IND vs ENG 2025: 'Bits-and-pieces cricketers won't win you Tests' - Navjot Singh Sidhu questions Shardul Thakur's selection for 4th Test
NEW DELHI: Former India cricketer
Navjot Singh Sidhu
has questioned the Indian team management's decision to field
Shardul Thakur
in the playing XI for the fourth Test against England at Old Trafford, taking a sharp dig at the 'bits-and-pieces' approach in Test cricket.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel.
SUBSCRIBE NOW!
Following Nitish Kumar Reddy's injury, India roped in Thakur, but Sidhu remained unconvinced. Speaking on his YouTube channel, the former opener said: 'Even if Shardul makes a fifty, at that number eight position, bits-and-pieces cricketers do well in one-day cricket, but in Test cricket, you always need specialists. If you could bring Shardul the bowler at number eight, then I would agree this is the right selection.
'
Rishabh Pant injury update: Will he come out to bat on Day 2? More on his swelling, fitness status
Sidhu argued that India has been using Thakur more for batting depth than for bowling impact.
'You do not bowl him enough and then in order to increase the batting you compromise with your bowling. Bits-and-pieces cricketers, I don't think will ever win you games abroad,' he said.
Poll
What do you think is more important in Test cricket?
Specialist bowlers
All-rounders
Batting depth
He added that even someone of
Ravindra Jadeja
's quality had struggled to take wickets in the earlier Tests despite favourable conditions.
'Even Jadeja could not pick wickets in the first two Tests with the rough.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Play this game for 3 minutes, if you own a mouse
planetcapture.io
Undo
Batting, fielding, as an all-rounder, par excellence,' he said, praising Jadeja's overall value but stressing the need for wicket-taking bowlers.
Sidhu doubled down on his criticism by questioning the purpose of having a batting all-rounder at No. 8.
'If seven can't do it, eight also won't. I have been repeating this point time and again. I feel this is again a compromise, and I feel it will not go in favour of India,' he asserted.
'He was in a lot of pain': Sai Sudharsan admits Rishabh Pant's absence could hurt India
Reflecting on Day 1, where India ended strongly at 264/4, Sidhu admitted India dominated.
'The first day will go in India's name. They have dominated 70 percent of the series but are still 2-1 down. This is the lack of experience — and you won't find experience in a mall or market,' he remarked.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
24 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
India wins 2 gold, 5 silver and 5 bronze at FISU World University Games
India concluded their campaign at the FISU World University Games with a total of 12 medals, including two bronze medals and a silver medal by Ankita Dhyani in women's 3,000 m steeplechase on the final day of the competition on Sunday. Fireworks during the opening ceremony of the Rhine-Ruhr 2025 FISU World University Games in Duisburg, western Germany, on July 16, 2025. India finished the campaign with 12 medals(AFP) Also read: Education ministry seeks explanation from JNU VC for skipping key conference without approval The three medals on the final day took the Indian tally to two gold, five silver and five bronze medals, a total of 12 medals. The bronze medals were secured by the men's 4x100m relay and women's race walk teams on Sunday, as per Ankita, who took part in the 5,000 m event in the 2024 Paris Olympics, took the steeplechase late last year and, in April, clocked her previous best timings of 9:39.00 in Iowa Ilona Mononen of Finland bagged the gold after finishing in 9:31.86, and Germany's Adia Budde bagged bronze with a time of 9:33.34. Also read: DU UG Admission 2025: CSAS 2nd allotment list today at 5 pm on India kick-started the final day of the competition with a bronze medal in the women's 20 km race walk event as the trio of Sejal Singh, Munita Prajapati, and Mansi Negi secured a combined timing of 4:56:06 hours. Sejal was the fastest amongst all Indian walkers, finishing 15th individually with a 1:35:21 hour timing, while Munita Prajapati (1:39:33) finished in 18th spot, and Mansi Negi (1:41:12) finished 20th. China walked away with the gold medal in the event with a time of 4:28:51 hours, and Australia finished second with a time of 4:31:20 hours in the women's 20km race walk event. Coming to the men's 4x100m relay, the quartet of Lalu Prasad Bhoi, Animesh Kujur, Manikanta Hoblidhar and Dondapati Mrutyum Jayaram took home the bronze medal with a timing of 38.89, while South Korea took home the gold with 38.50 and South Africa got the silver with 38.80. India secured a total of five athletics medals at the competition, with Praveen Chitravel and Seema getting the silver medals in men's triple jump and the women's 5000m race, respectively, on Saturday. India also had a fine medal count in compound archery, as Sahil Rajesh Jadhav and Parneet Kaur walked away with gold and silver medals in the men's and women's compound events. India also landed a gold medal in the mixed team event, and the men's team got a silver. The women's team bronze was another highlight in the compound category. Also read: NIRF Rankings 2024: How are India's best universities ranked? Here's everything you need to know India's medal tally opened with its second-ever badminton medal at the event, a historic bronze medal in the mixed team event. In tennis as well, India secured their first-ever medal, with Vaishnavi Adkar claiming a singles bronze. The first-ever tennis medal was won by Nandan Bal in 1979 in Mexico, a silver. India's best-ever performance in the World University Games came back in 2023 at Chengdu, finishing seventh with 26 medals, including 11 gold medals.
