Middle East unrest: On the supply of aid to Gaza, Australia sides with Hamas over Israel
The Gazans' plight is an outrage against humanity. But it might be fair to ask whether Ms Wong and her counterparts are playing into a analysis of the conflict between Israel and its Muslim opponents that ignores a truth so obvious it should not need to be stated: Hamas can end a war it started at any time.
The lopsided approach is not only due to the enormous public pressure generated by haunting images of malnourished children. It acknowledges the reality of diplomatic influence. Hamas, a terrorist organisation that celebrates the murder of Jews, is almost immune to international public opinion. Israel would struggle to survive without US military aid and relies on less-visible support from the rest of the Western world.
Hamas, fighting a last-ditch effort to survive in Gaza, was delighted by the Western gesture of support against what it calls the 'fascist occupation government'. Israel's 'criminal goal' it said, was 'killing and humiliating Palestinians'.
That characterisation of Israel is shared by hundreds of protesters who gathered on the Parliament House forecourt in Canberra on Tuesday. The Australian government's rhetorical support did not satisfy them. They want a full break in diplomatic ties with Israel and sanctions against its leading ministers, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Some held signs that said: 'Albo - Wong Accessories to Genocide'.
Israel's failure to provide the basics of life to Gaza is one of the terrible consequences of a war it did not start. The Israeli government decided it would no longer work with the United Nations food distribution network because the aid, it said, was falling under Hamas's control.
Israel set up its own system, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which isn't functioning properly. A Wall Street Journal reporter last Tuesday watched food being issued at Khan Younis in the south of the strip.
Thousands of Palestinians surged forward when a barbed-wire fence was opened to an aid centre. American security contractors tried to keep control but couldn't hold back the crowd. As gunshots rang out, the food was looted in 15 minutes of chaos.
The reporter couldn't work out who was shooting, but wrote that the aid workers rely on Israeli soldiers for protection. That places hungry Palestinian men in proximity of nervous armed Israeli soldiers, who don't have non-lethal arms to protect themselves against perceived threats.
Ms Wong and the other foreign ministers wrote that over 800 Palestinians have died seeking aid. The figure comes from Hamas officials and is disputed by Israel.
The situation is exacerbated by the refusal of Mr Netanyahu's right-wing government to allow a new government to emerge in Gaza. With their agreement, the Palestinian Authority could return from the West Bank or non-Hamas Gazans could take power.
Instead, the territory is left in anarchy while Israel tries to eradicate Hamas and find the 20 hostages estimated to have survived 715 days in captivity. 'We control Gaza,' former prime minister Ehud Olmert told the New York Times. 'It's incumbent upon us to make sure that the proper arrangements are made.'
While disappointed in Ms Wong's position, Australian Jewish leaders also expressed concerns about the lack of food in Gaza. At the same time, they believe Hamas has to lose its control over the strip's food supply to be properly defeated.
'I share the government's concern about the delivery of aid and humanitarian suffering in Gaza,' Zionist Federation of Australia president Jeremy Leibler said on Tuesday. 'The practical reality is that Hamas hijacks aid and uses it to extort its own people. Hamas intentionally interferes with alternative aid delivery mechanism for this very reason – it is their last remaining leverage.'
Israel deserves criticism. But too many critics in Australia and elsewhere refuse to acknowledge the Jewish state has rights too, including to defend itself.
