Dr. Brian Day's clinic to pay B.C.'s trial costs after failed private health lawsuit
Cambie Surgeries Corp. — owned by private health-care advocate Dr. Brian Day — launched a lawsuit back in 2009. It claimed B.C.'s Medicare Protection Act was unconstitutionally preventing people from getting private health care when the public system was unable to provide it.
The B.C. Supreme Court, the B.C. Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada all shot down the private surgery clinic's case, but the issue of trial costs was left in the air.
WATCH | Dr. Brian Day says the patients are left suffering:
Dr. Brian Day discusses Supreme Court's dismissal of his case
2 years ago
Duration 1:14
B.C. Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Lynn Whately ruled Monday that Cambie Surgeries should pay the attorney general of British Columbia's trial costs, calling the long-running litigation "prodigiously lengthy and complex."
The ruling says the lawsuit by Cambie Surgeries was being funded by the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
The ruling doesn't specify the province's costs, but the foundation said last year the B.C. government was seeking $1.7 million from the charitable foundation and "its partners."
The court ruling says the government argued that Cambie Surgeries was a "well-resourced" party that had a financial stake in the outcome of the case, rather than a public-interest litigant going to bat for patients let down by the public health-care system.
It says the B.C. government claimed the private clinic was making "tens of millions" in profit by violating the public health-care protection law.
The judge found that Cambie Surgeries' financial interest in winning the case "likely preclude them from being considered true public interest litigants."
Whately found that the case "involved matters of great importance to all British Columbians, not only in a legal sense, but in terms of the practical, day-to-day impact on access to health care, the funding of health-care services, and the principles that uphold our public health-care system."
The private clinic said the case involved "novel" legal issues and assessing the "government's constitutional obligations to provide public health care within a reasonable time, and the 'practical consequences' that must be associated to the failure to do so."
Both sides tried to blame one another for the case dragging on, with the attorney general of B.C. citing "egregious" conduct around document disclosure, experts and witnesses while pursuing a meritless claim under the Charter.
Cambie Surgeries and the other plaintiffs, on the other hand, said the B.C. government had its "own 'massive' shortcomings in document disclosure and production, and that it derailed the litigation process.
The case eventually went to trial in 2016 and spanned four years before the B.C. Supreme Court ruled against Cambie Surgeries. That decision was upheld by the B.C. Court of Appeal, before the Supreme Court of Canada denied leave for a further appeal.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
2 days ago
- Global News
Nearly 30K people gave up on waiting and walked out of Island Health ERs last year
Patients in British Columbia's Island Heatlh region are the most likely to walk away from an emergency room without seeing a doctor. That's one of the takeaways of new data highlighting just how much pressure the province's ERs are facing. According to the provincial numbers, 142,000 people walked away from B.C. hospital ERs before they received treatment. The number was highest in Island Health, where nearly 30,000 people gave up on waiting. The data was obtained by the opposition BC Conservative Party through a freedom of information request. 'We know people are leaving ERs because of long wait times — but we hadn't any idea how many,' said Courtenay-Comox MLA and opposition critic for rural health Brennan Day. 2:11 People leaving ER without care on the rise, stats show 'Certainly, the numbers we got back reflected what British Columbians have been telling us and that's ERs are in crisis here in B.C..' Story continues below advertisement The data shows that B.C. ER walk-aways are up 86 per cent in the last six years. In the Island Health region, the increase is a staggering 160 per cent. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'We need a change in culture, I think, in the health authorities more than anything,' Day said. 'We need to start prioritizing front-line patient delivery versus protecting the system for the sake of protecting the system.' In a statement, Island Health said it has recently launched a website where people can track estimated emergency room wait times. It added that it had recruited almost 1,800 net new employees last year, including more than 800 nurses. The B.C. Nurses' Union questioned those figures. 'I would ask, how many have left? How many vacant lines do you actually have in emergency? What is your percentage of emergency qualified nurses? Because I think there is much more to understand the context of the situation,' union president Adrian Gear said. 'This isn't just an Island Health concern — this is a provincial concern.' Gear said B.C.'s emergency rooms have become a 'pressure cooker' in part because so many people don't have access to primary care in the form of a family doctor or nurse practitioners, and end up relying on ERs when they get sick. Story continues below advertisement Health Minister Josie Osborne was not available for an interview. 'The number of patients leaving the emergency department is a small proportion of the total number of visits,' she said in a statement.
