logo
Inside Joyce Mitchell's bleak, reclusive life in upstate New York, where her name remains in the gutter 10 years after infamous escape from Dannemora

Inside Joyce Mitchell's bleak, reclusive life in upstate New York, where her name remains in the gutter 10 years after infamous escape from Dannemora

New York Post07-06-2025
There's been no redemption for the Shawskank.
New photos show Joyce Mitchell living a bleak, reclusive life in upstate New York nearly 10 years to the day after she helped her alleged lovers — convicted killers Richard Matt and David Sweat — escape from Clinton maximum-security prison in Dannemora, NY.
Neighbors in sleepy Dickinson told The Post they rarely see the disgraced 61-year-old or her head-scratchingly devoted husband, Lyle — whose names remain tainted across the North Country a decade after the jailbreak and 23-day manhunt captivated the nation and spawned a Hollywood miniseries.
Advertisement
8 A new photo shows Joyce Mitchell nearly 10 years to the day after she helped Richard Matt and David Sweat escape from Clinton Correctional Facility.
LP Media
'She is not regarded well around here,' said Connie Paquin, the owner of Mo's Bar and Grill in Malone, 18 miles north of the Mitchell's rural, two-story home.
'Nobody can really believe what she did,' said Paquin. 'Everybody around here thinks she really should have got more time than she got.'
Advertisement
Joyce Mitchell was a supervisor in the prison tailor shop when she began 'flirtatious' relationships with both Matt and Sweat, who were meticulously hatching an escape not unlike the fictitious one in 1994's 'The Shawshank Redemption.'
As the flings progressed, the dowdy seamstress gave Matt oral sex and passed along nude selfies for Sweat, she later confessed to authorities. Eventually she began helping the cons with their planned breakout, even smuggling in a hacksaw blade and drill bit concealed in hamburger meat.
8 The dowdy seamstress also gave Matt oral sex and passed along nude selfies for Sweat, she admitted in her confession.
vmodica
All the while, her husband worked as an industrial training supervisor in the same lockup.
Advertisement
After six months of planning and using the tools to cut through their steel cell walls and an 18-inch steam pipe in the facility's underbelly, the duo made their escape on June 6, 2015. They emerged from a manhole cover about 500 feet outside the prison walls around 11:50 p.m.
Joyce Mitchell was supposed to be waiting for her daring boytoys in a car at a nearby intersection at midnight, ready to ride off into the sunset toward Mexico.
But she never showed up.
8 Sweat (left) and Matt (right) used tools provided by Mitchell to break out of the prison on June 6, 2015.
AP
Advertisement
Instead, she went to the hospital in the throes of a panic attack.
The two inmates skulked around the neighborhood until about 12:20 a.m. Realizing she had backed out, they took off.
The escape, and Joyce's romantic role in it, made national headlines, and Joyce was dubbed 'Shawskank.' Then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo rushed to the prison, where he was photographed peering into the manhole.
The subsequent, 23-day manhunt riveted the nation, with 1,500 law enforcement officers, at a cost of $1 million-per-day, scouring the deep woods of the North Country for the desperate fugitives.
But they were elusive, trudging through dense forests and swamps, and setting up makeshift campsites when they weren't squatting in empty hunting cabins. In one, they picked up a 20-gauge shotgun, rum, boots, binoculars, maps and other supplies.
8 The escape, and Joyce's romantic role in it, made national headlines.
REUTERS
The duo finally split up on June 23. Three days later, Matt was cornered by border patrol agents near Lake Titus. When he ignored commands to surrender, he was shot dead.
On June 28, Sweat was spotted by a State Trooper near Constable. When he tried to run, the sergeant fired two rounds, hitting Sweat in the left arm and right shoulder before he was recaptured.
