Irish man claims State has ‘abandoned' his child in Poland, court filings show
High Court
proceedings against the Government over its perceived failure to intervene in locating his young daughter, whose mother moved her to
Poland
without his consent.
Irish authorities said they are aware of the case and have 'provided extensive consular assistance'.
An Irish man and a Polish woman are involved in a legal battle over where their daughter should receive care for a number of medical conditions,
as previously reported by The Irish Times
.
According to medical records, the girl, who is 3½ years old, is
autistic
and suspected to have epilepsy.
READ MORE
The couple, who are married but estranged, previously lived together in Ireland before the mother moved back to Poland with their daughter in March 2024.
In May 2025, a Polish court ruled that the young girl, who was born in Ireland and is an Irish citizen, should be brought back to Ireland as the mother relocated her to Poland without her father's consent.
The father made a number of attempts to return his daughter to Ireland in June and July but has been unable to confirm her whereabouts. He recently lodged legal proceedings against the
Department of the Taoiseach
, the
Department of Justice
and the
Department of Foreign Affairs
.
The father claims the Irish Government has 'abandoned' his daughter by failing to help locate her. He also believes The Hague Convention, one of the main legal frameworks for dealing with international child abduction cases, is 'completely and utterly inadequate'.
Irish authorities said they are aware of the legal proceedings but cannot comment on the specifics of the case.
A spokeswoman said the Department of Foreign Affairs was 'aware of this case and has provided extensive consular assistance' but, as with all consular cases, cannot 'comment on the details of individual cases'.
Both Ireland and Poland are signed up to The Hague Convention. As part of the convention, each country has a central authority that facilitates the return of abducted children to the country of their habitual residence. In Ireland, this body falls under the remit of Department of Justice.
A spokesman for the department said the central authority
'provides assistance to parents and guardians of children who have been removed from the jurisdiction without their consent' and communicates 'any updates or requests for information between an applicant and the authorities of the other state'.
The spokesman said 'any administrative and judicial measures required to decide on the return of a child are taken by the authorities in the contracting state that the child has been taken to' – in this instance, Poland.
'The Irish central authority is not involved in the legal proceedings of the other country. It relies on the authorities of the other state to progress the application through their institutions and to keep it informed of any developments or advise it of any information required from the applicant.'
A department or minister 'cannot intervene in private, civil or international legal matters which are the subject of court proceedings either in Ireland or another jurisdiction', the spokesman added.
The father said he had not seen his daughter in person in several months and was becoming increasingly concerned Polish authorities cannot confirm her whereabouts.
The mother's legal case centres on her belief their daughter will receive better treatment in Poland.
She told The Irish Times the child is 'safe and continues to receive appropriate medical care.
'Due to her health needs, we are currently focusing on her ongoing treatment, and I'm doing everything I can as a mother to protect her stability and wellbeing,' the mother said. 'She is currently taking new medications, and her condition remains serious, which means she cannot leave Poland at this time.'
There are
significant delays
for autism assessments in Ireland, with some families waiting up to three years. The father argues that he is able to pay for private healthcare in Ireland.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
8 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Records falsified relating to mentally ill inmate found dead, prison watchdog finds
Records relating to the supervision of a severely mentally ill Spanish resident who was found dead in his cell in Cloverhill Prison were falsified, a prison watchdog has found. The Office of the Inspector of Prisons, which is led by Mark Kelly, was highly critical of how the Irish Prison Service (IPS) handled the detention of the deceased, whom it called 'Mr O', in 2022. It determined Mr O was in custody on suspicion of a minor offence and was due to be transferred to a psychiatric hospital the day after he was found dead in a close-supervision cell on August 10th, 2022. Prisoners under close supervision are supposed to be checked every 15 minutes. A prison journal recorded that staff had checked the prisoner at 7am, 7.15am and 7.30am. However, Mr O had been found unresponsive sitting on the toilet in his cell at 6.50am, causing staff to issue a 'Code Red' and call for an ambulance. This 'clearly' indicates the three journal entries had been filled in ahead of time by staff, 'entirely negating the value of this recording safeguard', the inspectorate said in a newly published report. The inspectorate also noted 'an (unsuccessful) effort had been made to erase the three entries'. The statutory inspection body has raised concerns about the falsification of prison records on several previous occasions. It echoed concerns contained in a recent report by the Council of Europe's Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) that found several cases of records being falsified. The issue was particularly notable in Cloverhill and Limerick Prisons, where falsified records were discovered following several prisoner deaths in close-supervision cells. The CPT said minimal action had been taken by local prison management to address this. The Inspector of Prisons said it is 'imperative' the falsification of records 'is treated with the utmost seriousness' by management. Regarding Mr O, it said he was detained on a public order charge at Dublin Airport on August 4th after he was observed acting erratically. He was unable to take up bail after he was judged to be of unfit mind to sign the bond. In Cloverhill, his behaviour was observed as 'bizarre and erratic'. Staff reported he 'was standing on his bed in a state of undress and shouting at the floor and refused to respond to questions asked by the nurse'. Gardaí told prison staff the judge would strike out the charge against Mr O if treatment could be arranged. Staff also learned he had spent time in psychiatric hospitals outside the State and had not been taking his medication for a lengthy period of time. A place was found for Mr O in St Vincent's hospital in Fairview. He was due to be transferred on August 11th. However, early on August 10th, he was found unresponsive in his cell. Attempts to revive him were unsuccessful and he was pronounced dead at 9.45am. The inspectorate's report does not detail a cause of death. The inspectorate repeated recommendations that 'urgent consideration' be given to quickly transferring mentally ill suspects charged with minor offences to local psychiatric hospitals. 'It remains unacceptable that prisoner-patients such as Mr O, suspected of minor offences, and suffering from a mental health disorder, cannot more rapidly access in-patient psychiatric treatment in local civil psychiatric hospitals.' In response, the IPS said it is working on implementing several recommendations in this area and that additional resources are being assigned to Cloverhill. Regarding the falsification of records, it said a 'digitisation project' will commence later this year that will improve record-keeping and limit 'the risk of falsification'. It said staff who are found to falsify records 'are sanctioned in line with the code of discipline'.
