Dispute between nurse Sandie Peggie and transgender doctor Beth Upton posed 'no risk to patients'
Nurse Sandie Peggie was suspended after she objected to having to share a changing room with Dr Beth Upton at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023.
Ms Peggie was placed on special leave and then suspended after the doctor made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about "patient care".
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation.
Service manager Lottie Myles told the tribunal on Monday she perceived the dispute which led to Ms Peggie being suspended as a "she said/she said" situation, and there was "nobody who could provide evidence".
Ms Myles said she was tasked with conducting a suspension review on 27 February 2024, and was told by the nurse's manager, Esther Davidson, that Ms Peggie was "anti-trans" and "had transphobic views because of an incident that occurred in the changing room".
She said Ms Davidson alleged Ms Peggie had "some gender critical beliefs" alongside others that "may not be everybody's belief", an hour before a suspension review meeting.
However, Ms Myles said she was not given any documentation to examine prior to the review.
Jane Russell KC, counsel for NHS Fife, asked about these "other beliefs".
Ms Myles said: "There was views that Sandie was homophobic and there were elements of racism in her beliefs. It's hearsay. I try to disregard views which haven't been documented or there's little evidence of."
She noted Ms Peggie referred to Dr Upton using "male terminology", but said she believed Ms Peggie's feelings about Dr Upton were "circumstantial", and later challenged why allegations she branded "hearsay" had not been documented or escalated.
Ms Myles said: "I think Sandie probably wasn't too happy with Dr Upton, but I think that was more from the incident which had happened.
"In summary notes, I had asked if she was to treat a patient who was transgender, would she treat them differently. I was reassured she said she wouldn't treat anyone trans differently; I felt that it was circumstantial."
Ms Russell asked for Ms Myles's views on how Ms Peggie "might deal with transgender patients" after a suspension review meeting on 7 March 2024.
Ms Myles replied: "I felt reassured she wouldn't treat them differently. Sandie has been a nurse for 30 years, I'm sure in that time she has dealt with transgender patients. I felt there were no safety concerns."
She said she referred to the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) code, including on freedom of expression, and the Equality Act 2010 which she described as a "grey area in a lot of workplaces", and said there were "several reasons" why she lifted the suspension.
Ms Myles said: "I wanted to be sure I wouldn't be treating either party in breach of the Equality Act. I wanted to have Dr Upton and Sandie Peggie treated fairly and equally."
She said a meeting between herself, Ms Peggie and Royal College of Nursing (RCN) representative Stuart Fraser was "very difficult" and "emotional" for Ms Peggie, who was determined to return to the emergency department rather than be moved to another department managed by Ms Myles.
Ms Myles said: "I wanted both parties to be treated fairly and equally. The situation was 'she said/she said', we were limited on witnesses and things being documented."
Ms Myles said a return to work would be "beneficial" for Ms Peggie, and that she wanted to "make it as seamless as possible", after discussions about moving departments and moving on to dayshifts were both rejected.
Ms Myles said she was aware of reports of "negative interactions", which she branded "hearsay".
She said: "I actually challenged that by saying, 'why wasn't this documented? Why wasn't it escalated?'
"Nobody could confirm, but I felt that was hearsay. I felt that to try to prevent any other allegations from happening, having a senior team member on duty would be supportive for her."
Ms Myles said it was agreed to put the pair on "opposite shifts" and for Ms Peggie to be supervised during a phased return, describing it as a "compromise".
Ms Myles said her involvement ceased around 19 April at the request of head of nursing Gillian Malone, and she had no role in the investigation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 minutes ago
- The Independent
New research exposes the risk of store-bought self-test kits
Researchers from the University of Birmingham have warned that high street self-tests for conditions like vitamin deficiencies, menopause, and bowel cancer may not be fit for purpose. A review of 30 self-tests found many lacked crucial information on who should use them, how to interpret results, or what actions to take afterwards. Concerns were raised about the accuracy claims of these tests, with evidence often being unavailable or of low quality, and 18 tests were deemed "high risk". Experts, including Professor Kristien Boelaert, highlighted the potential for "false reassurance" and increased demand on the NHS due to these unregulated products. Calls have been made for urgent, tighter regulation of the booming self-test market, which is projected to reach £660m by 2030 in the UK.
