Two police officers who used taster on one-legged man cleared of assault
Two police officers who used a Taser and synthetic pepper spray on a one-legged 92-year-old man have been cleared of assault.
Pc Stephen Smith, 51, and Pc Rachel Comotto, 36, were accused of using excessive force on Donald Burgess during a confrontation at Park Beck care home in St Leonards-on-Sea, East Sussex, in June 2022.
Jurors returned their unanimous verdicts on both Sussex Police officers at Southwark Crown Court after around two hours of deliberations on Wednesday.
They found Smith not guilty of two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm for his use of Pava spray and for using a baton, whilst Comotto was found not guilty of one count for deploying her Taser.
Both officers will however face proceedings for gross misconduct, Assistant Chief Constable Paul Court, from Sussex Police, said in a statement he delivered outside court.
He said: 'I would like to acknowledge how incredibly difficult this period must have been for Mr Burgess's family and I offer them my sincere condolences.
'I recognise and understand the impact that this case has had on public confidence.
'It is with profound regret this happened.
'Police officers can find themselves in challenging and unpredictable situations where they must make split-second decisions to keep the public safe, and to do so with measure, compassion and skill.
'We support them to do this and this is what our communities expect.
'Use of force must be reasonable, necessary and proportionate and officers know they will be held accountable every time.
'The officers in this case have been held accountable to a criminal threshold and we respect the jury's decision.
'While this concludes the criminal investigation, both officers will now face gross misconduct proceedings.'
The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) said that both officers should face a gross misconduct hearing for potential breaches of the police standards of professional behaviour relating to use of force, and authority, respect and courtesy, with Pc Comotto facing a further misconduct allegation relating to comments she made on social media after the incident.
The watchdog said it would liaise with Sussex Police about the misconduct hearings now that criminal proceedings are over.
IOPC director Emily Barry said: 'Our thoughts and sympathies remain with the family of Donald Burgess.
'We know this case – including the police body-worn footage that was released during the trial – has caused understandable concern in the community.
'It was right that the evidence was put before a jury so the officers could be held accountable and we respect the jury's decision.'
The care home had called 999 after Mr Burgess, a single-leg amputee and wheelchair user, reportedly grabbed a knife he was given to cut his food and threatened to stab staff.
The court previously heard this was 'out of character' for Mr Burgess, whose movements with the knife were described by deputy care home manager Donna Gardner as 'extremely quick'.
'The reason for his behaviour that day, we now know, is that he was delirious as a result of a urinary tract infection,' judge Christopher Hehir told jurors.
Smith sprayed synthetic Pava pepper spray into Mr Burgess's face and used his baton to try and knock the knife out of Mr Burgess's hand, with Comotto deploying her Taser, all within a minute and 23 seconds of entering the wheelchair-bound pensioner's room.
Mr Burgess was taken to hospital after the incident and later contracted Covid.
He died 22 days later aged 93.
Care home manager Steve Cooper previously told jurors Burgess had been threatening staff for more than 30 minutes with a serrated knife before they decided to call 999.
'He was very aggressive and threatening to hurt my members of staff, ' he told the court.
'We tried to use different de-escalation techniques. He wasn't responding to anything we said.
'He had a look in his eyes I've never seen before – he wasn't the Donald I knew.'
He said Mr Burgess jabbed the knife towards him and told him: 'I'm going to murder you, and I'll enjoy it.'
The court heard both Smith and Comotto repeatedly asked Mr Burgess to drop the knife, with Smith warning him: 'Put the knife down mate, or you will be sprayed or tasered. That's up to you.'
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Footage from body-worn cameras played to the jury during the trial showed Smith then discharging the spray directly into Mr Burgess's face.
Mr Burgess then raised the knife a couple of times as Smith uses his baton to try and get the knife out of his hand.
When this failed, Comotto deployed her Taser.
