NPA petitions the Supreme Court of Appeal over Cholota ruling appeal
The National Prosecuting Authority has petitioned the Supreme Court of Appeal following a controversial dismissal by the Free State Division of the High Court, Bloemfontein on its application for leave to appeal.
The petition, filed on Monday, comes after Judge Loubser dismissed the NPA's request for the judge to reserve questions of law under Section 319 of the Criminal Procedure Act.
The ruling has drawn attention as it relates to the jurisdictional authority of the Free State Division of the High Court to hear the case against Moraidi Cholota, who has been implicated in the ongoing asbestos scandal that has plagued the region.
The court found that it has no jurisdiction to try the former Free State premier Ace Magashule's personal assistant in the R255-million asbestos case, as her extradition from the United States of America was unlawful.
NPA national spokesperson, Mthunzi Mhaga, said the judge's decision not only undermined the legal process but also initiated a potential gap in justice surrounding the serious allegations presented in the case.
"The NPA is of the firm view that the Honourable judge erred in dismissing the application for leave to appeal, and that there are reasonable prospects of success to appeal the Cholota judgment, and that there are compelling reasons for the SCA to hear our appeal.
"We are also exploring the possibility of approaching the Constitutional Court, challenging the same judgment, given the possible far-reaching implications on many other extradition matters," said Mhaga.
It is important to note that during the previous trial within a trial concerning the jurisdiction issue, the merits of the state's case against Cholota were neither adjudicated nor formally assessed.
This withdrawal from a full examination has led the NPA to maintain that the charges she faces remain viable and can be substantiated in a subsequent trial.
sinenhlanhla.masilela@iol.co.za
IOL News
Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Mathews Phosa: They did not call David Mabuza 'The Cat' for nothing
The ANC top six which emerged from the 54th ANC national conference in 2017 - deputy secretary-general Jessie Duarte, secretary-general Ace Magashule, chairperson Gwede Mantashe, president Cyril Ramaphosa, deputy president David Mabuza and treasury-general Paul Mashatile. Image: Picture: Motshwari Mofokeng/IOL Former Mpumalanga premier, Dr Mathews Phosa, has paid tribute to former deputy President David Dabede Mabuza who also hailed from Mpumalanga and also previously served as premier of the province from 2009 to 2018. IOL reported on Thursday that Mabuza died in hospital at the age of 64. He served as deputy president during President Cyril Ramaphosa's first term at the Union Buildings. On Friday, as tributes continue to pour for the man nicknamed 'The Cat' in South African politics due to his survival instinct, Phosa described Mabuza as a shrewd politician who contributed significantly to South Africa. 'He was a very shrewd politician. They call him the cat, not for nothing, he had many political tricks which entertained people. It got him where he got at the end of the day,' Phosa said in an interview with broadcaster Newzroom Afrika. As tributes pour in, many people are remembering Mabuza for his skillful maneuvering at the African National Congress (ANC) 2017 elective conference at Nasrec in Johannesburg, where the then Mpumalanga premier became kingmaker in Ramaphosa's path to the Union Buildings. Widely believed to be a backer of contender Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, Mabuza at the last minute threw his decisive weight behind Ramaphosa, a move which earned him the second-in-command position in South Africa. Reminiscing on the thriller conference, Phosa said Mabuza consulted him before making the tough decision. 'DD was initially standing with Nkosazana. I remember when we stood outside the conference room, he said what do I do? I said we have thrown our lot with comrade Cyril. He said he was being pulled this way and that way. I said to him it is a democracy and he had a right to choose, and he must decide and follow his heart. He supported comrade Cyril Ramaphosa," said Phosa. 'That is how the whole vote was swung against Nkosazana.' Mabuza and Phosa did not always have a rosy relationship. In 2017, IOL reported that Mabuza, then premier of Mpumalanga, lost his R10-million defamation lawsuit against Phosa, who is also former ANC treasurer-general. Former ANC treasurer-general, Mathews Phosa. Newspapers. Image: Timothy Bernard / Independent Judge Bill Prinsloo in the High Court in Pretoria not only dismissed the claim, but he also slapped Mabuza with a punitive costs order. Mabuza claimed Phosa defamed him in a spy report, which was published in the media, when he was already the premier of Mpumalanga. He claimed Phosa was the author of the report in which the premier was made out to be an apartheid spy. It contained claims that Mabuza was involved in the murder of former ANC activist Portia Shabangu. She was assassinated in the 80's by the controversial head of Vlakplaas, Eugene de Kock. Phosa earlier testified that he never compiled the so-called spy report. He said an unmarked envelope was found on the veranda of his White River farmhouse. Inside the envelope was a document which later became known as the so-called spy report. 'I was shocked by its content and worried about it, as it referred to the premier. The allegations were so serious that I decided to hand it over to the ANC top structures. If the allegations were true, the report could harm the ANC leadership. Only a traitor of the ANC would hide it from them.' Phosa said he forwarded the report to then ANC secretary-general Jessie Duarte, as before this she had visited him to discuss party issues. At the end of the meeting Duarte, out of the blue, asked him 'who is this David Mabuza', he said. Former deputy secretary general of the ANC, Jessie Duarte. Image: Nhlanhla Phillips/Independent Media 'When I held office as premier of Mpumalanga, I appointed Mabuza as education MEC and he served under me as part of my executive cabinet.' After this Phosa did not hear anything until a reporter phoned and asked him whether he knew that Mabuza was going to sue him. Phosa denied that he had anything to do with the report and said his former butler, Jan Venter – who is at the centre of this dispute – lied when he implicated him (Phosa). Venter testified that he overheard Phosa 'concocting' the spy allegations against Mabuza. But the controversial butler twice switched sides. In the end, Judge Prinsloo ruled that he could not find that Phosa was the author of the document. Meanwhile, President Ramaphosa has also paid tribute to his former deputy, Mabuza. Ramaphosa conveyed his condolences to Mabuza's family. "On behalf of government and the nation, I offer my profound condolences to the late deputy president's wife, Mrs Mabuza, and their children. I extend my condolences to deputy president Mabuza's friends and the people of Mpumalanga whom he served as Premier from 2009 to 2018, and previously as a member of the executive council of Mpumalanga across a range of portfolios." He said Mabuza had a deep commitment to the liberation struggle and to the nation's development as an inclusive, prosperous, democratic state.