Irish Times
38 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Indian taxi driver faces loss of livelihood as he recovers from unprovoked attack
An Indian taxi driver faces losing his livelihood after an unprovoked attack by two passengers last week amid a growing number of racist assaults in Ireland. 'My children are so scared, they have asked me to promise them that I will never drive a taxi again,' said Lakhvir Singh (46). He is recovering from his physical injuries sustained in the attack but he has been left fearful of what could happen in the future. The father of two was dropping off two young men at Poppintree Community and Sports Centre when they turned on him and struck him twice across his forehead with a bottle, shouting, 'go back to your country'. READ MORE The men ordered the taxi on the FreeNow app at about 11.10pm and one of the men willingly paid the €50 fare upfront. The other man initially refused to get into the taxi with a 'black' driver but he was persuaded to take the lift, according to Mr Singh. After a stop-off at a garage in Ballymun, Mr Singh dropped the two men at Poppintree, where they turned on him without warning. 'The customer sitting in the front ran out and around to my door,' he said. 'He tried opening it but I held it firmly shut and the second man ran around to help his friend open the door. When they couldn't get it open, one of the men ran back around to the passenger side, picked up a broken bottle from the ground and struck me twice across the forehead. He was shouting 'Go back to your country' at me. 'They ran off when they saw the blood. I couldn't find my phone so I knocked on doors of nearby houses but nobody answered to help me. I went back to my car and found my phone and called the emergency services.' Mr Singh, who has been living in Ireland for 23 years, was taken to Dublin 's Mater hospital, where he needed 12 stitches to a wound on his forehead. He has been driving a taxi for more than 10 years in Dublin but is thinking of changing his job because of the attack. His taxi is still being forensically examined by gardaí and Mr Singh will have to pay for it to be cleaned of blood when it is returned. 'My two teenage children are very scared for me and have made me promise that I'll never drive a taxi again. I'll certainly never drive at night but I may have to find another job altogether. 'I'm scared and I'm scared now for my children who will be using public transport when they go to college. Every day there seems to be another story of racist attacks and it seems to be getting worse in recent months.' The Indian community in Ireland more widely have warned of a growing number of racist incidents. Last month, an Indian man who had recently moved to Ireland to work in the tech sector was beaten, stabbed and stripped by a group of people who falsely accused him of criminal behaviour. [ 'He kept saying: what wrong have I done? Why me?' An Indian man is left stripped and bloodied on an Irish street Opens in new window ] Another Indian man, Dr Santosh Yadav, was reportedly attacked in Clondalkin, Dublin, in late July. The chairperson of a leading Ireland-India group says he is receiving reports of daily attacks in the Greater Dublin Area and has called on the Government to mount an 'immediate and co-ordinated State response'. The Ireland India Council wrote to Tánaiste Simon Harris and Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan in the wake of the Tallaght attack and believes the same group of assailants may be responsible for four other attacks on the Indian community in recent weeks. Among measures it is calling for is the formal recognition of the hate crime status, a cross-departmental taskforce on hate crime and youth violence and legislation to hold parents responsible both 'financially and criminally' for repeated violent actions of minors in their care. Prasant Shukla, chairman of the Ireland India Council, said he is receiving at least two calls or emails each day about racial attacks on members of the Indian community living in the Greater Dublin Area. 'Incidents of assault, intimidation or harassment targeting Indian residents in Dublin are happening on the street, on the buses or in residential areas,' he said. 'People are now afraid to step outside during daylight hours. In one particular egregious case, a man's eyesight was affected. These cases cannot be dismissed or ignored.' Meanwhile, an Irish-born medical registrar said he was left 'stunned and upset' after a group of children hurled racial slurs at him as he left a shopping complex last week. Dr Taimoor Salman estimates children as young as 10 years old shouted 'Mr Curry Man' in an exaggerated accent at him. The incident occurred after 9pm on Thursday evening as Dr Salman dropped into Blackcastle Shopping Centre in Navan, Co Meath, to pick up a few groceries on his way home from work at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda, Co Louth. One boy did impersonations of Apu, the Indian shopkeeper in The Simpsons. 'I just left. I didn't say anything more, as they were children,' he said. 'I was stunned and upset. I have seen racial abuse and throwaway remarks first hand to me and my colleagues at the hospital but I would never expect this from children who are generally very accepting of other nationalities. 'There seems to be a horrible pack mentality and this incident was insidious.' Dr Salman was born in Ireland, where his father trained and practised as a surgeon and worked in Our Lady's Hospital in Navan before moving the family to work in the UK and Saudi Arabia. 'I lived in Navan and went to primary school here and have nothing but good memories of the town as a child. I never experienced any racism here. 'That's part of the reason I came back to live here with my wife and young daughter in 2017 and after I began working in the hospital in Drogheda.' Dr Salman, whose parents were born in Pakistan, believes that the streets of Navan have become too dangerous for him to walk at night. 'This wave of hatred to people of colour is quite recent and increasingly more open and brash. I've been back in Ireland for 15 years. In 2017, it was a peaceful and safe place and I could walk anywhere at any time without fear. Now it is too unsafe and I would only go to crowded places.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
