logo
V&A can't return looted objects. Our hands are tied by law

V&A can't return looted objects. Our hands are tied by law

Times2 days ago
The Victoria and Albert Museum director has criticised the rules that prevent the museum from returning artefacts to their countries of origin as 'outdated and infantilising'.
Tristram Hunt said the 1983 National Heritage Act and the limitations it imposes on trustees are wrong, and called for the law to be 'amended and changed'.
He said trustees should 'have autonomy over their collections to be able to make a decision whether they should be deaccessioned [to remove an item from a museum to return or sell it] on ethical or moral grounds, or not'.
The British Museum Act of 1963, which provided the foundation for the 1983 legislation, means institutions such as the British Museum, the V&A, Kew Gardens, and the Royal Armouries are legally prohibited from permanently deaccessioning items in their collections, except under four specific circumstances.
They can get rid of an object only if it is a perfect duplicate; if it is unsuitable for retention in collections and can be disposed of 'without detriment to students or the public'; if it is damaged beyond repair; or if it is being transferred to another museum subject to the act.
'When people say, 'Why don't you return objects? You're just hiding behind the law' — the law is the law. Operating under the rule of law, particularly today, seems quite an important principle,' said Hunt, who has been making the case for the law to change since 2022.
Speaking at the University of Cambridge's Global Humanities Network last month, Hunt provided some examples of items acquired by the V&A that have a complicated history, but did not explicitly say he would return them.
He cited Tippoo's Tiger, which was made for Tipu Sultan, the ruler of Mysore in southern India from 1782 to 1799, and is described by the V&A on its website as one of its 'most famous and intriguing objects'. It was looted in 1799 after the Siege of Seringapatam when the British East India Company stormed Tipu Sultan's capital.
Hunt also mentioned a crown and gold chalice seized by British troops from Ethiopia 150 years ago, and Asante crown regalia acquired by the V&A in 1874 from items looted by British troops in Ghana.
Last year, a partnership with the Manhyia Palace Museum in Ghana meant the Asante royal regalia collections could be displayed in Ghana for the first time in 150 years in the city of Kumasi via a long-term loan. Ethiopia rejected a similar deal with the seized items.
Hunt said: 'The Ethiopian government, for perfectly understandable political reasons, took the view that, you know, 'you offering to lend stuff you stole from us' wasn't politically viable so we've reached a kind of impasse with these objects.'
The British Museum, which is not subjected to the same 1983 Act, has long been the subject of debate around the ownership of its artefacts, particularly the Elgin Marbles. For decades, Greece has voiced its desire for the the Parthenon sculptures — which were removed by Lord Elgin, the British ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, in the early 19th century and transported to the UK — to be returned.
Hunt, 51, who was the Labour MP for Stoke-on-Trent Central before becoming the director of the V&A in 2017, also said he was wary of museums becoming too politicised.
He said: 'We shouldn't be places where people who are Conservative feel they're not welcome. My salary is paid by Reform voters, Conservative voters, non-voters. If we think we should be places for instilling a sort of social justice mindset, then I think we invalidate our role.'
He also reflected on Britain's attitude to decolonisation and historical introspection, in contrast with the more celebratory approach taken in other parts of the world. 'You go to the Louvre, Abu Dhabi, and they are not concerned about this level of introspection. They just say, 'Here is a celebration of great civilisations across time and space',' he said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Firefighters tackle Blackpool storage unit blaze
Firefighters tackle Blackpool storage unit blaze

BBC News

time16 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Firefighters tackle Blackpool storage unit blaze

Firefighters have been tackling a fire at a storage unit in fire engines were called to the scene of the blaze at an industrial estate on Hoo Hill Lane in the Layton area of the town at about 06:00 BST, Lancashire Fire & Rescue Service items in the storage unit including carpets and furniture were destroyed by the fire service said an investigation has started into the cause but it was not believed to be deliberate. Listen to the best of BBC Radio Lancashire on Sounds and follow BBC Lancashire on Facebook, X and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.

Fire breaks out on busy London shopping street forcing Tube station to close as 70 firefighters tackle blaze
Fire breaks out on busy London shopping street forcing Tube station to close as 70 firefighters tackle blaze

The Sun

time18 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Fire breaks out on busy London shopping street forcing Tube station to close as 70 firefighters tackle blaze

A FIRE has broken out on a busy London shopping street, forcing a Tube station to close as 70 firefighters tackle the blaze. Firefighters were called to a fire in south London, where thick smoke was seen billowing over a shopping street. 3 3 3 Ten fire engines are tackling the blaze on Electric Avenue in Brixton, which is believed to have started in a storage area behind the busy shopping street. Brixton Tube station was temporarily closed on Monday morning due to the fire. Metropolitan Police officers were at the scene, blocking access to the street with police tape while the London Fire Brigade tackled the blaze. Firefighters could be seen heading in and out of several shops on Electric Avenue, trying to access a back area where the fire started. A large plume of smoke could be seen rising above the buildings on Monday morning. A fire engine with a long ladder could meanwhile be seen in use on Electric Lane, a small back alley behind the street which hosts Brixton market. No injuries have been reported as a result of the fire on Electric Avenue, Brixton, London Fire Brigade said. The fire on the busy south London shopping street appears to have been mostly extinguished. However, smoke can be seen billowing out of the doorway of one shop, while firefighters continue to work on Electric Avenue and a police cordon remains in place.

Loose peacock waking neighbours at 5am and destroying vegetable patches: ‘He's very annoying'
Loose peacock waking neighbours at 5am and destroying vegetable patches: ‘He's very annoying'

The Independent

time25 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Loose peacock waking neighbours at 5am and destroying vegetable patches: ‘He's very annoying'

A noisy peacock is causing chaos in a small town by climbing on roofs, pecking on windows and tearing up vegetable patches. The bird, named Percy by locals, wakes up residents in Marlborough, Wiltshire, at around 5am every day with a 'raucous' bellowing before searching for food. In one case, he destroyed a garden while enjoying a breakfast of lettuce, runner beans and other vegetables, according to residents. "It is quite vocal. People do find it gets them up about half past five in the morning with quite a raucous sound,' Eric Gilbert told the BBC. 'I found it in the middle of my lettuce patch, having a breakfast of my lettuce leaves," he said. 'It [also] likes my runner beans'. The 'annoying' bird has also taken to knocking on windows and doors and has been seen facing down cats and pigeons. Neighbour Angela Newberry added: "Very early in the morning, he taps on the window for food. He's very annoying, because he's got no snooze button." In one video, Percy could be seen walking on top of the roof of a detached house before calling out three times early in the morning. In February, a cockerel owner was ordered to pay more than £3,000 after neighbours repeatedly complained about his unruly cockerel's constant crowing. Officials from North East Derbyshire District Council (NEDDC) attended the address in New Tupton with specialist monitoring equipment and found the bird crowed 76 times in 50 minutes between 5.53am to 6.43am. It followed a previous investigation which saw equipment installed at the property, which found the frequency of the crowing was 'excessive' and continued in high numbers without the day. Speaking to the BBC, one female neighbour who wished to remain anonymous said: "A nuisance, a nightmare, early hours of the morning, crowing. And when you want to sleep at that time of the morning you don't need it.' She added the noise from the bird wasn't restricted to the morning. 'Sometimes it's all day. And I don't think it's right,' she said. Speaking outside court, Mr Brown disputed the complaints made by the neighbours against Brutus. The 82-year-old said: 'My cockerel does not make a lot of noise, he wears a neck collar which restricts the wind pipe and he can't suck in that amount of air to crow, he croaks, it's a croak.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store