Fate of Franz Josef southbank not ours to decide, regional council says
Photo:
Lois Williams / LDR
The long-term fate of Franz Josef farms, homes and businesses on the south bank of the Waiho (Waiau) River lies with the Westland District Council.
That was the message to regional councillors this week as they prepare to celebrate the completion of the north bank floodwalls protecting the West Coast tourist town of Franz Josef.
Regional Development Minister Shane Jones will officially open the
multi-million dollar project
, funded 60 percent by the government, on Friday morning.
The West Coast Regional Council is about to embark on Stage 2 of the project, building stopbanks on the south side of the wild, glacier-fed river.
The monthly planning report to the Resource Management Committee noted the Regional Council was making a submission on Franz Josef to the Westland District Council's long- term plan.
Regional councillor Allan Birchfield asked what was in it.
Planning manager Jo Field responded, saying the Regional Council wanted to see Westland committing resources and budget for a master plan for the future management of the south side.
"We felt there wasn't enough (in the long-term plan) given the dangers down there from the Waiho River. Once we've built the (southside) floodwall it's only supposed to have a ten-year life so they need to do some planning around what to do for the future."
The vast bed of the Waiho from stopbank, looking west.
Photo:
Lois Williams / LDR
Birchfield asked if the West Coast Regional Council (WCRC) was "still pushing" for the south side to be abandoned.
"We are pushing for them to do the master planning around that," Field said.
Birchfield asked: "That's what you want though? For everyone to be moved out?"
WCRC chair Peter Haddock said that was not the council's position.
"The council's position is to maintain the floodwalls - it's up to the WDC (Westland District Council) to do any master planning around that. Our role is to provide flood banks as necessary."
Birchfield said the plan to abandon the south side was in the WCRC's own long-term plan.
Haddock said that was the recommendation made by the council's Technical Advisory Group, not by the council itself.
Diggers at work on the stopbank protecting the town, last winter.
Photo:
Lois Williams / LDR
Regional Council chief executive Darryl Lew said despite the completed north side stop banks, and the imminent start of work on the south side, the threat from the river remained.
"The fact of the matter is that the Waiho River is continuing to aggrade in the reach below the bridge at a metre plus a year and every year that goes by diminishes the protection of those banks, to point where it's going to pose a risk despite the work you've done."
The council could not continue to raise the banks ad infinitum because already the bed of that river was well above the town, Lew said.
"We have to give the river some room for all of that sediment that's coming out of the Callery River and out of the main steam below the glacier, to move through the system."
Birchfield said the easiest way to do that would be to "knock a hole" through the geological feature known as the Waiho Loop.
But Lew said that had been dismissed as unfeasible by the Technical Advisory Group.
The Waiho River bed is getting higher by the year, as rock and gravel wash down from the retreating glacier.
Photo:
Lois Williams / LDR
Peter Ewen said Westland mayor Helen Lash had made it clear that her council wanted to take the lead on planning for Franz Josef's future and the ball was in her court.
Haddock confirmed that the WCRC's role was only to build walls on behalf of the Franz Josef rating district, and its committee decided what work would be done.
Westland councillor Andy Campbell said the biggest problem was that there was no money to buy out the southside property owners, resulting in a stalemate.
"So, just wash them out to sea without any compensation?" Birchfield asked.
Haddock said the WCRC had lobbied the government about a south side buyout and it was clear there was no money for it.
"So we'll just have to wait and see what happens but in the interim there is a plan to protect and hold the line."
- LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Le Posh: French bakers Veronica and Didier Crevecoeur vanish leaving unpaid bills
By Tracy Neal, Open Justice reporter of Veronica and Didier Crevecoeur set up bakeries in Marlborough and Nelson by the same name, Le Posh, but left landlords in debt over unpaid rent. Photo: NZME / Tracy Neal A couple who arrived in New Zealand and set up a French patisserie cut a swath of deceit before leaving the country suddenly. Tracy Neal explores the legacy left by French bakers Veronica and Didier Crevecoeur, whose victims are reeling in their wake. The crepes, gateaux, croissants and eclairs were once the talk of the town. But the couple behind the sweet French fare turned out to be a recipe for disaster for some landlords and businesses in the top of the South Island. They've been left shouldering debts left by Veronica and Didier Crevecoeur who, as it turned out, had a habit of not delivering on promises to pay their bills. They arrived in New Zealand around 2018 and were believed to have left this year, about the same time legal action against them was triggered over debt on a commercial lease. Inquiries by NZME since the court case in June have lifted the lid on a couple who some knew as "friendly", even "quiet and nice", and who brought a little taste of France to Picton, Blenheim and Nelson. "We could have been in Paris," said one neighbour of Le Posh patisserie in Nelson, who loved the aroma of pain au chocolat fresh from the oven, and coffee from a nearby roastery wafting through his house. But some landlords in the top of the South Island had a different view of the Crevecoeurs. One commercial property owner in Blenheim claimed they were "the worst tenants" he had ever known. "I'm 75 years old now and I've been in business since I was 19, and I've never struck anyone like them." The North Island-based businessman and director of an estate management firm says he was forced to evict the pair. "In the end I didn't give a s**t about the unpaid rent, I was just pleased to see the back end of them," he said. The owner of commercial premises in Picton where the Crevecouers launched the first of what would be four patisseries named Le Posh, said that despite the "wildly expensive" but "quite good" food they had on offer, they often had an excuse about why they couldn't pay rent, leases, or invoices on time, if at all. She ended up locking them out, and waved goodbye to around $3000 in unpaid rent, angry they had not only ripped her off, but allegedly done it to others as well. Then there was the owner of a home the Crevecoeurs once rented in Nelson, who says they struggled to get rent paid on time. "There was always a story about where money was coming from." Another Nelson business left out of pocket for vehicle maintenance and repair work said at first the couple paid, accompanied with free baguettes, but that soon changed and the debt grew. An Auckland property investment firm owed thousands for unpaid rent on commercial premises in Nelson claimed the couple were masters of deceit. "We are not novices at this, and we were taken in," a director of the company said. The Crevecoeurs also left a Marlborough homeowner $1000 out of pocket in rent owed on a beachfront home in Rārangi. A decision by the Tenancy Tribunal in December 2019 showed the landlord had applied for termination of the tenancy, rent arrears and refund of the bond. The Crevecoeurs were ordered to pay $1020 in rent arrears, but the Herald has been unable to determine if that money was ever paid. According to NZ Company Office records, the couple registered a company named Gazillions Limited, in July 2020 but it was removed a little under two years later. The company was classified as "internet only retailing" with a registered office in Blenheim. The couple moved to Nelson around 2021 and set up a patisserie by the same name. Le Posh, on the corner of Russell St and Haven Rd near Port Nelson, opened to media fanfare in January 2022. The Crevecoeurs told Stuff at the time they had "moved from Blenheim when the opportunity arose". They had planned to return to Australia to be closer to their children, but efforts were "stymied by the pandemic". They said Nelson was a "better fit" for their European flavours and fare. "They appreciate us being here. More people are happy to have a French patisserie," Veronica Crevecoeur said at the time. They then opened another Le Posh in Nelson, in a residential apartment and retail complex near Tāhunanui Beach, but that's where the New Zealand chapter to their story ended. In the Nelson District Court in June, the couple were ordered to pay more than $29,000 in unpaid rent, damages and legal costs. They didn't turn up to court, but the Crevecoeurs' son Alex, who responded to NZME's requests to several family members via social media, said that, sadly, it was likely "the tip of the iceberg". The property investment firm, Tawero Holdings (No2) Ltd, from whom the Crevecoeurs leased the second Nelson premises in November 2022, filed court action when they abandoned the lease. "They said they were going to retire and live half their time here and half overseas," one of the workers at a neighbouring cafe told NZME. According to the statement of claim filed by Tawero with the court, the couple took out a three-year lease on the second shop with an annual rent set of $20,000 (plus GST). They left owing $13,175 in rent and outgoings. Tawero Holdings sought, and was granted, a summary judgment of $22,547 against the Crevecoeurs, plus several thousand more in costs associated with re-letting the premises, plus damages. A summary judgment application allows a court to resolve a case without a full trial when the defendant had no genuine arguable defence. Judge Noel Sainsbury said in making the order the underlying basis was that the defendant had defaulted on the rent on premises leased to them by the plaintiff. "Clearly, the defendants have no defence to the claim," he said. A spokesperson for