Investors stripping cash from water firms ‘criminal' says ex-Wessex Water chief
Colin Skellett, who helmed the south-west England utility from 1988 to 2024, argued against nationalising water companies because of the industry requiring 'continuous levels of investment'.
He spoke as campaigners and experts urged the Government to explore public ownership during the UK River Summit in south London on Tuesday.
Ministers have promised a 'fundamental reset' following years of companies paying out large dividend that diverted money away from infrastructure investment and maintenance, leading to sewage pollution and rising bills.
However, they have ruled out nationalisation and instead are focusing efforts on tightening rules, increasing investment and strengthening penalties within the current system of regulated private firms.
Minister Emma Hardy talking about tackling sewage with @RiverActionUK but the government is ignoring the reality:
7 European countries with highest average of 90%+ bathing sites achieving 'excellent' status – all are 90%+ publicly owned 🇨🇾🇦🇹🇬🇷🇲🇹🇭🇷🇩🇪🇩🇰 https://t.co/cH05zfLzC0 pic.twitter.com/d4dxz35bPV
— Cat Hobbs (@CatHobbs) July 8, 2025
Speaking at the summit, Mr Skellett said he has seen the industry change since he joined it in 1974, saying it is one that 'requires continuous levels of investment'.
'The problem with public ownership is the Government always has other things it wants to spend its money on,' the former Wessex boss said.
He argued that privatisation helped to get debt off the Government's balance sheet and boost investment but this changed when the 'wrong sort of investors' began stripping cash out of companies through high dividends.
'It was bloody criminal what happened – the amount of money that was stripped out of not just Thames (Water), but a number of companies,' he said.
'So we need that to change (in) the system. It's not so much about ownership, it's more about how you regulate it, how you control it, and how you make sure the investment continues.'
It came as the Environment Department (Defra) announced an increase in funding for the Environment Agency from £114 million in 2022/23 to £189 million this current financial year, a sum which is understood to have been welcomed by the regulator.
🚨REVEALED: Over half of adults in England don't trust the Government to end the UK's sewage crisis. And who can blame them?
💩 158,000+ sewage spills already this year.
📣 We're in London today, demanding the radical change we need. Are you with us?✊➡️ Email your MP today and… pic.twitter.com/rz02U8abgY
— Surfers Against Sewage (@sascampaigns) July 2, 2025
Ministers are also currently awaiting the publication of the independent water commission's final report and recommendations, led by Sir Jon Cunliffe, which is expected in two weeks.
The review is not exploring nationalisation as an option, with campaigners at the summit indicating they will continue to campaign on the issue following its publication.
Ewan McGaughey, professor of law at King's College London, argued that the Government should take away licences from failing water companies and transition them into a long-term sustainable model of public ownership, calling privatisation in England a 'broken model'.
Mr McGaughey said 90% of countries and cities around the world have water in public ownership and cited examples such as Berlin and Paris, which brought their sectors back into public ownership in 2013 and 2009 respectively after the privatised model failed.
'Bills go down. Water quality goes up. It's actually not really that controversial. You just have to look at the evidence, and you can see that public ownership works better,' he said.
Cat Hobbs, founder and We Own It, which campaigns for public ownership of public services, said the Government's decision to not allow the independent review to explore nationalisation is a 'scandal'.
'That has to change. They still have time to change it,' she said,
And Ashley Smith, founder of Windrush Against Sewage Pollution (WASP), called privatisation a 'ludicrous scam', arguing that there has never been a single year since the firms were privatised when shareholders put in more money than they took out of the firms.
Later, water minister Emma Hardy defended the Government's approach to reforming the sector.
'There's been a lack of sustained investment in the industry for an incredibly long time,' she told the summit.
'We have taken immediate action, but there are some things that, of course, are going to take longer to fix.
'We want to listen to you and we can have difference of opinion – that is absolutely fine but I want to make sure that we try and bring as many people with us as possible because fundamentally we're all trying to get to the same place and that place is an effective water system with reduced pollution which is better for customers and better for the environment.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Evening Standard
26 minutes ago
- Evening Standard
Ministers urged to explain plans which could re-establish Hong Kong extraditions
In a post on social media, she added: 'I urge the Government to give urgent reassurances on how this system will be safely managed and what protections will be put in place to ensure no Hong Konger, CCP critic or anyone targeted by the CCP will be extradited under the new arrangement.'
