Can naturalised citizenships - like Elon Musk's - be revoked?
The Pretoria-born billionaire boasts three citizenships – South Africa by birth, Canada by parentage, and becoming a naturalised American in 2002.
In May, Elon resigned as head of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) amid public backlash.
In recent weeks, Elon Musk has been posting his strong-worded opinions about President Donald Trump's promotion of a controversial tax bill that was recently passed by the US Senate.
When asked about Elon's X posts about the prospective legislature, Trump told reporters on Tuesday, 1 July: 'We might have to put DOGE on Elon
'DOGE is the monster that might have to go back and eat Elon. Wouldn't that be terrible?'
Further questioned if Trump was considering deporting Musk, he responded that he would 'take a look'.
Trump added that Elon Musk had a 'lot more to lose', referring to his government electric vehicle subsidies.
On his Truth Social platform, the president posted: 'Elon may get more subsidies than any human being in history. By far. And without subsidies, Elon would probably have to close up shop and head back home to South Africa.
'No more Rocket launches, Satellites, or Electric Car Production, and our Country would save a FORTUNE. Perhaps we should have DOGE take a good, hard look at this? BIG MONEY TO BE SAVED!'
In a memo posted last month, the US Department of Justice vowed to prioritise the denaturalisation of citizens who posed a threat to the country.
The list of categories included individuals who had committed a host of crimes, those who had fraudulently acquired their citizenship, and those who threatened national security, particularly with regard to terrorism, espionage, and the unlawful export of technology and information.
The department also stated that they could use their discretion to pursue individual cases that they deemed necessary. Could Elon Musk be deported after tiff with Trump? According to a Department of Justice memo, naturalised citizens can have their status's revoked.
Images via X: @elonmusk/Canva
According to Muzaffar Chishti from the Migration Policy Institute, the process could become complicated. He told The Guardian: '[The administration] can't, on their own, denaturalize people. They still have to go to a federal district court.
'Denaturalisation finally does belong to federal district courts. But they are obviously keen on finding every way they can to denaturalize people they think did not deserve to be naturalized.'
In February, Canadian MP Charlie Angus started a petition to have Elon Musk's citizenship revoked.
Signed by close to 400 000 citizens, the petition stated that Elon has acted against Canada's national interest and undermined its sovereignty. It also claims that the world's richest man has used his wealth and power to influence their elections.
However, it's unlikely that Elon's citizenship will be revoked, as the Canadian legislature states that this is only the case for individuals who commit fraud or misrepresentation.
Immigration lawyer Gabriela Ramo told CBC: 'Before they could move to do this, they would need to introduce legislation. There would have to be amendments to the current Citizenship Act.
'There's no provision that would allow them to pursue revocation of citizenship of a Canadian birth, by virtue of his birth to a Canadian mother.'
In March, Economic Freedom Fighter (EFF) leader Julius Malema also questioned if Elon Musk was still classified as a South African citizen. This after he accused Elon of influencing diplomatic tensions between the US and his country of birth.
However, Minister of Home Affairs Leon Schreiber, in a written response, stated that divulging such information would infringe on the Protection of Personal Information (POPI) Act.
Schreiber stated that the party was required to submit an application, including identity numbers, to obtain the information through the Promotion of Access to Information Act (PAIA).
Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 .
Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
7 hours ago
- The South African
Donald Trump slams 'TRAIN WRECK' Elon Musk: 'He's gone off the rails!'
US President Donald Trump on Sunday slammed former ally Elon Musk's launching of a new political party as 'ridiculous,' deepening the Republican's feud with the man who was once his biggest backer. Trump also branded the SpaceX and Tesla tycoon a 'TRAIN WRECK' who had gone 'off the rails' after Musk said he wanted to challenge the current US political system. The world's richest man was almost inseparable from Trump as he headed the cost-cutting 'Department of Government Efficiency,' but they fell out hard over the president's 'big beautiful' tax and spending mega-bill. 'I think it's ridiculous to start a third party,' Donald Trump told reporters before he boarded Air Force One on his way back to Washington from his New Jersey golf club. 'It's always been a two-party system, and I think starting a third party just adds to confusion. Third parties have never worked. So he can have fun with it, but I think it's ridiculous,' he said. South Africa-born Musk announced on Saturday that he would create the so-called 'America Party' to challenge what he called the United States' 'one-party system.' Musk says the president's massive domestic spending plan would explode the US debt, and has vowed to do everything in his power to defeat lawmakers who voted for it. The former DOGE boss, who led a huge drive to slash federal spending and cut jobs, equated Trump's Republicans with rival Democrats when it came to domestic spending. 'When it comes to bankrupting our country with waste & graft, we live in a one-party system, not a democracy,' Musk posted on X, the social media platform that he owns. Musk gave few details of his plan and it was not clear whether he had registered the party with US electoral authorities, but it could cause Republicans headaches in the 2026 midterm elections – and beyond. In a sign of how sensitive the issue could be for Trump, he took to his Truth Social network while still on Air Force One to double down on his assault on Musk. 'I am saddened to watch Elon Musk go completely 'off the rails,' essentially becoming a TRAIN WRECK over the past five weeks,' Trump posted. 