BBC News
4 minutes ago
- BBC News
New cancer pain relief procedure becomes available in Leeds
A new procedure to reduce pain for cancer patients has been carried out in Yorkshire for the first time. Leslie Thompson, 79, was the first person in the region to undergo the treatment, at St James' Hospital in procedure, which is being offered to some terminally ill cancer patients, involves heating up nerves at the top of the spinal cord to permanently relieve the pain on the affected side of the body. Mr Thompson, from Yeadon, said he thought the treatment was a "good idea", having suffered "unbelievable" pain from lung cancer. Leeds has become the fourth centre in the UK to offer the procedure, after London, Glasgow and Liverpool. NHS bosses said eligible patients from across Yorkshire will no longer have to travel as far for the after the procedure, Mr Thompson said: "I feel less pain in my lung. I think it's a good idea and it will help a lot of other people. "The pain you get with cancer is unbelievable and it affects lots of people." While the nerves responsible for causing the pain are burnt in the neck, patients still retain their ability to walk and move around afterwards. The procedure involves using a radiofrequency generator, and needles which heat up and burn the nerves on the opposite side of the neck to where the pain is treatment is only suitable for patients who have pain on one side of the body and are well enough to benefit from the procedure, according to the NHS. Dr Sheila Black, consultant in anaesthesia and pain management at Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, said the procedure would make the last weeks and months of a patient's life "more comfortable". She said: "I asked Leslie after the procedure: "How is your pain?" and he said: "What pain?". That's really wonderful to hear."Lots of the other treatments we have for pain have side effects, like morphine, which can cause sickness and constipation and sometimes still not help relieve the pain." Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Daily Mirror
34 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
People born between 2000 and 2009 urged to get lifesaving jab
Experts have expressed concern as uptake of the vaccine has declined People born between certain years are being urged to come forward for a 'lifesaving' vaccine. The NHS is appealing to hundreds of thousands of young people who have yet to receive the crucial human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine. This jab can protect you against cervical and other forms of cancer. GP surgeries throughout England will be dispatching vaccine invitations to patients born between 2000 and 2009 (meaning they are aged 16 to 25) whose records indicate they missed their HPV vaccination at school. The vaccine is routinely administered annually to boys and girls in year 8 (aged 12 to 13) to safeguard them from contracting the HPV infection - which is responsible for nearly all cervical cancers and is associated with cancers of the mouth, throat, anus, penis and vagina. If anyone misses the jab, NHS teams conduct school catch-up visits and organise community clinics for home-schooled children. However, over the past three years alone, more than 418,000 children left school without receiving the HPV vaccination. It's believed there are many others now aged 16 to 25 who were not vaccinated at school. Therefore, NHS leaders aim to reach as many of these individuals as possible. That is in line with plans to eradicate cervical cancer by 2040 as outlined in the recently published 10 Year Health Plan. The NHS intends to increase uptake among girls to 90 per cent by 2040, whilst also boosting the number of women undergoing cervical screening. During the 2023/24 academic year, vaccination rates for 14 to 15-year-olds reached 76.7 per cent for girls and 71.2 per cent for boys by year 10. There was also a rise in uptake among year 8 pupils compared to the previous year, with 72.9 per cent of girls and 67.7 per cent of boys receiving the vaccine in 2023/24, up from 71.3 per cent and 65.2 per cent respectively for the first dose in 2022/23. Prior to 2023, two doses were necessary. Dr Amanda Doyle, national director of primary care and community services, said: "This vaccine is hugely important in our fight to eradicate cervical cancer but it isn't just for girls and women – it's also vital for boys and men to get vaccinated to protect themselves against cancers of the mouth, throat or genitals, while preventing spreading the HPV infection to sexual partners who could then develop cervical cancer. "Too many lives are lost to cervical cancer so the hard work of NHS staff across the country in vaccinating and screening as many people as possible will help us to meet our ambition of wiping out this disease. Encouraging progress has been made recently in increasing uptake but we know there is much more to do. "So if you're eligible for a HPV vaccination or are the parent of a child who is eligible, but didn't get the vaccine at school when they had the chance, I would urge you to come forward when your GP contacts you. Only a single dose is required and it could save you or your child's life." Public Health and Prevention Minister Ashley Dalton added: "The HPV vaccine is our most powerful tool in our fight to eliminate cervical cancer by 2040. But we've got a long way to go. Thousands of young people are still unvaccinated and vulnerable to this disease – which is so easily prevented. "If you missed your vaccination at school, it's not too late. Don't hesitate to make an appointment with your GP. One jab could save your life." The vaccine is also available to people up to the age of 45 with compromised immune systems and men who engage in sexual activity with other men. The most recent HPV vaccine, launched in England in 2021, has demonstrated increased effectiveness. It's projected to decrease instances of women's cancer by 16 per cent and HPV-related fatalities by nine per cent, compared to its predecessor. Research conducted in England indicates that the HPV vaccine prevents 90 per cent of cervical cancer cases. Just last month, the NHS initiated a new 'ping and book' service, sending digital invitations and reminders for cervical screenings via the NHS App.
