Doubt Cast On Claim Of 'Hints' Of Life On Faraway Planet
When astronomers announced last month they might have discovered the most promising hints of alien life yet on a distant planet, the rare good news raised hopes humanity could soon learn we are not alone in the universe.
But several recent studies looking into the same data have found that there is not enough evidence to support such lofty claims, with one scientist accusing the astronomers of "jumping the gun".
The debate revolves around the planet K2-18b, which is 124 light years away in the Leo constellation.
The planet is thought to be the right distance from its star to have liquid water, making it a prime suspect in the search for extraterrestrial life.
Last month, astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope made headlines by announcing they had detected hints of the chemicals dimethyl sulfide (DMS) and dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) on the planet.
These chemicals are only produced by life such as marine algae on Earth, meaning they are considered potential "biosignatures" indicating life.
The astronomers, led by Cambridge University's Nikku Madhusudhan, expressed caution about the "hints" of a biosignature, emphasising they were not claiming a definitive discovery.
Their detection had reached a three-sigma level of statistical significance "which means there is still a three in 1,000 chance of this being a fluke," Madhusudhan said at the time.
Biosignatures 'Vanish'
Two of Madhusudhan's former students, Luis Welbanks of Arizona State University and Matthew Nixon of Maryland University, were among the researchers who have since re-analysed the data behind the announcement.
When deploying other statistical models, "claims of a potential biosignature detection vanish", according to their preprint study published online late last month.
Like the other papers since the April announcement, it has not been peer-reviewed.
In one model, Welbanks and colleagues expanded the number of possible chemicals that could explain the signals detected by Webb to 90 from the original 20.
More than 50 received a "hit", Welbanks told AFP.
"When you detect everything, did you really detect anything?" he asked.
They are not saying the planet definitely does not have DMS -- just that more observations are needed, Welbanks added.
'Arguments Are Healthy'
Madhusudhan welcomed the robust debate, saying that remaining open to all possibilities is an essential part of the scientific method.
"These sort of arguments are healthy," he told AFP.
His team even went further, releasing their own preprint study last week that expanded the number of chemicals even further to 650.
The three most "promising" chemicals they found included DMS but not DMDS -- a major part of the team's announcement in April.
The other two chemicals were diethyl sulfide and methyl acrylonitrile, the latter of which is toxic.
Madhusudhan admitted that these little-known chemicals are likely not "realistic molecules" for a planet like K2-18b.
Welbanks pointed out that "in the span of a month -- with no new data, with no new models, with no new laboratory data -- their entire analysis changed".
'Closest We Have Ever Been'
Telescopes observe such far-off exoplanets when they cross in front of their star, allowing astronomers to analyse how molecules block different wavelengths of light streaming through their atmosphere.
Earlier this week, a paper led by Rafael Luque at the University of Chicago combined Webb's observations of K2-18b in both the near-infrared and mid-infrared wavelengths of light.
It also found "no statistical significance for DMS or DMDS", the paper said.
An earlier paper by Oxford astrophysicist Jake Taylor using a basic statistical test also found no strong evidence for any biosignatures.
Madhusudhan dismissed the latter paper, saying the simple exercise did not account for observing physical phenomena.
He also stood by his research, saying he was "just as confident" in the work as he was a month ago.
More data about K2-18b will come in over the next year which should offer a much clearer picture, Madhusudhan added.
Even if the planet does have DMS, it is not a guarantee of life -- the chemical has been detected on a lifeless asteroid.
However, many researchers do believe that space telescopes could one day collect enough evidence to identify alien life from afar.
"We are the closest we have ever been" to such a moment, Welbanks said.
"But we have to use the frameworks that are in place and build up (evidence) in a reliable method, rather than using non-standard practices and jumping the gun -- as has been done in this particular case," Nixon added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
4 hours ago
- Hans India
James Webb Telescope captures first direct image of possible exoplanet TWA 7 b
For the first time, NASA's James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has captured a direct image of what scientists believe is an exoplanet—TWA 7 b—orbiting a young star located about 111 light-years from Earth in the constellation Hydra. The discovery, published in the journal Nature, marks a significant milestone for the JWST, which until now had primarily confirmed or studied exoplanets using indirect methods. Unlike typical techniques that rely on the dimming of a star's light when a planet passes in front of it, this new detection used JWST's coronagraph to block out the overwhelming glare of the star TWA 7, revealing a faint source of infrared light in its surrounding debris disk. 'This is the first time Webb has directly imaged an exoplanet, and the result is incredibly exciting,' says Anne-Marie Lagrange, lead author and astrophysicist at the French National Center for Scientific Research. 'The planet's position aligns exactly with predictions based on previous observations of gaps in the debris disk.' The object, TWA 7 b, is estimated to have a mass similar to Saturn's and a temperature around 120 degrees Fahrenheit. It resides within one of the disk's three dust rings, about 50 times farther from its star than Earth is from the Sun. The odds of it being a background galaxy are slim—only 0.34%—making it a strong planetary candidate. What makes this discovery even more remarkable is that TWA 7 b is roughly ten times lighter than any exoplanet previously imaged directly. It may also be the first planet observed actively shaping its star's surrounding debris disk—an insight that sheds light on how planetary systems like our own form and evolve. To confirm their findings, Lagrange's team ran simulations of the TWA 7 system. The models mirrored the Webb images almost exactly, reinforcing their confidence in the planetary nature of the object. 'This discovery is a testament to the power of JWST's instruments,' says co-author Mathilde Malin of the Space Telescope Science Institute. 'It opens the door to studying exoplanets that were previously out of reach, both in terms of their mass and distance from their host stars.'
