Man released after 16 years as judge rules against 387-year rape sentence
Ajay Dev, 58, was released last week after spending 16 years in state prison for 76 convictions of sexual assault on a minor and related charges.
He had been convicted of the serial rape of an adopted daughter named Sapna Dev who he and his wife helped bring to the U.S. from his home nation of Nepal in 1998, when she was 15-years-old.
Superior Court Judge Janene Beronio said in her ruling that the then-teen girl had broken up with her boyfriend and accused her adoptive father of causing their split.
Sapna then told authorities that he raped her two or three times a week for three or four years before she moved out of their home.
Four witnesses who had not been contacted by Dev's trial lawyers testified at a recent hearing that Sapna had told them that her accusations were lies or were motivated by her anger at him, The San Francisco Chronicle reported.
One of the witnesses said Sapna told him she made the accusations because she 'was determined to return to the United States and needed to use the criminal charges to do that,' Beronio said.
According to the Daily Democrat, Sapna had returned to Nepal at that time and was imprisoned there due to wrong information being printed on her passport. It was then she made the allegations and U.S. authorities helped her with a new passport so she could return to the U.S.
Sapna was ultimately granted American citizenship in light of the case and her cooperation with prosecutors, according to CBS.
Critical evidence had been missed which stemmed from a phone call that cops had arranged between the two, the Chronicle reported.
The audio recording was not clear and the jury during Sapna's original testimony in the 2000s heard it as her father saying: 'You had sex with me when you were 18'.
Beronio said that an enhanced recording was now available which say he had actually told her: 'You came with me after you were 18'.
The judge also said that another witness had testified that Sapna had given contradictory statements when she said she had aborted or miscarried three kids after alleged pregnancies.
Beronio said that Sapna had frequently sent her adopted parents cards, texts and email expressing her love for them from 1999 up until 2004.
She added: 'If jurors had heard that evidence, the result of this case could have and most likely would have been different.'
His lawyer Jennifer Mouzis had filed his habeas corpus petition seeking to have him freed in 2018.
Judge Beronio scheduled a hearing for June 13 for Yolo County District Attorney Jeff Reisig to decide whether to retry Dev. Prosecutors could also appeal the ruling.
Deputy District Attorney Adrienne Chin-Perez contended during a hearing last week that Ajay Dev continues to pose a flight risk and a danger to the community.
She also read a statement from Sapna, who wrote that she is 'deeply afraid that Ajay will harm me'.
The judge's decision 'dismantles the DA´s case,' said Patricia Pursell, a member of advocacy group that has held demonstrations in support of Dev, who is also his sister-in-law.
'We have known from the beginning that Ajay Dev was wrongfully convicted,' she told the Chronicle. 'Judge Beronio was the first judge to really look closely at the evidence and read every document.'
Pursell also told CBS that when he was arrested his oldest son was two and that his wife was pregnant with another child. He was in prison when the child was born.
In a statement to the court seen by the outlet, Dev said: 'The absence of fatherhood has been the most difficult while doing time for a crime I never committed. You gave me a purpose to live. I cannot wait to be home with you.'
Mouzis said much of the prosecution's evidence was based on racial and ethnic bias that would be illegal today under California´s Racial Justice Act, a 2021 law barring testimony that appeals to prejudice.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
Idaho murder case highlights limits of victims' input in plea bargains
The man charged in the stabbing deaths of four University of Idaho students in November 2022 has agreed to plead guilty, according to an attorney for a victim's family, but the family says it opposes any deal that would take the death penalty off the table. Shanon Gray, an attorney for the family of Kaylee Goncalves, said the family has requested that a change of plea hearing for Bryan Kohberger set for Wednesday be delayed so that families could travel to Boise to attend. The family of Ethan Chapin, another of those killed, supports the plea deal, said family spokesperson Christina Teves on Tuesday. Karen and Scott Laramie, the mother and stepfather of Madison Mogen, plan to make a statement through their attorney, Leander James, after the hearing. Relatives of Xana Kernodle did not immediately respond to interview requests. Prosecutors stressed in a letter to victims' families, obtained by ABC News, that they had met with available family members last week before extending the offer. What happens when surviving families of crime victims or victims themselves disagree with prosecutors? Here's a little more on what rights and recourse victims do and don't have in the U.S. and in Idaho. Generally, what rights do crime victims have? A movement to address the needs and well-being of victims of crime started in the 1970s and made grassroots advancements, like the first victims help hotline. Laws addressing the rights of crime victims followed in the '80s, '90s and 2000s, and are relatively new for the criminal justice landscape. The 2004 federal Crime Victims' Rights Act granted eight specific rights to victims in federal criminal cases including the right to be protected from the person accused of committing the crime, the right to reasonable and timely notice of proceedings, the right to restitution and the reasonable right to confer with the prosecution. States were left to pass laws that governed victims' rights for state-level criminal prosecutions. Every state has some form of law addressing the rights of crime victims that vary. Most, at minimum, provide the right to seek restitution or to be informed about court hearings in advance. Many states have passed larger packages sometimes called a victim bill of rights. 