Tawero, who did not want to be named, told NZME taking legal action was a decision not made lightly but "a lot of deception" had been at play. "We are not novices at this, and we were taken in." He said the climate had been challenging post-Covid for tenants and landlords, but when people took advantage of others and were deceitful, it made it more difficult. "We were let down and lied to. "We just felt that in these circumstances, sometimes you have to take this sort of action to prevent these things from being perpetuated." The judgment granted included rent that hadn't been paid and outgoings, plus a damages claim for the costs associated with the early termination of the lease held by the Crevecoeurs, and the subsequent re-letting of the premises. They were also ordered to pay legal costs and disbursements of $6850 and interest of 12 percent per year on any non-payment. Tawero also sought indemnity costs, on the basis the Crevecoeurs had "promised to pay, but had left", but such costs were not normally granted, Judge Sainsbury said. Veronica and Didier Crevecoeur failed to appear in the Nelson District Court as defendants in a civil case over unpaid rent at business premises in Nelson. Photo: NZME / supplied Inquiries by NZME into the whereabouts of the Crevecoeurs have failed to pinpoint their location. Efforts have been made to reach them via email addresses that appear to still be active, and via their social media accounts. "Commonsense" would suggest where they were, their son Alex told NZME. There were suggestions they were back in Australia, while Judge Sainsbury said in court he believed they were in Europe - possibly in France, where Didier is from. Many who NZME spoke with referred to an online site about the Crevecoeurs. The site, set up by someone on Cloudflare, which offered multiple security layers, said it was intended as a "public service warning" and that all information provided was based on reports from affected individuals. The site claimed the Crevecoeurs were back in Perth with family, and "likely continuing similar schemes", having suddenly left New Zealand earlier this year, leaving debts with "multiple businesses". It speculates they were "probably" looking to relocate to France, near Dieppe, where Didier Crevecoeur is from. The site said Veronica Crevecoeur, 66, grew up in Paris, and that Didier was a chef in various big hotels, and ran restaurants and bakeries in various locations. Few in the tight-knit business communities of Nelson and Marlborough wanted to talk about it, mostly out of embarrassment, but NZME has heard some of the stories Veronica Crevecoeur allegedly cooked up to gain people's sympathy. Others claim they dished out personal loans and haven't seen a cent in return. The woman whose commercial premises the Crevecoeurs leased in Picton soon after they arrived from Australia in about 2018, was initially thrilled. "I was excited when they approached me. Here were people who wanted to start a lovely French cafe." She said the food they made was good, but "grossly expensive". The property owner "turned the key on them" over their failure to pay rent, just before the Covid lockdown in March 2020. "They'd been there about 18 months, and I had to chase them the whole time for rent. Didier always played the 'totally surprised' game, always saying, 'I didn't know'." They left, and took the Le Posh signs, which then popped up in Nelson. "I think they just carted the signage around with them," the Picton property owner said. She believed the Crevecoeurs had operated businesses in Perth and Cairns. Australian business records showed Didier Crevecoeur operated Paris Crepes Cafe in Western Australia from December 2012 until April 2016. Information online showed two businesses by the same name in Western Australia - one in the High Street Mall in Fremantle, and the other in Subiaco. However, the owners of the buildings where the two businesses operated said they had not heard of the Crevecoeurs. The premises on the corner of Nelson's Russell St and Haven Rd, where the initial Nelson Le Posh sprung up, are now up for sale. There's a sad collection of baking tins, tools and furniture stacked up against the window of the worn-looking building. NZ Companies Office records showed the building was owned by Dharmendra Patel, who has so far failed to respond to NZME's requests for comment on whether he was owed rent. Robin Whalley, who had been a regular buyer of the pain au chocolat, was surprised they had gone so suddenly, and even more surprised when he learned why, when NZME called him. "We thought from the notice on the door they must have just gone for the weekend, and that they would be 'back soon', and then it never happened," Whalley said. The Nelson business, left out of pocket for work done on the Crevecoeurs' car, said when the free baguettes dried up and the money due on invoice never arrived, their patience ran out. "I'd go over and be very polite about it, and she'd [Veronica] say, 'I promise you, I promise you, but don't push me,'" the business co-owner and office manager, Tania, claimed. She said the promises continued, that the money would arrive on a certain day. "In the end I said to him [Didier], 'how can you treat people like that'? "And he said, 'It's my wife, it's my wife'!" She said he once came over with a bottle of champagne but they still hadn't been paid. Alex Crevecoeur told NZME he was prepared to stand by his father, whom he painted as a broken man. "My father is only guilty by association as for reasons unknown to me, he let her [his mother] handle all business and financial matters." Tania agreed. She felt that Didier was "a bit caught out by her". "I think he was trying perhaps, but they're both culpable." - This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Waikato-Bay of Plenty's Hugh Jackson named Young Farmer of the Year
