logo
Coroner rejects calls to refer circumstances over Offaly farmer's death to gardaí

Coroner rejects calls to refer circumstances over Offaly farmer's death to gardaí

RTÉ News​15-07-2025
A coroner has rejected calls to refer the circumstances of the death of an elderly Offaly farmer on the day after he got married to gardaí for a detailed forensic investigation.
The dramatic application was made at the conclusion of a three-day inquest into the death of Joe Grogan, 75, who died at his home in Screggan, Tullamore, Co Offaly on 15 April 2023 just 24 hours after he got married to to his part-time carer, Lisa Flaherty, in a registry office unknown to any of his relatives who were unaware the couple were even in a relationship.
Mr Grogan was a well-known figure in Irish farming circles for hosting the National Ploughing Championships between 2016 and 2018, while the farm will also stage this year's event in September.
The inquest at Offaly Coroner's Court in Tullamore heard that Ms Flaherty - a special needs assistant and mother of three who was 26 years junior to her husband - stands to inherit the 220-acre farm which is valued at €5.5 million as his widow.
It had previously heard that the cause of the farmer's death could not be determined because it was embalmed before a post-mortem examination could be carried out which restricted the tests that could be conducted by a pathologist.
The farmer had been diagnosed with Stage IV Non-Hodgkin lymphoma (a form of blood cancer) in January 2023 and had responded well to treatment, although Ms Flaherty gave evidence that he believed he was dying.
Counsel for three cousins of the deceased - Alo, Margaret and Seán Grogan - Damien Tansey SC, called on the coroner, Raymond Mahon, not to return a verdict and to refer the matter to the DPP for a forensic examination of Mr Grogan's death by gardaí.
Mr Tansey said it would be most unfair to the farmer's memory and to his family if the request was declined.
Separately, Peter Jones, a solicitor for an aunt of the deceased, Teresa Mooney, also asked the coroner to refer the death to gardaí and to return an open verdict.
Mr Jones claimed the inquest had left "an awful lot of unanswered questions" and the circumstances of Mr Grogan's death could only be challenged by trained personnel used to investigating "suspicious deaths".
However, Mr Mahon returned a narrative verdict based on extensive evidence and claimed the farmer's death was probably due to an infection on the balance of probabilities.
He noted the deceased was a person with a Stage IV high grade cancer who was receiving chemotherapy treatment with a compromised immune system who had also suffered "significant weight loss".
Mr Grogan's weight went from 79kg in June 2022 to 67.6kg at the time he was diagnosed with cancer and to 51kg at the time of his death.
The coroner said evidence from witnesses of Mr Grogan's "slow, elongated decline" lent support to his view that Mr Grogan's death was caused by an infection.
He rejected the suggestion of Mr Tansey that a verdict of unlawful killing could be considered as the evidence was not "anywhere near the level of proof" required to support such a finding.
Referring to a claim by Mr Jones that the farmer had been "left to die," Mr Mahon said there was valid criticism about the way Mr Grogan's care was managed following his last session of chemotherapy.
However, Mr Mahon, who retired as coroner following the case, noted that the deceased had repeatedly told people he did not want to go to hospital and a relative had stated that it was obvious he was dying.
In a submission, Mr Tansey said there was disquiet in the area where Mr Grogan lived over the circumstances of his death which had been significantly added to by the evidence heard at the inquest.
He claimed that the coroner also appeared "sufficiently troubled" to repossess the body after it had been embalmed to allow an examination to be carried out to try and establish the cause of death.
Mr Tansey said the pathologist Charles D'Adhemar, was working in impossible circumstances due to the "irreparable damage" caused by the embalming process.
However, he noted that Dr D'Adhemar had been able to detect the presence of three drugs in the body of the deceased which if used in a combination of large quantities could cause respiratory depression.
Mr Tansey accused Ms Flaherty of telling "porkies" by putting out a false narrative that the farmer was at the end stage of life and requiring palliative care.
He observed that Ms Flaherty had not tried to explain that she was in an "on-off relationship" with Mr Grogan when she gave evidence that their relationship had been over 16 years but later having to admit that she had another partner up to 2020.
Mr Tansey said another troubling issue was the secrecy surrounding the couple's marriage about which even Ms Flaherty's sister and best friend were unaware.
He also observed she had not called any doctor to see Mr Grogan for the ten days, he had been at home before his death after being discharged from hospital after chemotherapy.
The barrister claimed Ms Flaherty had also called an undertaker with "indecent haste" and had tried to "ensnare" a doctor in her scheme for getting the body released.
There was a gasped reaction among the large crowd attending the inquest when Mr Tansey reminded the coroner that a verdict of unlawful killing was open to him.
He pointed out that Mr Grogan was clearly ill in the days before his death and there was going to be "a dreadful end" if there was no appropriate medical intervention.
However, he said the only time the farmer was taken from his house during that period was to go to a registry office "to hurriedly and secretly arrange a marriage".
In his submission, Mr Jones said the most solid evidence at the inquest came from doctors who had never given a direction that Mr Grogan required palliative care as suggested by Ms Flaherty.
He noted an oncologist had stated the farmer's death was not inevitable and Mr Jones said it would be a travesty to suggest otherwise.
The solicitor remarked that a "reign of secrecy" had prevailed over Mr Grogan's final days, while adding that his death was not due to cancer, heart failure or any infection.
However, he claimed the inquest, despite the coroner's best efforts, had not come any nearer to establishing the cause of death.
Mr Jones also noted the "cruelty" of members of the Grogan family being excluded and only being told of the farmer's death by a friend.
He argued the only people who could "get to the bottom of this" would be An Garda Síochána and a further investigation would "satisfy public disquiet".
The solicitor said Mr Grogan wanted to live and had "everything to live for".
However, counsel for Mr Flaherty, Stephen Byrne BL, claimed the inquest had been used to attack Ms Flaherty's good name and reputation.
Mr Byrne said one submission had just stopped short of accusing her of causing Mr Grogan's death.
He claimed the fact that gardaí had not taken any further steps to date "must carry some weight".
Mr Byrne reminded the coroner that one of Mr Grogan's own relatives, Enta Conroy, had given evidence that he was fading and approaching the end of his life.
He pointed out that no member of the Grogan family had contacted any doctor if they were so concerned about his health.
The barrister said he struggled to find the relevance of the marriage to the inquest, while the coroner had directed that its validity was not open for discussion.
He also sharply criticised the approach adopted by the Grogan family to the inquest and how they thought it fit and appropriate that Ms Flaherty should have been asked if her marriage had ever been consummated.
The previous two days of evidence of the inquest had also been dominated by bad-tempered exchanges between the legal representatives after the validity of the marriage was questioned, despite a marriage certificate being produced at the hearing.
There were further heated exchanges after Mr Tansey claimed previous evidence of Ms Flaherty which stated her relationship with the deceased started when she was 16 "puts it in the realm of being a paedophile".
Ms Flaherty was heard to call the barrister a "scumbag" in response.
Offering his commiserations to all parties at the conclusion of the inquest, the coroner said it had been "a very difficult case for everyone".
Speaking afterwards, Seán Grogan said his family had just wanted to find that "our cousin was treated properly in his dying days" after concerns were first raised when his funeral arrangements had been "chopped and changed".
Mr Tansey said the Grogans had been surprised and concerned to find out that no medical personnel had been contacted by Ms Flaherty in the ten days before his death when it was clear he was suffering some infection from his last session of chemotherapy.
The barrister said the focus "from here on in will be the merit and circumstances of that marriage".
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Former sports figure in court accused of sexual abuse
Former sports figure in court accused of sexual abuse

