ICBF TB scoring – What farmers need to know
Siobhan Ring spoke with the Irish Examiner about the ICBF tuberculosis (TB) scoring on animal profiles and what this could mean for your upcoming breeding season.
'Breeding for TB resistance is a bit like vaccination. You're protecting yourself for the future, it's not something you do as a reactive thing. Any farmer that tells you it doesn't interest them, should think again because TB impacts everybody, whether you've been locked up or not,' said Ms Ring.
The TB scores for animals were first introduced in 2019 on a trial basis via the active AI bull list on ICBF. By the end of 2023 TB scoring was added to the EBI and can now be found on all indexes and individual animal profiles.
TB scores range from 1 to 14 with 1 being the best score an animal can receive and are considered 'low risk' with 14 being labelled as 'high risk'. Currently, ICBF uses a traffic light system on its website to help visualise good, moderate, and bad scores on animal profiles.
'We [ICBF] categorise animals when they are calves and then we follow them through throughout their lifetime. What we see is that animals that were genetically 'high risk' for becoming reactors, they would have 26% more TB reactors than calves that ICBF have labelled for 'low risk' for becoming TB reactors,' explained Ms Ring.
The data used for the TB score is a combination of genomic and phenotypic data. When a calf is born and a sire and dam are listed or when that calf is tagged and genomically tested, progeny data from the sire and dam is used and applied to the calf. This data is accumulated from daughters of the calf's sire and dam as well as sibling data.
Dr Siobhan Ring, senior geneticist from ICBF
With the TB score farmers will also see a 'reliability' figure on their animal profiles. This is not a new concept for regular users of the ICBF's services and profiles across beef and dairy. For TB scoring, an animal with high reliability means the animal is well-proven with genomics, progeny, and sibling data.
Farmers might notice older animals within their herds might display lower reliability scores compared to their younger herd mates. This is because older animals are more genetically removed from the majority of animals being tested and logged today.
The phenotypic data is provided to ICBF by the Department of Agriculture (DAFM) every two months to ensure all figures are current and up-to-date for animal profiles. DAFM provides information and results of TB skin tests conducted on farms and TB-confirmed lesion cases found at factories.
All data is given equal weight when creating the score for each animal. However, it is important to note that ICBF uses data from herds that have had confirmed cases of TB. No data is reviewed from herds which have never had confirmed TB outbreaks.
Overall, a TB score only influences an animal's EBI by 2-3%. The TB scores are calculated using mixed model equations – an equation that takes into account fixed and random effects. Since the scores' inclusion into the indexes in 2023 it makes up two thirds of the health sub-index within the EBI.
'Breeding for TB resistance is not just for the herds locked up today… You want to future-proof the next generation so how you can do that is through the bulls you are selecting this spring,' Ms Ring explains.
Farmers who are selecting bulls with high health scores are subsequently improving TB scores without having to change any of their current practices. The average bull TB score is 8.5. This means 'if a herd gets locked up we expect that 8.5% of a bull's progeny will be infected with TB.'
When discussing what farmers should do when selecting their bulls Ms Ring said: 'The lower you can get that TB score the better, but don't forget to maximise the EBI.'
Based on demand ICBF has now made the TB score on herd profiles more accessible for farmers ensuring it appears on the first page on herd and animal profiles.
'This year there have been improvements on the website to ensure the TB score is front and visible on every herd's animal search. There are 30 traits on the EBI, four to five years ago there is no way that TB scores would have come to the front screen… Just goes to show how quickly things change as we adapt to the demand,' explained Ms Ring.
If you have been affected by the recent increase in bovine TB rates in Ireland and would like to speak with a journalist, please contact our Farming reporter Zoe Geary at zoe.geary@examiner.ie.
Read More
Ireland's TB herd incidence hits highest rate in 15 years
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
Gorman calls for more action amid bluetongue threat
The Irish Farmers' Association (IFA) president Francie Gorman has called for further measures to deal with the threat of bluetongue, including vaccination. Bluetongue is a notifiable exotic viral disease caused by bluetongue virus (BTV) which can cause severe clinical signs in ruminant species, such as cattle, sheep and goats, along with camelids. The virus, which does not pose a risk to human health or food safety, is primarily spread by the bite of infected midges, which are more active in warmer months. Ireland is currently free from the disease, however remains at risk of introduction, as it the virus is present across Europe. The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) said its current approach to bluetongue is early detection and eradication, where possible. There are three inactivated vaccines currently available for bluetongue serotype-3 (BTV3) in Europe. DAFM said that all three vaccines claim to reduce the levels of virus in the blood of infected animals and reduce clinical signs of disease. However, the vaccines do not claim to prevent animals from becoming infected. The department said that in the event that bluetongue becomes established in Ireland, "vaccination would become an important tool to minimise production losses". Last month, the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) permitted the voluntary use of three BTV-3 vaccines in Northern Ireland, subject to licensing. Francie Gorman claimed that Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine Martin Heydon and his officials "can and must do more to help farmers offset the impact of BTV 3 should the disease enter this country". He said farmers are playing their part in monitoring livestock for any signs of the disease and reporting any suspicions to their vets and the department. He added that the numbers of suspected cases being reported bears this out. 'It is vital we do everything in our control to prevent this disease entering the country, the trade disruption and potential on farm production losses would impact directly and solely on farmers. 'In refusing to make provision for the option of vaccination to limit the potential losses, the minister for agriculture and his officials are exposing farmers to greater risk than is necessary,' Gorman said. The IFA president said Minister Heydon "should keep an open mind on this approach". He said the minister "must immediately move to approve vaccines for use in this country". "It's not acceptable to hold off until there is an introduction of the disease or an urgent need to vaccinate," he said. IFA Animal Health Committee chair TJ Maher said early detection, containment and eradication of the disease must be the priority. However, he said farmers who want to take precautions to minimise the impact of the disease in their herds should not be prevented from doing so. Maher said the first step in this process is to have vaccines approved for use and a stock of them in the country, and this must be done immediately.