Hugh Jackson. Photo: FMG Young Farmer of the Year / supplied Waikato-Bay of Plenty farmer Hugh Jackson says he is over the moon to secure the title of New Zealand's top young farmer. The 26-year-old was crowned the 57th FMG Young Farmer of the Year on Saturday evening after the final event in Invercargill. Seven grand finalists competed in challenges involving heavy machinery and livestock as well as public speaking, quizzes and interviews. During Friday's practical contest at the Winton Racecourse, contestants were put through their paces with tasks such as shearing sheep, building bridges, filleting fish and making hay bales to show off their farming skills. Jackson said it was his second time being a grand finalist, and he said he was relieved to bring the trophy home. "It was a nerve-wracking last couple of hours, so to get that weight off my shoulders is massive. It's been a lot of years in the making," he said. Working on his family's farm in Te Akau, north of Raglan, Jackson said he spent his days working with his "old man". With an interest in technology and a passion for mental health he was also the chair of Hamilton City Young Farmers Club. "With this title, I really hope to help showcase the talent we have coming through and highlight the opportunities that are there for young people," Jackson said. 'Where the industry is moving in terms of technology is exciting, and there is an opportunity where we can really grow people and provide career opportunities within that." New Zealand Young Farmers chief executive Cheyne Gillooly said Jackson impressed everyone with his innovative thinking and talent across the agricultural sector. "FMG Young Farmer of the Year is one of the most prestigious farming awards in the country. It's inspiring to see the recognition go to someone who will not only be a strong ambassador for the next generation of young farmers, but across the agricultural industry," he said. Acting Prime Minister David Seymour extended his congratulations to Jackson. "Last night I was lucky enough to attend the Young Farmer of the Year grand final in Invercargill. It was a brilliant event, celebrating the future of farming and showcasing their expertise, leadership, and passion for agriculture," he said. "Hugh… demonstrated exceptional skill, leadership, and knowledge in one of the most historic competitions in the country. They have a bright future ahead of them, and I wish them all the best for their future in farming. "Even for a townie from Epsom it's impossible to not appreciate the contribution farmers make to New Zealand. We are lucky to live in a country that produces food the world loves, and with export revenue on track to surpass $60 billion for the first time, agriculture is very much central to New Zealand's future prosperity." Canterbury farmer Gareth McKerchar missed out on the title by 68 points in second place, with Tasman farmer George Letham finishing up in third place Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Glitch sends one person's rates bill to up to 1000 Central Hawke's Bay residents
A software problem at Central Hawke's Bay District Council is being investigated. Photo: LDR via Central Hawke's Bay Mail / Ian Cooper A software glitch at Central Hawke's Bay District council sent one person's rates bill to up to 1000 ratepayers. The council's chief executive, Doug Tate, said they were made aware of an issue with the rating system on Friday morning. "When our rate notices were sent out, one person's information from 2024 was sent out to multiple people," Tate said. "We're working to establish the fault. At this point, we understand it to be under 1000 people. "I'd urge anyone who received it to protect the person's privacy, please delete the email. "We take these matters, including protecting people's privacy, really seriously. I will be working with the team at Council to better understand what the fault was." The Council said on its Facebook page there was no need to phone them, "as we're aware and working hard with our software suppliers to understand the issue". "We'll will let you know more soon." Central Hawke's Bay District Council set its 2025/26 rates increase at 7.4 percent. It follows a 20 percent increase last year. The council is working to reduce predicted water rate hikes of $5000 per household over the next decade. At a meeting on Thursday, councillors voted to stay at the table to consider recommendations for the Regional Water Services Council-Controlled Organisation (HBWSCCO), including one on the impact of a 30-year investment strategy. Deliberations were held to consider the community's submissions on three options, a Regional CCO with our Hawke's Bay councils, in-house delivery, and a standalone CCO, and the views heard during the five-week consultation period. "Now's the time we need to sit at the table with Government and our regional partners to ensure the challenges of the district's three waters infrastructure are turned into opportunities for generations to come," Central Hawke's Bay mayor Alex Walker said. From the submissions, it was clear that most residents connected to and paying for water supported the change to the Regional CCO. "It's this group of people who are most impacted," Walker said. "But we also recognise this is a complex issue of ownership, control, Government reach, trust, confidence, as well as affordability. "We've listened to these points, and they helped strengthen our response. Your voices have armed us with the support for clear advocacy in the region and to push back at Government policy, and how to better right-size our investment. "Addressing the challenges of our water infrastructure is one of the most significant - if not the most significant issue for this district. "We have been advocating to the Government, and anyone who will listen, that the system is broken and must change to support districts like ours. "I have called on Local Government Minister Simon Watts, imploring him to consider changes that would benefit smaller rural communities, including Central Hawke's Bay." Council will meet again on 24 July. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
