Skellig Michael boat trips dispute resolved in High Court
The High Court dispute over boat trips to Skellig Michael has been resolved.
Mr Justice Garrett Simons was told on Tuesday that the parties had reached a settlement and a hearing date for the main case in the dispute next month could be vacated.
Advertisement
Earlier this month, the judge granted an application by the Office of Public Works (OPW) to lift an automatic suspension on landing at the Unesco heritage site and former monastic island which was also used as a film location for the Star Wars movies, The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi.
It meant that boat trips to the island off the Kerry coast could begin for the summer 2025 season immediately.
Annual landing permits issued by the OPW for mid-May to September were automatically suspended when two unsuccessful bidders for the licences brought a High Court challenge to the decision.
The OPW then had to apply to the court asking that the stay be lifted pending hearing of the substantive challenge.
Advertisement
The unsuccessful bidders, Atlantic Endeavour Ltd and SMBT Ltd trading as Skellig Michael Boat Trips, disagreed with the OPW interpretation of the legal effect of the automatic suspension.
They contended that there are a number of mechanisms open whereby landing permits might legitimately be granted to the successful tenderers for the balance of the 2025 season, while preserving their own right to challenge the allocation of landing permits for the 2026 and subsequent seasons.
Mr Justice Simons, following a hearing, ordered the stay be lifted.
He said his judgment entailed no finding whatsoever on whether the outcome of the tender process allows the OPW to confine the right to land passengers to the 15 successful tenderers for a five year period.
Advertisement
Ireland
90 arrests made during Donegal International Rally...
Read More
The proper interpretation of the request for tender and associated documentation, and the legal consequences of the tender process, remain open for debate at the trial of the action, he said.
On Tuesday, David Dodd BL, for Atlantic and SMBT, said the matter had been resolved and a hearing date for July could be vacated. He said his clients were very happy with the outcome especially in light of the judge's decision earlier this month.
The OPW had agreed to pay his side's costs.
The judge struck out the case.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
39 minutes ago
- The Sun
Cheapest shop to buy a Dyson fan revealed and the dupes that are £338 cheaper
BRITS are bracing for temperatures up to 34C as glorious sunshine continues to hit the UK. For those looking to keep cool over the next few days and into the summer, you don't have to spend a bomb on Dyson fans. 5 We've scoured retailers online to find the cheapest deals, with prices starting from £249. Shoppers with smaller budgets can opt for a number of dupes that do just as good a job for less as well. Of course, prices and stock change on a regular basis so it's worth double-checking if you can find any better deals than us. Price comparison sites like Trolley, Price Spy and Price Runner are all useful for comparing prices across the major retailers. That said, here are the best Dyson-branded fans we found and dupes which won't set you back as much. Dyson desk fan - John Lewis, £249 John Lewis is selling this Dyson desk fan, ideal for any home workers, for £249. Most other retailers we've seen are selling it for the slightly more expensive £249.99. Shoppers can't currently buy the fan online as it is out of stock, but there is some availability in stores. You can find out which branch nearest you has it in stock on the fan's product page. The nifty gadget comes with a night mode, which makes it quieter, and a timer so you don't have to worry about turning it off before falling asleep. Users can control the fan, which comes with 10 airflow settings, with a remote. Dyson tower cooling fan - Donaghy Bros, £269 We found this Dyson tower cooling fan cheapest at Donaghy Bros, which comes with a 4.8 out of 5 star rating on Trustpilot. The £269 fan comes with 10 speed settings, an up to nine hour timer and is adjustable so you can direct cold air up or downwards. The retailer is also offering free home delivery on the device, which measures 1metre high and weighs 2.85kg. The fan comes with a two year warranty in case anything goes wrong after purchase. Dyson jet focus fan hot and cold heater - Argos, £290 Argos is selling the dual-purpose Dyson hot and cold air fan for £290 which is cheapest we've seen out of the major retailers. It comes with 10 heat settings, is remote control-operated, and works either on the floor or tables. It's also, Dyson claims, super quiet meaning it would work well in the bedroom. The fan comes with a two-year parts and labour guarantee. Shoppers with a Nectar Card can also get 290 Nectar points when purchasing the fan. Dyson cool purifying fan - Donaghy Bros, £448 This slightly more expensive fan is cheapest at Donaghy Bros, where it costs £448. Dyson says the fan works by not only keeping you cool but sensing and removing pollutants around your home as well. The fan turns 350 degrees, weighs 4.85kg and is just over 1metre tall. You can place it on desktops, bedside tables and side tables, depending on where you need it most. THE BEST DYSON DUPES Dyson is, arguably, one of the most recognised brands selling fans on the market, but you can save money buying a dupe version. We haven't tested the dupes below - they are just suggestions we've made based on our own research. B&Q is selling a 