Environmental group brings court challenge against Shannon LNG permission
The planning authority in March granted permission to Shannon LNG for the proposed development of a 600-megawatt power plant and energy storage facility on a 255-hectare (630-acre) site between Tarbert and Ballylongford on the Shannon estuary.
Advertisement
On Monday, Mr Justice Richard Humphreys gave permission to John Kenny BL, appearing for Friends of the Irish Environment (FIE) and instructed by FP Logue solicitors, to bring judicial review proceedings against An Bord Pleanala, Ireland, the Attorney General and the Minister for Housing. Shannon LNG is a notice party in the action.
Last September, following proceedings brought by Shannon LNG, Mr Justice Humphreys overturned the board's refusal of planning permission for a power plant, battery energy storage system and a regasification unit at the Shannon estuary site.
In its court documents, FIE claims ABP breached Irish and European law in granting permission for the proposed power plant and energy storage facility.
FIE claims An Bord Pleanala failed to adequately consider statutory carbon budgets and sectoral emissions ceilings set out in the Government's Climate Action Plan 2024 in its decision, and its related obligations under the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Act 2015.
Advertisement
FIE says that the board did not engage how the proposed development was consistent with carbon budgets and sectoral emissions ceilings, other than to justify the granted permission because of Government policy support for constructing gas fired power stations deemed necessary for achieving the target of a 50 per reduction in carbon emissions by 2030.
FIE says the calculated greenhouse gas emissions arising from the proposed development is 'manifestly incorrect and significantly underestimated' in an environmental impact assessment report submitted to the board by the developer.
Based on these 'underestimated' calculations, the proposed development will account for one third of all budgeted emissions – based on limits set out in 2024 Climate Action Plan – from the entire electricity sector in 2030, FIE claim.
Ireland
Four local authorities spending over €500k per yea...
Read More
FIE also says the board was wrong to find that the proposed development constitutes a sustainable development, and its decision to grant permission is invalid as it constitutes a material contravention of the Kerry County Development Plan 2022-2028 and Listowel Municipal District Local Area Plan 2020-2026.
Advertisement
FIE says An Bord Pleanala breached obligations under the European Union's environmental impact assessment directive.
The environmental group claims the board could not and did not make a valid decision on the impact of proposed development under the EU's Habitats Directive.
The case returns to court in two weeks.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
31 minutes ago
- BBC News
Oil and gas drilling licence surrendered at Dunsfold site
A licence to drill for oil and gas at a site in Surrey has reportedly been relinquished by UK Oil & Gas (UKOG).The firm had previously applied to explore the site in Dunsfold, with the application approved by the government, despite it twice being refused by the local Borough Council said the decision for UKOG to surrender its licence marked a "significant victory for the local community, environmental campaigners and the council".UKOG has been approached for comment. Local farmers previously argued that the disruption to traffic, businesses and the environment were not in proportion to potential the decision, councillor Steve Williams said it was a "momentous day for our community and our environment"."The decision by UKOG to surrender their licence is a testament to the tireless efforts of residents and campaigners who have stood firm in their opposition to this project," he said."It is a clear message that the protection of our natural heritage and the well-being of our residents must come first."Council leader Paul Follows added that the decision was "a step in the right direction" and reinforced the council's commitment to protecting the environment for future Sir Jeremy Hunt said drilling in Dunsfold was "always a ridiculous idea and would have ruined the area".He added: "This is wonderful news and totally the right decision."Meanwhile, UKOG previously said the project would benefit energy and economic firm said it would be able to extract gas from the Dunsfold site worth £123m, and that the project was in keeping with the government's Hydrogen, Energy Security and Net Zero strategies.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Wicklow council paid €613,000 for beach land as it was cheaper than going to court
A local authority paid €613,000 for land to secure public access to an idyllic beach saying it would be more expensive than going to court to guarantee a right of way. In internal discussions, Wicklow County Council said the purchase price was likely to be less than a High Court challenge, which would have no guarantee of success. Advertisement The land at Magheramore Beach was owned by Paddy McKillen Jnr's Oakmount who outbid the local authority for it in 2021 when they paid €700,000. Mr McKillen Jnr had hoped to develop a €40 million surf school, accommodation, and restaurant there, but the proposal was rejected by An Bord Pleanála. The 21-acre clifftop site went to auction again this year with a successful bid made by a Chinese investor based in Ireland. The investor later contacted Wicklow County Council offering them an opportunity to buy the site for €613,000 and 'step into the shoes' of the purchaser. Advertisement An internal council memo said it would secure permanent public access to the beach and that private ownership could lead to it being blocked off. It said: 'There is a registered private right of way the full length of the access lane to the beach; however, there is no public right of way currently registered for the lane. 'Therefore, a High Court case would have to be taken to secure public access. The legal costs for such a case would come to at least €600,000 with no guarantee that it would be successful.' It said the council should go ahead with buying the land, with no VAT payable, and both parties responsible for their own legal costs. Advertisement A council order form said: 'The completion of the purchase represents the best value for money for Wicklow County Council versus the costs of a potential High Court case. 'It will eliminate the risk of access to Magheramore Beach being closed off to the public and the loss of a key recreational and tourism amenity.' Ireland Blue Flags 2025: Record number of Irish beaches gi... Read More The land was originally owned by the Columban order of sisters before its original sale back in the 1980s; it has changed hands multiple times since then. It offers access to Magheramore Beach, a cove that has been used as a setting for numerous TV productions including Vikings, Camelot, and Amy Huberman's Finding Joy. Asked about the purchase, a council spokeswoman said it was the best value for money choice available to them. She said: 'It has eliminated the risk of access to Magheramore Beach being closed off to the public and the loss of a key recreational and tourism amenity for the county.'
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Mobile help unit for people on nights out in Dublin to open this weekend
Dublin city centre is to see a new help zone for people on nights out introduced this evening, Friday, July 4th. It will operate on Camden Street every Friday and Saturday night from 10pm until 3am. Advertisement Nicknamed the "Nee Naw", the mobile unit will include a medic, a welfare officer, two trained security personnel - one male and one female - and a site operator. A similar initiative was previously trialled at College Green. Dublin's Night-Time Economy Advisor, Ray O'Donoghue, told Newstalk that it will offer non-judgmental support for anyone in need. "We're the go-between A&E and the guards, we don't want people necessarily having to go to a garda station, we don't want people having to go to A&E, we know how that can be and how that can last, you could be there for 10 or 11 hours on a busy Saturday, so we want to be able to deal with those small first aid cases, kind of be some kind of a triage," Mr O'Donoghue said. Advertisement The initiative is run by Dublin City Council and supported by the Department of Justice, and is designed to provide support to people who may need assistance during a night out, whether they feel unwell, overwhelmed or need a calm and friendly place to regroup. The help zone will be a branded mobile unit and will run for a six to eight-week pilot period from July 4th. Paul Clinton, who owns nearby Flannery's Bar, told the station that it will help cut down on ambulance call-outs. "It's a problem in the city, Dublin city suffers from people not feeling safe late at night, and this initiative will be fantastic, it just shows the city council someone cares, it's a great facility to have on the street, we think it's great, and we wish it the best." Advertisement Mr O'Donoghue added that it follows on from a similar pilot at College Green over Christmas, which was a "learning experience". "That was the whole idea behind it, we only ran it for three nights over a busy time, we had a lot of people come up, we were up to 150 over the course of the night, but only a few incidents. This will be a busier, higher footfall area, and a busier nighttime crowd, I'd say," he said.
