Huawei probe blunder sparks EU parliament rules change
It soon turned out she had nothing to do with it -- in a mix-up that has undermined confidence in the probe and pushed the European Parliament to review its rules to better shield lawmakers from unfounded accusations.
"To this day I cannot understand how they could have made such a blatant mistake," Princi told AFP of Belgian prosecutors.
The Brussels prosecutor office did not reply to a request for comment.
Princi, 52, a member of late Italian prime minister Silvio Berlusconi's Forza Italia party, was targeted by a request to lift her parliamentary immunity in mid-May, along with four other lawmakers.
Prosecutors alleged she attended a Brussels dinner with Huawei representatives seeking to curry favour among parliamentarians in June last year.
But on the day in question the Italian politician was yet to be formally appointed to the 27-nation bloc's assembly following European elections that month. She secured a seat only after another lawmaker renounced his.
Also, she was not in Belgium but in her native southern Calabria region, attending her daughter's Alice-in-Wonderland-themed end-of-year school play.
- No more 'tarnishing' -
Describing herself as "stubborn and pig-headed", Princi lawyered up, compiled an "almost 100-page long" dossier including geo-tagged photos of her daughter in a princess dress, and sent it to prosecutors.
Yet, her bid to get exonerated before things became public failed.
On May 21 EU parliament president Roberta Metsola named Princi among lawmakers targeted by authorities before a plenary sitting.
That was a step required by parliamentary procedure before the case could be passed to the committee on legal affairs, which is tasked to assess immunity waivers.
But the rules have since been revised, for, in an embarrassing about-face, prosecutors withdrew the request targeting Princi a day after she was publicly named.
"I will not accept the targeting and tarnishing of MEPs without a solid basis," Metsola told a press conference in late June, announcing the changes.
Her office said that going forward parliament will require requests to lift a lawmaker's immunity to include "essential elements" such as a clear description of the facts and the crime the accused is alleged to have committed.
"If the requests do not meet the minimum elements, the requesting authority will be asked to complement it" before any announcement is made, Metsola's office said.
Although brief, Princi said her involvement in the affair caused her a fair amount of stress during a few "days of hell" -- and dirty looks from colleagues.
- 'Question marks' -
The fiasco has fuelled a debate on whether Belgian authorities are best placed to investigate EU corruption.
Daniel Freund, a transparency campaigner turned lawmaker for Europe's Greens, is among those who would like the European Public Prosecutor's Office, which already probes the misuse of EU funds, to be tasked with such cases.
"I guess the Belgian taxpayer doesn't have a particular interest to dedicate a lot of resources to making sure that EU institutions are clean. But since EU institutions are located in Belgium, it somehow falls into their remit," he told AFP.
An earlier scandal over alleged bribery involving Qatar and Morocco, which erupted in 2022 when police raids in Brussels uncovered 1.5 million euros in cash at the homes of several lawmakers, is still weighed down in legal challenges with no trial in sight.
Were that to collapse, it "would seriously put into question the role of the Belgian judiciary," Freund said, adding "some question marks" also hung over the Huawei probe.
The Huawei scandal burst into the public in March when police staged raids in Belgium and Portugal.
Investigators suspect Huawei lobbyists of offering gifts, including meals and invitations to football matches to lawmakers who would defend its interests in Brussels.
Eight people have been charged on counts including corruption, money laundering and participating in a criminal organisation.
