crore to Noida, Greater Noida, and Yamuna authorities. In the initial phase, the company has committed to invest Rs 500 crore, with plans to deliver the flats within two years of taking over. Economic Times WhatsApp channel )
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
DoT issues Rs 7,800-crore demand notice to Tata Communications over AGR dues
The Department of Telecom has demanded Rs 7,800 crore from Tata Communications. This demand is for adjusted gross revenue dues from 2005 to 2024. Tata Communications is reviewing the demand notice. The company believes its licenses differ from those in a previous Supreme Court judgement. Tata Communications plans to defend its position based on legal opinions. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads New Delhi: The Department of Telecom has issued a "show-cause-cum-demand notice" of about Rs 7,800 crore to Tata Communications over adjusted gross revenue dues, according to an official note by the demand has been raised by the Department of Telecom ( DoT ) for adjusted gross revenue (AGR) from 2005-06 till 2023-24, as per the note dated July 17."As at June 30, 2025, the company has received 'Show Cause-cum Demand Notices' ('demand notices') from Department of Telecommunications of India aggregating to Rs 7,827.55 crore for financial years ranging from FY 2005-06 to FY 2023-24, which have been revised over a period of time," Tata Communications Managing Director AS Lakshminarayan said the demand notices include Rs 276.68 crore towards disallowance of deductions claimed by the company on payment basis for the financial year (FY) 2010-11 under ISP (internet service provider) licence and FY07 and FY10 under NLD (national long distance) Communications has existing appeals relating to its ILD (International Long Distance), NLD, and ISP licences that were filed in the past and are pending at the Supreme Court and telecom tribunal said the company's appeals are not covered by the apex court judgement dated October 24, 2019, on AGR under the old telecom licence regime called UASL."Further, the company believes that all its licences are different from UASL, which was the subject matter of Hon'ble Supreme Court judgement of October 24, 2019. The company, based on its assessment and independent legal opinions, believes that it will be able to defend its position," Lakshminarayan per initial calculation by the government, telecom operators had liability to pay around Rs 1.65 lakh crore in total AGR dues till calculation as of March 2022 showed that the AGR liability on Bharti Airtel was Rs 31,280 crore, Vodafone Idea Rs 59,236.63 crore, Reliance Jio Rs 631 crore, BSNL Rs 16,224 crore, MTNL Rs 5,009.1 crore up to financial year government calculation at that time did not include liability on Tata Communications.
New Indian Express
7 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Delhi government seeks SC review of ELV ban, calls it unfair
NEW DELHI: The Delhi government has filed a petition with the Supreme Court, requesting a reconsideration of the ban on 'End-of-Life Vehicles' (ELVs). It argues that the policy unfairly impacts middle-class vehicle owners, especially in the absence of solid scientific evidence to support its effectiveness. This comes in the wake of a 2018 Supreme Court ruling and a subsequent National Green Tribunal order that mandates the phase-out of petrol vehicles older than 15 years and diesel vehicles older than 10 years in the NCR. Delhi government officials argued that these age-based standards overlook advancements in vehicle emissions technology, especially considering the April 2020 introduction of Bharat Stage VI (BS-VI) standards. The application filed by the government said, 'The roadworthiness of a vehicle is a technical and scientific issue that must be linked to actual emissions as tested and recorded by mechanisms set out under the Motor Vehicles Act, the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, etc., as opposed to a blanket ban on the basis of age, which is unlinked to actual emissions.' The application notes that other nations, such as the European Union, Japan, and the United States of America, do not impose age-based bans and instead adopt a measured and sustainable approach that addresses both pollution and urban decongestion holistically. Environment Minister Majinder Singh Sirsa mentioned that the government's review application emphasises the need for data-backed assessment, rather than broad limitation, on the actual emissions produced by each vehicle, regardless of its age. The government argued that the ban unfairly impacts owners of well-maintained vehicles, ignoring factors like usage, upkeep, and PUC compliance, the plea stated. The Delhi government's petition highlights that around 2.8 million BS-IV and BS-VI vehicles are registered in the city. It also stated that the current age-based ban could exclude compliant vehicles. It has further prayed that the Court direct the Union Ministry of Road Transport and Highways and the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) to conduct a comprehensive scientific study on environmental benefits, the fairness of such a blanket ban, and if such a ban will improve the air quality in NCR.