Advertisement
Joyce was arrested June 12 – less than a week after the jailbreak. She pleaded guilty in September 2015 to promoting prison contraband and criminal facilitation, and was sentenced to two-and-a-half to seven years. She was released after less than five years spent at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in Westchester County.
8 A family photo Joyce posted on Facebook in August 2023 show the couple posing alongside six other adults and a little girl, grinning in the woods.
Joyce Mitchell/ Facebook
In the years since, Joyce has put up a happy front on Facebook, where she uses her old nickname Tillie — just like her character played by Patricia Arquette in Ben Stiller's mini-series 'Escape at Dannemora.'
Seemingly serene family photos of Joyce and Lyle posted in August 2023 show the couple posing alongside six other adults and a little girl in the woods.
Advertisement
Another Facebook snap shows the youngster, believed to be the couple's granddaughter, lovingly wrapping her arms around a grumpy-looking Lyle.
But away from social media, neighbors say the couple rarely poke their heads out from their gray, worn-down, two-story home, which is decorated with butterfly windchimes, a ceramic dog sculpture and other tchotchkes. A black Boston Terrier could be seen lazing inside a windowsill when The Post visited recently.
8 Another Facebook snap shows the youngster, who is believed to be the couple's granddaughter, lovingly wrapping her arms around a grumpy-looking Lyle.
Joyce Mitchell/ Facebook
It's unclear how the couple gets by financially. Joyce was fired and Lyle quit amid disciplinary actions. They both collect small state pensions, which were reduced because they left jobs long before their expected retirement dates.
Advertisement
'Obviously she's not working in corrections. I don't think anyone would hire [either of] them around here,' said Ed Work, who serves as a warden at nearby Franklin Correctional.
Lyle made $20,292 in 2024, while Joyce made only $8,775, according to public state pension records.
Until a few years ago, Work said he used to spot Joyce headed to her monthly parole-officer meetings.
'I've seen her a few times going to parole and I've seen her once at the store since she's been out, but I haven't seen Lyle once,' he said.
Advertisement
8 Lyle made $20,292 in 2024, according to public state pension records.
Matthew Symons for NYP
'It's a close community, but no, they're not really involved,' he continued.
At the Franklin prison, Work said correction officer trainees are taught Joyce's relationship with Matt and Sweat as an example of what not to do.
'You know, some prisoners might try to manipulate you, saying, 'You look nice today' and other stuff to get better treatment. But you can't let 'em get to you,' Work explained.
'Joyce isn't the prettiest girl in town, so I'm not sure what those guys were doing, but I guess you get pretty desperate in jail,' he added with a chuckle.
One neighbor described the Mitchells as 'friendly' and helpful.
Lyle has helped the neighbor, who gave his name as Jeff, clear his land. 'It's a lot of work clearing the lot, and that's what we talk about. Nothing personal,' said Jeff.
As for Joyce, 'she waves when I see her coming out, but it's not that often.'
8 'Leave us alone. Get the f–k away from us and leave us alone,' Lyle barked at a Post reporter before slamming the door shut.
Matthew Symons for NYP
Despite the allegations against Joyce – which included a plot to kill Lyle, according to Sweat and investigators – Lyle welcomed his wife back with open arms.
He is decidedly less tolerant of nosy journalists.
'Leave us alone. Get the f–k away from us and leave us alone,' he barked at a Post reporter before slamming the door shut. 'Stay the f–k away from us.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Diddy's ex-collaborator Tony Dofat says he'll work with rapper again after verdict
Diddy's ex-collaborator Tony Dofat says he'll work with rapper again after verdict

