Expulsions over fee hike: Parents turn down interim relief
DPS Dwarka
students challenging their expulsion from school for non-payment of hiked fees failed to get an immediate relief from
Delhi High Court
on Thursday. Justice Vikas Mahajan instead proposed an interim arrangement in which the parents deposited 50% of the unpaid fees subject to the outcome of the petition and the school readmitted the students.
The parents, however, declined this, stating that they were willing to pay the hiked fees only if a comprehensive
forensic audit
and a Comptroller and Auditor General of India audit were conducted into the school's finances and the findings were made public.
The parents rejected the claimed audit conducted by Delhi govt recently, which they argued had "done little to alleviate the ongoing struggles faced by their children". On May 9, the parents had received emailed notification about their children's names being struck off the rolls due to "non-payment of school fees".
Some parents alleged that DPS Dwarka posted bouncers at the gates on Tuesday to prevent listed students from entering classrooms.
On Wednesday, the aggrieved parents moved Delhi High Court, seeking the reinstatement of their children.
One parent alleged Delhi govt's claimed audits were "mere compilations of previously conducted reports". Mahesh Mishra, another parent, added, "If a private school seeks to increase fees citing financial losses, it must first undergo a comprehensive forensic audit and an independent audit by CAG, covering both the institution and the organisation under which it operates. If the audit reports confirm that the school is genuinely facing financial distress, parents are prepared to support their request for a
fee hike
."
Stating that the matter was in high court, the school principal refused to comment. The court has posted the matter for hearing on Friday.
This dispute unfolds as Delhi govt moves to implement a new law aimed at curbing arbitrary fee hikes in private schools. The draft legislation proposes setting up fee regulation committees at the school, district and state levels, and includes fines of up to 50,000 for coercive actions, such as isolating or denying entry to students.
The plea of the parents alleged that in the last few years, the school had pressured and used coercive methods to collect unapproved fees from parents, including hiring bouncers for duty at the gates. The parents' counsel claimed the school had increased the fee earlier to Rs 7,000 a month and now to Rs 9,000.
The plea said several representations on the matter had been made to the lieutenant governor, highlighting gross violations of the land allotment conditions by the school and alleged non-compliance with orders passed by the Department of Education.
The petition said, "On the one hand, DoE seems vigilant and fully aware of the misconduct of the school… but the larger question is what is stopping DoE from taking over after obtaining the approval of lieutenant governor of Delhi, who is appointed as administrator under Article 239AA of the Constitution of India?"
It cited another petition pending before a coordinate bench of the high court. In that case in April, the court examined an inspection report of an eight-member committee led by the district magistrate (southwest) that highlighted discriminatory practices by another school against students. The students were barred from attending regular classes and confined to the library, restricted access to the canteen, not allowed to communicate with friends and were closely monitored by guards during washroom visits.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Veena visits Bindhu's kin, assures aid
Kottayam: A day after opposition parties staged statewide protests demanding her resignation, health minister Veena George visited the family of D Bindu, the 52-year-old woman who had died after a portion of a building at the Government Medical College Hospital, Kottayam, collapsed three days ago. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now George reached Bindu's residence in Thalayolaparambu early on Sunday and spent time with her grieving family, including Bindhu's mother, husband, and children. Bindu had been staying at the hospital to care for her daughter, who was admitted as an inpatient, when she was trapped under the debris. The minister assured the family that the govt would cover the full cost of their daughter's surgery, with further treatment decisions to be taken after a medical board meeting on Monday. She added that the state would also consider the family's other demands, including compensation and a job for Bindu's son. "As far as I'm concerned, this family's sorrow is my sorrow. I met her husband, mother, and other relatives and shared their grief. The govt will stand by them in every possible way," George said, adding that chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan would announce the relief measures after a state cabinet decision. Bindu's husband, Visruthan, said that the family was hopeful about govt support and stated that the family is satisfied with the interventions made by the authorities. CPM state committee member K Anil Kumar, who accompanied the minister, also promised assistance for completing the family's house construction. Meanwhile, Kottayam MLA Thiruvanchoor Radhakrishnan demanded Rs 25 lakh in compensation for the family, a permanent job for Bindu's son and free treatment for her daughter. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now At a press conference, he said the hospital management committee hadn't met in two years. "Yet funds were spent. The public deserves an explanation," he said. He also called for the immediate commissioning of 12 operation theatres, highlighting that only four are functional and two of those lack sterility. "Ward 26 is leaking, a new building caught fire in 2023 and safety regulations were ignored," he alleged. UDF leader Ramesh Chennithala, who also visited Bindu's home, demanded a safety audit of all state govt hospital buildings. He criticized the health minister for fearing protests and avoiding a daylight visit to Bindu's residence. "People are unhappy with the health department's reckless actions," he stated. "There's no medicine or basic supplies, forcing doctors to treat poor patients only if they bring their own. We have good doctors, but what can they do without medicines?"
