Legal proceedings initiated against Department of Housing after pulling out of PPP deal in ‘11th hour'
Department of Housing
after it pulled out of a public-private partnership (PPP) agreement at the 'eleventh hour' over value for money concerns, an Oireachtas committee has heard.
Last month, the department pulled out of the PPP projects in which a private investment consortium was to deliver almost 500 social homes in Dublin, Kildare, Sligo and Wicklow. The decision was made on a 'value for money basis,' according to the department.
Minister for Housing
James Browne
initially told committee members on Tuesday he was not aware of any legal proceedings. However, he was later informed by department officials that a judicial review had been lodged.
Social Democrats housing spokesman Rory Hearne, who initially asked the Minister whether the preferred bidder for the PPP projects had initiated legal proceedings, said it was 'jaw-dropping' that Mr Browne was unaware.
READ MORE
While believing PPP 'has a role to play', Mr Browne, who would not speak further on the legal proceedings, said it must be 'completely overhauled and re-examined'.
'It is an important route to be able to get homes that we need in the country but it has to be done in a manner that is fair to the taxpayer as well as giving value for money for the taxpayer,' he said.
Labour TD Conor Sheehan said the cancellation of the PPP projects at the 'eleventh hour' has made the delivery route 'essentially unviable.'
Separately, Mr Browne told committee members that it will be 'exceptionally difficult' to meet housing targets in 2025.
Mr Browne said that while there was a significant increase in commencement notices last year, there was a sense that developers 'turned their attention to further commencements as opposed to finalising the projects they were working on at that time.'
Some 60,000 commencement notices were lodged last year, an increase of 84 per cent from the year prior. This was driven largely by temporary
development levies introduced to stimulate housing construction.
Mr Browne said there has been a consistent level of housing delivery predictions this year from different bodies 'in and around the low 30,000s mark'.
'When you see that level of consistency, it's difficult to disagree with. Certainly, it will be exceptionally difficult to meet our own target that was set out for this year coming from such a low base,' he said.
Several committee members also raised concerns over
new design standards for apartments
, with Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin saying they will allow for 'smaller, darker apartments with less amenities in sub-optimally planned residential developments'.
Several questioned how the changes would result in cost reductions of between €50,000 and €100,000 per unit, a claim made by Mr Browne earlier on Tuesday, with Mr Ó'Broin saying he did not believe such a reduction was possible.
Mr Browne said the cost reductions will be made possible by the 'significant increase' in the number of units that can be 'put on to the one box unit.'
The Minister said he would publish data concerning the projected cost reductions 'in the near future.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
27 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Goods from occupied territories ‘could still come into Ireland via another EU country', TDs and senators told
Goods from illegal settlements from Israel , which would be banned in Ireland under proposed occupied territories law, could legally enter the State if they were first imported to another EU country, the Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee has heard. Prof Graham Butler, an expert on EU law, said the proposed Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025 referred to direct imports and did not deal with goods imported from illegal settlements to other EU States. Referring to the draft of the legislation, he told TDs and senators: 'There would still be a way for it to come in lawfully.' Prof Butler was one of four legal academics and practitioners who were invited to discuss the proposed ban with the committee, which is carrying out pre-legislative scrutiny of the draft Bill. It is chaired by Fianna Fáil TD John Lahart. READ MORE In the Bill's present form trade and services are not included. Attorney General Rossa Fanning SC has been asked to give legal advice to the Government on incorporating this category into the Bill. That advice is expected shortly. The academics expressed contrasting views on the standing of the Bill and on the inclusion of services. Two leading authorities on European law, Prof Takis Tridimas and Prof Panos Koutrakos, said they took the view that a ban such as in the Bill would be justified on grounds of public policy. 'Although the public policy exception is to be understood narrowly, in our view, it allows Ireland to prohibit the importation and sale of goods originating in an occupied territory,' they said. They said the Bill sought to comply with international law, including the Fourth Geneva Convention. It also sought to protect human rights and it was in full alignment with the avowed objectives of EU law and the bloc's political stance on matters of occupied territories. They said a ban on trade in services with a third country would be justified under this provision. They said it would comply with obligations set out by an advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in July last year, which said Israel's occupation of Palestinian territories was in breach of international law . Human rights barrister Blinne Ní Ghrálaigh KC, who has appeared on behalf of South Africa in its case against Israel at the ICJ for violation of the Genocide Convention, also spoke at the committee. She said the Bill would enable Ireland to carry out obligations it has accepted for the purpose of maintaining peace and international security and the ICJ advisory opinion of July last year. Ms Ní Ghrálaigh said the State's obligation was not confined only to the advisory opinion but also to Israel's ongoing military assault on Gaza and its people. 'The State is obliged to do so in accordance with its obligations in the light of egregious violations by Israel of its obligations in the Occupied Territories and in Gaza and its seizure of territories by force,' she said. She said the long title of the Bill uses the language of the ICJ advisory opinion, but it omitted the term 'investment relations'. She said that omission resulted in Ireland not being fully compliant. 'There is no basis in international law for differentiating between trade in goods and trade in services in the manner proposed, and no international law justification for legislating for less than full compliance by Ireland with an international obligation articulated by the ICJ,' she said. In contrast, Prof Butler said the Bill was 'prima facie' incompatible with EU law, and European case law gave no comfort to the view that the public policy exception was as wide to accommodate what the State was trying to do. He said the competence to deal with what was being proposed, at present, resided where the State had put the competence: at the level of the EU.