Extra.ie​

time40 minutes ago

  • Extra.ie​

Former sports figure in court accused of sexual abuse

A former sports figure extradited from the US to face multiple allegations of the sexual abuse of girls in Ireland in the 1970s and 1980s was remanded in custody yesterday. The 77-year-old man, who cannot be named due to the nature of the charges, is facing 79 allegations of offences relating to the alleged abuse of four girls. The case features 78 charges of indecent assault and one count of attempted rape at various locations in Co. Dublin, including Dún Laoghaire, Killiney and Blackrock, from 1971 to 1981. A former sports figure extradited from the US to face multiple allegations of the sexual abuse of girls in Ireland in the 1970s and 1980s was remanded in custody yesterday. Pic: Colin Keegan, Collins, Dublin. The girls were minors, aged between eight and 15. Following extradition proceedings at the request of the Irish authorities, the man was arrested at Terminal 2 in Dublin Airport at 5.56 am yesterday. He was then brought to appear before Judge Michele Finan at Dublin District Court. Dressed in a pale green jumper, grey shorts, white socks and brown slip-on shoes, he sat silently in his wheelchair throughout the brief hearing. He has not indicated a plea, and there was no application for bail. State solicitor Rory Staines told Judge Finan that the Director of Public Prosecutions has directed that the man face 'trial on indictment in the Central Criminal Court'. It is expected that the prosecution's book of evidence will be ready to be served on the accused when he appears again at the District Court next Tuesday, July 29. Legal aid was granted after defence solicitor Tracy Horan said: 'He is not working; he has no assets.'

