Rift within Maharashtra govt as Shiv Sena minister backs Marathi rally, slams police crackdown
Remove Ads
Mumbai: Differences cropped up within the Maharashtra government between BJP and Shiv Sena over the issue of Hindi language and the handling of protests by Marathi outfits in the state.The disagreement came to fore when a Shiv Sena minister on Tuesday called out his own government for denying permission to MNS and other outfits wanting to carry out a ' Marathi Morcha ' in Mira Road over the language issue.Transport minister Pratap Sarnaik slammed police officials and said it was wrong to deny permission for the rally. "It is a democratic right to take out protest marches... the Marathi Ekikaran Samiti and several other organisations, including MNS, had asked for permission for the rally. Police should not work at the behest of a political leader or a political party. Police is detaining those who are going to the rally... I am going to the rally, if they want they can arrest me," Sarnaik said.Sarnaik castigated his own government after the Mira Road police denied permission to MNS and Marathi Ekikaran Samiti, an outfit committed to preserving and spreading Marathi, to take out a rally. The outfits wanted to take out a rally through the same spot where a non-Marathi speaking trader was assaulted a few days ago for not being able to speak Marathi. Traders, mainly non-Marathi speaking, had observed a day-long shut down and carried out a march in Mira Road in protest. The Marathi outfits wanted to take out a "countermarch".Justifying police action, Chief minister Devendra Fadnavis said: "Police asked organisers to change route as they deliberately wanted a route where there would be some confrontation (with traders)."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
‘Hatred for Modi is being projected onto Hindi': Pawan Kalyan on language controversy
Andhra Pradesh deputy chief minister and actor Pawan Kalyan on Wednesday addressed the ongoing language controversy and the debate around the 'imposition of Hindi.' Responding to allegations that the Centre is forcing Hindi across states, Kalyan said the current discourse reflects how resentment against the BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi is being redirected toward the Hindi language. Stating that English has become his language of thought, the Janasena founder expressed sadness that he could not find the same in Hindi or Kannada or Marathi.(@APDeputyCMO) Speaking to India Today, Kalyan stressed that no language should be forced on anyone, underlining his commitment to unity. 'No language should be imposed on anybody. I stand for national integrity,' he said. He criticised the anti-Hindi stance taken by some political leaders in Telangana, calling it politically motivated. 'It's surprising. I think this is more about the hatred towards BJP or Modiji, and that hatred is being transferred onto Hindi. That's how I see it,' he stated. His comments come amid ongoing tensions in states like Maharashtra and Karnataka, where heated debates have erupted over the use of Hindi and its role as a medium of instruction in schools and colleges. Kalyan, explaining his own experience with the language, noted its practical importance. 'We are surrounded by Hindi-speaking states. Hindi is a necessity for me,' he said. He also criticised how political entities manipulate the issue for their own advantage. 'Sometimes parties or people spark negativity,' he said, suggesting that the language issue is often politicised rather than driven by genuine cultural concerns. Reflecting on his own schooling, he recalled how Hindi was once just a regular part of the curriculum. 'When I was in school, Hindi was just a second language for all of us. I am able to read and write it today because I learned it then,' he noted. Pointing to the diverse linguistic identity of Telugu-speaking regions, he added, 'I don't know why suddenly it became such a big issue, even in Andhra Pradesh which shares borders with Chhattisgarh, Odisha and Karnataka. Telangana itself has a mixed culture — Urdu and Telugu coexist. Instead of saying 'hospital,' people say 'dawakhana'. What's wrong with that?' 'Like English, Hindi has become a practical necessity' Pawan Kalyan argued that Hindi, much like English, has become a practical necessity in today's world. 'No one taught me English by force. It became a necessity. Today we're speaking in English not because we love it, but because it has become essential. Similarly, Hindi is also necessary today,' he explained. Responding to criticism of inconsistency in his stance, Kalyan drew from his personal and professional background, citing his multilingual experience. 'I grew up in Chennai. I love Tamil. I learned it out of interest and necessity — not because anyone forced me. I do the same when I visit Karnataka or Maharashtra. I try to speak Kannada or Marathi. That is the approach we need. A multilingual perspective is important for national linguistic integration,' he said. When asked if he would maintain the same stand in Tamil Nadu, where opposition to Hindi is more pronounced, Kalyan said he already had. 'I have said this before and I will say it again. I love Hindi and respect it — it was my second language in school. Language should be for better communication and integration, not for division,' he said. Referring to Tamil poet Subramania Bharati, he highlighted the poet's example of embracing cultural and linguistic unity: 'Bharati grew up in Kashi. His attire resembled a Sikh turban. He embraced integration in thought, language and attire. There are great people in Tamil Nadu who welcome Hindi.' Kalyan cautioned that forcing any language would only backfire. 'Even a child resists when the mother forces something. You have to create awareness about why learning Hindi is important, not impose it. If you speak to people rationally and logically, you'll get results,' he noted. Earlier, speaking to PTI, Kalyan said, 'Majority of the people think they want to be multilinguistic (multilingual). Let us give them a fair chance and a fair opportunity,' in an interview with PTI Videos. He also shared his personal reflection on language and thought, expressing concern that Hindi and other Indian languages had not become his primary languages for thinking. 