32inch Pro Breeze bladeless tower fan which purifies the air and comes with nine speed settings for just £109.99. That makes it around £338 cheaper than the Dyson cool purifying fan we've listed above. The Pro Breeze model is slightly smaller, coming in 0.8metres tall, but still has plenty of five star reviews on the Argos website. One customer said the "Dyson looking fan" was super quiet and comes with good power and air purifier settings. Tesco is also selling a Russell Hobbs desk fan that's just £24.99 and £224 cheaper than the Dyson desktop model in John Lewis listed above. The Russell Hobbs fan is smaller than the Dyson one, at 0.3metres tall, but does come with a one-year guarantee. Lastly, Screwfix is selling a Blyss three-in-one bladeless fan which heats, cools and purifies the air, for £137. That's £153 cheaper than the Dyson focus fan hot and cold heater we spotted in Argos for £290. How to save money on summer essentials SUNNIER days and warmer weather will leave many of us wanting to kit out gardens and outdoor areas. Sun Savers Editor Lana Clements explains how to get a great deal on summer essentials… It pays to know how to bag big savings on the likes of hot tubs paddling pools, egg chairs and outside bars. Many retailers have flash sales across entire ranges – often this ties into payday at the end of the month or Bank Holiday weekends. Sign up to the mailing lists of your favourite brands and you'll be first to know of special offers. It can be worth following retailers on social media too. Keep a close eye on the specialbuys at Aldi and middle of Lidl drops which drop a couple of times a week and usually mean great value seasonal items such as beach gear and paddling pools. If you are not in a hurry to buy an item, try adding it to the shopping cart and leaving it for a couple of days. Sometimes big brands will try to tempt you into the sale by offering you a discount. Always check if you can get cashback before paying. It's especially worth using sites such as Topcashback, Quidco and app Jamdoughnut when buying bigger ticket items such as garden furniture as you'll get a nice kickback. .
The Guardian
44 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Starmer says he lost grip on Labour welfare revolt due to focus on foreign affairs
Keir Starmer has said he did not get a grip on the Labour rebellion over disability benefits earlier because he was focused on foreign affairs. The prime minister acknowledged he had not got it right, and said he would have wanted to make the concessions earlier. 'I'd have liked to get to a better position with colleagues sooner than we did,' Starmer said in an interview with the Sunday Times. 'I'm putting this as context rather than an excuse. 'I was heavily focused on what was happening with Nato and the Middle East all weekend. From the moment I got back from the G7, I went straight into a Cobra meeting. My full attention really bore down on this on Thursday. At that point, we were able to move relatively quickly.' He insisted there had been 'a lot of outreach' over the bill to backbench MPs but acknowledged more should have been done. 'Would I rather have been able to get to a constructive package with colleagues earlier? Yeah, I would. [But] I believe in the world we live in, not the world we want to live in,' he said. It is Starmer's third admission of having taken the wrong course in recent days, indicating he may be moving to try to reset his premiership. He gave an interview to the Observer saying he 'deeply regrets' having used the phrase 'island of strangers' about immigration and that he made the wrong choice in having originally appointed former civil servant Sue Gray to be his shortlived chief of staff. Starmer will be attempting this week to draw a line under the welfare rebellion, with whips working to persuade Labour MPs to back the bill with new concessions on Tuesday. Liz Kendall, the work and pensions secretary, offered the changes at midnight last Thursday, which would protect all existing claimants of personal independence payment (Pip) and raise the health element of universal credit in line with inflation. However, dozens of Labour MPs remain unconvinced, with No 10 facing a battle over the next 48 hours to minimise the size of the revolt. Wes Streeting, the health secretary, said he is confident the government will win the vote on Tuesday, telling Sky News's Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips that the changes 'have put us in a much better position'. 'As a result of the changes, it means anyone watching this morning who's in receipt of personal independence payments now has the peace of mind of knowing that their situation is protected,' he said. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion One of the original leading rebels, Louise Haigh, a former transport secretary, said she would now vote in favour, as long as the details confirmed the changes promised by Kendall. But she said Starmer should now reset the government's relationship with the public and backbenchers. She told the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme it was welcome that Starmer has 'acknowledged that mistakes have been made and that things need to change'. 'I think this is a moment and an opportunity to reset the government's relationship with the British public and to move forward, to adopt a different approach to our economic policy and our political strategy,' she said. 'And I think that has been accepted from within government and a lot of people, both in the parliamentary Labour party, but crucially, the country will really welcome that.'
