Supreme Court upholds ban on medical treatment for transgender minors
The ruling affirmed a previous decision by the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals that a Tennessee law banning certain treatments, like puberty blockers and hormone treatments, can remain in place.
In the 6-3 decision, delivered by Chief Justice John Roberts, the court said the case carries the weight of 'fierce scientific and policy debates about the safety, efficacy and propriety' of medical treatments in the 'evolving' field.
'The voices in these debates raise sincere concerns; the implications for all are profound,' Roberts wrote.
Roberts said the court's role is to ensure the Tennessee law does not violate the Constitution's equal protection clause and is not subject to heightened scrutiny.
He was joined by the other conservative justices, including Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. Thomas and Barrett issued separate concurring opinions.
'Having concluded that it does not, we leave questions regarding its policy to the people, their elected representatives, and the democratic process,' Roberts wrote.
The three liberal justices dissented. Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented, and was joined in full by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson and in part by Justice Elena Kagan.
Sotomayor argued that the court is authorizing 'untold harm' to transgender children and their families.
'Because there is no constitutional justification for that result, I dissent,' she said.
The case stems from a doctor, parents and transgender minors who challenged Tennessee's law. They secured a partial victory at the district court level, when the court ruled transgender youth should have access to treatments that were available to non-transgender peers.
The 6th Circuit overturned that decision on an appeal and argued the policy does not promote sex discrimination. The Supreme Court's ruling Wednesday affirmed the circuit court decision.
The case could impact around two dozen other states who also have similar gender-related restrictions on treatments, including Utah, and is a setback for some in the LGBTQ+ community who disagree with the Trump administration's actions on transgender issues.
Sen. Mike Lee was supportive of the Supreme Court's decision.
'A great victory for America's children and the right of states to protect them,' he said Wednesday in a post on X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Associated Press
2 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Smithsonian denies White House pressure to remove Trump impeachment references
WASHINGTON (AP) — The White House did not pressure the Smithsonian to remove references to President Donald Trump's two impeachments from an exhibit and will include him in an updated presentation 'in the coming weeks,' the museum said Saturday. The revelation that Trump was no longer listed among impeached presidents sparked concern that history was being whitewashed to appease the president. 'We were not asked by any Administration or other government official to remove content from the exhibit,' the Smithsonian statement said. A museum spokesperson, Phillip Zimmerman, had previously pledged that 'a future and updated exhibit will include all impeachments,' but it was not clear when the new exhibit would be installed. The museum on Saturday did not say when in the coming weeks the new exhibit will be ready. A label referring to Trump's impeachments had been added in 2021 to the National Museum for American History's exhibit on the American presidency, in a section called 'Limits of Presidential Power.' The section includes materials on the impeachment of Presidents Bill Clinton and Andrew Johnson and the Watergate scandal that helped lead to President Richard Nixon's resignation. 'The placard, which was meant to be a temporary addition to a twenty-five year-old exhibition, did not meet the museum's standards in appearance, location, timeline, and overall presentation,' the statement said. 'It was not consistent with other sections in the exhibit and moreover blocked the view of the objects inside its case. For these reasons, we removed the placard.' Trump is the only president to have been impeached twice — in 2019, for pushing Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to investigate Joe Biden, who would later defeat Trump in the 2020 presidential election; and in 2021 for 'incitement of insurrection,' a reference to the Jan. 6 siege of the U.S. Capitol by Trump supporters attempting to halt congressional certification of Biden's victory. The Democratic majority in the House voted each time for impeachment. The Republican-led Senate each time acquitted Trump.
Wall Street Journal
2 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Watchdog Agency Opens Probe Into Jack Smith, Who Investigated Trump
WASHINGTON—An executive-branch ethics watchdog has opened an investigation into Jack Smith, the former Justice Department special counsel who investigated Donald Trump before he returned to the White House. The Office of Special Counsel confirmed Saturday that it had opened the probe into Smith for possible violations of the Hatch Act, a federal law that bans partisan political activity by certain government employees. The agency has no criminal enforcement power, but can impose fines and other sanctions.
Fox News
32 minutes ago
- Fox News
Dems dig in, Trump demands all: Nominee fight boils over in Senate as GOP looks for a deal
The path to a deal on confirming a slew of President Donald Trump's nominees appeared shaky at best in the Senate Saturday, as Republicans and Democrats sparred over terms and conditions to find a way forward. Senators were supposed to be long gone from Washington by now, but Trump's demands to ram his nominees through Senate Democrats' historic blockade have kept lawmakers in town. But by late afternoon, not much progress had been made. When asked if any headway had been made, Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., told Fox News Digital, "Unfortunately, not really, no." "The Dems are dug in on a position that's just not working," he said. Negotiations have been ongoing among Republicans, Democrats and the White House. Thune and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., met last night to discuss an offer from Democrats. The two have not spoken directly since then, instead communicating through intermediaries, Thune said. However, he expected they would talk again later Saturday. Senate Republicans want to strike a deal that would see nominees that made it through committee with bipartisan support get lightning-fast votes on the floor, but Schumer has not relented. A source familiar with negotiations said Senate Democrats are looking for deals on the release of funding withheld by the White House and a guarantee that there will be no future rescissions packages — a particular sticking point for them heading into the looming deadline to fund the government. In exchange, they are offering a tranche of nominees to go ahead now, and another round later in the fall. But Trump, who is at his Bedminster, N.J., golf course, has demanded that lawmakers stay in town and pass the entire slate of nominees on the Senate calendar, which has ballooned to over 150. The president lauded Senate Republicans in a post to Truth Social on Saturday "for fighting, over the Weekend and far beyond, if necessary, in order to get my great Appointments approved, and on their way to helping us MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!" "The Radical Left Democrat Senators are doing everything possible to DELAY these wonderful and talented people from being approved," he said. "If George Washington or Abraham Lincoln were up for approval, the Dems would delay, as long as possible, then vote them out." While Republicans have confirmed well over 100 of the president's nominees, the only pick to make it to the floor without objection was Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Not a single one of Trump's nominees has gotten a voice vote or gone through unanimous consent, two floor actions that have been routinely used to advance nominees in the upper chamber throughout the years. At this point four years ago, 49 of former President Joe Biden's picks had been confirmed by voice vote. Sen. Markwayne Mullin, R-Okla., explained that Republicans have three options that they have enough support among the conference to move forward with: reach a deal with Democrats; adjourn the Senate and give the president runway for recess appointments and finally, a rules-change package, which some Republicans consider the "nuclear option." On recess appointments, a move floated since before Trump took office, Sen. Eric Schmitt, R-Mo., contended it would be up to Democrats whether Republicans actually went through with it. "The Democrats' obstruction is leading to, in very short order, us taking the necessary actions to give the President power to make recess appointments," he said. While it would be a touchy move that would set off a firestorm among Democrats, Republicans aren't afraid to move ahead with a rules change. When asked if a rule change should be done before lawmakers leave town, Sen. Kevin Cramer, R-N.D., said "I think that'd be best." But the preference is to strike a deal, preferably on a potential package on over 60 nominees that were advanced out of committee in a bipartisan fashion. "The reason why we're that way is because Schumer led us down this road," Mullin said. "He didn't have to do it this way."