'The one thing Third Parties are good for is the creation of Complete and Total DISRUPTION & CHAOS, and we have enough of that with the Radical Left Democrats.' In a lengthy diatribe, Trump repeated his earlier assertion that Musk's ownership of electric vehicle company Tesla had made him turn on the president due to the spending bill cutting subsidies for such automobiles. Musk has insisted that his opposition is primarily due to the bill increasing the US fiscal deficit and sovereign debt. Earlier on Sunday, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent also threw shade at Musk's attempts to enter the political fray, telling him to stick to running his companies. When asked by CNN if Musk's plan bothered the Trump administration, Bessent offered thinly veiled criticism. 'I believe that the boards of directors at his various companies wanted him to come back and run those companies, which he is better at than anyone,' Bessent said. 'So I imagine that those board of directors did not like this announcement yesterday and will be encouraging him to focus on his business activities, not his political activities.' Musk left DOGE in May to focus full-time on his corporate responsibilities, with Tesla's sales and image especially suffering from his brief venture into Trump's inner circle. Trump gave him a grand send-off in the Oval Office, during a bizarre ceremony during which Musk appeared with a black eye and received a golden key to the White House from the president. But just days later the two were exchanging bitter insults on social media after Musk criticised Trump's flagship spending bill. Trump would not comment on Sunday when asked if he would be asking Musk to return the golden key. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The South African
7 hours ago
- The South African
BREAKING: Donald Trump hits South Africa with 30% tariffs
South Africa is set to face a significant trade setback as US President Donald Trump has confirmed that 30% tariffs will be imposed on all South African goods starting 1 August 2025. The announcement was made in a letter from Donald Trump to President Cyril Ramaphosa. The tariffs are a result of the Donald Trump administration's stance on global trade imbalances, claiming that South Africa sells more to the US than it buys, a disparity that the US says justifies the imposition of a hefty tariff. This move is part of Donald Trump's broader 'reciprocal tariff' policy, which has sparked debate worldwide. Critics argue that the policy is based on flawed economic reasoning, with concerns over its long-term impact on international trade relations. 'South Africa's trade imbalance with the US has reached a point where it can no longer go unaddressed,' Donald Trump's letter stated. 'These tariffs are necessary to ensure fairer trade practices.' With just three weeks until the tariff implementation, South African exporters are bracing for the economic fallout. Key industries, including mining, agriculture, and manufacturing, are likely to be hit hard by the new tariff regime. Experts warn that the increased cost of doing business with the US could lead to reduced exports, putting pressure on local businesses already struggling with the global economic fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic. South African officials have expressed concern over the sudden move and its potential to harm their economy, urging Trump's administration to reconsider the punitive tariffs. Economic analysts and trade experts have widely criticised the tariffs, arguing that the trade imbalance with South Africa is not due to unfair practices, but rather structural and historical economic factors. They claim that the imposition of tariffs could lead to retaliatory measures from other countries, further exacerbating global trade tensions. 'The reciprocal tariff policy fails to account for the complexities of international trade,' said Dr. Thabo Mbeki, former South African president and economist. 'It's a short-sighted approach that risks worsening trade relations and harming economies on both sides.' With the August 1 deadline looming, South African officials are seeking diplomatic channels to resolve the issue before the tariffs take effect. However, with the Donald Trump administration's firm stance, it remains uncertain whether a last-minute resolution can be reached. The upcoming trade blow is a pivotal moment in South Africa's relationship with the US, and exporters will be watching closely to see how this affects their ability to access the lucrative American market. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
Trumps slaps SA with 30% tariffs - demands local companies move manufacturing to the US
South Africa will be hit with a 30% tariff on all its exports to the United States from August 1, following a formal letter from US President Donald Trump to President Cyril Ramaphosa demanding action on trade imbalances and long-standing market restrictions. Image: GCIS South Africa will be hit with a 30% tariff on all its exports to the United States from August 1, following a formal letter from US President Donald Trump to President Cyril Ramaphosa demanding action on trade imbalances and long-standing market restrictions. In a letter dated 7 July and sent on official White House stationery, Trump said the move was 'necessary to correct the many years of South Africa's Tariff, and Non Tariff, Policies and Trade Barriers,' blaming Pretoria for what he called 'unsustainable Trade Deficits against the United States.' The sweeping tariffs will apply to 'any and all South African products sent into the United States,' and are being imposed outside of any sectoral trade deals. The announcement follows a similar pattern of tariff notices sent to over a dozen countries in recent weeks, with South Africa facing one of the highest proposed rates. 'Our relationship has been, unfortunately, far from Reciprocal,' Trump wrote. 'Starting on August 1, 2025, we will charge South Africa a Tariff of only 30%... Goods transshipped to evade a higher Tariff will be subject to that higher Tariff.' Trump also warned that if South Africa were to retaliate by raising its own tariffs, those would be matched and added to by Washington. 'Whatever the number you choose to raise them by, will be added onto the 30% that we charge,' he wrote. 'This Deficit is a major threat to our Economy and, indeed, our National Security!' The letter reflects the hard line the Trump administration is taking with countries it accuses of taking advantage of American markets. South Africa is one of several emerging economies singled out by the White House over the past month, alongside Laos, Myanmar, Malaysia and Kazakhstan. Trump added: 'We invite you to participate in the extraordinary Economy of the United States, the Number One Market in the World, by far. We have had years to discuss our Trading Relationship... and have concluded that we must move away from these longterm, and very persistent, Trade Deficits.'