Auto Express
an hour ago
- Auto Express
Electric car appeal is at its lowest since 2019
It's been a manic few weeks. And here's the proof: my A-Z of the final days of the first half of 2025… on planet car. Antonio Filosa wins the bravest in the business gong for taking on the CEO role at Stellantis. Good luck, Ant. You'll need it. BYD founder Wang Chuanfu is more relaxed as he plays with his Yangwang and Fangchengbao brands. China's Government warns car makers not to brutally undercut each other – I think they should. De Meo's decision to quit as Renault CEO is a tragedy. The industry can't afford to lose Luca – its best and most respected chief executive. Electric car appeal is at its lowest since 2019 – at least in the US. Ferrari delays plans for a second EV thanks to lack of demand. Goodwood has an unlikely new lap record holder – an eight-year-old pedal car driver. HS2 is an 'appalling mess, a litany of failure,' says the Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander. Ideas for the Dragons' Den for Motorists stage at August's British Motor Show are being sought. Perhaps you have one? Jaguar remains disabled at the halfway point of the year. I've never known the firm to be saying, producing and selling less. It desperately needs its new plan to work. Kia's EV9 GT is marred by its greedy £82,000 price tag. Leaf EV from Nissan (starting at £30k-£35k) shows appropriate pricing is possible. Advertisement - Article continues below Skip advert Advertisement - Article continues below Musk's response to accusations of taking ketamine? A drugs test – which showed negative results, the Tesla boss says. Norris of McLaren crashed his F1 car then did what public figures rarely, if ever, do: admit guilt before apologising. Lando's honesty is refreshing. OneHealth is Renault's new wellbeing scheme to give global employees access to physical and mental healthcare and should therefore be applauded. Power outages adversely affected me and many others last week – just as France's energy industry was signed up to keep the lights on and the EVs recharged in Britain this winter. Yikes! Is Qoros the latest Chinese car brand bound for Britain? Maybe. Renault 4 the best car buy of the year so far? I think so. Suzuki's e Vitara: from £29,999, including free finance, home charger and a 10-year warranty. Tunnelling at Kent's Lower Thames Crossing will cost £9 billion, says the Government – which pays just £590 million towards it. Eh? UN warning: autonomous cars could be a terrorist threat. VW's Polo wins the official Best Car of the Half Century ('75-'25) prompting a special edition. WOMAC's cancer charity run by motor industry women staged its annual fundraiser (I was honoured to attend) – but the wealthy car business should do more voluntary work like this. X (as in Aygo X) emerges as Europe's 'cleanest' non plug-in car. Yuki Tsunoda wins my vote as worst-dressed driver at the F1 The Movie world premiere. Zero per cent finance deals are the new norm. At least that's what you must tell the hard-nosed sales execs you're negotiating with in the showroom! Find a car with the experts New Volvo EX60 electric SUV: latest details and confirmed reveal date New Volvo EX60 electric SUV: latest details and confirmed reveal date The upcoming, all-electric Volvo XC60 alternative is designed to 'keep learning and evolve with time' New Skoda Epiq vRS to headline brand's hot-SUV onslaught New Skoda Epiq vRS to headline brand's hot-SUV onslaught Every future Skoda will get the go-faster treatment, with the brand also working on making cars sharper and more engaging Nissan Qashqai e-Power hybrid gets more efficient, powerful and eco-friendly for 2025 Nissan Qashqai e-Power hybrid gets more efficient, powerful and eco-friendly for 2025 The mid-size family SUV segment has just got a whole load tougher thanks to Nissan