Cycling community in shock as young Irish rider dies on Tour de France trip
Cycling community in shock as young Irish rider dies on Tour de France trip

Extra.ie​

time2 hours ago

  • Extra.ie​

Cycling community in shock as young Irish rider dies on Tour de France trip

A young Waterford cyclist has been killed while on a trip to watch the Tour de France. Comeragh Cycling Club said that Tomás Walsh, 25, died after being electrocuted in a Paris Metro station. While details of the tragedy remained unclear, messages of sympathy flooded in last night for his devastated family. In a post on social media, the club announced: 'It is with great sadness that we have learned that our clubmate and friend, young Tomás Walsh, has lost his life in France. We're truly shattered by this news and extend our sincerest condolences to all his family and friends. Tomás Walsh. Pic: Comeragh Cycling Club/Facebook 'Ar dheis Dé go raibh a anam.' In a further statement, a club spokesperson said: 'Tomás suffered an electrocution in a Metro station in Paris on Monday morning. Full details still a bit unclear at the moment. He was 25 since April. 'Tomás joined us in his teenage years and had some great success on the bike at both underage and senior level. He'll be sorely missed by his family, friends and anyone who came across him in the world of cycling.' Tomás Walsh. Pic: Comeragh Cycling Club/Facebook Among the many messages of support and shock, a fellow cyclist wrote that he 'had the privilege of racing against Tomás during underage years, and also hosting him at the Rás Mumhan a few years ago'. Another person said: 'That's terrible news. I remember him riding the youth races we used to organise in Faugheen. A lovely young man.' 'Such a pleasant young man with the world in front of him,' wrote a friend, while another described him as a 'legend, to say the least'. Tomás Walsh. Pic: Comeragh Cycling Club/Facebook 'A really great lad' and a 'credit to his parents' were among the other descriptions of Tomás. Funeral details are yet to be announced. Tomás had attended the Irish-language school Gaelcholáiste Phort Láirge in Waterford. On the Facebook page of the Waterford radio station WLR, many people who knew his family, and his dedication to cycling, paid tribute. 'Rest in Peace Tomás, heartbreaking for Frank, Bernie, Caoimhe and Bronagh,' one person wrote, referring to the deceased's family members, while another wrote: 'Condolences to Bernie and his two sisters and Nanny. May his gentle soul rest in Heavenly Peace.' One woman wrote: 'Heartbreaking news. Sincere condolences to Bernie and all Tomás' family. May he rest in peace.' Another man wrote: 'My sincerest condolences to Frank and family. We are all in shock. Tomás was such a lovely, enthusiastic lad, a breath of fresh air. May he rest in peace.' Many people commented on how sociable and kind the deceased was. 'Tomás was such a lovely young man, so, so sad. God bless him. A pleasure to talk to,' one person wrote, while another penned: 'He was a good one. lovely bloke always chat to you. Thinking of Frank and Bernie and sisters at this time. Rest easy Tomás.' Irish cycling fans have been flocking to watch the Tour de France, where Ireland's Ben Healy held the yellow jersey for two days last week. Healy produced another courageous ride on yesterday's Stage 16, attacking early on Mont Ventoux and holding firm in the breakaway, only to be edged out in the final sprint by France's Valentin Paret-Peintre, securing second place and the day's combativity award.

Woman set up Facebook ‘honeytrap' to snare aunt's killer from 10,000km away
Woman set up Facebook ‘honeytrap' to snare aunt's killer from 10,000km away