EU halts retaliatory tariffs as Trump again raises spectre of higher tariffs on pharma
The EU on Tuesday said it would suspend its retaliatory tariffs on the United States even as the specifics of a trade deal reached last month, including lower tariffs on European cars, have yet to be signed off by Donald Trump . The US president last week signed an executive order that will implement as of Friday a 15 per cent tariff rate on most EU products, which European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen agreed to when the two leaders met in Scotland at the end of July. But Mr Trump again threatened on Tuesday to announce separate tariffs on semiconductor and pharmaceutical imports 'within the next week or so' and made particular mention of Ireland in doing so during an interview with CNBC 'We'll be putting a initially small tariff on pharmaceuticals, but in one year – one and a half years, maximum – it's going to go to 150 per cent and then it's going to go to 250 per cent because we want pharmaceuticals made in out country,' he said. READ MORE 'They [pharmaceutical companies] make a fortune with pharmaceuticals, and they make in China and Ireland and everything else. 'This is a, you know, this is a separate class than the 15 per cent tariffs on sort of everything. These are excluded classes, I like to call them, like steel, aluminium, made in our country,' Mr Trump said. 'We're going to be announcing on semiconductors and chips, which is a separate category,' the president continued. The bloc had readied higher levies on €93 billion worth of US exports, which were due to enter into force as of Thursday had trade talks failed. 'The suspension [of retaliatory tariffs] is a reflection of the fact that a political agreement has been reached,' said a senior EU official, noting that both sides were now implementing that deal. The official added that the retaliatory measures were now being 'put back into the freezer and we can always take it out if needed'. Washington and Brussels are still negotiating the text of a joint statement which was expected soon after Mr Trump and Ms von der Leyen shook hands in Scotland. Clarity is still lacking on when the US will lower its 27.5 per cent rate on European cars to 15 per cent – a key export sector for Germany – as well as the categories of products that will be traded at zero tariffs. 'We worked very hard to ensure we have that immediate tariff relief also for cars. We are working hard to see that in practice,' said the EU official. One aspect yet to be agreed is how to treat EU car parts that come from outside the bloc, particularly from China. The EU official said that 'there might be further ways to restrict content from certain non-market economies', adding that negotiations are ongoing. As for the zero-tariff exemption, the EU is still pushing for wine and spirits to be included, a key ask from France, Italy and Ireland – even as Washington has flatly denied they could receive such a carve-out. Brussels is also pushing for chemicals and certain medical devices to be excluded from the 15 per cent rate, but it remains unclear whether it will succeed. 'We're trying to get as many products into the list of exemptions ... we have a certain number of sectors where we agree [such as] aircraft and aircraft components,' said the official, while admitting that 'not all products that we care to see ... will be on that list immediately'. Negotiations are also ongoing on European steel and aluminium exports, currently subject to a 50 per cent rate. The EU is aiming to secure 'tariff rate quotas' – meaning lower rates for exports matching what has historically been traded with the US, while accepting higher rates above those thresholds. But US officials have not yet signed off on this concept. The EU official said there was an 'understanding reached at political level' on steel, but that it would 'take a little bit more time' to iron out. A majority of EU countries would eventually have to approve parts of the deal, such as lowering of EU tariffs on certain US exports, but that will only happen 'after the final deal' has been agreed, the EU official said. The EU-US deal was harshly criticised by countries including France and Germany for giving in too much and accepting higher tariffs. German finance minister Lars Klingbeil on Monday said that the EU had been 'too weak' in negotiations with the US and that Germany 'can't be satisfied with the result that was achieved'. The commission, which negotiates trade deals on behalf of the bloc, pushed back on Tuesday saying that it was 'most surprising ... given that nothing has happened here ... without the clear signal received from our member states'. Officials also pointed out that the agreement averted an all-out trade war and Washington making good on its threat of pulling its security guarantees from Europe. Ms von der Leyen's trade agreement includes investment pledges and more purchases of US weapons and energy products. 'We chose the less bad option and we feel this is the better choice,' said the EU official. 'We're very clearly operating in a second best world.' – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025 / Bloomberg