'My mother tongue is not Hindi. My mother tongue is not English. Sometimes I feel sad that my thinking language has become English or Telugu. Telugu is a natural way to think, but I could adopt English as a thinking language,' he said. Backing the need for multilingualism in a globalised society, Kalyan added, 'There is nothing wrong in a world where we are interacting with multiculturalism as multilingual skills are needed.' He also urged political leaders to consider the needs of future generations when it comes to language. 'Oncoming generations' must be taken into account, he said, suggesting space should be made for multilingual approaches.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Linguistic hatred will harm Maharashtra, affect investments: Governor C.P. Radhakrishnan
Amid the ongoing controversy over the Marathi language, Maharashtra Governor C.P. Radhakrishnan advised staying away from spreading 'linguistic hatred', as it would affect the industry and investments in the State. While speaking at the coffee table book launch on Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, Mr. Radhakrishnan on Tuesday (July 22, 2025) said, 'Can I speak in Marathi immediately after being slapped. Such hatred, in the long run, will harm the State.' Mr. Radhakrishnan narrated an incident reflecting on the linguistic hatred and said, 'When I was an MP in Tamil Nadu, I saw a group beating up another over not speaking Tamil. On inquiring, I learnt that the victim was a north Indian and miscreants wanted him to speak Tamil. Mr. Radhkrishnan, reflecting on his own struggle with Hindi, suggested to learn multiple languages while being 'proud of our own'. Minister Girish Mahajan also reiterated his sentiments and said, 'We should be proud of the Marathi language, but to enforce on others, especially violently, is not right.' He also highlighted the Maharashtrians, including those who travel outside Maharashtra. So, we need to have mutual respect across linguistic lines. Meanwhile, Shiv Sena (UBT) MLA Aaditya Thackeray responded to the governor's remarks, saying, no need to make political comments as there is no linguistic hatred in the State.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Calcutta HC asks Odisha to file affidavit on detention of Bengali migrants
The Calcutta High Court on Wednesday directed the Odisha government to file an affidavit on the alleged detention of Bengali-speaking workers on suspicion of being illegal Bangladesh migrants. Hearing habeas corpus petitions filed by the families of two migrant workers from West Bengal, the Division Bench of Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty and Justice Reetobroto Kumar Mitra directed the Advocate General of Odisha, who had joined the hearing virtually, to submit the affidavit by August 20 and to be physically present in the court. During the hearing, the Division Bench asked the Odisha government's counsel to apprise the court whether the two Bengali migrant workers – Rakhibul Islam Mondal and Sainur Islam, both from Murshidabad – 'were arrested, interrogated, or detained'. Pitambar Acharya, the Advocate General of Odisha government, denied they were arrested and called the petitions 'frivolous'. The petitioners' counsel then informed the court that Mondal and Islam were released by Odisha Police after the High Court's intervention and demanded compensation for 'illegal detention'. 'The detention was illegal and therefore, compensation should be given. Those who have been released have stated that many others like them remained in custody — detained illegally and not produced before a magistrate.' Odisha's AG, Acharya, told the High Court that the documents of the two migrant workers had been verified. 'As per the Foreigners Act, 1946, Section 3, when the citizenship of suspected persons is in doubt, we investigate for lawful verification of documents. People from all over the country come to work here, and lawfully, on suspicion, their documents are verified,' Acharya added. Senior counsel Kalyan Banerjee, appearing for the petitioners, argued, 'There must be some grounds. Only on suspicion, they cannot declare someone a foreigner.' Refuting the petitioners' contention that Bengali-speaking migrants were being targeted, the Odisha AG said: 'Bengalis are our brothers and neighbors. Don't mislead them by saying these things against us. Our Chief Justice is from Bengal. It is not a matter of Bengali or non-Bengali here. It is being verified whether they are citizens of this country or not.' To this, counsel Banerjee countered, 'Then tell me, how many Tamils and how many Gujaratis have been arrested? Why are Bengalis being selectively verified?' The High Court Bench then directed the Odisha government to file an affidavit on the detention. The petitioners were directed to file replies by August 27, before the court scheduled the next hearing on August 29. The Division Bench on July 10 had directed the Odisha government to place before it relevant documents on whether the two had been detained or were missing. They were directed to answer that if detained, whether such detention was in connection with any court's order and the grounds for that. One of the habeas corpus petitions has been filed by Nasima Mondal, mother of Rakhibul, resident of Hariharpara in Murshidabad district. She claimed that her son was detained in Odisha's Jagatsinghpur district on June 25 and was held for more than 24 hours without being produced before a magistrate in violation of his fundamental rights. According to her petition, Odisha Police 'ignored valid documents' in his possession — including Aadhaar, voter ID, and ration card. The petitioner alleged he was targeted for speaking Bengali and suspected of being Bangladeshi, without any proper identity checks. The second petition was filed by Rajjak Sheikh, also from Hariharpara, seeking the release of his son, Sainur. He claimed Jagatsinghpur police detained his son during a similar identity verification drive on June 30.