Pc Smith previously told jurors he did not see that Mr Burgess was disabled and using a wheelchair until after the incident as he was focused on the knife the pensioner was holding in his hand.
He added he believed Mr Burgess 'could clearly understand what we were saying to him' as Mr Burgess reportedly asked 'Are there many more of them coming?' – suggesting he was aware Smith and Comotto were police officers.
During his evidence, Pc Smith also denied hitting Mr Burgess with a baton, claiming he instead flicked the baton towards the pensioner's wrist to 'knock the knife out' of his hand.
Smith said: 'The way he had been threatening staff members – the threat was the knife, to the staff there and also to himself.
'I just wanted the knife out of the gent's hand.'
During her evidence, Pc Comotto said she believed using the Taser was the safest way to 'protect' Mr Burgess as she feared her colleague using the baton again would cause more harm.
She added she knew from her training the risk of injury to Mr Burgess was higher with a baton than with a Taser.
She said: 'It was proportionate because other tactics had failed. If I didn't act, something worse could happen.'
'I'm not a trigger-happy officer,' she added. 'It's the first time I've fired my Taser.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
5 hours ago
- BBC News
Crawley stabbing: Boy, 17, charged with wounding with intent
A 17-year-old boy has been charged with wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm after another boy, also 17, was stabbed in services were called to Martyrs Avenue in Langley Green at around 21:50 BST on 17 July, to reports of a victim was taken to hospital where he remains in a stable condition, Sussex Police suspect has also been charged with possession of a bladed article and making threats with a bladed article in a public place, the force confirmed. He has been remanded into police custody to appear at Crawley Magistrates' Court on Monday.A 37-year-old woman from Crawley, who was arrested on suspicion of assisting an offender, has been released on bail, said Sussex Imran Asghar said: "We understand the impact this incident has had on the local community and their concerns. "We take any such offences of this nature very seriously and we have been working tirelessly to investigate and bring those responsible to account."Our officers remain in the area to offer reassurance and to help, so if you have any concerns please do not hesitate to approach them."Police appealed for witnesses and anyone with information or relevant footage to contact the force.
BBC News
17 hours ago
- BBC News
PC to face misconduct hearing over alleged Lincoln assault
A police officer who was cleared of assaulting a man while attempting to catch a thief will face a misconduct hearing, his force has said. Last year, PC Alan Kirkwood was found not guilty during a trial at Nottingham Crown Court of assaulting Scott Barratt in 2023 after mistaking him for a robber and allegedly kicking him in the the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) has told Lincolnshire Police to bring misconduct charges against the long-standing officer.A Lincolnshire Police spokesperson confirmed "arrangements are in hand for a hearing" following the police watchdog's review. No date has been set. According to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, the court was told PC Kirkwood had been knocked to the ground while chasing two men on Danesgate, Lincoln, on 3 January then allegedly mistook Mr Barratt, who was walking his dogs, for one of the suspects and pointed his Taser at ordered him to get on the ground and then allegedly kicked him in the said PC Kirkwood quickly realised his mistake and later apologised to Mr jury took a short time to clear the officer of assault occasioning actual bodily James Sampson described him as "a man of exemplary character".Lincolnshire Police found there was no potential misconduct after the Mr Barratt appealed to the IOPC, which has instructed the force to bring Barratt's solicitor Iain Gould said it was important that forces properly policed themselves. Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here. Download the BBC News app from the App Store for iPhone and iPad or Google Play for Android devices
Scottish Sun
2 days ago
- Scottish Sun
Musician stabbed in the chest on street by mentally-ill girl, 14, who ‘slept with knife under her pillow', inquest hears