'Really, what these laws are designed to do is to make sure that victims are meaningful participants in the architecture of justice,' said Meg Garvin, the executive director of the National Crime Victim Law Institute. What rights are guaranteed in Idaho? Idaho's Constitution outlines 10 rights of crime victims, including to be treated fairly and respectfully, the right to notification of case events and to attend those events, and the right to communicate with prosecutors, among others. It also specifically allows for victims 'to be heard, upon request, at all criminal justice proceedings considering a plea of guilty, sentencing, incarceration or release of the defendant, unless manifest injustice would result.' It was unclear Tuesday if any of the families had requested to make a statement at that hearing, but Garvin said that would be a meaningful opportunity for them to speak to the court. 'When a court decides to accept or reject a plea agreement, it has to be done in the interest of justice,' she said. 'It's a victim's right to have input in the prosecution, but also to make sure the court knows how they feel about a plea. The victims don't have control over the outcome, but they can offer something that helps the court analyze whether the plea is in the interest of justice.' Judges can reject plea agreements in Idaho, but it is a rare occurrence. The judge in Kohberger's case previously denied a defense attorney motion to remove the death penalty from consideration that had argued Kohberger's autism diagnosis made him less culpable. What does the right to confer with prosecutors guarantee? The right to confer covers a broad range of communication with prosecutors, but largely means being kept informed and participating as a case proceeds. That can mean having conversations before a bail hearing to propose conditions of a defendant being released that increase a victim's feeling of safety, or strategizing victim impact statements before sentencing. It does not mean that victims or their families get the final say in how prosecutors try a case or whether they can offer or approve a plea agreement. There is no appeals process for victims or families who disagree with a prosecutor's decision, but that doesn't mean there isn't recourse if a victim believes their rights have been violated. Garvin said not providing an opportunity for meaningful victim input can lead to courts reconsidering sentences or overturning outcomes and holding new hearings. She cited the recent case of Adnan Syed in Maryland, whose murder conviction had been vacated in 2022 after Baltimore prosecutors said they had uncovered issues with the initial prosecution. The victim's family later succeeded in getting the conviction reinstated after challenging the ruling on procedural grounds, arguing they didn't receive proper notice to attend the hearing that freed Syed from prison— a victims' rights violation. In the letter sent to the families of the Idaho victims Monday, prosecutors wrote, 'Your viewpoints weighed heavily in our decision-making process, and we hope that you may come to appreciate why we believe this resolution is in the best interest of justice.' Goncalves' family wrote in Facebook posts that family members had spoken to prosecutors multiple times from Friday to Monday to register their objections to a plea and explain their views about pushing for a conviction at trial and the death penalty. The statement said the Friday discussions were vague, and that the whole process moved incredibly fast despite nearly two years of preparations and waiting for a trial that had been scheduled to start in August.
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
Big plans, hopes cut short for 4 slain Idaho students in 2022
The lives of four University of Idaho students were cut short in 2022 when a masked intruder entered their rental house and stabbed them to death as they slept -- a crime that shocked the nation and ended their hopes and dreams. Madison Mogen was a marketing major who ran a social media campaign for the Greek restaurant where she worked. Kaylee Goncalves was a senior planning a post-graduation trip to Europe. Xana Kernodle was a marketing major who was the kind of person who lifted a room. And Ethan Chapin was a freshman whose fellow triplets also attended the university. Now, the man charged with the murders, 30-year-old Bryan Kohberger, will ask a judge Wednesday to accept a plea deal that would spare him the death penalty, said Shannon Gray, an attorney for Goncalves' family. The students' bodies were found stabbed to death on Nov. 13, 2022, at a rental home across the street from the university campus in Moscow, about 80 miles (130 kilometers) southeast of Spokane, Washington. Chapin, Kernodle's boyfriend, was there visiting on the night of the attack. All of them were friends and members of the university's Greek system. The killings left many of their classmates and residents reeling with grief and fear. Autopsies showed the four were all likely asleep when they were attacked. Some had defensive wounds and each was stabbed multiple times. Here are profiles of the students: Madison Mogen Madison Mogen, 21, a senior, worked with Kernodle at a Greek restaurant in Moscow. She was a marketing major who ran a social media campaign for the business. She also was a member of Pi Beta Phi. Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves grew up together in northern Idaho and were best friends. Along with photos, Mogen collected quotes on her Instagram page. 'It's not all sunshine and rainbows, but a good amount of it actually is,' read one post. Ben Mogen, Madison's father, told a crowd at a 2022 vigil in Moscow that she was his only child, so 'everything she ever did was such a big deal.' Talking about 'Maddie' was his pride, Mogen said, and the two loved attending music concerts together. 