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
3,459 from unrestricted herds kill out with 'lesions suspicious of TB'
Latest official figures show 3,459 animals from non-restricted bovine TB herds, have been slaughtered with suspicions of TB lesions between January 1, 2025 and July 20, 2025. The figures were provided to Agriland by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM). DAFM also confirmed that out of that figure, 1,758 animals were confirmed to have TB following laboratory testing of tissues. Every animal that is sent to slaughter for human consumption in Ireland - even from non-restricted herds - is subject to post-mortem veterinary inspections. As part of this process a selection of glands (lymph nodes) are inspected, as well as lungs, chest cavity, and abdominal organs to check for any signs of TB lesions. The spokesperson clarified that there have been 19,610 total reactors between January 1 and July 20 of 2025. However, the department also stated that there have been 43,290 reactors in a 12-month rolling figure (June 2024 to June 2025). In addition to this the herd incidence rate has increased from 4.31% in 2022 to 6.04% in 2024, resulting in a 36% increase in the number of herds restricted between 2022 and 2024. DAFM confirmed that as of June 22, 2025, herd incidence over a 12 month period was 6.43% DAFM has outlined that inspection at slaughter is not as successful at detecting TB infections as the skin test programme. However, the department also said that laboratory testing is 100% accurate. If cattle are slaughtered as reactors under the TB Eradication Programme, the department said this is because they have tested positive for infection with TB. The DAFM spokesperson added: "The TB test has a specificity of more than 99%, which means the rate of false positives is very low." The department also clarified that culture or other laboratory tests are not routinely carried out on all TB reactors. The spokesperson said visual inspection of reactor carcases at post-mortem found that up until July 20, 2025, 26% of such reactors had visible lesions of tuberculosis. Year Total reactors No of lesions Lesion % 2025 (Jan 1 - July 20) 19,610 5,139 26% 2024 41,682 9,931 24% 2023 28,901 8,011 28% 2022 23,393 8,391 36% Table of TB Reactors and Lesions Source: DAFM According to DAFM visible lesions mean the infection has progressed to an advanced stage where the disease process has caused significant tissue damage to a degree where it can be seen with the naked eye. However the spokesperson also outlined that the absence of lesions does not mean the reactor is not infected with TB, instead it generally indicates that the disease had not reached an advanced stage where it could be detected. DAFM also confirmed that the skin test is approximately 80% accurate while the Gamma Interferon test (blood test) is typically 90% accurate.
Agriland
2 days ago
- Agriland
TB in focus: Record high reactors, soaring costs and the impact on farmers
Latest national bovine tuberculosis (TB) statistics show reactor numbers have hit a high of 43,290, while total expenditure in the first six months of this year has soared to more than €52.01 million. But behind the statistics is the very human cost of a TB outbreak on farm families, who have to put their daily lives on hold and then live with the fear that persists once a farm is declared TB-free. This week Agriland's special focus - 'Silent spread- Ireland's TB battle' - will examine the devastating cost of the disease, both economically and emotionally, and how the TB challenge may shape farming in the future and government spending. We visit one Kerry dairy farmer who lost his entire herd to the disease and find out how he rebuilt his herd. We also find out how other countries have adopted new policies and a 'strengthened partnership approach' in their campaigns to eradicate TB and how they are dealing with the persisting challenge of the disease. During our special focus week on TB, Agriland will also examine why enhancing genetic resistance to the disease can significantly "reduce the number of reactors, minimise herd disruptions, and lower costs". We also speak to the experts who are on the frontline of the battle against TB and find out what the latest research is telling us about the spread of the disease and what may be some of the key elements that might work when it comes to finding a solution. Millions of euro has been spent on research and on compensation to farmers in Ireland, but the current approach has not halted the spread of the disease or prevented herd breakdowns. However Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon has said he will unveil a new "action plan" to deal with rising TB levels in Ireland. Last month, Minister Heydon said he had secured "approval and support of my government colleagues to address the current high level of bovine TB". "My ambition with the bovine TB programme is to protect all farm families, those who are dealing with a bovine TB outbreak and those who are trying to keep their herds free from bovine TB," he stated.
