Proposed lawsuit alleges Toronto violated refugees' rights by denying shelter beds
TORONTO - A proposed class-action lawsuit against the City of Toronto alleges the city violated refugee claimants' Charter rights by denying them access to shelter beds for nearly a year even when beds were available, arguing the practice was 'systemically negligent.'
The proposed suit was filed Friday in an Ontario court on behalf of refugees, refugee claimants and asylum seekers who sought shelter in Toronto and were unable to get a bed between Nov. 7, 2022 and Oct. 1, 2023 — a period during which it says the city stopped allowing claimants to access its base shelter system.
The suit also includes shelter seekers who were told to contact either Service Canada or Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada, which the suit says were unable to provide housing assistance.
The lawsuit requires certification from a judge to proceed.
Linette King, a lawyer involved in the case, claimed thousands of refugees were denied shelter beds during that period — even when beds were available — causing mental health and physical security issues.
'Many of them will have had some trauma coming from their home country, and had that exacerbated here by the experience of facing homelessness when there are shelter beds available,' King said in a phone interview on Wednesday.
King added that referrals to Service Canada and the IRCC after shelter seekers were turned away were 'problematic' because the city allegedly knew those agencies wouldn't be able to provide shelter.
'Our position in this action is that it really exacerbates the harm because these individuals are not people that are aware of our systems,' King said. 'They are trusting the information they are being given, and if that information is ineffective ... it certainly creates confusion and can add to the harm.'
City spokesperson Elise von Scheel said in an emailed statement that the city will respond 'in due course' and has no further comment as the case is before the court.
The statement of claim says that in August 2023, about 3,300 refugee claimants were seeking a shelter bed nightly and more than 1,600 were turned away because of their immigration status, even when beds were available.
The proposed suit also claims the city's practice disproportionately impacted members of the Black community, as many of the refugee claimants had arrived from countries with predominantly Black populations.
The suit names a 40-year-old man from Nigeria who had arrived in Toronto as a refugee in September 2023 and was allegedly told there were no beds available at a number of city shelters, causing him anxiety and fear.
'The defendant knew its exclusionary practices were systematically racist and contrary to the Human Rights Code as it would — and in fact did — disproportionately impact members of the Black community,' the statement of claim alleges.
Preventing refugee claimants from accessing beds breached some of their Charter rights, the statement of claim further argues.
'Security of the person was compromised as they were unable to secure a bed leading to either precarious housing or sleeping out on the street,' it claims.
None of the allegations have been tested in court.
The proposed class action comes after Toronto Ombudsman Kwame Addo released a report in December 2024 investigating the city's decision to stop allowing refugee claimants to access its base shelter system beds. Addo found that the decision was 'inconsistent with city policies' and 'amounted to systemic racism.'
The ombudsman made several recommendations to the city, including clarifying processes for refugee claimants.
City Manager Paul Johnson wrote in a letter to Addo last year that he did not agree with the report's findings and 'would not take further action' in response to the recommendations.
King said the goal of the proposed class action suit is to ensure that Toronto and other cities are compliant with the Charter and its values, and that any proposed changes to the shelter system or services that impact refugee claimants are done 'in a thoughtful and responsible way.'
'The hope is that this action is going to provide access to some remedies for these vulnerable people, these refugee claimants,' King said.
