Private clinics get final say on fees
PETALING JAYA: Although some doctors' groups have proposed new service charges in retaliation against the newly enforced rule for displaying drug prices, private clinics can exercise their own autonomy in deciding their fees, says a private practitioners' group.
The Federation of Private Medical Practitioners' Associations Malaysia insists that the proposals made by some of its state affiliates were made in 'good faith', adding that they were meant to help GPs cover the rising operational costs.
Its president Dr Shanmuganathan Ganeson said while advisories were issued, it is not compulsory for clinics to fix prices accordingly, and clinics are able to exercise full autonomy in setting their charges.
He was responding to a Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC) statement last Friday where the commission had cautioned private medical practitioners against introducing new service-related charges, as it could infringe the Competition Act 2010.
Dr Shanmuganathan revealed that medical practitioners had a dialogue with MyCC in December last year, during which a proposal for a RM20 regulatory compliance charge was considered.
Consequently, he said these state affiliates were mindful of not imposing fixed charges and opted to provide indicative ranges, but the move has since backfired.
'While the meeting with MyCC was constructive, the Competition Act now flags the decision to provide an indicative range as potentially problematic.
'At this point, we are compelled to ask: what are the government's real intentions toward private GP clinics?
'From where we stand, it appears the system is simply tolerating us until something more centralised and controlled is in place.
'Our profession is for patient care and the health of the rakyat,' Dr Shanmuganathan said when contacted.
'We want a sustainable, transparent GP ecosystem that patients can continue to trust.
'If there is no future for general practitioners in Malaysia's health system, we ask for honesty.
'Let us begin to responsibly wind down our practices so that our staff, medical suppliers, and patients are not blindsided when community-based private primary care collapses,' he added.
Dr Shanmuganathan said what was more disturbing was the regulatory imbalance where independent GP clinics are being scrutinised while corporate third-party administrators (TPAs) continue to suppress fees without equivalent oversight from the authorities.
GP Dr Roland Victor said it is not feasible for the price of medicines prescribed by clinics to be regulated as operating expenses may vary based on location.
'A shophouse in Mont Kiara will cost much more than (one) in Hulu Selangor.
'However, GP consultation fees have remained capped at RM35 for the past 30 years.
'Hence, GPs have no choice but to mark up medicine prices to manage their overhead costs such as rental, staffing and other facilities to sustain their clinics,' he said.
Dr Victor said he was not against the display of drug prices but GPs need to see consultation fees fairly revised for sustainability.
He agreed that TPAs contribute to the escalation of medical costs but they are not being monitored enough, nor are they regulated by the same laws imposed on GPs and clinics.
'These companies often dictate terms and conditions to GPs on how medical charges should be imposed,' Dr Victor said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Borneo Post
3 days ago
- Borneo Post
Private doctors urge SST exemption on foreign workers' primary healthcare
Dr Shanmuganathan said that as an alternative, the government could implement a temporary moratorium on the tax to allow time to explore a fair and sustainable healthcare financing mechanism. – Photo by Rodnae Productions/Pexels KUCHING (June 28): The Federation of Private Medical Practitioners' Associations, Malaysia (FPMPAM) has proposed for the government to fully exempt primary care services for foreign workers from the Sales and Services Tax (SST). FPMPAM president Dr Shanmuganathan Ganeson said that as an alternative, the government could implement a temporary moratorium on the tax to allow time to explore a fair and sustainable healthcare financing mechanism. 'We have formally submitted an appeal to the Ministry of Finance (MoF), urging an urgent exemption from the upcoming six per cent SST on primary healthcare services provided to foreign workers, scheduled to take effect on July 1,' he said in a statement yesterday. Dr Shanmuganathan said although the Foreign Workers Medical Examination Monitoring Agency (Fomena) screenings remained exempt, many foreign workers would still require outpatient care for common illnesses, injuries, and chronic conditions — essential services typically paid for out-of-pocket by the workers themselves, or arranged through employer or Third-Party Administrator (TPA) programmes. Under the new SST rules, such services would be taxed once a clinic's annual revenue exceeds RM1.5 million. Dr Shanmuganathan said: 'The foreign workers are already vulnerable and underserved, and the SST to basic medical treatment risks deterring them from seeking timely care, delaying diagnosis, and ultimately compromising public health. 'We are also concerned about the eight per cent SST on commercial property rentals, which would further escalate operating costs for clinics renting shoplots, medical suites, or office units. 'These taxes compound the strain on solo and small-group practices that have seen no fee adjustments for decades.' Dr Shanmuganathan also highlighted that the Federation of Malaysian Manufacturing (FMM) recently called for a broader reassessment of the SST expansion, citing its potential to harm the business environment and consumers. 'FPMPAM echoes this concern, urging the MoF to prioritise public health and service sustainability. 'FPMPAM also notes a policy anomaly where beauticians and cosmeticians, which are not related to essential health, now have no tax, whilst tax is imposed for essential health and medical services.' Nonetheless, Dr Shanmuganathan said the federation stood ready to work with the MoF to ensure that tax policies would not inadvertently undermine access to essential healthcare or threaten the survival of community clinics.