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
James Webb captures first direct image of an exoplanet; key details inside
credit: In a groundbreaking moment for space exploration and technology, astronomers have captured the first-ever direct image of an exoplanet using the mighty James Webb Space Telescope. This is a significant achievement that marks a major leap in the ability of the world to study worlds beyond our solar system. There exists a more fascinating world, all waiting to be explored by us! The JWST has identified a faint source of infrared light in a disk of debris surrounding a young star, called TWA-7, approximately 34 light-years away from Earth. Their intelligent observations reveal that this planet is 10 times less massive than previous exoplanets to be directly observed with a telescope; the first was discovered back in 1992. But are we sure it is an exoplanet? What is the James Webb Space Telescope? Credit: canva JWST is one of NASA 's most powerful and advanced telescopes, launched back in December 2021. It doesn't orbit the Earth like other telescopes, but it orbits the Sun 1 million miles away from the Earth at what is called the L2 or second Lagrange point. Dr. Anne-Marie Lagrange, an astrophysicist at the French National Center for Scientific Research in Paris, quotes, 'The basic problem is that the star is bright and the planet seems to be a little faint.' Usually, the starlight outwits the planets, making them impossible to spot. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Adidas Three Shorts With 60% Discount, Limited Stock Available Original Adidas Shop Now Undo Dr. Anne, with all her colleagues, decided to focus on young stars that could be easily seen on the pole-on. The potential planet orbits roughly 50-52 times farther from its star than Earth is from the sun, and has a mass about one-third that of Jupiter's. Simulations of such an exoplanet in a dusty disk around a star produced images closely matching those from JWST. 'This was really why we were confident that there was a planet,' Lagrange says. What comes next? So, the team behind this magnificent discovery thinks that the JWST could soon be able to spot planets with just 10% of the mass of Jupiter, getting close to the size of Neptune. This groundbreaking discovery also gives scientists a roadmap for further space explorations and establishes ground-based telescopes that might detect even smaller and more Earth-like planets.
Hindustan Times
2 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Shubhanshu Shukla mission: How many astronauts have been to space?
India's Shubhanshu Shukla became the 634th astronaut to travel to space as he entered the International Space Station on Thursday after a 28-hour journey. This screen grab from a NASA+ broadcast on June 26, 2025, shows the Axiom Mission 4 crew inside the International Space Station's Harmony module.(AFP) Shukla and three other astronauts were formally welcomed on the space station by the members of Expedition 73 with warm hugs and handshakes. Axiom mission commander Peggy Whitson handed out astronaut pins to Shukla, Polish astronaut Slawosz Uznanski-Wisniewski and Hungarian Tibor Kapu, who marked their maiden voyage to space. "I am astronaut 634. It is a privilege to be here," Shukla said in brief remarks at the formal welcome ceremony on the space station. "With your love and blessings, I have reached the International Space Station. It looks easy to stand here, but my head is a little heavy, facing some difficulty; but these are minor issues," he said. "We will get used to it. This is the first step of this journey," he added. Shukla said over the next 14 days, he and the other astronauts will conduct scientific experiments and interact with people on Earth. "This is also a phase of India's space journey. I will keep talking to you. Let us make this journey exciting. I am carrying the tiranga and I am carrying all of you with me. The next 14 days will be exciting," he said. Shukla said the ride to the space station was wonderful and great and he was overwhelmed by the welcome he received from the crew of the orbital laboratory. "The minute I entered the International Space Station and met this crew, you just made me feel so welcome, as if you literally opened your doors, like your house doors, for us," he said. "That is true. It was fantastic. I just feel even better now. Whatever expectations I had of coming here were surpassed by the view, of course, that is a big part of it, but also by you guys," Shukla said. "So thank you so much. I think this is fantastic, this is wonderful and I am very confident that the next 14 days are going to be amazing, advancing science and research, and working together," he added.
