Building the Band review – Liam Payne's controversial final show is the kind of reality TV that made him
Building the Band aims to modernise the format by bolting on parts of other reality TV shows. Its wannabe singers perform to other singers, sight-unseen, who then decide whether they'd like to be in a band with each other, by pressing a button, and collecting 'likes'. It is Love Is Blind meets The Circle meets The Voice, though mostly, it is The Voice, replacing celebrity judges, in the early stages, with peers.
Though he does not appear in the first batch of episodes, Liam Payne features as a guest judge further down the line, alongside Kelly Rowland and Nicole Scherzinger. Payne died, aged 31, last October, and this is his final project. There has been some backlash already, questioning whether the show should be released at all. Some have seen it as a ghoulish enterprise: it is easy to see how watching Payne return to the kind of reality show that made him a star, knowing where and how his story came to an end, would be uncomfortable. The show chooses to frame its release as a tribute. Presenter AJ McLean, of the Backstreet Boys, opens the series with a sincere acknowledgment of Payne's 'deep love for music', acknowledging that they 'never imagined we'd soon be saying goodbye to our friend'.
As a reality show, it is fine, watchable, well-crafted, leaving sufficient cliffhangers to keep you pressing play, though its first four episodes do begin to feel a little drawn-out and repetitive. There are 50 singers, each in their own pods, or 'sound booths'. Everyone auditions as an individual. Six bands will be formed, each having between three and five members. Everyone has a maximum of 10 likes, which they can use, Voice-like, by thumping a big button. If a singer gets fewer than five likes, they are out. If they run out of people who have liked them, because they have formed other bands, then they are also out. It is not as mathematically demanding as it sounds.
All of the singers, or at least the ones we see performing, are professional-sounding and highly competent, in that belting-it-out, face-slappingly emotional, semi-strained sort of way. (As a point of contrast, watch old clips of Pop Idol or Pop Stars: The Rivals auditions on YouTube, if only to see how singing has evolved over the last 25 years. It's the difference between a bicycle and a Maserati.) In these early stages, the critiques are left to the performers themselves, and mostly, they offer these with tact, rather than cruelty. There are none of the old 'bad for comic effect' auditions here. The rejections, when they come, are swift, but heartfelt, and McLean is left to deliver the bad news.
Eventually, as those who impress most move into their bands, they perform together for the first time, when they are able to see who they've chosen as bandmates. As with Love Is Blind, you can tell whether there is chemistry or not in an instant. It reminds me of the moment when people finally see above the knee on Naked Attraction. They say one thing, but their expressions say something else entirely.
At the end of this first batch of episodes, there are hints of a more ruthless reality show beginning to emerge, not least because the winning band will walk away with half a million dollars. People make promises to each other that they are not sure they can keep. There is a Regina George character, one of those 'I'm not afraid of conflict' reality show staples. The bands live and work together, 24/7. The respectful peer-to-peer notes of the sound booths may not be the enduring mood of the series.
I did question why Building the Band would choose to focus on groups, in an era of solo singer dominance, but perhaps it has been designed less for making stars, and more for the dramatic spectacle. Whether that revives the format, or simply shifts it into a more standardised reality TV lane, remains to be seen. Incidentally, I keep calling it 'Breaking the Band', mostly because of the early 00s show Making the Band, but I do wonder if there might be something more to the slip.
Building the Band is on Netflix
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
14 minutes ago
- The Independent
Jeannie Seely, soulful country singer behind hits like 'Don't Touch Me,' dies at 85
Jeannie Seely, the soulful country music singer behind such standards like 'Don't Touch Me,' has died. She was 85. Her publicist, Don Murry Grubbs, said she died Friday after succumbing to complications from an intestinal infection. Known as 'Miss Country Soul' for her unique vocal style, Seely was a trailblazer for women in country music, celebrated for her spirited nonconformity and for a string of undeniable hits in the '60s and '70s. Her second husband, Gene Ward, died in December. In May, Seely revealed that she was in recovery after undergoing multiple back surgeries, two emergency procedures and spending 11 days in the ICU. She also suffered a bout of pneumonia. 'Rehab is pretty tough, but each day is looking brighter and last night, I saw a light at the end of the tunnel. And it was neon, so I knew it was mine!' she said in a statement at the time. 