'When I would meet people ever since she was first born, and they would say, 'Tell me about yourself,' the first thing I would say is, 'I have this daughter — here's a picture of her, she's on the dean's list at college, she works hard, she has all these friends at her sorority,'' Mogen said. Kaylee Goncalves Kaylee Goncalves, 21, was a senior majoring in general studies. She had joined the Alpha Phi sorority and was planning a trip to Europe the following year. Kaylee and Madison met as sixth graders and became inseparable, Kaylee's father, Steve Goncalves, said at the 2022 vigil. 'They went to high school together, then they started looking at colleges, they came here together. They eventually got into the same apartment together,' he said. 'And in the end, they died together, in the same room, in the same bed.' 'It's a shame and it hurts, but the beauty of the two always being together comforts us,' he said. Kaylee Goncalves chronicled some of her history with Mogen in an Instagram post celebrating Mogen's 21st birthday in May 2022. 'I wouldn't have wanted anyone else to be the main character in all my childhood stories,' she wrote. Mogen replied, "love you more than life! My best friend forever and more,' with a heart emoji. Xana Kernodle Xana Kernodle, a 20-year-old junior from Post Falls, Idaho, was studying marketing and had joined the Pi Beta Phi sorority. Jazzmin Kernodle described her younger sister as lighthearted, saying she was the kind of person who always lifted up a room. 'You rarely get to meet someone like Xana,' her sister said. 'She was so positive, funny and was loved by everyone who met her.' For her high school graduation in 2020, Xana decorated her mortarboard with flower and butterfly cut-outs and the words, 'For The Lives That I Will Change.' Kernodle and Chapin were friends before they began dating, according to Chapin's mother, Stacy Chapin, and Kernodle spent time with the entire Chapin family. Ethan Chapin Ethan Chapin, a 20-year-old freshman from Mount Vernon, Washington, was a triplet. His brother and sister also attended the university and this spring the family celebrated their graduations in a social media post. The brothers were both members of the Sigma Chi fraternity. Chapin spent his last day with his siblings, attending a dance hosted by Chapin's sister's sorority, according to their mother. Ethan Chapin was his sister's date and their brother was her roommate's date, Stacy Chapin said. 'They all spent their last day together, all dressed up, and had a great time,' she said. 'We're all thankful that they spent that time together.' Stacy Chapin described her son as 'carefree' and said he could 'read any situation and make it better.' 'Since attending the University of Idaho, Ethan lived his best life,' according to his obituary. 'He loved the social life, intramurals and tolerated the academics. He also continued to play sports.' 'If he wasn't on the golf course or working, you could usually find him surfing, playing sand volleyball or pickle ball,' the obituary said. The Chapin family has created the Ethan's Smile Foundation in his memory to provide scholarships that enable others to follow their dreams.
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
UPenn to ban transgender athletes, feds say, ending civil rights case focused on swimmer Lia Thomas
The University of Pennsylvania has agreed to ban transgender women from its women's sports teams to resolve a federal civil rights case that found the school violated the rights of female athletes. The U.S. Education Department announced the voluntary agreement Tuesday. The case focused on Lia Thomas, the transgender swimmer who last competed for the Ivy League school in Philadelphia in 2022, when she became the first openly transgender athlete to win a Division I title. It's part of the Trump administration's broader attempt to remove transgender athletes from girls' and women's sports. Under the agreement, Penn agreed to restore all individual Division I swimming records and titles to female athletes who lost out to Thomas, the Education Department said. Penn also agreed to send a personalized apology letter to each of those swimmers. It wasn't immediately clear whether Thomas would be stripped of her awards and honors at Penn. The university must also announce that it 'will not allow males to compete in female athletic programs' and it must adopt 'biology-based' definitions of male and female, the department said. Education Secretary Linda McMahon called it a victory for women and girls. 'The Department commends UPenn for rectifying its past harms against women and girls, and we will continue to fight relentlessly to restore Title IX's proper application and enforce it to the fullest extent of the law,' McMahon said in a statement. The Education Department opened its investigation in February and concluded in April that Penn had violated Title IX, a 1972 law forbidding sex discrimination in education. Such findings have almost always been resolved through voluntary agreements. If Penn had fought the finding, the department could have moved to refer the case to the Justice Department or pursued a separate process to cut the school's federal funding. In February, the Education Department asked the NCAA and the National Federation of State High School Associations, or NFSHSA, to restore titles, awards and records it says have been 'misappropriated by biological males competing in female categories.' The most obvious target at the college level was in women's swimming, where Thomas won the national title in the 500-yard freestyle in 2022. The NCAA has updated its record books when recruiting and other violations have stripped titles from certain schools, but the organization, like the NFSHSA, has not responded to the federal government's request. Determining which events had a transgender athlete participating years later would be challenging. ___ The Associated Press' education coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at