New York Post

time9 hours ago

  • New York Post

Diddy's ex-collaborator Tony Dofat says he'll work with rapper again after verdict

One of Sean 'Diddy' Combs' former collaborators has revealed where he stands after the embattled music mogul's bombshell sex trafficking trial concluded this week. Tony Dofat, who worked alongside Diddy on several projects from the early '90s to the late aughts, exclusively told The Post that he would 'definitely' collaborate with the rapper again following the surprising verdict. The 55-year-old record exec was acquitted on racketeering and sex trafficking charges on Wednesday, July 2. Advertisement 12 One of Sean 'Diddy' Combs' former collaborators has revealed where he stands after the embattled music mogul's sex trafficking trial concluded this week. REUTERS 12 Tony Dofat exclusively told the Post that he would 'definitely' collaborate with Diddy again following the surprising verdict. Instagram/@tonydofat However, he was found guilty on two lesser charges of transportation to engage in prostitution. Advertisement He also still faces 66 civil lawsuits, according to Vulture, connected to a slew of sexual impropriety allegations against him. 'I would definitely work together with him again,' Dofat told The Post shortly after the verdict was announced. 12 Dofat worked alongside Diddy on several projects from the early '90s to the late aughts. Instagram/@tonydofat 12 'I would definitely work together with him again,' Dofat told the Post. Instagram/@tonydofat Advertisement 'We made a lot of great records together,' he added. 'A lot of people make music together, and I don't see why I wouldn't wanna continue making music with him.' Dofat said he first began collaborating with Diddy in 1992 when the 'I'll Be Missing You' singer introduced the New York native to the hip-hop music business and Uptown Records. Dofat went on to compose and produce many chart-topping songs and remixes alongside Diddy, including Mary J. Blige's hits 'Love No Limit' and 'You Don't Have To Worry.' 12 Diddy was acquitted on racketeering and sex trafficking charges on Wednesday. Getty Images for Sean Diddy Combs Advertisement 12 Diddy and Dofat first began collaborating in 1992. Instagram/@tonydofat 12 Diddy and Dofat worked together to produce remixes of Mary J. Blige's hits 'Love No Limit' and 'You Don't Have To Worry.' Getty Images for Strength Of A Woman Festival & Summit Besides being a member of Diddy's Bad Boy Records in-house production team, The Hitmen, Dofat also served as the record producer for Diddy and MTV's 'Making The Band 2' from 2002 through 2004. The last time the pair collaborated was for Diddy's 'Press Play' record in 2006, according to Dofat. While they 'severed ties' shortly after, Dofat claimed that it was not 'in a negative manner.' 'I mean, we're all artists, and this is, believe it or not, just the life that we live,' Dofat continued regarding whether he would want to collaborate with Diddy again. 'It's part of the art when you look at it like that.' 12 Diddy was still found guilty on two lesser charges of transportation to engage in prostitution. AP 'Maybe going through these things will put them in a different perspective, and it'll probably create a different type of art, just from that point of view,' he added. Dofat also thinks the 'Mo Money Mo Problems' rapper can mount a music career comeback after serving his sentence for the prostitution charges. Advertisement The judge denied Diddy's request for bail. His sentencing is currently scheduled for Oct. 3. 12 Dofat also believes the 'Mo Money Mo Problems' rapper can mount a music career comeback after serving his sentence for the prostitution charges. Instagram/@tonydofat 'Of course,' Dofat told The Post. 'I mean, the thing about Diddy's music is that he always has a passion and love for music. He has great ideas, and he's an incredible producer.' 'I can't see why not. I can't see why he would just leave music alone,' Dofat concluded. 'Music is something he's always gonna do.' Advertisement Dofat isn't the only one who believes Diddy could make a successful comeback after his conviction, either. 12 Diddy's sentencing is currently scheduled for Oct. 3. REUTERS Tyrone Blackburn, an attorney representing Rodney 'Lil Rod' Jones and others in civil suits against Diddy, also believes the rapper will make a big return to music. 'Because these are not viewed as the really serious claims, or serious charges, I think he may be able to come back,' Blackburn told The Post. Advertisement Attorney Joel Denaro said something similar. 12 Diddy was also denied bail, meaning he will remain behind bars until his sentencing later this year. REUTERS 'Like always, people's memories will fade, and given Diddy's considerable talent, I'm sure he will flourish musically going forward,' Denario said. However, not everybody agrees that the 'Last Night' hip-hop star will be able to 'come back' to the industry after his legal woes. Advertisement 'I do not think the court of public opinion will be forgiving,' Ann Olivarius, an attorney focused on women's rights, told The Post in a statement. 'The damage to Diddy's reputation is real, and demonstrates that the world is watching and survivors matter, even if their abusers are powerful.' 12 Not everybody agrees that the disgraced hip-hop star will be able to mount a comeback after his prostitution conviction. Getty Images for iHeartRadio Ana Garcia, host of 'True Crime News: The Podcast,' expressed a similar sentiment about the rapper's future. 'Combs may have been spared life in prison but I am not so sure his career can be saved,' she said. 'How can you look at Diddy and not think this man is repulsive?' 'I think Diddy's image and endorsements are ruined,' Garcia added.