India Gazette
an hour ago
- India Gazette
"Working on new law to tackle issue of duplicate fertilisers, seeds," says Shivraj Singh Chouhan
Vidisha (Madhya Pradesh) [India], July 6 (ANI): Union Agriculture Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan on Sunday said that the government is preparing a new, stricter law to address the problem of duplicate fertilisers and seeds. He stated that the current law imposes only a small fine of around Rs 500, allowing offenders to escape easily. Speaking to the reporters, Chouhan said, '...We are working on bringing a new law to tackle the issue of duplicate fertilisers, seeds... The law will be strict as the present law is not that strict, but just about a compensation of around Rs 500, and hence those who commit this get released easily.' Earlier, Chouhan described Bharatiya Jana Sangh founder Syama Prasad Mookerjee as an 'ardent' nationalist leader and noted that the tricolour is now 'flying high' in Kashmir. 'We pay our respects at the feet of the ardent nationalist leader and founder of Bharatiya Jana Sangh, Dr. Shyama Prasad Mookerjee. It was Dr Mukherjee who established Bharatiya Jana Sangh as a new political party based on Indian culture, values, and traditions, as an alternative to Congress,' Chouhan said in Bhopal in his tribute to Shyama Prasad Mookerjee on the occasion of his birthday. Recalling Mookerjee's protest against Article 370, Chouhan said, 'The Jana Sangh proclaimed that there cannot be two flags, two constitutions, and two heads in one country... He made the supreme sacrifice, and today, by paying our respects at his feet, we feel satisfied that under the leadership of Prime Minister Modi, his resolve has been fulfilled. The tricolour is now flying high in Kashmir.' Syama Prasad Mookerjee was the founder of Bharatiya Jana Sangh, the ideological parent organisation of the BJP. Born on July 6, 1901, in Calcutta, he was a multifaceted personality - patriot, educationist, parliamentarian, statesman, and humanitarian. He inherited a legacy of erudition and nationalism from his father, Sir Ashutosh Mookerjee, an esteemed Vice-Chancellor of Calcutta University and Judge of the Calcutta High Court. (ANI)
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Security heightened as farmers protest land acquisition in Nuh
Nuh: Security measures were tightened in IMT Rozka Meo area and a riot control drill was conducted at Nuh Police Lines on Sunday amid ongoing farmers' protests over land acquisition and compensation. Prohibitory orders have been clamped in anticipation of the upcoming Jalabhishek Yatra and to prevent any law-and-order disturbances. Farmers from nine villages in Rozka Meo area have been protesting since Feb 2024 over a long-pending land compensationfor land acquired for industrial model township. You Can Also Check: Gurgaon AQI | Weather in Gurgaon | Bank Holidays in Gurgaon | Public Holidays in Gurgaon Nuh SP Rajesh Kumar said Section 163 of BNSS (BNSS), 2023 was enforced in the region, prohibiting the assembly of five or more individuals and the carrying of deadly weapons. "This order will remain in force until Aug 4," the SP said. The restrictions apply to the area acquired by Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation (HSIIDC) and surrounding zones, including Dhir Dhaunka village and the Rozka Meo police station area. Carrying weapons such as firearms, swords, sticks, spears, axes, knives, chains and other potentially harmful objects is banned — except for the kirpan worn as a religious symbol by Sikhs. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Ingin Tahu Tentang Diagnosis Limfoma? Dapatkan Info Selengkapnya Limfoma Baca Undo Meanwhile, the SP said on Sunday, "The restrictions are aimed at preventing disruptions to govt development projects and deterring antisocial activities. Govt officials, police personnel and HSIIDC officers are exempted from this order." Duty magistrates have been assigned monitoring responsibilities while the SP warned against any violations or attempts to incite unrest. In 2010, around 1,600 acres of land were acquired for the IMT Rozka Meo project and the govt paid them Rs 25 lakh per acre. The govt also acquired land from the villages of Chandawali and Machhgar in Faridabad. However, the farmers from these areas filed a petition in court, alleging the govt was buying their land at unfairly low rates. They appealed to the court to direct the govt to increase the compensation amount. In response, the court ordered the govt to pay Rs 2 crore per acre to those farmers. When the farmers from the other nine villages heard about this decision, they too began staging protests, demanding an increase in compensation for their acquired land. After a long struggle, the govt agreed to pay them Rs 46 lakh per acre and got them to sign affidavits to prevent further legal action. Farmers were initially paid Rs 21 lakh each, with a promise of receiving the remaining Rs 25 lakh later. However, that additional compensation has still not been paid. As a result, the farmers of nine village have been staging an indefinite sit-in protest since Feb 2024.