Irish Independent

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Independent

Woman set up Facebook ‘honeytrap' to snare aunt's killer from 10,000km away

'It was brutal,' recalls Ms Sergison, the shock still raw 11 years later. 'The waiter was passing me a pizza and I was taking in what I'd been told.' Her 59-year-old aunt lived nearly 10,000km away in Thabazimbi, South Africa. The pair were close, speaking on the phone every Sunday and exchan­ging emails. And now Ms Robinson had been found, raped and murdered, in the lodge she had bought and built up with her late Irish husband. Initially, it was thought to be a farm killing, but then it emerged that the 26-year-old gardener, Andrea Imbayarwo (then known as Andrew Ndlovu), had disappeared along with £1,400 (€1,600) that had been drawn from the bank to pay staff wages. With such an obvious suspect, Ms Sergison and her family expected his arrest and trial to be swift, but as days became weeks and months turned into years, any chance of justice seemed to slip away. She was driven by a desire for justice for the aunt she had shared a close bond with Catching Ms Robinson's murderer became something the South African authorities, the UK government and, eventually, even Ms Sergison's own family gave up on. Everyone, in fact, except Ms Sergison. She never quite stopped believing that it might be possible to bring him to justice. So began a quest that would eventually result in the man responsible being arrested. That he was finally caught was all thanks to Ms Sergison, who had single- handedly made contact with the main suspect, honeytrapping him into messaging with her on Facebook and ultimately leading the police to his whereabouts – all without ever visiting South Africa. How she managed to secure the conviction of Imbayarwo is the subject of a new documentary, The Facebook Honeytrap: Catching a Killer, available on Amazon Prime Video from July 27. She was driven by a desire for justice for the aunt she had always shared a close bond with, but the past 11 years have shown her how femicide still goes virtually unchallenged. In South Africa, an average of 153 rapes are reported and eight women are murdered every day. ADVERTISEMENT 'I think life is cheap there. It's acc­epted,' Ms Sergison said. 'Even when they find the men responsible, cases fall apart because the systems aren't robust enough. And then you start to read UN reports about femicide, rape and gender-based violence and they show that – right across the world – women have no value.' In 2002, after Ms Robinson met and married Irishman 'Robbie' Robinson – the love of her life – the couple bought a game park near the Botswana border. While she and Mr Robinson had been concerned about violence, the life they opted for was a long way from any of South Africa's volatile townships. They had CCTV and two Alsatians that were trained to protect. And life was good until Mr Robinson was diagnosed with cancer. In 2012, he died at home in Belfast with Ms Robinson by his side. Afterwards, still deep in grief, she made the decision to return to South Africa to continue running the 30-guest lodge near Limpopo. By the time Ms Sergison took that call in 2014, Ms Robinson was in the process of selling the place with the intention of returning to the UK. There were three or four attempts at extradition, but the paperwork was always wrong On the day of her murder, she missed an appointment about the sale. The same day, Imbayarwo fled to his native Zimbabwe. There followed a painfully inadequate attempt to extradite him. 'There were three or four attempts at extradition, but the paperwork was always wrong in some way. They'd tell me it was getting done, but it wasn't. The authorities were so incompetent,' Ms Sergison said. Her dealings with the British Foreign Office were equally frustrating. And going to South Africa herself was out of the question due to health problems. Through texts and emails, she maintained contact with the lodge manager – and Ms Robinson's friend – Noelle Denis. It was through Ms Denis that, in 2015, Ms Sergison was told about a sighting of Imbayarwo. He was back in South Africa, living in Johannesburg. Ms Sergison told the South African authorities. Nothing happened. Imbayarwo's Facebook page had been inactive since he fled in 2014, but in 2016, turning sleuth, Ms Sergison discovered he had three other active profiles. Taking matters into her own hands, she created a fake profile of her own – a flirty 20-something cabin attendant called Missy Falcao – to reel him in. She messaged him flirtatiously, telling him he was 'so hot' and had 'sexy eyes'. Imbayarwo took the bait and, over the next six months, Ms Sergison gleaned new information that she passed on to the South African authorities. 'I told him I was a stewardess, as it meant I wasn't always contactable. I had to keep it light. I didn't want to tie myself up in lies that I couldn't remember. I thought if I kept him flattered, it would keep his interest,' she said of her messages. Her information led to a failed triangulation of his location by the authorities in 2017. When a sting operation failed after Imbayarwo did not show at a meet-up, the trail went cold in 2018. Then, on July 30, 2020, the sixth anniversary of Ms Robinson's murder, Ms Sergison posted: 'Six years ago today, this man raped and murdered my aunt Christine Robinson. Andrew Ndlovu is still a free man enjoying his life after taking hers.' It was important the judge heard that she wasn't a nobody. She wasn't just a photo The post went viral and, on the same day, a woman got in touch. Imbayarwo had been working for her family for the past five years and living in her yard for the last year. That evening, he was arrested. 'He'd worked for them for years and was trusted,' Ms Sergison said. Although too ill to travel to the court case in April, 2022, Ms Sergison wrote a victim impact statement to be read out. 'It was important the judge heard that she wasn't a nobody. She had family. She had friends. She was real. She wasn't just a photograph in the evidence docket,' she said. Imbayarwo was found guilty of murder and rape eight years after killing and raping Christine Robinson. Ms Sergison's grief for her aunt remains raw. She said: 'The phone calls and the emails don't come. There was a life left for her to lead and someone took that away from her for £1,400.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store