'Access should be for everybody, irrespective of their status.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 4, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
2 hours ago
- CNN
‘I wanted to do something to fight back': This iPhone app alerts users to nearby ICE sightings
Joshua Aaron has worked in and around the tech industry for around two decades. He built his first app — a blackjack game — at computer camp when he was 13. His newest app is designed for a very different purpose: to let users alert people nearby to sightings of Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in their area. Aaron launched the platform, called ICEBlock, in early April after watching President Donald Trump's administration begin its immigration crackdown. The White House's immigration policies have sparked mass protests across the United States; a CNN poll in April showed 52% of Americans polled said Trump has gone too far in deporting undocumented immigrants. ICEBlock currently has more than 20,000 users, many of whom are in Los Angeles, where controversial, large-scale deportation efforts have taken place. 'When I saw what was happening in this country, I wanted to do something to fight back,' Aaron told CNN, adding that the deportation efforts feel, to him, reminiscent of Nazi Germany. 'We're literally watching history repeat itself.' ICEBlock is designed to be an 'early warning system' for users when ICE is operating nearby, Aaron said. Users can add a pin on a map showing where they spotted agents — along with optional notes, like what officers were wearing or what kind of car they were driving. Other users within a five-mile radius will then receive a push alert notifying them of the sighting. Aaron said he hopes those notifications will help people avoid interactions with ICE, noting that he does not want users to interfere with the agency's operations. The app provides a similar warning when users log a sighting: 'Please note that the use of this app is for information and notification purposes only. It is not to be used for the purposes of inciting violence or interfering with law enforcement.' ICE did not respond to a request for comment from CNN about the app or Aaron's characterizations of its actions. ICEBlock doesn't collect personal data, and users are completely anonymous, according to Aaron. It's only available on iOS because Aaron says the app would have to collect information that could ultimately put users at risk to provide the same experience on Android. Reassuring users of those privacy protections will likely be key to growing ICEBlock's user base, given how the government is building a database to aid in its deportation efforts. 'We don't want anybody's device ID, IP address, location,' Aaron said. 'We don't want anything being discoverable. And so, this is 100% anonymous and free for anybody who wants to use it.' Although ICEBlock has no surefire way of guaranteeing the accuracy of user reports, Aaron says he's built safeguards to prevent users from spamming the platform with fake sightings. Users can only report a sighting within five miles of their location, and they can only report once every five minutes. Reports are automatically deleted after four hours. Aaron says he has no plans to monetize the free app but rather wants it to be a service to the community. Aaron's work on ICEBlock stands in contrast to the support that some leaders in Silicon Valley have shown to Trump, including by donating to and attending his inauguration. Some companies have also announced investments in expanding their US presence following the president's push for domestic tech manufacturing. 'I think I would say grow a backbone. You can't just be about the money,' Aaron said when asked what he would say to those tech leaders. 'I understand that you have shareholders to report to. I understand that you have employees that need their paychecks,' he added. 'But at what point do you say, 'Enough is enough'?'
CNN
2 hours ago
- CNN
‘I wanted to do something to fight back': This iPhone app alerts users to nearby ICE sightings
Joshua Aaron has worked in and around the tech industry for around two decades. He built his first app — a blackjack game — at computer camp when he was 13. His newest app is designed for a very different purpose: to let users alert people nearby to sightings of Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in their area. Aaron launched the platform, called ICEBlock, in early April after watching President Donald Trump's administration begin its immigration crackdown. The White House's immigration policies have sparked mass protests across the United States; a CNN poll in April showed 52% of Americans polled said Trump has gone too far in deporting undocumented immigrants. ICEBlock currently has more than 20,000 users, many of whom are in Los Angeles, where controversial, large-scale deportation efforts have taken place. 'When I saw what was happening in this country, I wanted to do something to fight back,' Aaron told CNN, adding that the deportation efforts feel, to him, reminiscent of Nazi Germany. 