ITV News
26 minutes ago
- ITV News
Newry sandwich firm's multi-million pound investment creates jobs and upskills workforce
Some 130 jobs are to be created at a sandwich firm in Co Down. Deli Lites is planning a £12.8 million investment to automate the company's production and broaden its product range. The move is being supported by Invest NI's Agri-Food Investment Initiative, while a further £6 million investment by the company is to help upskill the existing workforce and create 130 jobs in Warrenpoint. The new jobs include senior positions such as a new chief commercial officer. Deli Lites was established in 1998 by husband and wife Brian and Jackie Reid and supplies fresh gourmet sandwiches and food-to-go products to convenience stores, supermarkets, major coffee chains and international airlines. Its customers include Applegreen, Costa Coffee, Aer Lingus and American Airlines. Economy Minister Caoimhe Archibald hailed the investment. 'The north's food and drink processing sector is a true local success story, with latest statistics showing that it generates £6.5 billion in sales and supports over 25,500 jobs across our towns and countryside,' she said. 'This investment will unlock significant growth opportunities for Deli Lites in this exciting sector. 'Increased capacity and new automated equipment will boost productivity and enable it to expand its fresh and frozen ranges, growing its sales in Britain and Ireland, and open up additional export markets. 'With 78% of our food and drink sold outside the north, this industry showcases the quality, innovation, and global appeal of what we produce right here at home. 'The creation of 130 new jobs in Warrenpoint, which will help leverage almost £10 million in wages and salaries across the Newry, Mourne and Down District Council area by 2027, is also good news as we work to deliver a more regionally balanced economy.' Brian Reid, chief executive at Deli Lites, said: 'Since our beginnings over 30 years ago, we are now an all-Ireland business with export sales growing in international markets. 'We've always been a trailblazer in our sector, shown when we became the first sandwich maker in the UK and Ireland to achieve B Corp certification.' Jackie Reid, co-founder and CSO at Deli Lites, said: 'Bringing even more products to our snacking and convenience range and investing in production and automation will significantly increase our capacity and customer reach. 'We're delighted to be growing our team in Warrenpoint to bring further expertise into the business and help us achieve our vision, to transform how the world experiences food on the move.' Grainne Moody, director of food and drink at Invest NI, said the project builds on its previous support for the firm to develop its product range for the European market. 'Its success has positioned the company to become a key supplier for the global airlines sector,' she said. 'This new project will increase innovation and boost productivity by transforming labour-intensive processes and increasing digitalisation.
Reuters
27 minutes ago
- Reuters
Ghana narrows fiscal deficit target after better-than-expected first half
ACCRA, July 24 (Reuters) - Ghana has narrowed its fiscal deficit target for 2025 after a better-than-expected first six months of the year, its finance minister said on Thursday, pledging to get public finances back on track. The West African country is emerging from its worst economic crisis in a generation, featuring turmoil in its cocoa and gold industries, a severe cost-of-living squeeze and a lengthy debt-restructuring process. But this year, key macroeconomic indicators have improved, with growth accelerating to 5.3% year-on-year in the first quarter and inflation falling to 13.7% in June, its lowest since 2021. The government now expects a fiscal deficit of 3.8% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) this year, narrower than the 4.1% targeted in March, Finance Minister Cassiel Ato Forson told parliament during a mid-year review of public finances. In the first six months the deficit was 1.1% of GDP, ahead of the 2.4% targeted. Forson said economic growth could possibly exceed the March target of 4% and officials were hopeful they could hit the year-end inflation target of 11.9% ahead of schedule. "We have borrowed less than we planned, signifying strong expenditure control and fiscal discipline," Forson said. "This is a strong signal to the investor community and all stakeholders that the needed fiscal consolidation is happening here in Ghana and it will be sustained." In the first half of the year, total revenue and grants were roughly 3% short of target, but expenditure came in 14% below target. Forson said risks to the public purse included a shortfall in customs revenue, mounting wage pressures and smuggling of marine gas oil, adding Ghana was not out of the woods yet.
