SNP MP dismisses call for party to enter House of Lords
He told The Times it was 'inconsistent' for the SNP to 'remain mute on the self-anointed meritocracy that rules over the most important aspects of Scottish public life today' – pointing to the quangos which run transport and water infrastructure and the position of Lord Advocate – while refusing to participate in Westminster's unelected second chamber.
But his suggestion was shot down by the SNP's deputy Westminster leader Pete Wishart (below).
(Image: PA)
The top MP, who once ran to be the Commons speaker, tweeted: 'Absolutely hilarious, and I don't think we'll be taking any advice from them. But finally a route to Parliament for the Albists.
'A place in the House of Lords certainly gets them over their tricky never being elected to anything problem.'
McEleny pointed to the SNP's support for the monarchy as evidence of inconsistency in their opinion.
READ MORE: Anas Sarwar 'hypocrisy' row as Labour council orders no busses from Alexander Dennis
He said: 'Being opposed to the House of Lords on the principle that it is unelected while simultaneously being at ease with supporting a policy of maintaining an unelected head of state and swearing an oath of allegiance to King or Queen is not coherent.'
And he claimed that Salmond was 'not opposed in principle' to getting nationalists into the second chamber were he still alive.
There was 'simply just no need for it when he was leading the national movement because he was leading us away from Westminster towards independence', McEleny (below) added.
(Image: Martini)
Former SNP Westminster leader Ian Blackford found himself under fire last year after he suggested the party should drop its opposition to entering the House of Lords, though he insisted he had no personal ambitions to join.
Plaid Cymru, the Welsh nationalist party, have peers and one of their members in the second chamber, Carmen Smith, told The National last year the SNP's position should be reviewed to get independence "in as many rooms as we can'.
McEleny was sacked as Alba's general secretary during a fractious leadership race which resulted in the election of Kenny MacAskill.
The latter previously saw off a bid by McEleny to suspend him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Shetland tunnels connecting to four islands could ‘transform' life – but locals are ‘frustrated' by controversial plans
Elsewhere, bold new plans to tunnel beneath a major UK city have been revealed ROAD DRAMA Shetland tunnels connecting to four islands could 'transform' life – but locals are 'frustrated' by controversial plans Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SHETLAND Islands Council is said to be pushing ahead with plans to build inter-island tunnels. The underwater network will connect the four outlying isles in the Scottish archipelago. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Tunnels in Shetland to connect the four islands could 'transform' lives Credit: Getty However critics have taken a swipe at council bosses and highlighted that the nearby Faroe Islands has had a similar system in place for years. The 18 islands - under Denmark's sovereignty - are connected by 23 tunnels, including four that run beneath the sea. The multi-million pound project could "transform" the life of locals but some residents have raised concerns. Anne Anderson of salmon producer Scottish Sea Farms branded the absence of tunnels as "frustrating". Tunnel builder Andy Sloan added: "Without doubt, Shetland can copy what has been achieved in [the Faroe Islands]." Elsewhere, bold new plans to tunnel beneath a major UK city for a massive underground train and tram network have been officially unveiled. The dramatic move aims to transform how people travel in and out of the busy urban centre and tackle future congestion. The ambitious project, based in Manchester and led by Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham, would see trains and trams running below ground for the first time in the city's history, aiming to ease congestion and support future economic growth. Speaking at the launch of Greater Manchester's new 10-year strategy, Mr Burnham said early design work would begin immediately, with Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) tasked with drawing up initial concepts. The network is expected to start with a new underground station at Manchester Piccadilly and could eventually stretch east-west and north-south across the region. Mr Burnham said: 'We are going underground. "We are building the Bee Network on the surface. "But if we achieve our economic ambitions, we'll struggle to cope with just that. "I'm going to ask TfGM to explore underground service options."