The Star
09-06-2025
- The Star
Review of GP consultation fees brought to DPM, says Health Minister
KUALA LUMPUR: The review of consultation fees for private general practitioners (GPs) has been raised to a task force chaired by Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, says Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad. Dr Dzulkefly stated that after a meeting between the Health Ministry and the National Action Council on Cost of Living (NACCOL), it was decided to escalate the issue to the executive task force led by the Deputy Prime Minister. 'We will bring it up for further details,' said Dr Dzulkefly to reporters after attending the opening ceremony of the 31st Association of Private Hospitals Malaysia (APHM) conference at the KL Convention Centre on Monday (June 9). Dr Dzulkefly also mentioned there is no deadline for finalising the review of consultation fees for private GPs. 'No, but at the soonest time possible, we will raise this Deputy Prime Minister, who chairs the executive task force, will look into the final touches of this,' said Dr Dzulkefly. On May 3, Dr Dzulkefly said the review of consultation fees for private GPs would be finalised within a month. The Medical Practitioners Coalition Association of Malaysia (MPCAM) proposed on Monday (June 9) to raise private GP fees to a range of RM50 to RM80. MPCAM noted that GP consultation fees have remained at RM10 to RM35 for more than three decades since 1992.
New Straits Times
06-06-2025
- New Straits Times
GPs: Outdated fees make practice a hard pill to swallow
KUALA LUMPUR: Outdated consultation fees and rising operational costs are squeezing general practitioners (GPs), forcing them to see more patients daily just to stay afloat. Consultation fees are regulated under Schedule 7 of the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Regulations. The fees were last revised in 1992, before construction of the Petronas Twin Towers, and are fixed between RM10 and RM35. The government is currently studying a possible increase. Federation of Private Medical Practitioners' Associations Malaysia president Dr Shanmuganathan T.V. Ganesan said a typical clinic needed at least RM40,000 a month to operate. This covers rent, wages, utilities, maintenance, medical supplies and statutory contributions, excluding the GP owner's or doctors' salaries and loan repayments. Dr Shanmuganathan said based on a flat RM30 consultation fee per patient, and excluding revenue from medicine or additional services, a GP would need to see about 53 patients a day to break even — nearly three times the actual average. "Unfortunately, consultation fees are no longer sufficient to sustain clinic operations. "Rising costs in wages, medical consumables, digital systems and regulatory compliance, especially with new price display mandates, have compounded the financial burden," he told the New Straits Times. The Malaysian Medical Association has called for a minimum RM60 consultation fee. On Thursday, the association urged the government to expedite cabinet approval for the revised rates, warning that continued delays could threaten the survival of private clinics nationwide. On May 3, Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad indicated that revisions would be finalised within a month. Dr Shanmuganathan said many patients required time-consuming consultations, counselling and emergency care, services that are often uncompensated. Clinics are also required to stock life-saving medications, many of which have short shelf lives and go unused. Former Johor assemblyman and practising GP Dr Boo Cheng Hau said a sustainable clinic needed to see at least 15 patients a day, five to six days a week, charging RM70 to RM100 per visit, including medication. He said the public must be educated on what constitutes a fair consultation fee. "For instance, for uncomplicated cough and cold cases, the market price in my area is about RM70 to RM80, inclusive of consultation and medication." he said. "Often, doctors have to lower their consultation fees to meet market demand, as medication costs exceed the consultation fee itself." PROFITS FROM MEDICINES Dr Shanmuganathan said many clinics were not operating on conventional "profits", as current consultation fees alone cannot sustain operations. To stay afloat, clinics often rely on modest profits from medicine sales. "This is not profiteering, but a pragmatic workaround in a system that restricts doctors from transparently charging for other professional services, such as nursing care, regulatory compliance, equipment use or consumables," he said. He estimated that a clinic spending RM12,000 per month on medicine stock might generate RM15,000 to RM17,000 in revenue, leaving a slim profit margin of RM3,000 to RM5,000. Additional revenue comes from procedural fees, health screenings and medical report preparation, but these are irregular and often underpriced due to market pressure. Dr Shanmuganathan said the recent implementation of medicine price display mandates had worsened matters. The Galen Centre for Health and Social Policy previously warned that the rule could lead more consumers to request prescriptions and buy medicines at lower prices from pharmacies. Its chief executive, Azrul Mohd Khalib, said while patients had every right to do so, this trend could undermine clinics' sustainability, as consultation fees remained low. "GPs hesitate to itemise every charge — nursing, registration, equipment use — for fear of alienating patients or appearing to overcharge," he said. AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION Both Dr Shanmuganathan and Dr Boo said Malaysia should adopt a national health scheme to address the crisis. In the United Kingdom, the National Health Service is funded primarily through general taxation, supported by National Insurance contributions. These fund services such as GP visits, hospital care and prescriptions. In November 2023, then health minister Datuk Seri Dr Zaliha Mustafa said Malaysia was exploring a national health insurance scheme involving contributions from employees, employers and the government. However, it has yet to materialise. Dr Boo said insurance policies must also cover outpatient management and GP visits, not just hospitalisation. He urged the government to raise its health spending from four per cent of the gross domestic product to between five and 10 per cent, in line with advanced nations. Dr Shanmuganathan added that such a scheme was necessary to strengthen healthcare financing and service delivery. He also proposed revising the GP consultation fee range to between RM50 and RM100, depending on case complexity. "It is important to recognise that these fees represent payment for the doctor's professional services and should not be subject to arbitrary discrimination," he said. "Doctors with the same qualifications should be paid fairly and equitably for the same scope of work."