Shoeless maniac attacks random pedestrians in ritzy NYC neighborhood: ‘Did he attack you too?'
Shoeless maniac attacks random pedestrians in ritzy NYC neighborhood: ‘Did he attack you too?'

New York Post

time9 hours ago

  • New York Post

Shoeless maniac attacks random pedestrians in ritzy NYC neighborhood: ‘Did he attack you too?'

A shoeless maniac randomly attacked several strangers and even cops in an unhinged Wednesday morning spree in Chelsea – leaving one victim lamenting to The Post 'this shouldn't be happening.' The unhinged man allegedly punched photographer and artist Jose Castillo, 38, at West 26th Street and Seventh Avenue around 9:20 a.m., police said. Castillo, a New Yorker of 12 years who has a studio in SoHo, was walking to pick up supplies in Chelsea when he strolled past a man who had been asking people for money on the street. Advertisement Out of nowhere, that man turned violent, Castillo said. 'I felt [like I was] punched in the face, and it knocked me to the ground,' he said. 'A couple people that were around came by to see if I was OK and helped me up. I wasn't knocked out, but I was knocked down to the floor by the punch.' The maniac punched a 38-year-old man and as many as four other people in an unhinged spree at West 26th Street and 7th Avenue Wednesday morning, cops said. Google Maps Advertisement 'And as I was getting up, to just you know, dust it off and keep on walking because it's New York, one of the people that was helping me said like, 'You're bleeding in your face,' and she said, 'You should call the cops,'' Castillo added. As he dialed 911, he looked back to see if the madman was still in sight – and caught him punching a teen girl, a tourist who was visiting the city with her mom. 'I saw it from maybe like half a block away as I was walking over and he hit her in the face too,' Castillo said. 'But by the time I reached them, the young girl was inconsolable. She was crying because she had just been attacked in the middle of the street. 'When I went over and approached them, and I was like, 'Hey, did he attack you too?', and they were like, 'Yeah, he just punched her too,' and by then I was already on the line with 911 and I was telling them what was happening.' Advertisement The crazed attacker was hospitalized for an evaluation and taken into custody with charges pending, police said. William Miller Both mom and daughter, who were 'quite shaken up,' were no longer at the scene by the time cops arrived. 'I assume this is gonna be their New York story, you know,' Castillo said. As Castillo was on the phone with the dispatcher, he said he witnessed the crazed man attack another youngster. Advertisement 'He got up to these young kids that looked like they were in middle school and when they didn't pay any attention to him, he smacked one of them in the back of the head,' he said. 'I was telling all of this to the dispatcher and letting them know that they should get there fast, because this guy was, you know, attacking people randomly.' As the officers approached, the street menace became 'combative' and turned on them too — punching a 30-year-old male officer in the face, and spitting on a 30-year-old female cop, authorities said. Another officer, 53, also hurt his shoulder while attempting to take the assailant into custody, police said. 'As they get close to him, this guy just starts swinging, and hits one of the officers on the right side of his face, and they tried to contain him,' Castillo said. 'You know, that guy wasn't that tall, he was about 5-foot-7, but he was really strong for someone that was that skinny. 'It was just havoc,' the victim recalled. 'The cops tried to…restrain him and they were having issues with that. Two other police officers came by and helped … .I know that he was spitting at officers at the station and in the car.' Castillo was treated at the scene for minor injuries, but said he thinks he needs to get checked out further. 'Right now, I'm going to get an X-ray of my face because…. I have pain, like I think that he moved one of my teeth in the back of my mouth,' he said. The two male officers were hospitalized in stable condition, according to cops. Advertisement Meanwhile, the attacker — who is considered an emotionally disturbed person — was taken to Bellevue Hospital for an evaluation, police said. He was taken into police custody with charges pending. His name was not immediately known and police were considering him a 'John Doe.' He wore only socks but no shoes during the string of attacks, and appeared to be in his mid-40s, Castillo said. Advertisement 'Mostly he was just silent and threatening, getting in people's faces,' he recalled. 'You know, this guy was serious. I've been living here for 12 years, and I've seen some people that were acting a little deranged, but this guy definitely was….I think that he needed some help.' Meanwhile, Castillo said that attacks like these 'shouldn't be happening.' 'There are alternatives that could be put in place to help these people out,' he said. 'The police response was quick, they were very helpful. I think that we should be thankful that we live in a city that has such a strong police force that is there for us.'