By emphasising the actions of one side, the critics oversimplify a complex conflict and contribute to an environment in which self-righteous activists feel emboldened to harass Jews, including some of those leaders willing to accept their opponents' arguments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
The ABC faces 'existential reckoning' after the US defunded NPR and PBS in a clarion call that shatters the myth of state-backed media's indispensability
The once-cherished ideal of publicly-funded media teeters on the brink of irrelevance – a relic of a bygone era when airwaves were scarce and governments saw themselves as arbiters of impartial truth. The rise of digital streaming and decentralised content creation, coupled with fiscally irresponsible governments and a polarised public sphere, has exposed state-backed broadcasters as lumbering dinosaurs in a world awash with private media alternatives. As trust in institutions wanes and fiscal scrutiny intensifies, the very concept of taxpayer-subsidised journalism faces an existential reckoning. The centre-right side of the political aisle from Washington DC to London to Canberra and beyond has long been debating the cost-benefit of such entities in serving the public interest – to little result. Finally, on July 18, 2025, the US Congress passed the historic Rescissions Act of 2025, marking a watershed moment in this protracted debate and providing a bold precedent to nations everywhere – including and especially Australia – to fundamentally challenge the merits of publicly-funded media. The Historic US Rescission Bill The Rescissions Act of 2025 passed in the United States Congress last week by a narrow House vote of 216-213 and a Senate vote of 51-48, clawing back $7.9 billion in previously approved federal spending for foreign aid programs, and eliminating $1.1 billion in federal funding for fiscal years 2026 and 2027 for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB), the parent entity over public broadcast network PBS and public radio network NPR. The bill, driven by the Trump administration and supported by Republican majorities, required only a simple majority to pass due to the rarely used rescission process, which allows Congress to cancel previously appropriated funds within 45 days of a presidential request. This rescission marked a historic first in defunding public media among Western democracies, succeeding where previous attempts in the US and elsewhere had failed. In the US, Republican-led pushes to defund CPB date back to the 1970s under President Nixon, with notable attempts under Reagan, George W. Bush, and during Mitt Romney's 2012 campaign. In Canada, the CBC has faced Conservative Party budget cut proposals to no avail. In Europe, the BBC, Germany's ARD/ZDF, and France Télévisions have endured calls to reform or abolish license fees but retained government support. And right here in Australia, the Coalition government has looked to trim around the edges, under Howard ($55 million reduction in 1996), Abbott ($254 million over five years), and Turnbull ($83.7 million over three years in 2018), though never fully defunded the broadcaster. The 2025 US success hinged on unified Republican control of Congress, the will to invoke the rarely used rescission process, and Trump's once-in-a-generation talent for framing and persuading contentious political issues allowed for a swift, party-line vote to finally challenge a centuries old, entrenched belief system. This alignment of political will, executive pressure, and procedural strategy marks a first among Western democracies. Defeating the Commonly Cited Objections to Defunding Public Media Two primary arguments are typically cited by opponents of defunding public media: (i) the impact it would have on media access by rural communities, and (ii) its role in producing cultural and local content that the global media industry would not naturally prioritise. Both arguments are increasingly outdated in today's media landscape. Rural communities now benefit from significant internet penetration ( Critically, defunding public media has no bearing on funding for emergency alert systems, which are managed separately and thus ensure rural areas retain access to vital public service announcements. The second objection—that publicly funded media is necessary for cultural and locally relevant content not prioritised by global media—ignores the extreme democratisation of content creation and distribution enabled by the internet over the past quarter century. Independent creators are now producing a full spectrum of content from mass to niche, including cultural/ localised content and citizen journalism at a fraction of the cost. As an example, private media companies (both corporate and independent) are two to five times as efficient as their publicly funded counterparts, demonstrating the expected differences in incentives and outcomes brought about by competition. Finally, private donations has always been and remains a viable source of funding for local/cultural content that may not be prioritised by global media conglomerates. Notably, one to two per cent of NPR's and only 15 per cent of PBS's budgets are funded by the American taxpayer whereas their counterparts in countries like the UK, Canada, Germany, France and Australia are close to or fully 100 per cent taxpayer funded. While this may be a reflection of the more socialist heritage of these nations relative to the US, it is getting harder to defend in an era of irrational government debts, and conversely, so many more avenues for private funding from crowdfunded donations to traditional corporate and large-scale