Cision Canada
3 days ago
- Cision Canada
BC Association of Clinical Counsellors (BCACC) records 10,000 members
More Registered Clinical Counsellors (RCCs) are expected to address growing demand for mental health services in BC VICTORIA, BC , July 24, 2025 /CNW/ - Memberships to the BC Association of Clinical Counsellors (BCACC) have crossed 10,000, marking a significant step towards addressing the growing demand for mental health services in the province. "Access to mental health care can change lives, and it starts with people who care deeply," said Amna Shah , Parliamentary Secretary for Mental Health and Addictions. "Reaching 10,000 members is a powerful milestone for the BC Association of Clinical Counsellors and a reflection of their commitment to walking alongside people on their healing journeys. Thank you for the care, strength, and hope you bring to communities across the province." Currently, the association's Registered Clinical Counsellors (RCCs) comprise 90% of clinical counsellors and psychotherapists in BC, making it the largest association for the profession. Since its formation in 1988, the association has advocated for improved public access to mental health care and enhanced public protection. To earn the title of Registered Clinical Counsellor (RCC), members must meet rigorous academic, clinical, and professional standards and commit to upholding BCACC's standards of practice and code of ethics. BCACC members also include over 1,000 student members. BCACC CEO, Michael Radano says "This milestone reflects the strong and growing professional community of psychotherapists in BC, and that clinical counselling and psychotherapy is a trusted and essential service for British Columbians. We hope that this continued growth helps to make mental health services more accessible in BC. I would like to congratulate the members, our board, and staff on this achievement. We look forward to collaborating with partner associations, organisations, and governments and lending our expertise as we move towards regulation" A rising demand for mental health services 5.7 million people call British Columbia home. According to the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA), by age 40, 50% of the population will have experienced a mental illness, and 1 in 5 experience mental health problems annually. The incidence of mental health issues has also been rising, particularly since the COVID-19 pandemic. It is estimated that approximately 1.25 million British Columbians may seek psychotherapy or clinical counselling annually. Many individuals face long wait times, cost restrictions, and insufficient coverage. The addition of more RCCs is expected to bridge this gap and address the growing demand for quality mental health services. The BCACC engages its membership to educate the public on mental health through free public presentations called 'Matters of the Mind' on a variety of topics aimed at increasing knowledge and awareness. Additionally, BCACC's 'Find a Counsellor' tool allows the public to find a suitable clinician by filtering for modality, gender, cultural background, specializations, availability, session style, and more. The tool currently records approximately 125,000 visits a year. In addition, the association maintains a public registry, publishes public notifications, and has a detailed inquiry process to protect the public and maintain accountability. The BCACC is currently preparing for its annual conference scheduled from September 19-20, 2025 in Vancouver. BCACC: The BC Association of Clinical Counsellors (BCACC) is a not-for-profit provincial professional association founded in 1988 with more than 10,000 members. BCACC advocates for the clinical counselling/psychotherapy profession and public access to mental health services. Its 9000+ Registered Clinical Counsellors (RCCs) are held to the highest standards of practice and a strict code of ethics in service and protection of the public which includes a robust complaint, inquiry, and remedial process. SOURCE BC Association of Clinical Counsellors For media enquiries, contact Joshua Karunakaran: Manager - PR & Communications, [email protected]
Vancouver Sun
4 days ago
- Vancouver Sun
Man on B.C. wait-list gets surgery in Florida, but court rejects effort to make province pay
A B.C. man who waited months for surgery during COVID-19 got the operation in Florida instead, but has lost his legal battle to make the province cover the medical bills. The judge sided with B.C.'s health minister and attorney general, two health authorities and the man's B.C. doctor, who asked the court to throw out the lawsuit. The patient, Vincent Jonckeau, acted as his own lawyer, arguing his rights to life, liberty and security of the person as guaranteed under Section 7 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms were infringed on by the wait. But the defendants argued during a one-day hearing that the lawsuit was based on an incorrect interpretation of constitutional rights because — by demanding that B.C. pay for the U.S. surgery — it sought to 'impose positive obligations on government.' Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. 'It is argued that Section 7 imposes no such obligations,' wrote Justice Alison Latimer. The Fraser Health Authority, the Providence Health Care Society and Dr. Adrienne Melck also argued that they aren't state actors and so aren't subject to the Charter, according to the judgment. 'Specifically, Dr. Melck argues that managing a wait list and making medical decisions are not governmental actions and therefore the Charter does not apply to her,' it said. Jonckeau in 2021 was awaiting surgery for his primary aldosteronism, or Conn's syndrome, an endocrine condition that causes dizziness, vertigo, mental fog and fatigue, but Melck said he needed a radiologist to perform adrenal vein sampling before surgery to remove an adrenal gland, Latimer wrote. The wait in mid-2021 for the sampling was nine months at Royal Columbian Hospital. But in January 2022 he was told that because of COVID, those registered in October 2021 wouldn't get the procedure until December 2022, according to the judgment. With his symptoms worsening, Jonckeau contacted a doctor in Tampa Bay in February 2022, and was told he didn't need the sampling, it said. Melck wouldn't perform the surgery without the sampling and said she couldn't insist to Royal Columbian Hospital that his case was more urgent than others. In April 2022, Jonckeau paid an undisclosed amount for an MRI and the surgery at the Tampa Bay Hospital and spent one night there, it said. About a year later, he learned he had never been added to the Royal Columbian waiting list, Latimer wrote. In August 2022, he submitted a claim for a refund to B.C.'s medical services plan. But Melck ignored his request to fill out the necessary form approving the out-of-country service, it said. Latimer called Jonckeau's lawsuit a 'species of claim which has been repeatedly rejected by the courts.' She agreed with the defendants' arguments, including that the Charter doesn't apply to Melck's actions. Latimer said the Hospital Insurance Act says anyone who leaves the province for treatment is only entitled to reimbursement if he had 'prior written approval to do so' from the B.C. government, and if the procedure is not available in B.C. and should be. Jonckeau couldn't be reached for comment.