The four EU lawmakers named besides Princi have denied any wrongdoing.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
6 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
The Chinese political bribery scandal that's rattling Europe
While prosecutors in Brussels did not name those charged, media reports have identified some members of parliament – known as MEPs – and their staff. The payments reported, however, appeared relatively modest. One report said more than €45,000 ($81,000) was transferred to a lobbyist and this was used to pay €6,700 to a member of parliament and about €16,000 to aides. Transparency International EU director Nick Aiossa said the charges demonstrated the lack of action in the parliament to stop corruption. 'The allegations that have been reported upon certainly point to a potential complex corruption scheme involving MEPs, their staff, Huawei and other legal entities,' he told this masthead. In a setback for prosecutors, Italian MEP Giusi Princi went public this month about claims by prosecutors that she attended a dinner with Huawei in Brussels in June last year. She was not an MEP at that time and was in her home region of Calabria on the date of the dinner, attending an event with her daughter. Loading 'To this day I cannot understand how they could have made such a blatant mistake,' Princi told Agence France-Presse. That mistake raised questions about whether Belgian prosecutors had their facts right – or whether the case should be investigated instead by stronger EU authorities. Huawei has insisted in statements over several months that it had a 'zero-tolerance policy toward corruption or other wrongdoing' and was complying with the law. Several of the politicians who put their names to the 2021 letter have told the media they received no payments from the company. Xi Jinping will host von der Leyen in Beijing on Thursday to mark 50 years of diplomatic recognition – the EU's predecessor recognised mainland China in 1975, 2½ years after Australia did the same – but against the backdrop of rising tensions. Von der Leyen has warned against China using its vast production capacity to flood markets and ruin competitors, and says it denies fair access to its market for EU companies. 'China is running the largest trade surplus in the history of humankind. Its trade surplus with our Union has surpassed €300 billion last year. And this is while it is getting harder and harder for European companies to do business in China,' she told legislators on July 9. The major dispute between the two sides, however, is Ukraine, because of China's economic support for Russia and the supply of Chinese technologies that find their way into Russian weapons. 'China's unyielding support for Russia is creating heightened instability and insecurity here in Europe,' von der Leyen said. 'We can say that China is de facto enabling Russia's war economy. We cannot accept this.' The lobbying concerns in Brussels are not only about Chinese influence but the broader question of ethics in parliament after an earlier uproar over payments from Qatar. Dubbed Qatargate and seen as the biggest scandal of its kind in decades, the affair began with allegations the Gulf state paid members of parliament to curry favour in Brussels. While some MEPs have been charged, the case has not been decided in court. Corporate Europe Observatory, a non-profit campaign group, has named Huawei as one of the top tech lobbyists in Brussels, with a budget of more than €2 million and 11 full-time lobbyists, according to its own declarations. 'We already have a transparency register at the EU level that repressive regime lobbyists easily bypass because it is weak, voluntary, and poorly enforced,' it said, naming China, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. Aiossa, from Transparency International, said the European Union had made some progress on transparency, for instance by disclosing meetings between lobbyists and politicians, but was failing on ethics. Loading 'The Huawei case is crucially important because it demonstrates that the European Parliament needs to have much stronger and robust integrity and anti-corruption frameworks in place to prevent these scandals,' he said. 'There was a moment in the wake of Qatargate when they could have been brave and brought forward ambitious reforms. They didn't do it, which has led to the current Huawei scandal.'