philanthropy. The Case and Blueprint for Australia The bold precedent set by the US Congress last week, coupled with the structural shifts seen in the media landscape over the last twenty years, reveals how the case for eliminating publicly funded media in Australia is now more compelling than ever before. As mentioned above, it is 100 per cent taxpayer funded when compared to its US counterparts, disincentivising private donations that could foster accountability and diversity in funding, Australia's rural broadband penetration is higher than the US, with only 10–15 per cent of its 7 million rural residents lacking access (compared to 24 per cent in the U.S.), enabling streaming alternatives to serve regional audiences effectively. Australia's gross debt will exceed AUD $1 trillion by 2027 As an English-speaking market, Australia benefits from access to a vast array of top-tier global media, from major English-language broadcasters and platforms in news and entertainment, to independent media voices in podcasting, Substack, and beyond, offering diverse subjects and worldviews that reduce the need for a large and bloated taxpayer-funded broadcaster. Last week's historic precedent in the US offers a blueprint for any Australian politician willing to build on the case made by previous Coalition governments and take it to its logical endpoint. The Liberal-National Coalition must embed ABC defunding in its election platform, as the US. Republicans did with CPB cuts. This aligns with criticisms from Liberal figures and the Institute of Public Affairs, which regularly cite ideological biases in the ABC alongside its fiscal unsustainability. A skilled PR campaign, mirroring Trump's 'one-two-punch' approach of political pressure and narrative persuasion, should leverage public scepticism about the ABC. A 2022 Guardian Australia poll showed 56 per cent of Australians supported restoring ABC funding, but 44 per cent were opposed or neutral, indicating a sizable persuadable audience. The campaign should emphasise conceptual obsolescence, fiscal responsibility, and ideological bias. To win over sympathetic rural communities, where 24 per cent lack adequate broadband, the policy prescription must emphasise that it would preserve essential services like emergency broadcasts, while highlighting the expected ongoing increases in internet connectivity across rural Australia. Lastly, the parliamentary budget process in Australia is generally easier to execute than the recissions procedure in the US congress, due to its annual cycle and simple majority requirements – a greater indictment on the lack of success towards this goal by the Coalition government thus far. When next in a parliamentary majority, the Coalition can defund the ABC through an amendment to zero out its $1.1 billion allocation in the annual budget or a standalone bill amending the Australian Broadcasting Corporation Act 1983, requiring only a simple majority in both houses. To counter Labor and Greens opposition, citing the ABC's 14.5 million monthly reach, the Coalition could propose a transition plan (e.g., partial privatisation) and secure crossbench support. A taskforce would oversee asset sales and ~4,000 staff redundancies, with targeted subsidies ensuring rural service continuity to mitigate backlash from groups like ABC Friends. In Conclusion As the airwaves of yesteryear give way to the boundless digital frontier, the US Rescissions Act of 2025 stands as a clarion call, shattering the myth of state-backed media's indispensability and igniting a revolution in how nations fund their narratives. Australia, tethered to the ABC's $1.1 billion yoke, now faces a pivotal choice: cling to a fading paradigm or embrace a vibrant, market-driven media ecosystem. The numbers lay bare the ABC's inefficiencies against a range of comparable media entities. As the US forges ahead, finally breaking its decades old public media burden, Australia has a fleeting chance to sever the chains of subsidy, unleash private creativity, and redefine its voice in a world where the marketplace, not the state, shapes the stories we tell. Kosha Gada is a tech entrepreneur and broadcast commentator on US and international current affairs, appearing live three nights a week on Sky News Australia. She is a board member of sports betting platform PointsBet.
Sydney Morning Herald
3 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Brisbane news live: Man arrested after allegedly climbing onto roof after police chase
Go to latest Man allegedly tries to evade arrest by climbing onto roof after police chase By Police have taken a man into custody who had attempted to hide on a roof in Ipswich, after road spikes stopped him driving an allegedly stolen vehicle. Officers were called to Pine Mountain Road, in Brassall, just before 8.40am on Wednesday to reports a stolen Honda HR-V hit the back of a Hyundai I40. The driver of the allegedly stolen vehicle fled the scene before police arrived, but was tracked with the help of Polair. Officers said the 20-year-old Brassall man behind the wheel was stopped with tyre spikes several suburbs over on Quarry Street. The man then ran away, police said, climbing onto a roof before he was arrested. Police will allege the driver tried to evade police several times, resulting in several police vehicles being hit and damaged. Police said yesterday that no one was significantly injured, and investigations were ongoing. 