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
14 more charges added, but ‘most wanted' is nowhere to be found
Vuyolwethi 'Yesu' Tshukela faces charges including murder, attempted murder, and extortion. Image: Armand Hough / Independent Media WHILE the State added a host of new criminal charges against Vuyolwethu 'Yesu' Tshukela, bringing the total to 18, the Athlone Magistrates' Court heard on Thursday that his exact whereabouts were temporarily unknown. Alleged taxi hitman, Tshukela, was arrested last month in Welkom in the Free State after months on the run, initially facing four charges. These included murder, attempted murder, and extortion. However, the State revealed on Thursday that after consulting with a senior advocate, 14 more charges were added. Among them are kidnapping, robbery, assault, intimidation, malicious injury to property, arson, and a second count of attempted murder, this time allegedly involving a security officer. Alleged taxi hitman, Vuyolwethu 'Yesu' Tshukela, failed to appear in the Athlone Magistrate's Court on Thursday. Image: Armand Hough / Independent Newspapers The State prosecutor told the court: 'Your Worship, the charge sheet at first appearance only reflected four charges. That has now changed to 14 additional charges being added after consultation with the State advocate.' Before proceedings began, court orderlies informed the State that Tshukela had not been brought to court. A police officer explained that when he went to Pollsmoor Correctional Facility in the morning, Tshukela was not there and had been moved the week before to another facility, due to safety concerns, but no one seemed to know which. 'The accused is not before the court, Your Worship. He wasn't brought from Pollsmoor this morning,' the prosecutor said. The State confirmed that arrangements had since been made with Pollsmoor officials to ensure the accused is present at his next scheduled appearance. The prosecutor added: 'Due to the higher risk posed by the accused, he is not kept at Pollsmoor. However, after speaking to the chief at Pollsmoor, arrangements have been made for him to be brought to court next time.' The court heard that Tshukela's legal representative had been consulted on Thursday morning and indicated that the accused would be abandoning his bail application. However, this could not be confirmed due to his absence. Magistrate Keith Le Keur expressed concern about Tshukela not being in court, highlighting the procedural importance of the accused being present. 'But the only reason he is not here must be in terms of Section 159(3)(c) of the Criminal Procedure Act, for example, if he were in hospital. There must be a medical certificate,' said Le Keur. 'Pollsmoor cannot simply decide to keep him there arbitrarily. Under normal circumstances, I would have postponed it to the next day to have him here and then roll the matter in his presence. The proceedings must happen in the presence of the accused.' The State asked that a J7 warrant be issued for Tshukela in absentia and for the matter to be remanded. 'Your Worship, a date has been arranged with Mr Ntsindane for July 18. The State requests that the matter be remanded to that date, for the accused to be before the court as well as his attorney.' The magistrate agreed and postponed the case to July 7. The accused will face all 18 charges, including two counts of attempted murder, robbery, arson, assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, and extortion. Cape Times
TimesLIVE
5 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Man spotted carrying a printer near guesthouse led to fake cash bust
The three men arrested in connection with a counterfeit money racket in Pretoria are Cameroonian nationals. National Prosecuting Authority spokesperson Lumka Mahanjana said Philliph Mumbai, 42, exited an e-hailing service vehicle in Elardus Park and was walking to a nearby guesthouse when he was stopped by patrolling police officers on July 1. "They questioned him about a printing machine he was carrying and where he was headed. When he could not answer, the police requested t he take them to the guesthouse. On arrival, they discovered Maxwell Basong, 39, and Tieze Zemeniouh, 38, operating a similar printing machine and printing counterfeit money. "During the arrest, Mumbai allegedly attempted to bribe the officers with R2,000 in exchange for their release." The men have appeared in the Pretoria magistrate's court on a charge of possession of counterfeit goods. Mumbai also faces a charge of corruption. The case was postponed to July 10. Mahanjana said: "It is alleged the three accused operated a syndicate involved in the printing and distribution of counterfeit rand and US dollar notes. The counterfeit money was allegedly sold and used to purchase goods."