Can Diddy stage a career comeback after his trial verdict? Experts weigh in
Can Diddy stage a career comeback after his trial verdict? Experts weigh in

New York Post

time11 hours ago

  • New York Post

Can Diddy stage a career comeback after his trial verdict? Experts weigh in

Sean 'Diddy' Combs' supporters chanted 'free Puff!' — and poured baby oil over themselves — outside Manhattan federal court Wednesday after the stunning verdict in his bombshell weeks-long sex trafficking trial was revealed. But could he really make a comeback? The once-renowned music producer, 55, was convicted of two counts of transportation to engage in prostitution by the jury, but acquitted of the more serious sex trafficking and racketeering charges that could have landed him in prison for the rest of his life. 14 Sean 'Diddy' Combs poses with the Global Icon award at the 2023 MTV Video Music Awards. AFP via Getty Images Combs is now facing a maximum sentence of up to 20 years in prison on the two prostitution charges. Before he was arrested in Sept. 2024, the three-time Grammy Award winner was riding high as one of the most powerful men in music. 14 A sketch of Sean 'Diddy' Combs in court during his trial. REUTERS 14 Sean 'Diddy' Combs at the 2012 Cannes Film Festival. Hahn-Marechal-Nebinger/ABACA/Shutterstock And while his career quickly came tumbling down, the jury's shocking decision opens the door to the possibility that Combs will try to rejoin the industry to fix his battered reputation. 'I do not think the court of public opinion will be forgiving,' Dr. Ann Olivarius, women's rights attorney and the founder of McAllister Olivarius law firm, told The Post in a statement. 'The damage to Diddy's reputation is real, and demonstrates that the world is watching and survivors matter even if their abusers are powerful.' David B. Allan, a professor of music marketing at St. Joseph's University, similarly believes Combs can't make a comeback. 14 Keyshia Cole and Diddy perform at the 2023 MTV Video Music Awards. Getty Images for MTV 14 A sketch of Sean 'Diddy' Combs in court during his trial. REUTERS 'Once the wave of getting off on the more serious charges settles, the music business will pass judgment and his reputation will be done,' Allan exclusively told The Post. 'Sean has always been great at PR and publicity, but there's no coming back from this, as this is his legacy. 'There will always be an asterisk by his name and his hits,' Allan stated. Ana Garcia, host of 'True Crime News: The Podcast,' shared a similar sentiment about Combs' future in the industry. 14 Ana Garcia. Courtesy of Ana Garcia 'Combs may have been spared life in prison but I am not so sure his career can be saved,' Garcia exclusively told The Post. 'How can you look at Diddy and not think this man is repulsive? The public cannot unsee Cassie's beating or the vile things he made her do.' 'I think Diddy's image and endorsements are ruined,' Garcia continued. 'This trial didn't up Diddy's gangsta cred. Instead, it revealed a pathetic and violent man who gets off on seeing his beautiful girlfriend urinated on. Who wants that guy endorsing your product?' Meanwhile, Tyrone Blackburn, a lawyer who is representing Rodney 'Lil Rod' Jones and others in civil suits against Combs, believes the star could make a grand return. 14 Sean 'Diddy' Combs parties in Jamaica in 2013. Marlon Reid / MEGA 'Because these are not viewed as the really serious claims, or serious charges, I think he may be able to come back,' Blackburn exclusively told The Post. 'I think if he shows some sort of remorse, I think if he submits an apology, I think if he falls on his sword and takes ownership for what he has done, thanks the jury for their thoroughness and says he will get some help, he possibly can,' Blackburn added. Attorney Joel Denaro told The Post: 'Like always, people's memories will fade and given Diddy's considerable talent, I'm sure he will flourish musically going forward.' 14 Sean 'Diddy' Combs on stage at the 2023 MTV VMAs. Getty Images for MTV Tony Dofat, for example, is up to collaborate with the embattled mogul again. He composed and produced hit tracks for Diddy and Bad Boy Entertainment in the '90s. 'I would definitely work together with him again. We made a lot of great records together,' he told the Post. 