Hong Kong NGO defends ecotourism research after ‘soft resistance' accusation from Beijing-backed paper
The paper ran a full-page report on Tuesday, accusing the NGO of using 'pseudo-science' to challenge the bottom line of national security.
The report also named Greenpeace Hong Kong, which co-hosted a seminar event on ecotourism with Liber and other environmental groups online last month after a local university cancelled their venue booking.
According to the Wen Wei Po report, Liber 'has been using pseudo-science as 'camouflage' to spread untruthful comments to vilify the government.'
Brian Wong, a researcher at Liber, said he was confident that the think tank's research was well-founded.
'Our last report was solid, with methodologies, data, and case studies,' Wong told HKFP on Tuesday, adding that the NGO would continue its work.
'If they think what we're putting out is pseudoscience, more information is needed to substantiate their claim,' he said.
Addressing the 'soft resistance' accusation, Wong said: 'We are just conducting research and making suggestions for the benefit of Hong Kong's people and environment.'
'Done well'
According to Wen Wei Po, Liber's research is based on the 'false premise' that development will always have environmental impacts.
But Wong maintained that Liber was not opposed to the government's ecotourism initiatives.
'We just want it to be done well. There are always details from which we can derive insights by conducting research,' he said. 'The government has itself said that recommendations are welcomed as long as they are based on fact.'
Last month, Liber and Greenpeace published a joint report urging the authorities to set a clear framework for eco-tourism development after discovering that existing arrangements may grant developers more flexibility to build private housing on ecologically sensitive land.
In early July, 10 green groups, including Greenpeace, separately called on the authorities to align ecotourism policies with international standards. They warned that such eco-projects would otherwise endanger local communities and ecosystems if they skewed in favour of property developers' interests.
On both occasions, the NGOs did not state that they opposed the plan or called for it to be shelved.
Wong also said that the Wen Wei Po report contained inaccuracies.
Contrary to the report's claims, he said Liber did not attend the press conference held by the Society for Protection of the Harbour, an environmental NGO, which the Development Bureau accused of making 'misleading remarks' about a legislative amendment streamlining approval for harbour reclamation works.
Liber also did not draft a template for representation letters regarding the San Tin Technopole, a planned tech park development in the New Territories that has been green-lit despite a 90 per cent opposition rate in a consultation exercise.
The Wen Wei Po report also said that one of Liber's events, which one of the paper's reporters attended without revealing their identity, had the makings of an 'underground assembly,' quoting a host's remark that 'what's said here, stays here.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Why investor confidence is key to acing Hong Kong's Northern Metropolis ‘test'
Hong Kong must instil investor confidence by eliminating uncertainties over the Northern Metropolis , a megadevelopment near the border viewed by Beijing as a test of the administration's governance capability, analysts have said. Advertisement The megaproject, featuring the city's new innovation hub located in the northern New Territories, grabbed headlines again last month after a five-day visit by Beijing's top official on Hong Kong affairs and subtle bargaining by the city's major developers. The 30,000-hectare (74,132-acre) development is not only a new engine to drive the city's economy, but repeated calls from the central government to speed up the project also indicate it has become a testing ground for the administration to demonstrate its ability to govern, a political commentator has said. 'In the face of a volatile geopolitical environment and the city's economic downturn, Hong Kong has to find its new economic impetus,' said Professor Lau Siu-kai, a consultant with Beijing's semi-official think tank, the Chinese Association of Hong Kong and Macau Studies. '[The project] can help Hong Kong expedite its economic transformation and upgrade and develop new industries so that Hong Kong has a better foundation for achieving sustainable economic growth. Advertisement 'From Beijing's perspective, it is a testing ground for the administration's governing capability.'
South China Morning Post
4 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Berlin says Chinese ship targeted German plane with laser over Red Sea
Berlin on Tuesday said the Chinese military had targeted a laser at a German aircraft taking part in an EU-led mission to protect marine traffic in the Red Sea. 'Endangering German personnel and disrupting the operation is entirely unacceptable,' the foreign ministry said on social media, adding that Beijing's ambassador to Berlin had been summoned for talks. The German aircraft was targeted 'without reason or prior contact … during a routine operation' over the Red Sea while taking part in the European Union's Aspides mission, a spokesman for the German defence ministry said. The aircraft in question was a 'multi-sensor platform' used as a 'flying eye' for reconnaissance. The Chinese vessel had 'taken the risk of endangering [German] personnel and equipment', the spokesman added. The German aircraft's mission was subsequently abandoned following the encounter and returned to a base in Djibouti.
South China Morning Post
4 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
China told its officials to tighten their belts. Did they go a notch too far?
This is the first story in a three-part series exploring the domestic economic challenges China faces as it navigates an unprecedented trade war with the United States. In this piece, we explore Beijing's drive to rein in wasteful government spending – and its unintended consequences. Wang, a civil servant from a small town in northeastern China, is too scared to go to restaurants these days. He even skipped his niece's wedding due to his fear of being seen at a banquet. An avid foodie, the 55-year-old used to dine with his friends once or twice a day – usually at purely social gatherings unrelated to his government job. But now, even casual meals out can cause serious problems. 'Nobody dares to stick their neck out nowadays,' said Wang, who declined to give his full name for privacy reasons. 'So I only eat at home now.' Wang is one of millions of Chinese state-sector workers who have been impacted by a government austerity drive that has sent shock waves across the country in recent weeks, hitting businesses hard and sparking concern in the corridors of Beijing The campaign started in May when the central government introduced stricter rules for civil servants and state-owned enterprise employees attending official receptions, which banned the consumption of cigarettes, liquor and 'high-end dishes'. The new guidelines were the latest in a string of measures to limit ostentatious celebrations by officials – a practice viewed as a waste of public funds and a slippery slope to corruption – that have long been a source of simmering public resentment.