'We're literally watching history repeat itself.' ICEBlock is designed to be an 'early warning system' for users when ICE is operating nearby, Aaron said. Users can add a pin on a map showing where they spotted agents — along with optional notes, like what officers were wearing or what kind of car they were driving. Other users within a five-mile radius will then receive a push alert notifying them of the sighting. Aaron said he hopes those notifications will help people avoid interactions with ICE, noting that he does not want users to interfere with the agency's operations. The app provides a similar warning when users log a sighting: 'Please note that the use of this app is for information and notification purposes only. It is not to be used for the purposes of inciting violence or interfering with law enforcement.' ICE did not respond to a request for comment from CNN about the app or Aaron's characterizations of its actions. ICEBlock doesn't collect personal data, and users are completely anonymous, according to Aaron. It's only available on iOS because Aaron says the app would have to collect information that could ultimately put users at risk to provide the same experience on Android. Reassuring users of those privacy protections will likely be key to growing ICEBlock's user base, given how the government is building a database to aid in its deportation efforts. 'We don't want anybody's device ID, IP address, location,' Aaron said. 'We don't want anything being discoverable. And so, this is 100% anonymous and free for anybody who wants to use it.' Although ICEBlock has no surefire way of guaranteeing the accuracy of user reports, Aaron says he's built safeguards to prevent users from spamming the platform with fake sightings. Users can only report a sighting within five miles of their location, and they can only report once every five minutes. Reports are automatically deleted after four hours. Aaron says he has no plans to monetize the free app but rather wants it to be a service to the community. Aaron's work on ICEBlock stands in contrast to the support that some leaders in Silicon Valley have shown to Trump, including by donating to and attending his inauguration. Some companies have also announced investments in expanding their US presence following the president's push for domestic tech manufacturing. 'I think I would say grow a backbone. You can't just be about the money,' Aaron said when asked what he would say to those tech leaders. 'I understand that you have shareholders to report to. I understand that you have employees that need their paychecks,' he added. 'But at what point do you say, 'Enough is enough'?'
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Review: ‘I Want to Burn This Place Down' confronts the myths of the American Dream
With a title like 'I Want to Burn This Place Down,' you'd think that Lit Hubcolumnist Maris Kreizman's book of 10 essays would be a scathing takedown of American capitalism run amok and skewering of a country that prizes greed, power and getting ahead over decent values and being kind to others. Add a nearly empty matchbook to the cover — the middle match projected defiantly upward — and you might also presume that the tone of the collection would fall somewhere between cunningly pithy and downright incendiary. On the whole, the book is a meandering yet honest depiction of Kreizman's evolution from being an earnest, if naïve rule-follower enamored with working hard and embracing the American Dream to a disillusioned 40-something who's realized that meritocracy and 'playing by the rules can be futile and demeaning if the game itself has always been rigged.' Kreizman is at her strongest when she's discussing topics close to home — which, coincidentally, are the same ones that may resonate with people of all stripes. As a person with Type I diabetes, the essays in which she deconstructs her fear of living with a chronic disease and someday losing her health insurance or access to insulin at no fault of her own feel equally raw and representative of America's broken healthcare system. (Her methodical cataloging of all the poking, levels-checking, and diet-watching she's endured in 'She's Lost Control Again' provide a convincing backdrop.) In tandem, the pieces that hint at the myriad ways she's felt hoodwinked by the '80s promise of a bright, accessible-to-all future — equal access to a job that brings stability and fulfillment, affordable housing, a dependable income — echo much of the zeitgeist in America these days, no matter which side you're on. 'The American Dream of my parents, and of boomers more broadly, has become less and less attainable for the next generation, and especially for the people who were never intended to dream such dreams in the first place: Black and Brown people, poor people, differently abled people, genderqueer people,' she writes. But Kreizman's essays aren't all home runs. While the points in 'A Series of Unfortunate Salaries' — an essay that reads like a blend of nostalgic remembrances of paying dues in publishing circa the early 2000s (ah, all that faxing and those happy hour vodka sodas) and a laundry list of complaints about the notoriously cheap and elitist publishing world — are all valid (and spot on), there's nothing that revelatory about illuminating the industry's oft-documented shoddy business practices and culture. Other essays, like 'My Dumb Obsessions,' in which Kreizman rehashes old dating strategies, or 'I Found My Life Partner (and My Health Insurance) Because I Got Lucky,' an otherwise charming love letter to her husband, feel either a little light or underdeveloped compared to the rest of the offerings. (I wanted to hear more from Kreizman in 'Having It All Without Kids,' for example.) Still, what unites these thought-provoking, heartfelt essays is Kreizman's clear commitment to dissecting and openly sharing all the ways she's felt let down by the institutions she once trusted — something we can all relate to.