'Maybe going through these things will put them in a different perspective. It'll probably create a different type of art, you know, just from that point of view.' Jeff Apruzzese, professor of the music industry at Drexel University, believes Combs will 'certainly try' to wiggle his way back. 14 Chris Brown and Diddy partying in Las Vegas in 2012. WireImage 'Diddy has always positioned himself as both a creator and a CEO. That said, a public-facing comeback, whether through performance or media appearances, would likely face steep resistance,' Apruzzese noted. 'If he returns at all, it's more likely to be behind the scenes in a production or mentorship role, though that still depends on whether business partners are willing to reengage.' Combs wouldn't be the first once-disgraced celebrity to recover from a major scandal. Chris Brown was all but canceled for getting into a domestic violence incident with then-girlfriend Rihanna in 2009. The 'Forever' singer, 36, has also faced other assault allegations over the years. 14 Chris Brown and Sean 'Diddy' Combs at the Playboy Mansion in Beverly Hills in 2010. WireImage But Brown experienced a career resurgence with the release of his albums 'Breezy' in 2022 and '11:11' in 2023, the latter of which won him the Grammy Award for Best R&B Album. He's also about to embark on the US leg of his Breezy Bowl XX tour from July 30 to Sept. 20. Apruzzese doesn't think Combs can replicate what Brown has done. 'Chris Brown's return unfolded gradually and under very different cultural conditions,' the professor said. 'The nature of the allegations against Diddy and the current climate in Hollywood, means people are far more cautious about public associations that could create long-term reputational risk.' Apruzzese also speculated that other famous names 'will likely keep their distance, at least publicly,' from Combs for now. 14 Diddy steps out in London in Nov. 2023. 'Collaborators now have to think about brand alignment, audience expectations, and potential backlash,' he noted. 'So even if relationships still exist behind the scenes, we may not see them out in the open.' Along with the current lack of public support, Combs' finances have taken a hit since he became a pariah. Forbes last year estimated the rapper's net worth at around $400 million, down from the $740 million he was worth in 2019. Before his arrest, he reportedly stepped down and later fully divested from his cable television network, Revolt. He also settled a legal dispute with Diageo, which involved him relinquishing control of his alcohol brands CÎroc and DeLeó. 14 Sean 'Diddy' Combs at the 'Get Him to the Greek' premiere in 2010. AFP via Getty Images Combs' record label, Bad Boy Entertainment, has also been affected by his legal troubles. In 2023, Combs returned the music publishing rights to the artists and songwriters who helped build the company. At the time, Combs told Variety: 'It's just doing the right thing. I think that we as an industry, and as a people, have to look in the mirror and make a shift forward. It's about evolving, leading by example and reforming an industry that needs it, in a world that needs reform.' Bad Boy Entertainment has not announced any major releases since Combs' arrest. The last album Combs put out before he went to prison was 2023's 'The Love Album: Off the Grid.' 14 Sean 'Diddy' Combs at a club in France in 2005. Pinguet Benoit/ABACA/Shutterstock However, Combs was recently featured on Kanye West's new song that also included West's 12-year-old daughter North. West, who has also been shunned for his own controversies, has voiced support for Combs and even made a brief appearance at the trial. Combs' legal costs have certainly added up over the past year, which could also endanger his potential resurgence. 14 Cassie Ventura and Sean Combs at the 2018 Met Gala. Getty Images for The Hollywood Reporter Before his trial began in May, an expert told Fox News that Combs' legal defense could cost him $15 million. After the verdict, legal expert Neama Rahmani told The Post that Combs' sex-trafficking case was the 'most expensive prostitution trial in American history.' In addition, Combs' ex, Cassie Ventura, claimed she received a $20 million settlement in her 2023 lawsuit against the hip-hop mogul. Video evidence of Combs physically assaulting Ventura, 38, from 2016 was released in 2024, before she testified against Combs during the trial in May. Ventura reacted to Wednesday's verdict in a statement via her attorney, Doug Wigdor, who said she 'paved the way' for the jury to convict Combs on the prostitution charges. 'By coming forward with her experience, Cassie has left an indelible mark on both the entertainment industry and the fight for justice,' Ventura's lawyer said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store