7.43am Australians 'going to sleep' on China threat, Morrison tells US Congress By Michael Koziol Former prime minister Scott Morrison has told the United States Congress that Australians are at risk of 'going to sleep' on the security threat posed by China, and warned the US and its allies that they must be prepared to wear economic pain to stand up to Beijing. Appearing before a congressional hearing on the Chinese Communist Party, Morrison cited polling by the Lowy Institute that showed, in 2025, 50 per cent of Australians said China was 'more of an economic partner to Australia', whereas 47 per cent said it was 'more of a security threat'. That had changed significantly from 2021-22, a time of strained relations between Canberra and Beijing, when 63 per cent said China was more of a security threat and 33 per cent said it was more of an economic partner. 'That is an objective of the CCP – that Western democracies will go to sleep on the threat,' Morrison told the hearing. 7.40am Man allegedly tries to evade arrest by climbing onto roof after police chase By Catherine Strohfeldt Police have taken a man into custody who had attempted to hide on a roof in Ipswich, after road spikes stopped him driving an allegedly stolen vehicle. Officers were called to Pine Mountain Road, in Brassall, just before 8.40am on Wednesday to reports a stolen Honda HR-V hit the back of a Hyundai I40. The driver of the allegedly stolen vehicle fled the scene before police arrived, but was tracked with the help of Polair. Officers said the 20-year-old Brassall man behind the wheel was stopped with tyre spikes several suburbs over on Quarry Street. The man then ran away, police said, climbing onto a roof before he was arrested. Police will allege the driver tried to evade police several times, resulting in several police vehicles being hit and damaged. Police said yesterday that no one was significantly injured, and investigations were ongoing. 7.28am Man dies in Brisbane watchhouse By Catherine Strohfeldt Police have launched an internal investigation after a man died in custody at the Brisbane city watchhouse over the weekend. A 41-year-old Zillmere man was arrested last Wednesday following an outstanding arrest warrant. He became unresponsive about 5pm on July 19 and – despite first aid by watchhouse and nursing staff – died about an hour later. Police launched an investigation, which will be overseen by the Crime and Corruption Commission. 7.23am Rain, rain, gone away By Felicity Caldwell After yesterday's afternoon of winter storms, we can look forward to a beautiful sunny day in Brisbane today. The Bureau of Meteorology is predicting a top of 21 degrees for Brisbane today, with sunny skies and light winds. Meteorologist Dean Narramore said there would be 'lots of sunshine' for the Sunshine State on Thursday. 'It could be a cooler morning through inland areas, we may see a few isolated frost patches for the Darling Downs and Maranoa and Warrego, but otherwise a dry and sunny day after a cool start,' he said. 7.18am While you were sleeping Here's what's making news further afield this morning: Australia has quietly paid the US another $800 million towards the AUKUS submarine deal, taking the total to $1.6 billion, despite the Trump administration placing the agreement under a review. Anger is rising among Labor's base over the war in Gaza, with nearly 80 local branches passing recent motions calling for Australia to impose sanctions on the Netanyahu government and sever military ties with Israel. An international survey into non-prescribed drug use has made a surprising link between cannabis, psychedelics and treating eating disorders. Screen time and social media use among kids is a hot topic, but experts say parental device use can also hinder child development, and affect their adulthood. Countries besieged by the effects of climate change can legally pursue their neighbours for reparations if they fail to uphold their obligations to curb emissions, International Court of Justice has found. Former prime minister Scott Morrison has told the United States Congress that Australians are at risk of 'going to sleep' on the security threat posed by China, and warned the US and its allies they must be prepared to wear economic pain to stand up to Beijing. In Poland, one of the country's biggest media businesses is embroiled in a rapidly escalating family dispute that's playing out like a real-life version of the hit television show Succession, with a billionaire sacked by his children. 7.12am Good morning, and welcome to Brisbane Times' live news coverage for Thursday, July 24. Today should be sunny, with a top temperature of 21 degrees. In this morning's local headlines: Construction of Brisbane's new Olympic stadium could begin earlier than first thought, with the man tasked with delivering Games infrastructure keen to get excavators into Victoria Park sooner rather than later. A review into a satirical race debate at QUT that sparked media outrage has cast a shadow over the future of one of the university's specialist research institutes. Brisbane's median house price has surged by $22,000 in just three months, reaching a record high, while one suburb's median is approaching $3 million. A deal between a gangland associate and a Gold Coast developer has been revealed amid a call for action on 'crime and corruption' in the construction industry. The seemingly disparate worlds of ballet and blindness are coming together in a groundbreaking work by Queensland Ballet. A 17-month inquiry into Queensland's 'broken' child safety system, which began on Wednesday, will investigate failures in the institutions and processes that exist to protect our young. In sport, Queensland Rugby Union chief Dave Hanham has outlined visions of taking the Reds' brand worldwide, and a former Wallabies star's daring US move could hold the key to realising them.