Irish Times
42 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Consumers advised to stop using several Tower air fryer models due to ‘dangerous manufacturing defect'
Consumers are being advised to stop using almost 60,000 air fryers sold across the State in recent years due to a risk of them overheating and potentially catching fire. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) issued a warning on Thursday regarding a number of Tower brand air fryer models following a recall by the company. 'Almost 60,000 affected models have been sold in retail outlets across the Republic of Ireland,' it said. 'The affected air fryers have a manufacturing defect that may cause the appliance to overheat, potentially leading to fires and risking injury or death. Although no incidents have been reported in Ireland to date, there have been reports in the UK of these products catching fire.' READ MORE The air fryer models affected by the recall are the T17023 Tower 2.2 litre Manual Air Fryer; T17061BLK Tower 4 litre Manual Air Fryer; T17067 Tower 4 litre Digital Air Fryer; T17087 Tower 2 litre Compact Manual Air Fryer; T17129L Vortx 8 litre Dual Basket Air Fryer. The affected products were manufactured between 2020 and last year and sold by retailers including Argos, Tesco, DID, Dealz, Lidl, Amazon and the Tower Housewares website. People with Tower air fryers are advised to unplug it out and check the appliance rating label located at the bottom to see if the model number is one of those being recalled. 'Consumers who have one of the affected air fryers should stop using the product immediately, unplug it and contact Tower Housewares. They can do this on the website or by emaile-mailingrproduct@ Grainne Griffin of the CCPC said: 'This recall covers five Tower air fryer models with a dangerous manufacturing defect that could cause the models to overheat. 'Almost 60,000 affected units have been sold in Ireland so it's vital that consumers who have a Tower air fryer check their model. If their model is affected, it is not safe to use.'
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘We can't just tear up the rule book': Tánaiste defends denial of visas to young Palestinian GAA players
Tánaiste Simon Harris has defended the approach taken by the Department of Justice in refusing visas to young GAA players from Palestine . Mr Harris, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, said 'every visa has to be issued on its merits' and there needed to be 'legitimate checks in relation to child protection'. A number of TDs on Thursday raised the issue involving 33 young hurlers and 14 mentors who were refused visas for a GAA Palestine summer tour due to begin this month. He said an appeals process is in place and the department 'will continue to robustly apply rules particularly when it involves minors and particularly when it involves minors travelling without their parents and accompanied by other adults'. READ MORE The Department of Justice issues the visas which are processed through the Department of Foreign Affairs . Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín said there should be a strict system, but a compassionate response as well. He pointed out that there are already 'dozens of children coming into this country unaccompanied on an annual basis'. He said the refusal of visas to the 33 Palestinian children was an example of the different treatment the EU demonstrates towards the wars in Ukraine and Palestine. 'It is very obvious there's a two-tier approach,' he said. In reply, Mr Harris said many visas have been granted to Palestinian nationals, mostly to family members of Irish citizens. 'We do try to take a compassionate approach,' he said, adding that the Government did not doubt the bona fides of the trip's organisers. 'Unfortunately not all people will be able to demonstrate that they satisfy the conditions to be granted a visa to come to Ireland.' He said there was a request for 47 people to travel to Ireland from Palestine, '33 of these are children who are not travelling in the company of their parents'. 'These applications were given very careful consideration. A visa officer has to be satisfied that children are travelling in the company of their parents or an appropriate guardian. Additional documents such as birth certs, consent letters are regularly requested to establish the relationship and there is an appeals process under way.' Sinn Féin foreign affairs spokesman Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire said 'some of this is political will' and called for contact with the organisation to work through whatever issues exist to ensure 'it's all rectified quickly'. Mr Harris said that if children 'from far flung parts of the world are travelling to this country with adults, some of whom are not their parents, there do need to be legitimate checks in relation to child protection'. He added: 'I don't think any immigration system in the world would grant visas, without satisfying itself in relation to visa applications for minors. 'We can't just tear up the rule book when it comes to migration.'