The Age
6 hours ago
- The Age
The Chinese political bribery scandal that's rattling Europe
While prosecutors in Brussels did not name those charged, media reports have identified some members of parliament – known as MEPs – and their staff. The payments reported, however, appeared relatively modest. One report said more than €45,000 ($81,000) was transferred to a lobbyist and this was used to pay €6,700 to a member of parliament and about €16,000 to aides. Transparency International EU director Nick Aiossa said the charges demonstrated the lack of action in the parliament to stop corruption. 'The allegations that have been reported upon certainly point to a potential complex corruption scheme involving MEPs, their staff, Huawei and other legal entities,' he told this masthead. In a setback for prosecutors, Italian MEP Giusi Princi went public this month about claims by prosecutors that she attended a dinner with Huawei in Brussels in June last year. She was not an MEP at that time and was in her home region of Calabria on the date of the dinner, attending an event with her daughter. Loading 'To this day I cannot understand how they could have made such a blatant mistake,' Princi told Agence France-Presse. That mistake raised questions about whether Belgian prosecutors had their facts right – or whether the case should be investigated instead by stronger EU authorities. Huawei has insisted in statements over several months that it had a 'zero-tolerance policy toward corruption or other wrongdoing' and was complying with the law. Several of the politicians who put their names to the 2021 letter have told the media they received no payments from the company. Xi Jinping will host von der Leyen in Beijing on Thursday to mark 50 years of diplomatic recognition – the EU's predecessor recognised mainland China in 1975, 2½ years after Australia did the same – but against the backdrop of rising tensions. Von der Leyen has warned against China using its vast production capacity to flood markets and ruin competitors, and says it denies fair access to its market for EU companies. 'China is running the largest trade surplus in the history of humankind. Its trade surplus with our Union has surpassed €300 billion last year. And this is while it is getting harder and harder for European companies to do business in China,' she told legislators on July 9. The major dispute between the two sides, however, is Ukraine, because of China's economic support for Russia and the supply of Chinese technologies that find their way into Russian weapons. 'China's unyielding support for Russia is creating heightened instability and insecurity here in Europe,' von der Leyen said. 'We can say that China is de facto enabling Russia's war economy. We cannot accept this.' The lobbying concerns in Brussels are not only about Chinese influence but the broader question of ethics in parliament after an earlier uproar over payments from Qatar. Dubbed Qatargate and seen as the biggest scandal of its kind in decades, the affair began with allegations the Gulf state paid members of parliament to curry favour in Brussels. While some MEPs have been charged, the case has not been decided in court. Corporate Europe Observatory, a non-profit campaign group, has named Huawei as one of the top tech lobbyists in Brussels, with a budget of more than €2 million and 11 full-time lobbyists, according to its own declarations. 'We already have a transparency register at the EU level that repressive regime lobbyists easily bypass because it is weak, voluntary, and poorly enforced,' it said, naming China, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. Aiossa, from Transparency International, said the European Union had made some progress on transparency, for instance by disclosing meetings between lobbyists and politicians, but was failing on ethics. Loading 'The Huawei case is crucially important because it demonstrates that the European Parliament needs to have much stronger and robust integrity and anti-corruption frameworks in place to prevent these scandals,' he said. 'There was a moment in the wake of Qatargate when they could have been brave and brought forward ambitious reforms. They didn't do it, which has led to the current Huawei scandal.'
The Advertiser
2 days ago
- The Advertiser
Ex-Aust PM Morrison to testify before US House on China
Former Australian prime minister Scott Morrison will testify at a US House panel hearing about countering China's "economic coercion against democracies," the committee says. Former US ambassador to Japan Rahm Emanuel will also testify on Wednesday before the House Select Committee on China. Relations with China, already rocky after Australia banned Huawei from its 5G broadband network in 2018, cooled further after Canberra called for an independent investigation into the origins of COVID-19. China responded by imposing tariffs on Australian commodities, including wine and barley and limited imports of Australian beef, coal and grapes, moves described by the United States as "economic coercion." Morrison was defeated in a bid for re-election in 2022. Reuters reported this week Canberra is close to an agreement with Beijing that would allow Australian suppliers to ship five trial canola cargoes to China, sources familiar with the matter said, a move towards ending a years-long freeze in the trade. China imposed 100 per cent tariffs on Canadian canola meal and oil this year amid strained diplomatic ties. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited China this week, underscoring a warming of ties Emanuel, who told a Chicago news outlet in June he is considering a run for president in 2028. Emanuel as been a harsh critic of China, saying in 2024 Beijing constantly uses coercion and pressures other countries, including Japan and the Philippines. "Economic coercion by China is their most persistent and pernicious tool in their toolbox," Emanuel said in a separate speech in 2023. The Chinese Embassy in Washington did not immediately comment. Former Australian prime minister Scott Morrison will testify at a US House panel hearing about countering China's "economic coercion against democracies," the committee says. Former US ambassador to Japan Rahm Emanuel will also testify on Wednesday before the House Select Committee on China. Relations with China, already rocky after Australia banned Huawei from its 5G broadband network in 2018, cooled further after Canberra called for an independent investigation into the origins of COVID-19. China responded by imposing tariffs on Australian commodities, including wine and barley and limited imports of Australian beef, coal and grapes, moves described by the United States as "economic coercion." Morrison was defeated in a bid for re-election in 2022. Reuters reported this week Canberra is close to an agreement with Beijing that would allow Australian suppliers to ship five trial canola cargoes to China, sources familiar with the matter said, a move towards ending a years-long freeze in the trade. China imposed 100 per cent tariffs on Canadian canola meal and oil this year amid strained diplomatic ties. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited China this week, underscoring a warming of ties Emanuel, who told a Chicago news outlet in June he is considering a run for president in 2028. Emanuel as been a harsh critic of China, saying in 2024 Beijing constantly uses coercion and pressures other countries, including Japan and the Philippines. "Economic coercion by China is their most persistent and pernicious tool in their toolbox," Emanuel said in a separate speech in 2023. The Chinese Embassy in Washington did not immediately comment. Former Australian prime minister Scott Morrison will testify at a US House panel hearing about countering China's "economic coercion against democracies," the committee says. Former US ambassador to Japan Rahm Emanuel will also testify on Wednesday before the House Select Committee on China. Relations with China, already rocky after Australia banned Huawei from its 5G broadband network in 2018, cooled further after Canberra called for an independent investigation into the origins of COVID-19. China responded by imposing tariffs on Australian commodities, including wine and barley and limited imports of Australian beef, coal and grapes, moves described by the United States as "economic coercion." Morrison was defeated in a bid for re-election in 2022. Reuters reported this week Canberra is close to an agreement with Beijing that would allow Australian suppliers to ship five trial canola cargoes to China, sources familiar with the matter said, a move towards ending a years-long freeze in the trade. China imposed 100 per cent tariffs on Canadian canola meal and oil this year amid strained diplomatic ties. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited China this week, underscoring a warming of ties Emanuel, who told a Chicago news outlet in June he is considering a run for president in 2028. Emanuel as been a harsh critic of China, saying in 2024 Beijing constantly uses coercion and pressures other countries, including Japan and the Philippines. "Economic coercion by China is their most persistent and pernicious tool in their toolbox," Emanuel said in a separate speech in 2023. The Chinese Embassy in Washington did not immediately comment. Former Australian prime minister Scott Morrison will testify at a US House panel hearing about countering China's "economic coercion against democracies," the committee says. Former US ambassador to Japan Rahm Emanuel will also testify on Wednesday before the House Select Committee on China. Relations with China, already rocky after Australia banned Huawei from its 5G broadband network in 2018, cooled further after Canberra called for an independent investigation into the origins of COVID-19. China responded by imposing tariffs on Australian commodities, including wine and barley and limited imports of Australian beef, coal and grapes, moves described by the United States as "economic coercion." Morrison was defeated in a bid for re-election in 2022. Reuters reported this week Canberra is close to an agreement with Beijing that would allow Australian suppliers to ship five trial canola cargoes to China, sources familiar with the matter said, a move towards ending a years-long freeze in the trade. China imposed 100 per cent tariffs on Canadian canola meal and oil this year amid strained diplomatic ties. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited China this week, underscoring a warming of ties Emanuel, who told a Chicago news outlet in June he is considering a run for president in 2028. Emanuel as been a harsh critic of China, saying in 2024 Beijing constantly uses coercion and pressures other countries, including Japan and the Philippines. "Economic coercion by China is their most persistent and pernicious tool in their toolbox," Emanuel said in a separate speech in 2023. The Chinese Embassy in Washington did not immediately comment.