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Remembering grave atrocity should strengthen resolve to uphold peace, human rights and justice
The Scottish delegation visits Srebrenica Memorial Centre with Bosnian mothers of genocide victims This month marks 30 years since the genocide at Srebrenica, where over 8000 Bosnian men and boys were murdered by Bosnian-Serb forces. It remains the gravest atrocity committed on European soil since the Second World War. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... In February 2014, I led the first Scottish delegation to Srebrenica, supported by the UK charity Remembering Srebrenica. During our visit, we met survivors, religious leaders, police and the International Commission on Missing Persons in Sarajevo. The experience left a lasting impression and deepened our understanding of the importance of remembrance and justice. Shortly after the trip came the foundation of Remembering Srebrenica Scotland, an independent charity which has since led national efforts in education, commemoration and outreach. Across Scotland, schools, faith groups and local authorities take part in Srebrenica Memorial Week each July. The charity, now called Beyond Srebrenica, also runs a schools programme that helps young people learn about the consequences of hatred and division. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In May 2024, the United Nations General Assembly officially designated July 11 as the International Day of Reflection and Commemoration of the 1995 Genocide in Srebrenica. The resolution underlines the global responsibility to remember and to challenge genocide denial and hate speech. Scotland's engagement reflects a strong commitment to those principles. Beyond Srebrenica Scotland has amplified the voices of survivors, encouraged critical discussion, and built solidarity with Bosnia's diaspora communities. Marking this anniversary is not only about remembering the past. It is also about strengthening our collective resolve to uphold peace, human rights and justice in the present and for the future. Indeed, as we observe devastating conflicts in the world today, genocide remains very real. Angus Robertson is SNP MSP for Edinburgh Central and Constitution, External Affairs and Culture Secretary
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Scotland would be a lot stronger without economic impact of Brexit
The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates that Brexit has permanently reduced UK GDP by 4 per cent Edinburgh's economy has reached a historic milestone. For the first time, the capital's GDP per head has overtaken London's with output per person now sitting at £69,809 compared with London's £69,077. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A generation ago, Edinburgh was 19 per cent behind. The reversal is not just remarkable in statistical terms but speaks to long-term structural shifts in the balance of economic power within the UK. The growth has not come out of nowhere. Edinburgh has built up its reputation as a centre of financial services, data innovation and higher education. These sectors have attracted global firms, skilled workers and sustained investment. Recent figures show that Scotland as a whole has increased its share of all UK foreign direct investment (FDI) projects to 15.8 per cent. This is the highest proportion in over a decade. The number of financial services projects in Scotland reached a 10-year high with Edinburgh playing a key role. Across the UK the picture looks different. While Scotland's FDI numbers are increasing, the total number of projects in the UK fell by 12 per cent last year. Business confidence remains shaky, especially in sectors like manufacturing, energy and logistics. Global investors cite political instability and post-Brexit uncertainty as major deterrents. London experienced a 15 per cent fall in new investment projects. This should give the UK Government much food for thought about what does and doesn't work for balancing economic power and investment across the country. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scotland has shown resilience. For the past ten years, it has ranked as the most attractive UK location for inward investment outside London. That consistency is not accidental. It has been supported by coordination between the government, local authorities, national agencies and universities, especially in Edinburgh and Glasgow. Having seen their work first hand, Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Development International, and our economic and international-focussed public servants deserve great credit for the country's success. Scotland's financial and business leaders continue to secure our place at global industry top-tables. The Scottish Government's approach to key industries like clean energy, digital infrastructure and fintech has focused on attracting high-quality jobs and future-proofed investment. In Edinburgh, that strategy has yielded visible results. Long-established banks and insurers continue to invest, while emerging firms in green finance and software development are choosing the city as their base. Major institutions, from universities to cultural venues, help reinforce the city's appeal to talent. Combined with infrastructure upgrades and a commitment to climate-friendly development, this creates the kind of environment global investors look for. Despite this success, the wider economic reality for many people is still extremely difficult. Wages are under pressure. Public services are stretched. Core costs like housing, energy and food continue to rise. Against this backdrop, it is vital to be clear about what is holding Scotland back. The decision to leave the European Union has had a lasting and measurable economic impact. The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates that Brexit has permanently reduced UK GDP by 4 per cent. The Centre for European Reform estimates that business investment is 19 per cent lower than it would have been. Exports are weaker, inflation higher and key sectors have lost access to vital labour markets. Scotland did not vote for this path. Edinburgh's strong performance shows what is possible – but there is no doubt we would be in a stronger, fairer and more prosperous position today had Brexit not been forced upon us. Angus Robertson is SNP MSP for Edinburgh Central and Constitution, External Affairs and Culture Secretary