The Age
3 hours ago
- The Age
Brisbane news live: Man arrested after allegedly climbing onto roof after police chase
Go to latest Man allegedly tries to evade arrest by climbing onto roof after police chase By Police have taken a man into custody who had attempted to hide on a roof in Ipswich, after road spikes stopped him driving an allegedly stolen vehicle. Officers were called to Pine Mountain Road, in Brassall, just before 8.40am on Wednesday to reports a stolen Honda HR-V hit the back of a Hyundai I40. The driver of the allegedly stolen vehicle fled the scene before police arrived, but was tracked with the help of Polair. Officers said the 20-year-old Brassall man behind the wheel was stopped with tyre spikes several suburbs over on Quarry Street. The man then ran away, police said, climbing onto a roof before he was arrested. Police will allege the driver tried to evade police several times, resulting in several police vehicles being hit and damaged. Police said yesterday that no one was significantly injured, and investigations were ongoing. 7.43am Australians 'going to sleep' on China threat, Morrison tells US Congress By Michael Koziol Former prime minister Scott Morrison has told the United States Congress that Australians are at risk of 'going to sleep' on the security threat posed by China, and warned the US and its allies that they must be prepared to wear economic pain to stand up to Beijing. Appearing before a congressional hearing on the Chinese Communist Party, Morrison cited polling by the Lowy Institute that showed, in 2025, 50 per cent of Australians said China was 'more of an economic partner to Australia', whereas 47 per cent said it was 'more of a security threat'. That had changed significantly from 2021-22, a time of strained relations between Canberra and Beijing, when 63 per cent said China was more of a security threat and 33 per cent said it was more of an economic partner. 'That is an objective of the CCP – that Western democracies will go to sleep on the threat,' Morrison told the hearing. 7.40am Man allegedly tries to evade arrest by climbing onto roof after police chase By Catherine Strohfeldt Police have taken a man into custody who had attempted to hide on a roof in Ipswich, after road spikes stopped him driving an allegedly stolen vehicle. Officers were called to Pine Mountain Road, in Brassall, just before 8.40am on Wednesday to reports a stolen Honda HR-V hit the back of a Hyundai I40. The driver of the allegedly stolen vehicle fled the scene before police arrived, but was tracked with the help of Polair. Officers said the 20-year-old Brassall man behind the wheel was stopped with tyre spikes several suburbs over on Quarry Street. The man then ran away, police said, climbing onto a roof before he was arrested. Police will allege the driver tried to evade police several times, resulting in several police vehicles being hit and damaged. Police said yesterday that no one was significantly injured, and investigations were ongoing. 7.28am Man dies in Brisbane watchhouse By Catherine Strohfeldt Police have launched an internal investigation after a man died in custody at the Brisbane city watchhouse over the weekend. A 41-year-old Zillmere man was arrested last Wednesday following an outstanding arrest warrant. He became unresponsive about 5pm on July 19 and – despite first aid by watchhouse and nursing staff – died about an hour later. Police launched an investigation, which will be overseen by the Crime and Corruption Commission. 7.23am Rain, rain, gone away By Felicity Caldwell After yesterday's afternoon of winter storms, we can look forward to a beautiful sunny day in Brisbane today. The Bureau of Meteorology is predicting a top of 21 degrees for Brisbane today, with sunny skies and light winds. Meteorologist Dean Narramore said there would be 'lots of sunshine' for the Sunshine State on Thursday. 'It could be a cooler morning through inland areas, we may see a few isolated frost patches for the Darling Downs and Maranoa and Warrego, but otherwise a dry and sunny day after a cool start,' he said. 7.18am While you were sleeping Here's what's making news further afield this morning: Australia has quietly paid the US another $800 million towards the AUKUS submarine deal, taking the total to $1.6 billion, despite the Trump administration placing the agreement under a review. Anger is rising among Labor's base over the war in Gaza, with nearly 80 local branches passing recent motions calling for Australia to impose sanctions on the Netanyahu government and sever military ties with Israel. An international survey into non-prescribed drug use has made a surprising link between cannabis, psychedelics and treating eating disorders. Screen time and social media use among kids is a hot topic, but experts say parental device use can also hinder child development, and affect their adulthood. Countries besieged by the effects of climate change can legally pursue their neighbours for reparations if they fail to uphold their obligations to curb emissions, International Court of Justice has found. Former prime minister Scott Morrison has told the United States Congress that Australians are at risk of 'going to sleep' on the security threat posed by China, and warned the US and its allies they must be prepared to wear economic pain to stand up to Beijing. In Poland, one of the country's biggest media businesses is embroiled in a rapidly escalating family dispute that's playing out like a real-life version of the hit television show Succession, with a billionaire sacked by his children. 7.12am Good morning, and welcome to Brisbane Times' live news coverage for Thursday, July 24. Today should be sunny, with a top temperature of 21 degrees. In this morning's local headlines: Construction of Brisbane's new Olympic stadium could begin earlier than first thought, with the man tasked with delivering Games infrastructure keen to get excavators into Victoria Park sooner rather than later. A review into a satirical race debate at QUT that sparked media outrage has cast a shadow over the future of one of the university's specialist research institutes. Brisbane's median house price has surged by $22,000 in just three months, reaching a record high, while one suburb's median is approaching $3 million. A deal between a gangland associate and a Gold Coast developer has been revealed amid a call for action on 'crime and corruption' in the construction industry. The seemingly disparate worlds of ballet and blindness are coming together in a groundbreaking work by Queensland Ballet. A 17-month inquiry into Queensland's 'broken' child safety system, which began on Wednesday, will investigate failures in the institutions and processes that exist to protect our young. In sport, Queensland Rugby Union chief Dave Hanham has outlined visions of taking the Reds' brand worldwide, and a former Wallabies star's daring US move could hold the key to realising them.