'The unsinkable Seely is working her way back.' Seely was born in July 1940, in Titusville, Pennsylvania, about two hours north of Pittsburgh and raised in nearby Townville. Her love of country music was instant; her mother sang, and her father played the banjo. When she was a child, she sang on local radio programs and performed on local television. In her early 20s, she moved to Los Angeles to kick-start a career, taking a job Liberty and Imperial Records in Hollywood. She kept writing and recording. Nashville was next: She sang on Porter Wagoner's show; she got a deal with Monument Records. Her greatest hit would arrive soon afterward: 'Don't Touch Me,' the crossover ballad written by Hank Cochran. The song earned Seely her first and only Grammy Award, for best country & western vocal performance in the female category. Cochran and Seely were married in 1969 and divorced in 1979. Seely broke boundaries in her career — at a time when country music expected a kind of subservience from its women performers, Seely was a bit of a rebel, known for wearing a miniskirt on the Grand Ole Opry stage when it was still taboo. And she had a number of country hits in the '60s and '70s, including three Top 10 hits on what is now known as Billboard's hot country songs chart: 'Don't Touch Me,' 1967's 'I'll Love You More (Than You Need)' and 1973's 'Can I Sleep In Your Arms?', adapted from the folk song 'Can I Sleep In Your Barn Tonight Mister?' In the years since, Seely continued to release albums, perform, and host, regularly appearing on country music programming. Her songs are considered classics, and have been recorded by everyone from Merle Haggard, Ray Price and Connie Smith to Ernest Tubb, Grandpa Jones, and Little Jimmy Dickens. And Seely never stopped working in country music. Since 2018, she's hosted the weekly 'Sunday's with Seely' on Willie Nelson's Willie's Roadhouse SiriusXM channel. That same year, she was inducted into the Music City Walk of Fame. She appeared nearly 5,400 times at the Grand Ole Opry, which she has been a member of since 1967. Grubbs said Saturday's Grand Ole Opry show would be dedicated to Seely. She released her latest song in July 2024, a cover of Dottie West's 'Suffertime,' recorded at the world-renowned RCA Studio B. She performed it at the Opry the year before.
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Katie Price and Kerry Katona reveal they WANT their teenage daughters to go on Love Island and follow in their reality TV footsteps as they weigh in on 'nepo baby' debate
Katie Price and Kerry Katona have confessed that they want their teenage daughters to go on ITV 's flagship show Love Island. Katie, 47, is a mother to Harvey, 22, with her ex Dwight Yorke, Junior, 19, and Princess 18, with ex-husband Peter Andre, and Jett, 11, and Bunny, 10, with ex-husband Kieran Hayler. Meanwhile, Kerry, 44, shares daughters Molly, 23, and Lilly Sue, 22, with her first husband Brian McFadden; Heidi, 18, and Max, 16, with second husband Mark Croft and her youngest DJ, 10, with late husband George Kay. Now, the famous friends have confessed that they want their respective teenage daughters, Princess and Heidi, to sign up for Love Island and follow in their reality TV footsteps. Katie told The Sun: 'I always say Love Island, Heidi and Princess need to do it together.' To which Kerry added: 'The way I see it is, forget management, forget fame, what an amazing memory, what an amazing adventure.' The pair have confessed to The Sun that they want their two teenage daughters, Princess and Heidi (pictured with her mother Kerry) to be a competitor on the dating reality show Love Island Kerry also hit back at 'nepo baby' accusations as she insisted their children would only be able to thrive in the industry if they had the talent as well. 'Everyone talks about nepotism right, but everyone has a contact for somebody, I can open a door for you, whether you get through that door and you stay through it, that's on your own f*cking merit,' she said. 'You don't see Brooklyn Beckham playing f*cking football, because he's sh*t - this is our family business, this is what we do as a family.' Love Island is a UK dating competition where a group of singles live together in a luxury villa and try to form romantic connections in a bid to win a £50,000 cash prize. It would not be Princess' first foray into reality TV as she has teamed up with ITV to release her fly-on-the-wall series, The Princess Diaries. Princess is also said to already have a net worth of £500,000 and starred on the cover of OK! Magazine for her 18th birthday as she follows in her mum's showbiz footsteps. While this is a substantial amount of money, this is just 10 per cent of what Princess's ratings can secure as she has vowed to become a 'millionaire by the age of 20' For a single sponsorship brand deal video, the blonde beauty can be anywhere between £2,540 to £3,810. Meanwhile, Heidi, who boasts 18,000 followers on Instagram, has reportedly just 'done her first solo shoot', according to her mother Kerry. Heidi is currently a brand ambassador for In Print We Trust, and she offers fans discounts for using her code as she has proven herself to be the budding influencer. And it is not just TV appearances and brand deals that Heidi can capitalise off, as her TikTok and Instagram accounts have amassed over 20,000 followers. With her 18,000 Instagram followers, she is estimated to earn anywhere between £160 to £245 for each sponsorship brand deal video. Heidi has been trying to break onto the showbusiness scene for many years as she appeared on The Voice Kids in 2020. Having confessed previously that 'she knows she will be famous in the future', the brunette beauty has also teased that she has considered going on Love Island when she is older enough. And there is more to come for the star as a source told the Sun last year that she had 'already secured some incredible opportunities, including a casting in for a lead role in a Pinocchio feature film'. Heidi appears to be taking inspiration of success from family friend Princess as the Katona and Price families have been spending more time with one another over recent years.