NDTV
26 minutes ago
- NDTV
Gautam Gambhir Tears Into Stokes On Handshake Row, Says "If Someone's Batting On 90..."
Indian cricket team head coach Gautam Gambhir gave his blunt verdict on the 'handshake' controversy on Day 5 of the fourth Test match between India and England at Old Trafford on Sunday. England skipper Ben Stokes offered to end the match in a draw with 15 overs left on Day 5. However, Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar were close to their centuries and India decided to not accept the 'handshake' at that moment. Stokes was not happy but play continued and both Jadeja as well as Sundar was able to slam centuries. Gambhir completely supported the decision to not take the draw at the point and questioned whether England would have left the field if their players were on verge of hundreds. 'If someone's batting on 90 and another on 85, don't they deserve their centuries? Would England have walked off if their own players were close to milestones? No. Our boys weathered the storm. They earned those tons. We're not here to please anyone,' Gambhir said at the post-match press conference. Meanwhile, Gill lauded the batting effort of his side after salvaging a draw in the fourth Test against England and backed the decision to not accept Ben Stokes' offer to end the game early, saying Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar deserved to complete their centuries. India, who started their second innings 311 runs behind, produced a spirited batting display to finish on 425 for four in 143 overs, with Gill (103), KL Rahul (90), Jadeja (107 not out) and Washington (101 not out) leading the resistance. There was a brief moment of drama in the final hour when England skipper Stokes proposed ending the contest early, with both Indian batters approaching individual milestones. But the offer was turned down, allowing Jadeja and Washington to reach their hundreds. 'Definitely it was up to the boys, but we thought they batted brilliantly. Both of them were in their 90s, so we thought they deserved a century,' Gill said at the post-match presentation. India were reduced to 0 for two early in their second innings after openers Yashasvi Jaiswal and Sai Sudharsan fell without scoring, but the middle-order stood firm under pressure. "With our batting effort, the past couple of days I think we were put under a lot of pressure. But I think the way we responded, especially after losing those two early wickets, never easy but a very brave effort," Gill said. "It's all about taking the wicket out of the equation. Day five wicket, the ball is doing, something is happening, every ball is kind of an event. So you just want to play ball by ball and want to take the game as deep as possible."
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
IND vs ENG: Ben Stokes matches Andrew Flintoff with rare bat-ball double in Test series
Ben Stokes (Getty Images) NEW DELHI: Ben Stokes etched his name into the history books during the fourth Test against India at Old Trafford, becoming the first England captain to score over 300 runs and take more than 15 wickets in a single Test series. In a remarkable all-round performance in Manchester, Stokes hammered a 198-ball 141—his first century in two years—and claimed six wickets across both innings, including a five-wicket haul in the first. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! So far in the series, Stokes has amassed 304 runs in seven innings at an average of 43.42, with one century. With the ball, he has been just as lethal, claiming 17 wickets at 25.23—making him the leading wicket-taker in the series. His best figures stand at 5/72, along with another four-wicket haul. Only once in the last 40 years has an England player managed such a feat: Andrew Flintoff during the iconic 2005 Ashes series. Flintoff scored 402 runs at 40.20, including a century and three fifties, and picked up 24 wickets at 27.29. Stokes also equalled Ian Botham's tally of 12 'Player of the Match' awards for England—just one behind Joe Root's 13, the most by any English player. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Cengkareng: Unsold Sofas Prices May Surprise You (Prices May Surprise You) Sofas | Search Ads Search Now Undo Ben Stokes press conference: On handshake controversy, India fightback, his own fitness After being put in to bat, India posted 358 in their first innings, with solid contributions from Yashasvi Jaiswal (58), Sai Sudharsan (61), and Rishabh Pant (54). England's bowlers, led by Stokes (5/72) and Jofra Archer (3/73), kept breakthroughs coming, preventing any big partnerships from forming. Poll How do you rate Ben Stokes' all-round performance in the series so far? Excellent Good Average Below expectations In reply, England unleashed a batting onslaught. Openers Zak Crawley (84) and Ben Duckett (94) stitched a 166-run partnership, followed by dominant knocks from Joe Root (150) and Stokes himself (141). Their combined effort propelled England to a massive 669-run total, giving them a 311-run first-innings lead. Ravindra Jadeja was the pick of India's bowlers with 4/143, while Jasprit Bumrah struggled, returning 2/112. India's second innings began in trouble, with Chris Woakes removing both openers for ducks. But KL Rahul (90) and captain Shubman Gill (103) responded with grit, adding a crucial 188-run partnership across three sessions. The finishing touches came from Ravindra Jadeja (107*) and Washington Sundar (101*), who combined for a 203-run stand for the fifth wicket. The duo frustrated England with their composure and defiance, batting India to safety and finishing at 425/4. The draw means England maintain a 2-1 lead in the five-match series, with the final Test scheduled to begin at The Oval on July 31. For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