The teenager had stabbed her mother in the leg, tried to burn down her building and assaulted police officers in the months leading up to the fatal attack KNIFE TRAGEDY Musician stabbed in the chest on street by mentally-ill girl, 14, who 'slept with knife under her pillow', inquest hears A TALENTED musician died after being stabbed in his chest by a mentally-ill teenage girl who slept with a knife under her pillow, an inquest has heard. Nimroy Hendricks, 24, was chased down a street and fatally stabbed by the 14-year-old girl in West Sussex in 2020. He collapsed on the road and was later pronounced dead at the scene, despite the best efforts of paramedics to save his life. The teenager - who was known to be vulnerable and was on a Child Protection Plan - had been flagged as posing a "high risk", often "carrying a knife" around with her. Eight months before attacking Nimroy, the girl - who can only be identified as Child A because of court-imposed reporting restrictions - had stabbed her mother in the leg, tried to burn down her building and assaulted police officers. Frederick Powell, the barrister representing Nimroys' relatives, told West Sussex Coroner's Court that the teen had "been known to carry knives and on occasions slept with a knife under her pillow". Child A lived with her mum at the property in West Sussex, with the family having recently moved from Birmingham. Just four days before the fatal attack, Child A had gone missing from the home. Although police were able to find her, she was unable to return home as her mum was away in London. However, instead of placing her into protective custody, she was instead allowed to stay with a woman who claimed to be her "cousin". The woman was not a relative and was in-fact known to police as she had criminal convictions and was a known drug user. Coroner Penelope Schofield said cops had failed to verify whether the woman was a relative of the teenager - instead leaving Child A on the side of the road at 2am with a stranger. She said: 'The police did not physically attend the address given to them and therefore did not realise this person was not a relative.' Ms Schofield also said social services had failed to hold an emergency strategy meeting which had been organised when the child went missing. She said that as a result 'There was no opportunity to put in place additional safeguarding measures. It is possible that had these matters been addressed, the perpetrator may not have been in a position to carry out the act which led to Mr Hendrick's death.' The coroner also ruled that failings by Sussex Police and social services at West Sussex County Council may have contributed to the death of the 'peaceful and loving' musician. The inquest heard that Child A's mum had told an earlier investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct that she had been advised by social services to stay away. Mr Powell said "because the threat to him [Nimroy] was never properly assessed, he was never told he shouldn't go to the property". Nimroy, who was in a relationship with the girl's mum, had gone to the flat to collect work tools when he found the interior had been "annihilated", following an outburst by the teen. After finding the flat in disarray, he angrily banged on the girl's bedroom door. He then left the home and was making his way towards a nearby train station when the girl chased him down the street, confronting him. She then stabbed him once in the chest, telling a bystander: "I've stabbed Nim," as she calmly walked away. Child A - who had a long criminal record - was then arrested by police and later judged to be suffering form a "significant abnormality of mind". 'THE POLICE AND AUTHORITIES FAILED' Speaking after the inquest his parents Nimroy Hendricks Snr and Lisa Hendricks said their son had been failed but they were relieved by the coroner's findings. Lisa said: 'Nim should never have been put in the position he was. The authorities were well aware of the risk posed by the child.' She said the impact on the family had been shattered by his death and accused the police and social services of trying to cover up their errors. Mr Hendricks said: 'The police and authorities failed, they failed in every sense of the word.' The inquest in Horsham, West Sussex, heard the 14-year-old girl had a history of violence and suffered from mental health problems. She had been diagnosed with PTSD and a split personality disorder, had a criminal record and had previously attacked police. The hearing was told the girl had suffered a 'turbulent' childhood and had been the repeated victim of sexual assault, sex abuse and child sexual exploitation which had compounded her mental health condition. Mr Powell said Nim had never been told the risk of violence from the girl. He said: 'Nim was overlooked. He was never told of the risk this child posed. He was in a blindspot due to the failure of examining what was known.' Paying tribute to her son, his mum Lisa said Nim was a hugely loving child and man and a talented musician. She said: 'He was a leader and a performer. He loved books and reading. He was confident, happy and inquisitive. 'He was a joy to us. He loved the environment, the mountains and being close to the sea.'