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Hugh Hefner's widow Crystal makes jaw-dropping claim about Playboy mogul's family and her inheritance
Crystal Hefner has made another shocking claim about her late husband Hugh. The former DJ, 39, already exposed the legendary Playboy mogul in her tell-all memoir Only Say Good Things, but now she's made another wild claim about Hugh's relationship with his family. During an argument with former Playmate Audra Lynn on Instagram, Crystal called Hugh's youngest son Cooper a 'narcissist' and said that father-of-four Hugh didn't even like his own children. 'Hef didn't even like his own kids, he would tell me he's not a good dad and shoo them out of the room when they would come in trying to talk to him,' she wrote. She also denied an accusation that she had 'walked away with inheritance meant for [Hefner's] family', but did confirm that she had been left with the $5million Hollywood Hills home that Hef bought her during their marriage. has contacted Crystal's representatives for comment. The blonde bombshell, who now works as a real estate agent, has been at war with her late husband and his family over the last few years. Last year, Hugh's son Marston launched a scathing attack on Crystal, accusing her of being a 'master manipulator' – and even appeared to suggest that she took advantage of his father before his death. Marston, 35, made a series of damning claims about his father's widow on the Girls Next Level podcast, suggesting Crystal was hellbent on power and oversaw changes to Hef's will when he was mentally fragile. Speaking to hosts Holly Madison and Bridget Marquardt, he said that Crystal became addicted to the 'idea of control and power,' and would determine who could and could not enter the Playboy Mansion. 'She liked controlling the guest list,' he said. 'She liked taking girls off and on the guest list depending on how, whatever the whims were at the time… She liked being in that position where you had to go through her or you had to ask her for things.' Her alleged obsession with control appeared to extend to matters of Hugh's will, with Marston suggesting Crystal oversaw changes when his father was 'sick' and 'dosed with f***ing medication,' which he claims left the businessman unaware of his surroundings. 'He was really sick and that's why she got all these NDA things,' he said. 'According to her, she didn't want people to see him not able to walk, not able to talk.' Marston, whose mother is model Kimberley Conrad, said his father would struggle to remember how to play backgammon with him due to the strong back pain medication he was on at the time. 'The year that he passed away, he changed the will and he gave me, another person, and Crystal more money,' he said. 'And I don't know how much more, I don't remember if Crystal got more than us.... 'I was looking at that when I was getting the inheritance, and I was like, "Why? When he wasn't here, when he didn't know what the f*** was up or down half of the time, why would he change his will?"' He continued: 'And that's why I sent an email saying, "I don't think he's competent anymore, guys, can we agree on this?" And nobody really wanted to address what I perceived as the elephant in the room. 'And then more than that, it's like why is it when somebody can't play his favorite thing and doesn't know where he is, why is he changing his f***ing will? Why are people allowing that to happen?' Crystal famously wed the magazine publisher in 2012 when she was 26 and he was 86. They were married until his death at age 91 in 2017, which was the result of heart failure and septicemia after contracting a deadly strain of e-coli. He left a reported $43 million fortune behind. Last year, Crystal published her explosive memoir, Only Say Good Things: Surviving Playboy And Finding Myself, in which she made a number of bombshell claims, including that she never loved the late magazine kingpin and she felt imprisoned in their four-year marriage. Marston revealed how he had messaged Holly and Bridget, referring to Crystal as a 'master manipulator' after reading her book, and questioned some of her claims - as well as her motivation for writing the memoir. Suggesting that she buys Instagram followers, he asked: 'If you're not interested in fame, why are you buying Instagram followers? 'If you're not after money, then why was she hustling as Crystal DJ Hefner?' Crystal later fired back at Marston's claims in a statement to Us Weekly. 'I feel that obviously he has a lot of pain and hurt still from the relationship or lack thereof with his father.' She added, 'And there are some things I think he's trying to heal or get answers to that he's realizing may never be answered. So maybe he's filling in the blanks themselves.' Crystal also strongly denied Marston's claims that she had Hugh 'dosed with f***ing medication' and that she had 'invited strangers' to Hugh's funeral. 'I was married to him. I was closest to Hef,' she insisted. Regarding Holly and Bridget, Crystal said that the duo were trying to 'sabotage' her and 'pull my life apart'. 'If I have a problem with someone, I'll go to the person and talk to them. Obviously they just want attention,' she sniffed. In another statement, this time to the New York Post, Crystal said that Marston's claims about her changing Hef's will were false. 'This story is untrue and was discredited by Hef's estate attorney who wrote his will years before Hef passed,' she said. Last month, Crystal announced that she had officially taken legal steps to change her name, nearly eight years after her husband's death. On June 13, 2025, she filed a petition in Los Angeles Superior Court to revert to her maiden name, Crystal Margaret Harris. The filing, which was reviewed by People, indicates that she is seeking to resume the name she held before her marriage to Hugh.
